Cyphermage
Critical Thinker
- Joined
- May 13, 2006
- Messages
- 358
Yes, it's appropriate to punish a person for research misconduct.
I don't see what the rest of the quotation has to do with it, or in what way this question is at all "interesting."
If Churchill committed research misconduct, he should be punished for it. The motivations of the investigators are irrelevant as long as their findings are factually adequate.
He should be investigated to the degree that other university researchers are investigated for the same type of thing, and punished to the degree other university researchers are punished when they are investigated and determined to have committed similar misconduct.
In this particular case, it appears that any misconduct would have flown under the radar, absent his political views.
Alan Dershowitz was investigated for lifting entire passages without attribution in his book, "The Case for Israel", and found not to have done anything punishment-worthy.