"We are going to see the worst depression in the history..."

But that doesn't make a new point at all. The "natural providence of the land" in Manhattan isn't really different from the Bronx either. What makes it more valuable is overwhelmingly network effects, which are a human providence. Not "land".
Sigh. But Francesca, you get the benefit of those 'network effects' by purchasing the land (yes, drkitten, buy buying it outright, or leasing it).

Those 'network effects' get crystallized into land value; they're positive externalities that landowners are able to internalize.

The value of land is due to three factors: the materials nature provides, the opportunities and amenities the community provides, and the services and infrastructure government provides.

The materials nature provides, the opportunities and amenities the community provides, and the services and infrastructure government provides should benefit society as a whole, but instead they're internalized by landowners, who are able to pocket them for their personal benefit. Meanwhile, taxation bears on production. A tax on this unearned increment landowners get is obviously superior.
 
If there's enough "suitable land that is either vacant or not built to the maximal zoned density," then the actual land prices can remain the same or even drop, depending upon how much room there is between the amount that has been currently built and the maximal zoned density.
Nope. Land prices will only drop if demand drops. Period.

Similarly, land prices can drop if the zoning commission decides to dramatically increase the maximal zoned density; a plot of undeveloped land can actually lose value in this instance, because it's cheaper to expand existing developed land than it would be to build a new condominium from scratch.
LOL! That's a pretty big error for someone who claims to understand economics. In fact increasing maximal zoned density increases land value. The reasoning is simple: if I'm a owner of bare land, the potential buyers are able to pay me based on how densely they can use my land. If they can sell twice as many apartments than before, they're able to pay me more for my land.

You managed to get it exactly backwards: something even most economic ignoramuses I've debated don't manage!

Something like this happened in Colorado in the early 1990s, if I remember right. The state rules for building the "prairie palaces" that were in vogue at the time (and much in demand) among ex-Californians required you to have something like five acres of land upon which to build. Undeveloped land parcels of five acres or more were therefore extremely valuable; a four acre parcel was almost worthless. In response to the high demand, the legislature was considering a change dropping the required land size down.

In response to the mere consideration of this change, the prices for undeveloped five-acre lots dropped considerably. The price for housing continued to increase, but the price for the actual land under the house dropped.
Mm. Tell me: when the price of the five-acre lots dropped, what happened to the price of the four-acre lots? If you looked at total demand (lots of all size), you'd see that it kept increasing. It's just the case that a government intrusion into the market changed which parcels collected how much of the total.
 
Last edited:
The value of land is due to three factors: the materials nature provides, the opportunities and amenities the community provides, and the services and infrastructure government provides.
The government is not nature, other economic agents ("the community") are not nature. Thus, land value is not a providence of nature and actual use/capture of it is not a right but an earned/traded priviledge. Thank you. That's your entire argument for LVT self-refuted--you have blown yourself out of the water (after others already had)

Ownership of what is created by labor, or any income therefrom is not immoral: it doesn't make anyone any worse of than they'd be had the creator/owner not existed. [ . . . ] Ownership of that which is provided by nature, and income therefrom, on the other hand, is immoral, because it necessarily deprives others of what they would have, had it not been for the "owner": the providence of nature. There is no just basis for ownership of that which nature provides.

Couldn't you have done this before . . . ?
 
Last edited:
LOL! That's a pretty big error for someone who claims to understand economics. In fact increasing maximal zoned density increases land value.

It demonstrably didn't. The value of the five+ acre lots dropped substantially.

Mm. Tell me: when the price of the five-acre lots dropped, what happened to the price of the four-acre lots?

It went up, of course. But you're now averaging apples and oranges and claiming that if the price of oranges goes up, that proves that apples just became more valuable.

So once again, you're wrong.
 
Free Thinkr said:
The value of land is due to three factors: the materials nature provides, the opportunities and amenities the community provides, and the services and infrastructure government provides.
The government is not nature, other economic agents ("the community") are not nature. Thus, land is not a providence of nature and actual use of it is not a right but an earned/traded priviledge.
Fail. Land is the providence of nature. Land value is a creation of the community and government. If land has no value -because no one is suffering any deprivation based on that ownership- there's nothing really wrong with it. It's the effects of land ownership -the deprivation it imposes on others- that is the problem. That's why land values should be taxed: to recover the value produced by the community for the community.

Try to keep up.

Thank you. That's your entire argument for LVT self-refuted--you have blown yourself out of the water (after others already had)
Nope.

Ownership of what is created by labor, or any income therefrom is not immoral: it doesn't make anyone any worse of than they'd be had the creator/owner not existed. [ . . . ] Ownership of that which is provided by nature, and income therefrom, on the other hand, is immoral, because it necessarily deprives others of what they would have, had it not been for the "owner": the providence of nature. There is no just basis for ownership of that which nature provides.
Couldn't you have done this before . . . ?
?? Ownership of land enables the owners of land to collect what others, namely, society and the government, create.
 
Free Thinkr said:
LOL! That's a pretty big error for someone who claims to understand economics. In fact increasing maximal zoned density increases land value.
It demonstrably didn't. The value of the five+ acre lots dropped substantially.
But, as you admit below, the lots which benefit from the increased density allowance -the smaller lots- increased in value.

So, just as I said: increases in zoning allowances enable landowners to get more money, not less.

It went up, of course.
Of course!

But you're now averaging apples and oranges and claiming that if the price of oranges goes up, that proves that apples just became more valuable.
No. Land is land. The lot size is just an arbitrary subdivision, and the zoning rules are just arbitrary usage allowances. The increased zoning allowance cause land as a whole -that is, aggregate land rents- to increase.

Frankly, this story of yours reeks anyways. What about an 8-acre lot? Couldn't it just be divided into two 4-acre lots, and then be worth far more than before? I doubt you'll be providing any details on this supposed event.

So once again, you're wrong.
Predictably, it is again you who is wrong.
 
See edits which were added momentarily before you posted.
Ok. Still as wrong as before. The government/community produced the value (really, just the community, as the government is funded by the community). So to whom does the value rightfully belong:

A. the community who created it
B. landowners

Take your time; this is a real brain-buster.

Value is the V in LVT. No part of it is "immoral".
Other than landowners being privileged by the government to collect the value the community created, you mean?

Other than the fact that landowners effectively own part-shares in millions of part-time slaves called "taxpayers," you mean?
 
Ok. Still as wrong as before. The government/community produced the value (really, just the community, as the government is funded by the community). So to whom does the value rightfully belong:

A. the community who created it
B. landowners
The answer to that is B in this case.

You would need to be a utopian socialist to believe that the positive value of everything created by the community should benefit the community collectively. You claim not to be, but that is what you are. Which is fine--but you really should say so. (Typically, advocates of utopian socialism deny it)
 
Last edited:
The answer to that is B in this case.
Why, if the community produced the value, should the landowners be privileged to collect it? Remember, you're not just saying it's expedient: you're saying it's right.

You would need to be a utopian socialist to believe that the positive value of everything created by the community should benefit the community collectively. You claim not to be, but that is what you are. Which is fine--but you really should say so. (Typically, advocates of utopian socialism deny it)
LOL. You've just realized I've backed you into a corner, and now you've decided you'd best switch to a strategy of using ad hominem arguments.

There's nothing Utopian socialist about using the fund naturally created by the community to disburse government spending; in point of fact, your own country implemented such a system in Hong Kong when it took over the island after WW2. The result of that system has been what economists who don't understand the nature of the land market call a "miracle."

Aside from being an ad hominem argument, it's just a lie to call me a Socialist; I'm strongly for individual rights to what they create: including capital.
 
No. Land is land.

Yeah, and fruit is fruit. The difference between apples is just an arbitrary biological division.

I'm really glad that you're continuing to hammer on this point, though, because it makes it clear just how irrational one needs to be in order to support your version of LVT theory.
 
Yeah, and fruit is fruit.
If we're discussing fruit, obviously the discussion includes both apples and oranges.

We weren't discussing parcels of land of more or less than 5 acres: we were discussing land, period.

The difference between apples is just an arbitrary biological division.
Actually, the difference between apples and oranges is not arbitrary. Perhaps you should consult a dictionary.

See how sad you're becoming? This inevitably happens when anti-Georgists dispute with Georgists.

I'm really glad that you're continuing to hammer on this point, though, because it makes it clear just how irrational one needs to be in order to support your version of LVT theory.
Hahah! Mirror time. Seriously. I have Francesca claiming that the community creates land value, but somehow landowners are rightfully entitled to it, and you claiming that the difference between apples and oranges is arbitrary!

Time to stop and think.
 
I have Francesca claiming that the community creates land value, but somehow landowners are rightfully entitled to it, and you claiming that the difference between apples and oranges is arbitrary!

Time to stop and think.

In all but hardline communist societies the "community" is built of those who lve and work in the area (or state or country), landowners, tenants, freeloaders whoever. The community comprises of those people who use the land to live, work, farm or just admire. The community and the landowners are essentially one and the same, you are creating an artificial distinction between the two.

Steve
 
Why, if the community produced the value, should the landowners be privileged to collect it? Remember, you're not just saying it's expedient: you're saying it's right.
Expedient and right in the realm of land value. If someone, or even "the community", builds an apartment block next to my grocery store, I don't compensate them for the extra customer flow that ultimately increases my profits, or the higher resale value of my property right in the store itself.

Aside from being an ad hominem argument, it's just a lie to call me a Socialist; I'm strongly for individual rights to what they create: including capital.
Hardly. Your views on LVT are borne of utopian socialism. Granted you might not apply the same belief to everything, but that would be you being expedient. You can say my views on it are borne of private property title rights and capitalism and that wouldn't be an ad-hom. I'd agree with it. Moreover you're entitled to have utopian socialist views, but I am entitled to highlight them and disagree with them.

If you think it's an ad hominem attack, report my post.
 
Last edited:
In all but hardline communist societies the "community" is built of those who lve and work in the area (or state or country), landowners, tenants, freeloaders whoever. The community comprises of those people who use the land to live, work, farm or just admire. The community and the landowners are essentially one and the same, you are creating an artificial distinction between the two.

Steve
The distinction's not artificial at all. Sure, the landowners are part of the community, but only the landowners collect the land rents.
 
Expedient and right in the realm of land value. If someone, or even "the community", builds an apartment block next to my grocery store, I don't compensate them for the extra customer flow that ultimately increases my profits, or the higher resale value of my property right in the store itself.
You haven't explained how that's right.

Hardly. Your views on LVT are borne of utopian socialism.
False. The underlying ideology was first identified by the French physiocrats. Not socialists.

Granted you might not apply the same belief to everything, but that would be you being expedient.
No, because my ideology doesn't say that workers should control the means of production.

It's therefore simply inaccurate to call me a socialist. I suggest you apologize to me for lying about my beliefs, and to the forum for making a fallacious argument.

You can say my views on it are borne of private property title rights and capitalism and that wouldn't be an ad-hom. I'd agree with it.
You may agree or disagree, but factually, making the argument about you, rather than what you wrote, would still be a an ad hominem argument in either case.

Moreover you're entitled to have utopian socialist views, but I am entitled to highlight them and disagree with them.
Sure, but that's not what you did. You made me, personally, the focus of the argument. You did so because you can find no support for your contention that landowners are rightfully entitled to the land value the community creates.
 
Last edited:
Actually, the difference between apples and oranges is not arbitrary.

And the difference between lots that are large enough to build on and lots that are not large enough to build on is also not arbitrary. Which explains why the price of one can fall while the price of the other rises, and only by taking an unsupported average can you maintain your belief that they're interchangeable.

See how sad you're becoming? This inevitably happens when anti-Georgists dispute with Georgists.

It inevitably does. The Georgists find their arguments shredded beyond repair by the anti-Georgists and start resorting to insults, ad-hominem attacks, and whining to forum administrators about how unfair it is that people are not taking their gibberish seriously and are instead batting them around like intellectual cat toys.

Just remember, the longer you squirm, the longer people get to see what a fool you're making of yourself. We did that experiment already in this thread, but I'm willing to repeat it -- if there's anyone who thinks Free Thinkr has reason on his side, feel free to pipe up.

I assume you'll be reporting this post as well.

Don't you get tired of being wrong about everything?

Yeah, well,.... I have real work to do. Papers to publish and so forth. So I'll leave you for the other sharks to finish off; Francesca, as usual, has you well in hand.
 
And the difference between lots that are large enough to build on and lots that are not large enough to build on is also not arbitrary.
But that's not what we're talking about. We're talking about land as a whole.

You introduced the distinction of lot size in an effort to avoid knowing the point.

Which explains why the price of one can fall while the price of the other rises, and only by taking an unsupported average can you maintain your belief that they're interchangeable.
Well, you haven't supplied any data nor any other evidence for your claims, so I'm good with that.

It inevitably does. The Georgists find their arguments shredded beyond repair by the anti-Georgists and start resorting to insults, ad-hominem attacks, and whining to forum administrators about how unfair it is that people are not taking their gibberish seriously and are instead batting them around like intellectual cat toys.
LOL. Which one of us has resorted to bluster and ad hominems?

Just keep on projectin'.

Just remember, the longer you squirm, the longer people get to see what a fool you're making of yourself. We did that experiment already in this thread, but I'm willing to repeat it -- if there's anyone who thinks Free Thinkr has reason on his side, feel free to pipe up.

I assume you'll be reporting this post as well.

Don't you get tired of being wrong about everything?

Yeah, well,.... I have real work to do. Papers to publish and so forth. So I'll leave you for the other sharks to finish off; Francesca, as usual, has you well in hand.
Good idea. This was really getting embarrassing for you. Every time you put an actual economic argument forth, I demolished with ease. I quick bit of bluster and an exit was certainly the only logical choice (other than admitting you're wrong, of course, which can never happen).
 
The underlying ideology was first identified by the French physiocrats. Not socialists.
That hardly matters. Faraday was a chemist, ergo electromagnetic induction is chemistry. Da Vinci was an artist, therefore the hang-glider is a painting. (Adam) Smith was a moral philosopher, therefore "Wealth of Nations" is philosophy. While we're at it, Henry George was a newspaper editor so Georgism is print media. Well the last one might be right.

It's therefore simply inaccurate to call me a socialist. I suggest you apologize to me for lying about my beliefs, and to the forum for making a fallacious argument.
Respectfully declined; please pursue this via the report channel.
 
That hardly matters. Faraday was a chemist, ergo electromagnetic induction is chemistry. Da Vinci was an artist, therefore the hang-glider is a painting. (Adam) Smith was a moral philosopher, therefore "Wealth of Nations" is philosophy. While we're at it, Henry George was a newspaper editor so Georgism is print media. Well the last one might be right.
You said my ideology was borne from socialism. That claim was factually inaccurate: it was developed by the predecessors of classical economics.

You are just flat-out wrong. Furthermore, what actually does matter is what socialism is, and whether or not the label accurately describes me. Socialism actually is worker control of means of production; I am not for worker control of all capital, therefore I'm not a socialist.

So you're actually wrong twice, in addition to arguing a fallacy.

Respectfully declined; please pursue this via the report channel.
I figured you wouldn't do the right thing. I won't even bother reporting you: the the existence of your post is punishment enough, as everyone can see you inaccurately name-calling, like a child.

Maybe it's time to follow drkitten's lead and lay down a thick layer of bluster and make a speedy escape. You know I'll demolish any economic argument you make, after all.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom