"We are going to see the worst depression in the history..."

Nope. My condominium doesn't rest on land. It rests on another condominium.
And what, it's condominiums all the way down?

Or does the building rest on land?

Which floor of the condo owns the land under the parking garage?
Presumably, all the condo owners have joint ownership of the land under the building and the parking garage.
 
And what, it's condominiums all the way down?

Or does the building rest on land?

I don't own the building. I own the condominium. I didn't buy land, I bought housing.

Even if you don't understand the distinction, the law and the economy do.
 
Location is an inseparable property of land. It's probably the most important aspect of land.
Total rubbish again. Location depends on what/who else chooses to locate where. Location is about network effects far, far more than it is about soil, climate or co-ordinates. What an unreal joke.

Mm. That's why at least 4 Nobel Laureates in economics advocate land value taxation, right? Because it's "whackjob" stuff?
You apparently misunderstand. I am not arguing against a Nobel laureate, but against your nonsense. The two are rather different quantities. Yes, rather.
 
I don't own the building. I own the condominium. I didn't buy land, I bought housing.

Even if you don't understand the distinction, the law and the economy do.
As a matter of fact, unless your condominium is some special example, part of your purchase included a part-share in the land on which the building sits.

You bought not just housing, but housing in a specific location. Your condo would be worth much less if (possibly nothing) it was located in the middle of nowhere. How much would your condo be worth if it were located in the middle of the Sahara desert?
 
Total rubbish again. Location depends on what/who else chooses to locate where. Location is about network effects far, far more than it is about soil, climate or co-ordinates. What an unreal joke.
That doesn't change the fact that location is an inseparable quality of the land. If you thought the Georgist argument applies only to, or even focuses mainly on, the the physical properties of land, you don't understand the Georgist argument at all.

You apparently misunderstand. I am not arguing against a Nobel laureate, but against your nonsense. The two are rather different quantities. Yes, rather.
Nope. Those Nobel Laureates understood the principles I've advanced, which is why they support a land value tax.

Ditto Winston Churchill, Albert Einstein, Leo Tolstoy, Dwight Eisenhower, Sun Yat Sen, Mark Twain, Albert Nock, and many others.

You're simply compelled to not know that fact, because it proves you wrong.
 
Fly by night home loan companies started loaning money to people who couldn't afford to pay it back. Wall Street was buying these bundled up loans, fueling the fire. The risk assessment was based on flawed models, models based on an ever increasing market. The SEC turned a blind eye to what was going on. Millions of loans worth Billions of dollars were made to the wrong people. The economy slowed, the first thing to go was large ticket items such as cars. The only reason they survived as long as they did was the fact that many people needed cars to get to work, having moved to homes outside of the city ;) As things slowed even more, the homes started getting repossessed.

The automakers are a victim of this. There's no doubt they contributed to their own demise, but the real problem is there is no money. If it were simply a matter of not competing with the Japanese they wouldn't be posting losses like they are.

If you consider what happened to cars during the same period these home loans were being made, cars got cheaper, houses got more expensive. With houses being more "exepensive" the problem was twofold. First, people who really couldn't afford the loans were stuck with them and their increasing hidden rates. Second, people who could afford the houses ended up borrowing against equity that didn't really exist. Either as a second mortgage or on credit cards.

So yes, it's the banks fault no one can repay their loans. That's what happens when you make bad loans.


Wow, you are still being incredibly silly!

Have you never heard of Ditec? That's a home-loan and mortgage company owned by GMAC (and GMAC was formerly owned by GM) to plow profits from car loans into the subprime lending market ...

Just for the record, when was the last year that GM made a profit from manufacturing and selling automobiles? Or the last decade?

:rolleyes:
 
The automakers are a victim of this. There's no doubt they contributed to their own demise, but the real problem is there is no money. If it were simply a matter of not competing with the Japanese they wouldn't be posting losses like they are.
Losses are just what we'd expect if a business can't compete.

So yes, it's the banks fault no one can repay their loans. That's what happens when you make bad loans.
And yet other carmakers are still staying afloat (with varying degrees of difficulty). What was so special about the credit cruch that it hurt the Big Three selectively? Could it be, perhaps, that the Big Three were uncompetitive and needed a steady supply of credit just to stay alive? In that case, yes, when credit becomes scarce then they'll be in trouble. Doesn't mean the banks should take first responsibility, though.

Let's look way back to 2006 or 2007; when consumers were still buying lots of vehicles, and credit was still widely available. In other words, before the "external" factors that you blame for the big 3's failure. In previous years, did they make a profit, or a loss?
Well, here's Ford's results: http://www.ford.com/doc/2007_ar.pdf
And here's GM: http://www.gm.com/corporate/investor_information/docs/fin_data/gm07ar/content/financials/selfin/selfin_01.html
And Chrysler: http://www.breitbart.com/article.php?id=D8V2ON4G4&show_article=1
(I wanted to post something from the Chrysler website but gave up after ten minutes of searching)
Looks pretty conclusive to me.

The real problem is that the big 3 are uncompetitive. The credit crunch just pulled away one of their crutches.
 
Last edited:
As a matter of fact, unless your condominium is some special example, part of your purchase included a part-share in the land on which the building sits.

You bought not just housing, but housing in a specific location.

That's like saying I bought not just milk, but milk in a specific bottle.

Yes, that's right.

But I didn't particularly pay for the bottle -- I paid for the milk.

And even so, "land" isn't the same as "location." For example, if the hospital near my condo shuts down, housing prices will probably fall (because there aren't as many jobs), but the "land" remains exactly what it was.

Don't you get tired of being wrong about everything?
 
Losses are just what we'd expect if a business can't compete.

Yes, but my Gold plated Diamond studded iPhone detailing business isn't doing so hot right now either. Despite there being no other competition in this market I'm taking a loss these days.

And yet other carmakers are still staying afloat (with varying degrees of difficulty). What was so special about the credit cruch that it hurt the Big Three selectively? Could it be, perhaps, that the Big Three were uncompetitive and needed a steady supply of credit just to stay alive? In that case, yes, when credit becomes scarce then they'll be in trouble. Doesn't mean the banks should take first responsibility, though.

I can see you're not really up to date on this. The whole automotive sector has taken a hit over the past year. The Japanese were in a better position to weather the storm than the Big 3. That hasn't insulated them from the effects of the market collapse. Toyota has posted its biggest losses ever, and last I heard Nissan was seeking Government assistance. Honda has taken a hit as well. This isn't selective, far from it.

The banks shouldn't take the responsibility? Lol, they made huge loans, backed by absolutely nothing, to people who can't afford them, in an unregulated market. They produced nothing tangible besides debt and made huge profits. Not only that, but they sold off these loans to unsuspecting investors all over the World by creating a totally phony rating system in order to do so. They bankrupted a country and severly hurt may others along the way. Nice.

No they shouldn't take responsibility for their actions. Instead, the American public should stick their collective heads in the sand, throw $300 Billion at them and say "Good Job!" Then sellout the biggest industry they have by making them beg for a loan to keep the economy afloat while subsidized foreign competitors funnel money out of the country.

God I'm glad I'm Canadian.
 
Wow, you are still being incredibly silly!

Have you never heard of Ditec? That's a home-loan and mortgage company owned by GMAC (and GMAC was formerly owned by GM) to plow profits from car loans into the subprime lending market ...

So, even the Fed's got in on it. Eventually, when they saw the profits the banks were making. Does that some how make it right in your eyes? Talk about being silly.

Just for the record, when was the last year that GM made a profit from manufacturing and selling automobiles? Or the last decade?

:rolleyes:

Right before people started buying houses they couldn't afford. Then for a brief period during when people were taking out loans on the "equity" in their homes that didn't exist.
 
The real problem is that the big 3 are uncompetitive. The credit crunch just pulled away one of their crutches.

Yes, but there's capacity to rebound if given opportunity. The credit crunch came at a very unopportune time for the Big 3.

The feds were making changes faster than the companies could react. These are huge operations running on razor thin margins. Hard to do an about face as fast as the price at the pump changes or laws regarding emissions are enacted. Being the new guy, or smaller operation when this happens isn't a bad thing.

Then the states were creating tax havens for the foreign manufacturers to start up operations. Totally unfair, yet somehow Capitalism at its finest.

I'm not saying the Big 3 aren't in part responsible for their own situation. I'm just saying looking at the bottom line and pointing fingers without taking into account all of the factors leading up to this point is foolish. You have a viable industry that essentially created the working middle class and all of a sudden the bottom falls out and you just say "Your fault!"?

I say it's the banks fault, they found a way to inflate the market and suck every last penny out of these people without reprise.
 
That doesn't change the fact that location is an inseparable quality of the land.
Except that it does. Move the location of the central business district to a different area and you've separated the location from the land. What an unreal joke your reponses are.

Nope. Those Nobel Laureates understood the principles I've advanced, which is why they support a land value tax.
Attempt to associate detritus with others' authority dismissed.
 
The horror, the horror......

This a truly dismal read.....all 5 pages....

http://www.salon.com/news/feature/2009/02/26/state_budgets/

Can we say "bottomless pit" :boggled:

Compared to revenue, (I'm guessing) those deficits, in the current economic climate, are reasonable, and even necessary. California has a bigger economy than many sovereign countries.

This is more worrying.

http://business.theage.com.au/busin...-loss-most-ever-by-uk-firm-20090226-8j17.html

The Royal Bank of Scotland has reported a net loss of 24.1 billion pounds ($52.75 billion) in 2008, the largest annual shortfall ever recorded by a British company.
RBS, which is nearly 70% owned by the British state after a massive bailout, said it would sell off a large part of its assets, withdraw or reduce operations in 36 countries and re-focus its activities on the domestic market.
The beleaguered bank said the state had agreed to insure RBS ``toxic'' assets worth 325 billion pounds ($711.3 billion) and would cover 90% of losses stemming from such holdings.
The Australian governments ban on shorting is about to end, and banks are in the firing line.


Kevin Rudd and Wayne Swan have a dilemma. The short-selling ban is scheduled to come off on March 6 and hedge funds around the world are lining up to short Macquarie Group and other Aussie banks.

BusinessDayhas spoken with a handful of funds. They are like-minded. The banks here are in far better shape than their offshore peers but they remain expensive.
Does the Government persist with its arbitrary shorting ban which has favoured a select few companies at the expense of others, and which has damaged liquidity and Australia's reputation for free markets, or does it keep protecting its cosy cabal?
Banks around the globe are under extreme pressure, with Citi bank well on the way to being state owned, Irish Banks in huge trouble, and many others in severe distress. The banks are central to the running of an economy. So what do the hedge funds do with their massive reserves? Ensure that banks are hammered even harder. But it will look good on their balance sheets, and the bonuses will buy a sports car or overseas holiday.
 
Last edited:
I see predatory hedge funds as an aspect that needs reigning in.

They were hammering currencies a decade ago - how did that get resolved as we don't hear much about that these days.
 
Except that it does.
No, of course it doesn't.

Move the location of the central business district to a different area and you've separated the location from the land. What an unreal joke your reponses are.
If your aunt had a penis, she'd be your uncle.


Face it, Francesca, when you buy land, you pay for location. That's in inarguable fact of objective reality.

Attempt to associate detritus with others' authority dismissed.
Translation: facts that prove your beliefs false ignored.
 
If your aunt had a penis, she'd be your uncle.
:rolleyes:

Face it, Francesca, when you buy land, you pay for location. That's in inarguable fact of objective reality.
You said "location is an inseparable quality of the land". When you buy land or real property that is one moment in time. Therafter, land and location are separable.

More wrongness from yourself.
 
Well, seriously: central business districts aren't just moved around.

You said "location is an inseparable quality of the land".
Which is an inarguable fact of objective reality.

When you buy land or real property that is one moment in time. Therafter, land and location are separable.
No, the location is not separable from the land in any case. What you're talking about is the benefit from that location may increase or decrease thereafter. True, but irrelevant.

More wrongness from yourself.
LOL. You're claiming you can separate a location from the land that it describes, and you're accusing me of wrongness!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom