"We are going to see the worst depression in the history..."

Well, seriously: central business districts aren't just moved around.

The hell they're not.

Central business districts are often -- especially in small towns -- defined by major economic landmarks; the business district is near the major employer, or the major shopping mall. When the employer shuts his door or another mall opens at the edge of town, the district moves.

Similarly, they're often defined by major physical landmarks; if the bridge collapses and traffic can't get to the business district, the business district folds.

And in many cases, they're defined by legal landmarks as well. The business district is the area zoned for commercial activity, and the zoning commission can destroy it or move it at a stroke of the pen.

In fact, "moving business districts around" is what most urban planners try to do on a daily basis; they try to lure or create new business in an otherwise mundane area, in the hope of creating new jobs around it. Look at the proposal and justification for any new athletic stadium created in the United States in the past twenty-five years.

Any of these changes can change your "location" without altering the "land" a hair.

Don't you get tired of being wrong about everything?
 
The hell they're not.

Central business districts are often -- especially in small towns -- defined by major economic landmarks; the business district is near the major employer, or the major shopping mall. When the employer shuts his door or another mall opens at the edge of town, the district moves.
Organically, over time a CBD can shift. It cannot, however, be picked up and moved.

There's a shortage of land in Hawaii, but you can't relieve the shortage by taking locations in Nebraska and adding them to Hawaii.

When you talk about plots of land, you're talking about things which are defined by their location. Duh.

Similarly, they're often defined by major physical landmarks; if the bridge collapses and traffic can't get to the business district, the business district folds.

And in many cases, they're defined by legal landmarks as well. The business district is the area zoned for commercial activity, and the zoning commission can destroy it or move it at a stroke of the pen.

In fact, "moving business districts around" is what most urban planners try to do on a daily basis; they try to lure or create new business in an otherwise mundane area, in the hope of creating new jobs around it. Look at the proposal and justification for any new athletic stadium created in the United States in the past twenty-five years.

Any of these changes can change your "location" without altering the "land" a hair.
No, they of course can't. The location is the same in any case. The benefit accruing to the location -the land rent- changes.

You're being very, very stupid when you claim that location can be separated from land.

Don't you get tired of being wrong about everything?
One of the great joys of being a Georgist is seeing the unpredictably ridiculous things people will say in order to avoid knowing the facts that prove their beliefs false; it's a guarantee that, before long, anti-Georgists will be willing to say anything whatever to do so, but you never know what it'll be. You and Francesca have both evidently reached that stage, and have humored me greatly in doing so.
 
Organically, over time a CBD can shift. It cannot, however, be picked up and moved.

Wrong. I can literally move my firm from the west side of town to the east side of town in the time it takes to load and unload my trucks.

It will probably take a little longer for the shops that relied on all my employees doing their shopping during the lunch hour to fold or move, but the handwriting is on the wall as soon as my trucks roll out the gate.


When you talk about plots of land, you're talking about things which are defined by their location.

... which is not what realtors are talking about when they mention "location, location, location." Duh.


Don't you get tired of being wrong about everything?
 
Wrong. I can literally move my firm from the west side of town to the east side of town in the time it takes to load and unload my trucks.
?? Your business manifestly isn't a CBD.

It will probably take a little longer for the shops that relied on all my employees doing their shopping during the lunch hour to fold or move, but the handwriting is on the wall as soon as my trucks roll out the gate.
A CBD that is utterly dependent upon a single business isn't much of a CBD, though, is it?

... which is not what realtors are talking about when they mention "location, location, location." Duh.
LOL!

Beat that, anyone. I challenge you. There is no chance you can get more ridiculous than claiming that Realtors aren't talking about location when they say "location, location, location."

Don't you get tired of being wrong about everything?
LOL. You are destroyed. Utterly, and completely.
 
?. You are destroyed. Utterly, and completely.

Yes, and I'm sure that, in the privacy of your own head, the voices are reassuringly telling you that.

You have never "destroyed" me, or even seriously presented a rational argument for any of your positions.

That's not simply bravado, but merely a historical review. And I'm sufficiently confident of that that I'm willing to invite the entire membership of the Randi forum to look at all of our exchanges and see if they can find a single one where your Georgist land-rent economic theory was actually rationally supported.

I'm confident that they can't, although I await the results with interest. And the reason I'm confident that they can't is because, not only are you wrong about everything, but you're so out-of-touch with actual economic theory that you don't even realize how wrong you are.
 
Well, seriously: central business districts aren't just moved around.
Right, suuuure. London E14 used to be the centre of shipbound exporting industry. Then it was a rust belt used by nobody much except Millwall Football Club and the occasional movie director called Kubrick who wanted to pretend it was Vietnam. Then it was glass towers with Citi and Barclays and HSBC on top. No CBDs never move around. Especially not in centuries-old cities or anything like that.

Which is an inarguable fact of objective reality.
I think that this forum may have picked up a little about your grasp of "inarguable" and "fact" and "objective" and "reality" now

You're claiming you can separate a location from the land that it describes, and you're accusing me of wrongness!
Why yes, that I am. Because you're wrong. Try to understand why. Ideologues and utopianists pretty much always are when pressed into a corner.
 
Oh, by the way, drkitten, here's a brain-buster for you (in case you want to discuss something substantial, and not ad hominem in nature):

How does one go about acquiring the benefits that accrue to locations. Think hard!
 
^Hmm. Well, perhaps we need to get back to how this whole tangent started.

drkitten said
drkitten said:
Right. More buyers for the same physical houses.
To which I replied:
Me said:
Actually, the supply of housing increased considerably. But the supply of land didn't, so prices rose.
Now, this is not a very controversial claim. Anyone can check the tax roles and see that the price increases for bare land mirrored the increases in cost of housing or office space. Clearly, the boom was a land boom.

But drkitten wasn't satisfied:
drkitten said:
Wrong at several levels. People buying "housing" aren't buying "land."
This is a manifestly ridiculous claim. If drkitten is right, people are just buying housing; in drkitten's mind, it apparently doesn't matter where the housing is located.

But is that the case? I don't think so. We all know that housing located in areas which are in higher demand cost more: because people clearly are purchasing more than housing. They're also purchasing the location. That's why, as I've stated numerous times, the Realtor's credo is "location, location, location."

There. While drkitten has failed to evidence a single instance where he's proved me wrong, I have now shown that a claim he made in this thread was dead wrong as a matter of objective fact, and very obviously so.
 
This is a manifestly ridiculous claim. If drkitten is right, people are just buying housing; in drkitten's mind, it apparently doesn't matter where the housing is located.

And so we see the misrepresentations begin.

Of course someone buying housing cares where the housing is located, but that doesn't mean that they're buying the land. An obvious counterexample, which has already been provided, is purchasing a condominum. A condomium obviously has a location, but housing available has little to do with the land. One can easily provide twice as much housing on the same "land" simply by building more stories.

Similarly, many townships and gated communities do not offer "land" precisely because they don't want the loss of legal access control that would involve; instead they offer hugely long leaseholds to supply the demand for housing, leaseholds that in many cases are transferrable (i.e. you can sell your "lease" to whomever you like) and infinitely renewable at the lessor's option for a nominal fee.

The idea being that you buy the right to "lease" the land for an up-front payment, of, say $500,000, made directly to the land-owner. The terms of the lease are that you owe $1 a year (plus property taxes) for as long as you like --- and, as described, you have a property right in the lease; it can't be taken away from you (subject to various provisos) and you can re-sell it as you see fit, for any price you and the seller agree upon.

If you buy one of these, what did you just buy?

You didn't buy the land; you don't own the land.

You didn't rent the land; you have a demonstrable property right in something.

Answer -- you bought the housing. (And, of course, you have the same property right in a condo, even though you don't own the land -- typically the condominium corporation does. The condo corp bought the land and turned around and sold you the housing.)

And so we see that housing is different, both legally and factually, from the land that underlays it.

While drkitten has failed to evidence a single instance where he's proved me wrong, I have now shown that a claim he made in this thread was dead wrong as a matter of objective fact, and very obviously so.

No. Actually, we see that Free Thinkr is so incompetent as to not only misunderstand my argument, but to misunderstand his own.
 
How do you explain the current fall in the price of houses as the supply of land has remained unaltered?

I would argue that the rise in land prices only mirrored the rise in house prices because the vendors of land did the sums for the houses that could be built on them and adjusted their prices accordingly. The land was only as valuable as the houses that could be built on them. The location premium has nothing to do with the intrinsic value of the land, the location premium is a function of what else is in the area and is related to the fact that the property exists not that the land has an intrinsic value.

Steve
 
How do you explain the current fall in the price of houses as the supply of land has remained unaltered?
The supply of land is fixed, so its value is determined solely by demand. Because there is less demand, land prices, and thus housing prices, have dropped.

I would argue that the rise in land prices only mirrored the rise in house prices because the vendors of land did the sums for the houses that could be built on them and adjusted their prices accordingly. The land was only as valuable as the houses that could be built on them. The location premium has nothing to do with the intrinsic value of the land, the location premium is a function of what else is in the area and is related to the fact that the property exists not that the land has an intrinsic value.

Steve
There's no such thing as intrinsic value.
 
And so we see the misrepresentations begin.

Of course someone buying housing cares where the housing is located, but that doesn't mean that they're buying the land.
They're buying location, as I said. The only way to get the benefit of location is to get access to land. Thus, they're in fact paying for the land.

There's just no way for you to do away with that obvious fact.

An obvious counterexample, which has already been provided, is purchasing a condominum. A condomium obviously has a location, but housing available has little to do with the land. One can easily provide twice as much housing on the same "land" simply by building more stories.
Of course. Which is why housing won't appreciate: like other goods, quantity supplied will increase in response to increased demand.

But quantity of land supplied is always the same. Which is why "housing" (read: land and improvements together) appreciates in general.

Similarly, many townships and gated communities do not offer "land" precisely because they don't want the loss of legal access control that would involve; instead they offer hugely long leaseholds to supply the demand for housing, leaseholds that in many cases are transferrable (i.e. you can sell your "lease" to whomever you like) and infinitely renewable at the lessor's option for a nominal fee.
Hello? How do leases for land supply housing? Obviously, they're just "supplying" (read: charging others to use) land. The people who build the houses are supplying housing. The leases are just a different way of selling location than what's generally employed.

You're either very confused, or actively attempting to deceive.

The idea being that you buy the right to "lease" the land for an up-front payment, of, say $500,000, made directly to the land-owner. The terms of the lease are that you owe $1 a year (plus property taxes) for as long as you like --- and, as described, you have a property right in the lease; it can't be taken away from you (subject to various provisos) and you can re-sell it as you see fit, for any price you and the seller agree upon.

If you buy one of these, what did you just buy?

You didn't buy the land; you don't own the land.
But you've said you pay $500,000 to the landowner! What does it matter whether you've paid to lease it or buy it outright? Either way, you're paying for the land. In boom times, someone might get $500,000 for such a leasehold; in times like this, maybe they only get $250,000. The housing will cost about the same amount to build now or in boom times.

You didn't rent the land; you have a demonstrable property right in something.

Answer -- you bought the housing. (And, of course, you have the same property right in a condo, even though you don't own the land -- typically the condominium corporation does. The condo corp bought the land and turned around and sold you the housing.)
But, as I've already pointed out, you own a part share in the condominium corporation, and thus the land, which remains an asset of the corporation.

And so we see that housing is different, both legally and factually, from the land that underlays it.
?? Where have I claimed that housing is not different from the land that underlays it?

Again, my original point was that the massive run-up in "housing" prices was in reality a run-up in land prices. You've practically admitted as much by pointing out that the supply of housing can be increased simply by building up.

No. Actually, we see that Free Thinkr is so incompetent as to not only misunderstand my argument, but to misunderstand his own.
This argument was quite convoluted, and yet it didn't even manage to address my point at all. All you've managed to do in a fairly verbose post is show that you're so hopelessly confused that you think selling leases for land "supplies demand" for housing.
 
They're buying location, as I said. The only way to get the benefit of location is to get access to land. Thus, they're in fact paying for the land.

And, in a single sentence, Free Thinkr demonstrates how thoroughly I devastated him and how thoroughly out-of-touch this theory is; he -- or his theory -- can't address the fundamental difference between buying and leasing.

Or, for that matter, that the right of access to land might be different from the land.

Wait until I introduce him to other rights that can be bought and sold -- water rights, airspace rights, mineral rights, logging rights, easements. All of which are property rights, none of which are "land."
 
Last edited:
And, in a single sentence, Free Thinkr demonstrates how thoroughly I devastated him and how thoroughly out-of-touch this theory is; he -- or his theory -- can't address the fundamental difference between buying and leasing.
Buying vs leasing isn't the issue. This issue is what you're paying for: housing, or land.

Or, for that matter, that the right of access to land might be different from the land.
It's the same for the purpose of this discussion, at least.

Wait until I introduce him to other rights that can be bought and sold -- water rights, airspace rights, mineral rights, logging rights, easements. All of which are property rights, none of which are "land."
All of those are land. When I say that I advocate a land value tax, I mean it to be a tax on the value of the entire providence of nature.
 
Buying vs leasing isn't the issue. This issue is what you're paying for: housing, or land.

And the answer is obviously housing, since you can stack arbitrarily many people into "land" if you build the "housing" high enough.

It's the same for the purpose of this discussion, at least.

Wrong.

All of those are land.

Wrong. All those are certainly valuable, but none of them are land.

When I say that I advocate a land value tax, I mean it to be a tax on the value of the entire providence of nature.

Which, in turn, means that you're not advocating a land value tax. So once again, you're wrong.

Don't you get tired of being wrong about everything?
 
And the answer is obviously housing, since you can stack arbitrarily many people into "land" if you build the "housing" high enough.
That's a non sequitur. You can in fact stack tons of people into a small parcel of land if you build the housing high enough. But so what? People don't stack housing where land values are low: they stack housing where land values are high. Because, to make housing affordable, the higher value land must be used more intensely.

That doesn't somehow mean that the land isn't getting paid for. Obviously, it is, which is why bare land where housing gets stacked (think Manhattan) is worth tens of millions of dollars per acre

Wrong. All those are certainly valuable, but none of them are land.
No, they're land.

Which, in turn, means that you're not advocating a land value tax. So once again, you're wrong.
No, I just recognize that "land," in the economic sense, means the providence of nature.

Don't you get tired of being wrong about everything?
Yawn. Says the person whose argument implies land in Manhattan should have no value whatever, because people build skyscrapers there.
 
So, is it going to be the worst depression in history?

Could you clarify this for me? As usual, this seems to be centered around the US or perhaps NA. These days a depression would have to take on a more Global meaning wouldn't it? If China rebounds and continues to grow at 10% per year like they were, Cananda remains insulated from the effects of any US slowdown as we remain a large exporter to China.

Likewise the "Great Depression" seems to pale in comparison to the plagues in the 1400's and 1700's. I'm not really a Historian, but these must have caused an econmic depression during those eras.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom