"We are going to see the worst depression in the history..."

Mods: Please change Free "Thinkr" to "Ball of Yarn".

Thanks.

Civility, civility, civility. Thank you.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LibraryLady
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Mods: Please change Free "Thinkr" to "Ball of Yarn".

Thanks.
Yeah, I'm not the one claiming that landowners should get the value society produced or that the difference between apples and oranges is arbitrary. And I'm not the one resorting to bluster or affirmation by trolls. And I'm not the one who has shrunk from debate, ignored points, and resorted to ad hominems and other fallacies.

It's pretty clear who's the ball of yarn in this debate, and I aint it. Oh, and reported.
 
So, is it going to be the worst depression in history?


Consider the following (all figures for the U.S.):

Jan. 2009 unemployment rate: 7.6%
Jan. 2009 inflation rate: 0.3%
Jan. 2009 prime interest rate: 0.5%

Jan. 1981 unemployment rate: 7.5%
Jan. 1981 inflation rate: 11.8%
Jan. 1981 prime interest rate: 20.0%

Which, overall, looks worse to you? Unemployment is virtually identical between the two time periods, but inflation and interest rates are vasly lower than they were twenty-eight years ago.

So it seems things have a ways to go before reaching the depths of the 1980-82 recession period.
 
Only problem is that the economy is very nearly into deflation (which part of the reason interest rates are so low as they're not needed to combat inflation) and if the US ends up with a deflation rate then it could get a whole lot worse. Why spend today if it it'll be cheaper in future?

The counter argument would be that certain sectors of retail already live with deflation (eg the PC market) and counter that by increasing the spec on computers all the time. Not sure it would work for a whole economy though.

Steve
 
It can work if the metrics change in certain sectors so that houses etc are viewed a depreciating assets - more value for money.

Then every year instead of needing more wages to meet higher costs (shelter is a killer ) - then each year as with technology ( my biz so I know where of you speak ) the same wages by more value.

See vested interests want assets to inflate to protect their loans.
They got smart with vehicles - with a vehicle you would kill yourself laughing it I whispered in your ear - it's be worth 10% more next year.

When we get to that point with housing things will turn around.

The whole people will wait is nonsense as the tech industry shows. People buy for the value of what they need at the time.

We get to that with shelter and other services insurance etc we'll all be better off.

Henry Ford knew, drop prices, more value every year and sell more and pay enough wage so people can buy his products.
 
When we get to that point with housing things will turn around.

The whole people will wait is nonsense as the tech industry shows. People buy for the value of what they need at the time.

We get to that with shelter and other services insurance etc we'll all be better off.
We can never have that with housing so long as land rents remain privatized; because the prices are entirely demand-driven, by default prices will be higher if people can afford to pay more.
 
The problem is the mindset that sees a house as an appreciating asset, sometimes at ludicrous rates. I see my house as a place to live and work for which I pay a cost. As I do not intend to move it's asset value is irrelevant.

Steve
 
The problem is the mindset that sees a house as an appreciating asset, sometimes at ludicrous rates.
No, no: the problem is that housing is generally an appreciating asset, sometimes at ludicrous rates.

If it wasn't, it wouldn't matter one whit what people's mindset was.

I see my house as a place to live and work for which I pay a cost. As I do not intend to move it's asset value is irrelevant.

Steve
Don't be so sure about that. Say you have some sort of tragedy, and you're strapped for cash. If your housing is worth more, can borrow more against it if need be.

Or maybe something in your life just changes, and you need to move. If your house is worth more, you'll have more to spend wherever it is you move.

If houses appreciate, sometimes at ludicrous rates, it's only rational for people to look at their house as a money-maker, and speculators to do likewise: because it is.
 
Interesting, you're talking about the value of the house, not the value of the land.

Steve
 
Interesting, you're talking about the value of the house, not the value of the land.

Steve
The value of the land is what's actually appreciating, of course, but most people don't make the distinction because it's irrelevant to them.
 
o, no: the problem is that housing is generally an appreciating asset, sometimes at ludicrous rates.

If it wasn't, it wouldn't matter one whit what people's mindset was.

It's a ponzi scheme and you fell for it....the Economist called it in 2005....

The figures detailing the bubble are daunting:

The total value of residential property in developed countries rose by more than $30 trillion, to $70 trillion, over the past five years – an increase equal to the combined GDPs of those nations.
The current real estate boom has seen prices go up more than 100 percent of many countries GDP – a number that "is larger than the global stock market bubble in the late 1990s (an increase over five years of 80 percent of GDP) or America's stock market bubble in the late 1920s (55 percent of GDP)," The Economist notes.

"In other words, it looks like the biggest bubble in history."

welcome to pain......

and for a more amusing look at the catastrophe - it's a good read and you can imagine the laughter when he started it in 2005 and it all turned out just as he called it.

http://housingpanic.blogspot.com/2006/05/on-ponzi-schemes-and-housing-bubble.html

http://housingpanic.blogspot.com/

The pain part.....

Reinventing America
After the Crash
http://sootandashes.blogspot.com/
 
The value of the land is what's actually appreciating, of course, but most people don't make the distinction because it's irrelevant to them.

That's the socially destructive aspect that need to be stomped on.
Long term leases by municipalities are a good method with punitive speculation taxes on any flippers.

We don't speculate on roads or libraries or universities or schools......affordable housing falls into the same category.
Civilized nations know that.
 
Last edited:
The value of the land is what's actually appreciating, of course, but most people don't make the distinction because it's irrelevant to them.

If you look back at your quote you didn't refer to the land value you referred to the house value.

The fact that land value is irrelevant to them is because it is. The value is in the package and the biggest part is what sits upon the land not the land.

Steve
 
It's a ponzi scheme and you fell for it....the Economist called it in 2005....
No, I'm well aware that the massive run-up in "housing" value was actually a speculative land bubble. But even when there's no bubble, land values grow at a rate greater than the GDP.
 
Only because suckers buy into the into idea fed by the banks, realtors, real estate lawyers and short sighted munipalities that want high mill rates.

Now they are all broke.

Only value add should bring up a property price - in Switzerland you try the speculative nonsense and you'll be deservedly hammered

It's all over for a generation at least and with energy costs it's likely all orver period.

Small high tech and affordable and cheap upkeep just like cars.

psst I got a Dutch tulip bulb sure to climb in value.....:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
If you look back at your quote you didn't refer to the land value you referred to the house value.
Yes, I know that.

The fact that land value is irrelevant to them is because it is. The value is in the package and the biggest part is what sits upon the land not the land.

Steve
No, that's false. For most of the lifetime of an improvement, the land is worth more, because land typically starts as 1/5th or more of the value (think a typical housing costing $250,000 actually being a $200,000 house on a $50,000 lot), and while land appreciates, improvements depreciate.

Remember: the actual value of improvements is cost of replacement minus depreciation.
 
Only because suckers buy into the into idea fed by the banks, realtors, real estate lawyers and short sighted munipalities that want high mill rates.
No, because landownership constitutes a legal privilege that has economic implications.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom