Ward Churchill

Sorry for the hijack folks.

The rules of war apply to soldiers fighting in a foreign land, but they do not apply to homeland defense. International law considers homeland defense so important, that any means is justified to repel an unlawful invader, including terrorism, and chemical and biological weapons.

Really. I would love to see a citation on this, because no International Law that I am familiar with says anything about "homeland defense" allowing for the use of any means, including biological or chemical weapons. What "International Law" are you referring to? The Hague Convention? The Geneva Convention? The UN Charter? It sounds to me like you're making stuff up right now.

For this reason, we should regard all Iraqis dead at the hands of the US military as murder victims, and dead US soldiers, by whatever means produced, as the lawful act of citizens resisting an illegal occupation of their homeland.

Ugh. So now we move the goalposts to all dead Iraqis becoming murder victims, thus avoiding having to defend the wild assumptions you made in your last post. Funny that a lot of the Iraqis shooting at US soldiers are also shooting at other Iraqis. I suppose they are just defending their homeland too? Are they justified in driving a truck bomb into a crowded market full of civilians, since that is also an act of "defending the homeland." ??
 
Really. I would love to see a citation on this, because no International Law that I am familiar with says anything about "homeland defense" allowing for the use of any means, including biological or chemical weapons. What "International Law" are you referring to? The Hague Convention? The Geneva Convention? The UN Charter? It sounds to me like you're making stuff up right now.

Yup - it's pretty much made up. Putting aside the issues of the chemical weapons ban for a moment, Article 4 of the Third Geneva Convention specifies who must be treated as lawful combatants. There are two categories that consist of non-regular forces:

Paragraph (2):
Members of other militias and members of other volunteer corps, including those of organized resistance movements, belonging to a Party to the conflict and operating in or outside their own territory, even if this territory is occupied, provided that such militias or volunteer corps, including such organized resistance movements, fulfil the following conditions:

(a) that of being commanded by a person responsible for his subordinates;

(b) that of having a fixed distinctive sign recognizable at a distance;

(c) that of carrying arms openly;

(d) that of conducting their operations in accordance with the laws and customs of war.

Paragraph (6)
Inhabitants of a non-occupied territory, who on the approach of the enemy spontaneously take up arms to resist the invading forces, without having had time to form themselves into regular armed units, provided they carry arms openly and respect the laws and customs of war.

In both cases (occupied vs. non-occupied territory), battlefield immunity is only granted to those who "carry their arms openly" and "respect the laws and customs of war."
 
The only relation between the US/Iraq War and Ward Churchill is that the latter is being harrassed because of his views on the former.

Even if this were true, a point you have not yet successfully made, it still doesn't amount to a justification for lying, falsification, fabrication, and plagiarism.

If we had held Dr. Martin Luther King to the same plagiarism standards that are being applied to Ward Churchill, he'd be Mr. Martin Luther King,

You know, I'm cool with that. Do you really think that the reason Dr. King was a successful activist was because of his tenured professorship at the University of Colorado?
 
That's part of the Neoconservative doctrine of moral superiority. When we do something, it isn't the same as someone else doing the same thing, because we are doing it for a more noble purpose.

Just because you state it, alas, does not make it so.

Moral equivalence is a shaky doctrine precisely because it does not make distinction between motive and result. per your reasoning every road accident that results in death is the same as a terrorist bombing - after all the result is the same, dead people.



Dead people are dead people. There is fundamentally little difference between someone with few technically advanced military assets blowing something up, and us flying overhead in a billion dollar plane, at no risk to ourselves, and blowing something up.

roflmao! That's the best you have? It would be less equivalent if there were more risk??

wow.
 
Is the global financial nexus of a superpower which has, as the global situation has changed to make it more difficult for it to exert hegemony over the rest of the world through financial intimidation, resorted more and more to direct military force, a legitimate military target? .
By wording everything in the form of a question, you insinuate a position without actually taking one.

If Ward, or you by insinuation, wish to assign guilt to the 911 victims, at least assign the guilt equitably:

First, there's nothing special about the financial institutions that were located at the WTC. All financial institutions are equally guilty. (Applying WC reasoning that is.)

Second, the customers and stockholders of the financial institutions are surely just as culpable as the employees. This means that anyone who has a bank account or a credit card is also a "little Eichmann".

Lastly, to be fair here, I don't see why the the general population gets a free ride, seeing as they fund this evil enterprise by paying taxes to it. And while many may claim ignorance -- and rightly so I think -- the worst of the lot are the ones that are aware they are funding evil, yet continue to do so.

So far so good?

That said, I hope that neither you nor WC have a bank account, credit card, or pay taxes otherwise it would be hypocritical on a grand scale, and that would make you little Eichmanns of the worst kind.
 
The entire Iraq war is a crime. It is an illegal war of aggression, in violation of international law,
Why don't you alert the appropriate law enforcement authorities?

Or better yet, raise an army and enforce it yourself. Idiot.
 
I hope that neither you nor WC have a bank account, credit card, or pay taxes otherwise it would be hypocritical on a grand scale, and that would make you little Eichmanns of the worst kind.
Cyphermage, please enlighten me. Do you have a bank account? A credit card? Do you pay taxes? (Ward does, I assume.) Are you too a little Eichmann of the worst kind, knowingly fueling "the mighty engine of profit"?

And will you cite some of the "other academics" you referred to? (3rd request)
 
Why don't you alert the appropriate law enforcement authorities?

Or better yet, raise an army and enforce it yourself. Idiot.

Well, of course, when the world's sole remaining superpower violates international law and defies the UN, there isn't a whole lot the rest of the world can do about it, except sit and spin.

Rumsfeld has admitted the Iraq war was illegal.

The appropriate law enforcement authorities have been alerted. Ramsey Clark has been trying to get Bush indicted as a war criminal since this thing started.

Suggesting it isn't wrong if you can get away with it, sort of replaces international law with "might makes right," which of course, is the way the PNAC folks view the world.

Their basic thesis boils down to the following.

1. Political change can be accomplished by military force.

2. Overwhelming military force can be achieved by advanced technology.
 
By wording everything in the form of a question, you insinuate a position without actually taking one.

If Ward, or you by insinuation, wish to assign guilt to the 911 victims, at least assign the guilt equitably:

First, there's nothing special about the financial institutions that were located at the WTC. All financial institutions are equally guilty. (Applying WC reasoning that is.)

Second, the customers and stockholders of the financial institutions are surely just as culpable as the employees. This means that anyone who has a bank account or a credit card is also a "little Eichmann".

Lastly, to be fair here, I don't see why the the general population gets a free ride, seeing as they fund this evil enterprise by paying taxes to it. And while many may claim ignorance -- and rightly so I think -- the worst of the lot are the ones that are aware they are funding evil, yet continue to do so.

So far so good?

That said, I hope that neither you nor WC have a bank account, credit card, or pay taxes otherwise it would be hypocritical on a grand scale, and that would make you little Eichmanns of the worst kind.


I've always felt the notion that civilians bore no responsibility for the actions of their government was an oversimplification. In WWII, both sides targeted civilian populations to "demoralize" the enemy. Hell, we even blew up the civilian populations of two cities wth nuclear weapons.

I realize that my participation in the financial infrastructure of an immoral society makes me partially responsible for its actions. If I am ever vaporized by an Iraqi retaliatory strike, I won't hold it against them.
 
Well, of course, when the world's sole remaining superpower violates international law and defies the UN, there isn't a whole lot the rest of the world can do about it, except sit and spin.
You do understand realpolitic.

Rumsfeld has admitted the Iraq war was illegal.
Cite?

Suggesting it isn't wrong if you can get away with it, sort of replaces international law with "might makes right," which of course, is the way the PNAC folks view the world.
International Law: a figment in the imagination of all good liberal, do-nothing-but-blather, appeasers.

Their basic thesis boils down to the following.

1. Political change can be accomplished by military force.

2. Overwhelming military force can be achieved by advanced technology.
Kewl. You understand that too. What's not to like ... or do? Where is your army?
 
Sometimes you have to think of the greater good for the greater number, even if it means cutting an imperfect activist a bit of extra slack.

The view here is that, in order to achieve some worthy goal, it is OK to tolerate "imperfection" in the "activists" which will perform it.

The more important and worthy the goal, of course, the more "imperefection" is to be tolerated from the "activists" in the meantime, since, under the "greater good for the greater number" view of morality (which means nothing is moraly bad in itself) future good will cancel out, or justify, present evil--and the greater the future good someone promises, the more present evil they can do and still be on the "plus" side.

The result of such thinking is usually the love of tyranny, and support of the "imperfect activists" of the Robspierre (to say nothing of the Stalin) type. True, they killed a few lousy millions of people, but you need to cut them some slack--how else is the socialist utopia / age of reason / eternal happiness of all mankind is to be achieved? This future good is so good, nothing in the meantime matters--as long, of course, as the dead are nobody I know.
 
but he has successfully refuted everything they've thrown at him so far.

That's interesting. Could you please point me to where he has refuted the charges that he invented his ethnic identity as a Native American?
 
That's part of the Neoconservative doctrine of moral superiority. When we do something, it isn't the same as someone else doing the same thing, because we are doing it for a more noble purpose.

In WWII, both sides bombed cities, killed enemies, put those they considered politically unreliable in concentration camps, and did many other nasty things. But one side did it for a noble purpose, and the other side did it for an evil purpose. This made quite a bit of difference as to the moral status of both sides.

Similarly, in the cold war, both sides armed themselves with nuclear weapons, used brinkmanship, and spied on each other. But one side did it for the goal (officially at least) of a worldwide Marxist dictatorship, while the other did it for the goal (officially at least) of a worldwide democracy. That made quite a bit of difference in the moral status of both sides, a difference that remains immesurable even if one admits, of course, that the actual motives were murkier than this sketch allows. Intent matters in ethics.

What I don't understand, however, is why YOU, the champion of "the greatest good for the greatest number", would find any fault whatever with (your version of) the neocon's argument behavior. After all, if the goal is a democratic Iraq or world democracy or some other worthy goal, surely--as you said about Ward Churchill--one should "tolerate" a bit of "imperfection" in the "activists" (such as US soldiers) who are trying to bring this utopia about?

After all, "the greatest good for the greatest number" is not much more, in practice, than "the end justifies the means". And if this is so, the USA is not only morally better than the Islamic terrorists because intent matters, but purely blameless because intent--what your goal, or end, is--is all that matters.
 
Cyphermage, please enlighten me. Do you have a bank account? A credit card? Do you pay taxes? (Ward does, I assume.) Are you too a little Eichmann of the worst kind, knowingly fueling "the mighty engine of profit"?

And will you cite some of the "other academics" you referred to? (3rd request)
Just bumping since Cyphermage seems to have missed it.
 
With regard to Churchill's having "successfully refuted" the committee's charges: It's true that he responded to the charges, but if you read both the committee's report and his response, you'll see that he didn't actually refute any charges. He mischaracterized their report (in the case of his feud with another reasearcher), he claimed that they were out to get him, he said that everyone else does it (in the case of so-called ghostwriting), but he never actually offered proof that there were any false statements in the report.
 
That's interesting. Could you please point me to where he has refuted the charges that he invented his ethnic identity as a Native American?

Well, I did see earlier in this thread that he claims it was based on family oral history, basically. In which case, it would mean that _he_ didn't invent it, although someone apparently did.

And to be fair, that's not an unreasonable claim, if true. If his family told him he was part Indian, should he run off and get a blood test to verify it?

There is no reason to doubt that, so far as he knew, he was part Native American, is there? You could ask his parents if they told him that, but then, I doubt anyone would actually believe them. If it was discovered later that he was misled in being part Indian, you can't say he "invented his ethnic identity." He was incorrect about it, sure, but it doesn't require that he lied. in order to show that, you would have to be able to verify that he _knew_ that he wasn't actually part Indian. Given that they did a blood test afterward tells me they didn't have the information beforehand.

I don't know much about Ward Churchill or any of the details surrounding him, but just from what I read in this thread, I have seen enough to address your challenge.
 
<hijack>
International Law: a figment in the imagination of all good liberal, do-nothing-but-blather, appeasers.
Article VI said:
This Constitution, and the laws of the United States which shall be made in pursuance thereof; and all treaties made, or which shall be made, under the authority of the United States, shall be the supreme law of the land; and the judges in every state shall be bound thereby, anything in the Constitution or laws of any State to the contrary notwithstanding.
If we sign a treaty (such as the treaties that created the UN) we are required by federal law to uphold that treaty. International law may be a fantasy, but once we ratify a treaty, it isn't international law; it's federal law.
</hijack>

As for the thread itself:
* Investigating a tenured professor because of his politics is unacceptable. Please provide evidence that Churchill was investigated because of his politics. Note that I do not think it's unacceptable to take a closer look at a tenured professor who is drawing attention to the university, so long as famous professors who you agree with are investigated just as closely.
* Regardless of the motivation of the investigation, once it has been conducted, it is right to follow through with the findings. From everything I've seen here, Churchill's conduct (specifically the ghostwriting and art plagiarism) was unacceptable, and he should be punished by the University for it. If he can prove that the investigation was politically motivated, the University should be punished for that conduct, equivalent to the separation of punishments for racial profiling from the punishments of individuals caught because of racial profiling.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom