Ward Churchill

Yes, it's appropriate to punish a person for research misconduct.

I don't see what the rest of the quotation has to do with it, or in what way this question is at all "interesting."

If Churchill committed research misconduct, he should be punished for it. The motivations of the investigators are irrelevant as long as their findings are factually adequate.

He should be investigated to the degree that other university researchers are investigated for the same type of thing, and punished to the degree other university researchers are punished when they are investigated and determined to have committed similar misconduct.

In this particular case, it appears that any misconduct would have flown under the radar, absent his political views.

Alan Dershowitz was investigated for lifting entire passages without attribution in his book, "The Case for Israel", and found not to have done anything punishment-worthy.
 
In this particular case, it appears that any misconduct would have flown under the radar, absent his political views.

I still don't see why that's relevant.

Let me repeat myself.

Research misconduct is unacceptable and should be punished.

Alan Dershowitz was investigated for lifting entire passages without attribution in his book, "The Case for Israel", and found not to have done anything punishment-worthy.

To my knowledge, Alan Dershowitz has never been a faculty member at the University of Colorado, so again, I fail to see the relevance.
 
You understand Churchill's statement. You defend his statement. But you don't have an opinion about it. I'm a bit confused.

Yes, you are a bit confused.

The ability to understand an opponent's argument is not a defense of it.

You must be one of those people who characterize anything short of condemnation of views you don't agree with by smearing it with the tired old "advocating and promoting" label.
 
I still don't see why that's relevant.

Let me repeat myself.

Research misconduct is unacceptable and should be punished.

Political profiling to cherrypick who to punish in a university is just as immoral as racial profiling to select people to be stopped on the highway. Even if "having crack in your car is unacceptable and should be punished."


To my knowledge, Alan Dershowitz has never been a faculty member at the University of Colorado, so again, I fail to see the relevance.

So are you saying the academic misconduct standards at the University of Colorado are higher or lower than those at Harvard University?
 
Even if "having crack in your car is unacceptable and should be punished."

Which doesn't mean that people caught with crack in their car should go free.

The courts have long experience with this sort of argument, and it simply doesn't fly.

So, again, I don't see the relevance.

At the risk of becoming repetitive:

Research misconduct is unacceptable and should be punished.

Let me know when you have a responsive counterargument to that.
 
Which doesn't mean that people caught with crack in their car should go free.

The courts have long experience with this sort of argument, and it simply doesn't fly.

The courts have ruled that you can't single people out based on race, religion, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, or their exercise of their First Amendment free speech rights, when fishing around to find someone who has committed a crime so you can punish them.

You also can't give greater punishments or longer sentences to people based on such characteristics.

It is patently evident from looking at the way the investigation of Ward Churchill was conducted, that it was merely a pretense to attack him for political views some didn't like. The mistakes he made are regularly made by other scholars, and are generally no big deal, aside from correcting them when they are uncovered.

This investigation itself solicited some of the complaints it investigated, went through Churchill's work with a fine-toothed comb, denied Churchill a timely opportunity to respond, and twisted minutia into mountains.
 
The courts have ruled that you can't single people out based on race, religion, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, or their exercise of their First Amendment free speech rights, when fishing around to find someone who has committed a crime so you can punish them.

The courts have also, however, ruled that just because someone has been singled out does not prevent the state from punishing them.

"Racial profiling" is not a defense in any jurisdiction I'm aware of. It is at best grounds for a separate lawsuit in civil court.

Do please let me know when you get a responsive answer to the statement I have now made three times upthread.

Or, more directly, let me ask you the following question:

Did Ward Churchill commit research misconduct?

If the answer is "yes," then there is no concievable circumstance under which he should not be punished.
 
Churchill even lied to get the job, didn't he? He's not even slightly American Indian.

Churchill believed family legends which suggested he was a small part Indian. Recent geneological tests have demonstrated that the bloodlines involved contain no indian DNA.

He was hired because he was a prominent activist for indian rights. At the time he made the claims of being an American indian, there was no concrete reason for him to believe he was in error.

I think the suggestion that claiming to be indian was the "reason he got the job" is a gross exaggeration.
 
Other scholars regularly copy other's artwork and sell it as their own?

There is no suggestion that Churchill engaged in the regular practice of taking the work of others, and passing it off as his own. If anything, he let others do that to him, by ghostwriting their papers, and copy-editing their work into publishable papers.
 
The courts have also, however, ruled that just because someone has been singled out does not prevent the state from punishing them.

"Racial profiling" is not a defense in any jurisdiction I'm aware of. It is at best grounds for a separate lawsuit in civil court.

Do please let me know when you get a responsive answer to the statement I have now made three times upthread.

Or, more directly, let me ask you the following question:

Did Ward Churchill commit research misconduct?

If the answer is "yes," then there is no concievable circumstance under which he should not be punished.

You just keep reciting your "talking point" and ignoring everything else that is said. Politically motivated attacks on people shouldn't be tolerated, and that is a more important issue that whether some publisher removed an attribution for a phamplet in one of his publications, or any of the other trivial acts on his part which are alleged.

Research misconduct is a continuum. Not a binary variable. Clearly it runs the gamut from the insignificant to the important.

Repeating "research misconduct should be punished" like a mechanical parrot isn't going to impress anyone.
 
You just keep reciting your "talking point" and ignoring everything else that is said.

That's because nothing else that has been said is relevant.

Politically motivated attacks on people shouldn't be tolerated,

I disagree. Whether the attack is politically motivated or not, if the allegations are true, then Ward Churchill has committed research misconduct and should be punished.

So unless you want to write some more irrelevant drivel for me to ignore, you might consider answering the question I posed earlier.

Did Ward Churchill commit research misconduct?
 
That's because nothing else that has been said is relevant.



I disagree. Whether the attack is politically motivated or not, if the allegations are true, then Ward Churchill has committed research misconduct and should be punished.

So unless you want to write some more irrelevant drivel for me to ignore, you might consider answering the question I posed earlier.

Did Ward Churchill commit research misconduct?

Again, you are simply performing the parrot function, and you are completely non-responsive to anything I've said in my posts.

The research misconduct he is accused of committing would not even be deemed worthy of investigation much less punishable in the first place, absent political motives.

The research misconduct is a surrogate issue, and his employment contract as a tenured professor is considered an inconvenient barrier to be circumvented by any means necessary.
 
Last edited:
If it was just that he was a d**khead who cheered the 9/11 attacks, that would be no reason to fire him. But it turns out that he had simply lied about his background and achievements in order to get his job, so I say, fire him.
 
As for the allegations about copied artwork, it's about paintings and drawings. If you google Ward Churchill copied art (I still can't post links), you'll find references to at least 4 pieces of his art that are obvious copies of earlier works.

The committee's report looks to me like it was written by a group of people trying hard to be fair and impartial and in my opinion succeeding. It was meticulously documented. They investigated only the 7 allegations they were asked to investigate (they didn't look over all his work with a "fine tooth comb"). It looks like the university was actually treating him better than everyone else, in terms of demanding good scholarship (until this flap occurred), by ignoring previous complaints. As for Churchill's reply, what did he say, really, besides "they're out to get me" and "everyone else does it"?
 
If it was just that he was a d**khead who cheered the 9/11 attacks, that would be no reason to fire him. But it turns out that he had simply lied about his background and achievements in order to get his job, so I say, fire him.

It is being represented that he lied about his background and achievements as an excuse to fire him. The truth, however, is not as clear cut. You have a bunch of complex issues being spun by both sides to their advantage.

He made some mistakes, but there is no "smoking gun" in any of this.

The issue of not permitting politically motivated witch hunts against tenured academics with unpopular views is orders of magnitude more important than the issue of not catching your publisher deleting an attribution, or the issue of whether you can include a paper you have ghostwritten under another name in the bibligraphy of one you've authored under your own name.
 
As for the allegations about copied artwork, it's about paintings and drawings. If you google Ward Churchill copied art (I still can't post links), you'll find references to at least 4 pieces of his art that are obvious copies of earlier works.

The committee's report looks to me like it was written by a group of people trying hard to be fair and impartial and in my opinion succeeding. It was meticulously documented. They investigated only the 7 allegations they were asked to investigate (they didn't look over all his work with a "fine tooth comb"). It looks like the university was actually treating him better than everyone else, in terms of demanding good scholarship (until this flap occurred), by ignoring previous complaints. As for Churchill's reply, what did he say, really, besides "they're out to get me" and "everyone else does it"?

He issued both a short statement, and a point by point refutation of their conclusions.
 
Last edited:
You just keep reciting your "talking point" and ignoring everything else that is said. Politically motivated attacks on people shouldn't be tolerated, and that is a more important issue that whether some publisher removed an attribution for a phamplet in one of his publications, or any of the other trivial acts on his part which are alleged.

Politically motivated accusations can still be entirely valid. If I report a local crack dealer because I disagree with his neo-Nazi activism, should that give him a legal get-out clause? If a professor's plagiarism is found out and reported because some disagree with his political views, that's unfortunate for him - but doesn't mean the allegations should not be dealt with.
 
Again, you are simply performing the parrot function, and you are completely non-responsive to anything I've said in my posts.

Had you said anything, I might have been non-responsive to it.


The research misconduct he is accused of committing would not even be deemed worthy of investigation much less punishable in the first place, absent political motives.

Ah, finally, an actual responsive statement. It only took me, what, four repetitions of the question to get it?

Have you evidence for this? I have sufficient personal contact with the University of Colorado to know that they take research misconduct (and academic freedom in general) extremely seriously. The faculty are almost notorious for their unwillingness to bend to political pressure from the Regents, state legislature, or any other external agency (witness the debate in the mid-1990s about the renaming of the Dalton Trumbo fountain court). The faculty in general seem make a point of courting political controversy (witness, for example, the unending battle over the World Affairs Conference.

I also find it significant that the committee was specifically instructed to disregard the politically-charged statements such as his "little Eichmans," because the Standing Committee on Research Misconduct recognized out of the gate that such political speech is simply free expression. The subcommittee whose report we've been discussing were strictly limited to seven specific allegations, investigated them in depth without regard to his other work, and unanimously found a pattern of misconduct on six of the seven allegations.

So, basically -- I disagree. I don't believe that this is a politically-motivated witch-hunt (because I know too many of the hunters), and I don't believe that this level of research misconduct would be considered as minimal as you suggest.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom