Ward Churchill

<hijack>


If we sign a treaty (such as the treaties that created the UN) we are required by federal law to uphold that treaty. International law may be a fantasy, but once we ratify a treaty, it isn't international law; it's federal law.
</hijack>
A good demonstration of "The Law is an Ass". Enforcement may be tricky, since the Exec controls the military. I missed hearing about the judiciary raising an army to enforce their fiats.
 
Some of the quibbling was over a claim that the US killed indians with smallpox infected blankets, certainly widely reported by other academics who aren't getting investigated.

The only case I can think of of that happening was when a Swiss mercenary, under British command, deliberately delivered smallpox-infected blankets to the Delaware Indians during the French and Indian War, in the 1750s. But since the image of American Cavalrymen in blue uniforms leaving such blankets for the Lakota and the Cheyenne sounds correct, it's taken as such. Doesn't mean it's true.
 
The age of Superpowers is over. Splitting the US and China into geopolitical entities the size of Denmark would be a great gift to future generations.

They said the same thing about Austria-Hungary at the end of WW1. Look what happened there.
 
If it was just that he was a d**khead who cheered the 9/11 attacks, that would be no reason to fire him. But it turns out that he had simply lied about his background and achievements in order to get his job, so I say, fire him.
Exactly.

I find the hysterics over this guy pretty funny. It's clear to me that nobody discussing the issue actually read his work (no, I haven't read them either. I don't care.) Maybe he wrote horrible things, or maybe he wrote a great paper and just made a really terrible analogy. Nobody thinks the papers are important enough to actually read, but everyone wants to have an opinion about them. When did we all suddenly become little Ann Coulters?

This bears repeating: the papers that everyone is upset about aren't important enough for them to read.
 
I've already started. My plans to secede and create my own country shall soon come to fruition.... very soon. It shall be called "ARubberChickenWithaPulleyintheMiddloria."

President for life.

You know what I don't much care for the tone of some of your replies. As the newly appointed emporer for life of Valisland I hearby declare war of ARubberChickenWithaPulleyintheMiddloria.

As soon as I figure out how to attack you from my kingdom here in Florida you are in big trouble! :)
 
There is some truth here, but the extent of criminal activity by US Soldiers is something you or I do not know. I think that in any conflict involving thousands of soldiers over a prolonged period, there would be numerous instances of wrongful killing- intentional or not. I'm not sure this invalidates the purpose of the conflict; although it certainly reveals certain weaknesses in planning and frontline discipline.

And please note that we consider this conduct to be a scandal and that the persons involved are being prosecuted. That is far different from us approving of someone blowing up a mosque or setting a bomb off in the middle of a crowded market.
 
The big problem I have with Ward Churchill's analysis is that the CIA office, the military's power is not what the terrorists were really hoping to dismantle. They were simply trying to kill civilians and attack big icons to make the public scared.

As far as has come to my knowledge, the terrorists never expressed the sort of ambitions which Ward has dreamed up for them.
 
ghostwriting = plagiarism?

As for citing a ghostwritten paper in one of his own, I'm not sure a substantial body of evidence exists one way or another on whether that is a horrible offense, if it is not the sole support for a conclusion one is reaching.

Ghostwriting in academia equals plagiarism. I'm a professor in the Univ California system and I can't imagine that having someone write a paper for you without attribution (ie, ghostwriting) wouldn't result in an Academic Senate investigation of your research. In academia, this is simply fraud.
 
...I can't imagine that having someone write a paper for you without attribution (ie, ghostwriting) wouldn't result in an Academic Senate investigation of your research. In academia, this is simply fraud.

The finding - at least for the allegation that I have read - was kind of the opposite. In his essay, "Perversions of Justice,” Churchill cites other essays he had previously claimed to have ghostwritten to support his conclusions. In other words, he used a sockpuppet to butress his cliams.

From Page 24:

The course of the Committee’s inquiry into Professor Churchill’s alleged misrepresentation of the provisions of the General Allotment Act of 1887 explains much about its findings. It began by looking at the sources Professor Churchill cited to support the paragraph quoted at the start of this allegation, the most elaborated version of his General Allotment Act claim. The Committee immediately noted a number of quite unconventional aspects to Professor Churchill’s use of sources. Footnotes 63 and 64 of his “Perversions of Justice,” in Struggle for the Land (1993 edition), contain basically three sources to support the claims regarding the General Allotment Act of 1887. All appear to the reader to be reputable, independent third-party sources. First, Professor Churchill cites directly to the originally enacted version of the General Allotment Act of 1887, which, as noted above, contains absolutely no express support for his statement since it only employs the word “Indian.” Not only is his statement unsupported by his source, but also more significantly, he did not follow the referencing convention that a lawyer or historian citing a lengthy statute for a particular detail normally would follow, which is to pinpoint the precise section number of the multi-section statute that supported his claim. As one will see throughout this report, this general reference to an apparent independent source in its entirety constitutes an unconventional referencing style frequently employed by Professor Churchill to create the appearance of independent support for his claims, while simultaneously discouraging or, at least, making far more difficult, any effort by other researchers to check his claims by failing to pinpoint the precise location of his claimed support in an otherwise lengthy work. Standing alone, this referencing failure might constitute some level of sloppiness, but certainly would not constitute research misconduct. When it is combined with a pattern of other misconduct reflected in this and other allegations, however, the Committee is left with a firm impression, by a preponderance of the evidence, that it constituted part of a deliberate research stratagem to create the appearance of independent verifiable support for claims that could not be supported through existing primary and secondary sources. To put it most simply, it was part of a pattern and consistent research stratagem to cloak extreme, unsupportable, propaganda-like claims of fact that support Professor Churchill’s legal and political claims with the aura of authentic scholarly research by referencing apparently (but not actually) supportive independent third-party sources. The next problem discussed with these two footnotes makes this stratagem far clearer.

The other two apparently independent third-party sources cited in footnotes 63 and 64 are essays published in the same volume, The State of Native America, one under the name of a person named Rebecca Robbins and the other under the name of M. Annette Jaimes, the editor of the volume.33 Since both essays do contain statements of the type that Professor Churchill claims, that might have put an end to the matter of research misconduct regarding this allegation, except for the fact that in response to the separate allegation that he had plagiarized the Robbins essay in another later published piece, Professor Churchill said in Submission E that he had in fact ghostwritten both the Robbins and the Jaimes essays, in full. He continued to adhere to that position in his discussion with our Committee, claiming that he wrote both pieces “from the ground up."

Emphasis mine.

O what a wicked web we weave...
 
academic misconduct (of some kind ... probably)

The finding - at least for the allegation that I have read - was kind of the opposite. In his essay, "Perversions of Justice,” Churchill cites other essays he had previously claimed to have ghostwritten to support his conclusions. In other words, he used a sockpuppet to butress his cliams.

O what a wicked web we weave...

A wicked web indeed. This looks like a quite involved, twisted mess of dependencies in the writing. Too bad I'm not going to read the thing...

Glad he's not in my department!
 
This bears repeating: the papers that everyone is upset about aren't important enough for them to read.

The papers that were important to CU Regents was read, documented and cited in their report linked above. His behavior would not pass muster in many serious internet fora and it should not pass muster for a department chair at a university of Cu's caliber.

Even here at JREF, sock-puppetry is a violation of Rule 7 and plagiarism is a violation of Rule 4.

As pointed out in the report, faking data in a hard science report would never be tolerated - even if your ultimate conclusion is verified by other means. For CU's policy on academic freedom, rightness or wrongness is not a factor in standard of scholarship - it is judged purely on the method by which a rational person determines proof.

Lying and stealing fall well short of those standards.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom