"We are going to see the worst depression in the history..."

You do eventually have to hoard the oil, or pay to have it stored when it is delivered. You cant keep rolling ever-increasing futures positions.

And people were hoarding houses. Just not for very long in some cases. (Might be hedging contracts available on the Case-Shiller index . . . not sure, but I seriously doubt that would have been driving the (US) housing market if there are)

and the contracts were sold to refineries in most cases where it was made into gas and sold to the consumer at $4 an gallon
 
and when everything leveled out the bubble burst and we saw 1.75 gas over christmas

*edit for spelling
 
Last edited:
BTW Shiller (of "Irrational Exuberance" notoriety) made a stong case for perpetual cash-settled hedging contracts to be available on local housing values, as well as on national income and a number of other currently missing markets for trading/pooling significant risks.
 
Thats incorrect for most contracts.

When you hold most contracts that come due you are obligated to take delivery.

That's right. When I buy a stove from Best Buy, I'm obligated to take delivery.

About the only type of contract for which I am NOT obligated to take delivery is the cash-settled futures contracts, as you can tell from the name (it's settled in cash, not via delivery).

And it's also the dominant form of futures contract. If you want to dabble in the futures market, you will have a difficult time finding a broker who will even sell you a contract that obligates you to take delivery, precisely because no one wants to have ten zillion barrels of oil.

Even the oil companies tend to use the cash-settled futures contract, because they don't want to deal with the hassles. So what they tend to do is buy oil at whatever price seems reasonable at the time and then use a cash-settled futures contract to offset (or increase) the price as the market sets.

For example, the company buys a contract for oil at $40 a barrel (from you, say). When they actually need to take physical possession of the oil, it costs them $50. But at the same time they're paying $50/bbl at the well-head, the futures contract is due and you owe them $10/bbl, so the net cost to them is the agreed $40. If the spot price were $55, you'd owe them $15. And if the spot price were $35, they'd only pay $35 spot price, but they'd also have to pay you $5, so the net cost is still $40.

And that's why futures contracts for commodities are universally cash-settled.
 
OT but

BTW you were asking what "predator friendly" meant....here you go....from a poster on another forum.....

Got a phone call from a debt collector yesterday, looking for my youngest daughter. She defaulted on a motorcycle loan 6 months or so ago and they repossessed the bike. Now, the sons-of-bitches lent a 19 year old (without a steady job) $7000 for a bike that was worth maybe $3500, at 18% interest. When she couldn't pay they sold it at auction, for $300. Ok, she shouldn't have taken the loan, it was stupid and short-sighted. But now they want the remainder of the loan paid to them, plus interest, and the amount is now over 8Gs. I told them to go pound sand up their ass, I wasn't going to give them my daughter's number or address and didn't give a **** if they lost their money, it was their own bloody fault for making the loan in the first place. They blustered and moaned and threatened legal action, I told them to bring it on, they can get a judgment and garnish her $7.00 an hour wages. ****ing ********.

How many PayDay Loan places are near YOU??? :garfield:
 
Thats incorrect for most contracts.

When you hold most contracts that come due you are obligated to take delivery.

And if you don't want to take delivery of the oil you have to sell your oil on to someone who actually wants it at whatever the spot price is on that day? In which case you may well make a loss because you have to settle at the price of the the contract you bought some months ago which in a falling market will be higher than you get spot. Isn't this one of the classic reasons given for why oil, gas and electricity prices tend to come down slowly as it takes time for all the forward postions to unwind and if (as many appear to have done) the company has read the market wrong then they're still stuck with the high price for some time to come (at least that's the excuse BG always give).

Steve
 
They're not though. NYMEX crude futures are physical settlement. You have to close out the position if you don't want an oil tanker on your lawn, seriously.

Interesting. Unusual. (Even by the standards of the contracts -- if you look at the page you cited, they list zillions of cash-settled futures contracts that they offer precisely to prevent this.)

However, the simple fact that you don't want an oil tanker on your lawn makes it effectively a cash-settled future contract unless you have the (rather expensive) facilities to park that oil tanker.
 
Last edited:
Rubbish. The demand for housing increased faster than the supply (some of it was speculative). Little to do with land.
Wrong. Inevitably.

http://markwadsworth.blogspot.com/2008/11/investing-in-bricks-and-mortar-2.html

From the link:
housepricecomponents830.jpg
 
Wrong at several levels. People buying "housing" aren't buying "land."
Actually, they inarguably are (houses rest on land). They're also buying location.

For instance, tearing down farmland for single-family housing developments puts new housing onto the same amount of land, which tends to produce an increase in supply and a drop in prices.

Tearing down single family houses for apartment buildings does the same thing.

And, of course, zoning previously unusable land for residences does the same thing.

Of course, if the demand continues to increase faster than the (increased) supply, we'll still see price increase -- which is what actually happened in the reality-influenced world.
Nope. Construction costs didn't rise dramatically. The dramatic increase was due to the increased demand on a fixed supply, and the speculative influence of seemingly-limitless increases in anticipated future gain.
 
What they WERE buying was a future value which far too many bought into.
It was speculation plain and simply fueled by realtors and financiers.

That's what a bubble is...irrational exuberance...we are now paying the price collectively.
 
When we first bought a house (UK) we were expected to have 10% deposit and the maximum loan was approx three times the main income and, if lucky, half any second income. That effectively capped house prices. Once conditions were relaxed (we got an offer before this last crisis of five times joint income and I could self-certify my bit as I'm self-employed) then prices could and did rocket as not only were there lots of buyers they had mortgage offers which meant that silly prices were available if you as a buyer held out for them. How to fuel a bubble in one easy stage!

Steve

PS We didn't take the offer, we did the sums and decided that we had better ways of spending that amount of money each month.
 
What rubbish. The land values are imputed from house prices because house prices are what you can observe and measure. And what people bought and sold.

Yes but the price of building land is also worked out from what the final houses are expected to sell at. Certainly in Hull the price of land has gone up in tandem with the cost of housing (and has yet to fall, it's just not selling) so it's a bit chicken and egg.

You also get perverse effects where a developer was trying to persuade my mother-in-law and seven neighbours to sell their bungalows in Kent because they all had huge gardens. He was offering a premium of £100,000 each over the value of the properties sold seperately because if he could get all eight he could build 20 plus properties on the land. They didn't sell anyway as to them (and they're mainly elderley) they didn't want to move and didn't need the money.

Steve
 
When the going gets tough....

When in trouble
When in doubt
Run in circles
Scream and shout
 
What rubbish. The land values are imputed from house prices because house prices are what you can observe and measure. And what people bought and sold.
Wrong again. The same house or apartment building in two different locations will generally have differing values. Why? Because people are paying for location every bit as much as they're paying for the house itself.

That's why the Realtor credo is "location, location, location."

You are wrong, and the chart I provided as well as the facts of the real estate market prove it. Don't you get tired of being proved wrong every time you presume to debate with me on this topic?
 
Location is not land. Location has little to do with land. Location has to do with things rather different from land.

Also posting blogs from Georgists does not get you to the first base of "proof".

Don't you get tired of being wrong about everything?

Actually you are not wrong about everything, but the Georgist ideas are whackjob stuff.
 
The carmakers needed to borrow cash to pay the bills, and then it turned out the carmakers couldn't even afford to repay the loan, so... the banks are to blame!

Are you serious?

Fly by night home loan companies started loaning money to people who couldn't afford to pay it back. Wall Street was buying these bundled up loans, fueling the fire. The risk assessment was based on flawed models, models based on an ever increasing market. The SEC turned a blind eye to what was going on. Millions of loans worth Billions of dollars were made to the wrong people. The economy slowed, the first thing to go was large ticket items such as cars. The only reason they survived as long as they did was the fact that many people needed cars to get to work, having moved to homes outside of the city ;) As things slowed even more, the homes started getting repossessed.

The automakers are a victim of this. There's no doubt they contributed to their own demise, but the real problem is there is no money. If it were simply a matter of not competing with the Japanese they wouldn't be posting losses like they are.

If you consider what happened to cars during the same period these home loans were being made, cars got cheaper, houses got more expensive. With houses being more "exepensive" the problem was twofold. First, people who really couldn't afford the loans were stuck with them and their increasing hidden rates. Second, people who could afford the houses ended up borrowing against equity that didn't really exist. Either as a second mortgage or on credit cards.

So yes, it's the banks fault no one can repay their loans. That's what happens when you make bad loans.
 
Location is not land. Location has little to do with land. Location has to do with things rather different from land.
Location is an inseparable property of land. It's probably the most important aspect of land.

Also posting blogs from Georgists does not get you to the first base of "proof".
Sorry, you're just flat-out wrong. Wait, no, I'm not sorry.

The fact that the Realtor's credo is "location, location, location" just proves how laughably wrong you are. Literally, you couldn't be more wrong.

Don't you get tired of being wrong about everything?
Fail. Bluster doesn't cover how badly I've demolished your point.

Actually you are not wrong about everything, but the Georgist ideas are whackjob stuff.
Mm. That's why at least 4 Nobel Laureates in economics advocate land value taxation, right? Because it's "whackjob" stuff? Please. You just think it is because you're so cocksure of your economic knowledge, even though it's plainly evident you haven't given much thought to the spacial aspect in which human production and exchange takes place.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom