Ward Churchill

EBU

Thinker
Joined
Mar 25, 2006
Messages
176
Ward Churchill is the University of Colorado professor who referred to some WTC victims as "little Eichmanns." After that, he was acused of research misconduct and the University appointed a committee to investigate. I am not allowed to post links but the full report and his response can both be found if you google Ward Churchill report full text.

The report found him guilty of misconduct and recommended either that he be suspended (for 2 to 5 years) or that he be fired.

Any opinions?
 
Here is the link.

It's 125 pages; needless to say I'm not planning to read it.

I find it disgusting that he would call the victims of terrorism by the name of a renowned terrorist. I don't know about the falsification charges, obviously, but I have also read that he has claimed to be a Native American, but is not of that ethnic origin. I need to look for that citation.
 
Here is the link.

It's 125 pages; needless to say I'm not planning to read it.

I find it disgusting that he would call the victims of terrorism by the name of a renowned terrorist. I don't know about the falsification charges, obviously, but I have also read that he has claimed to be a Native American, but is not of that ethnic origin. I need to look for that citation.

He wrote a book titled On the Justice of Roosting Chickens: Consequences of American Conquest and Carnage
whose thesis was that 9/11 and other bad things that happen to the US are our foreign policy chickens coming home to roost.

One line in the book refers to some of the beancounters in the WTC as "Little Eichmanns", an allusion to Eichmann's administrative role in the Holocaust. Of course, this is the only line from the book that's ever quoted in the press, and supporters of what Noam Chomsky calls an "offshore US military base" do their best to make sure it is the only thing most Americans remember about Ward Churchill.

They couldn't fire him for expressing his opinion, so there has been this mad search to find some other excuse. He's at a taxpayer funded state school, and the governor wants him gone. They are going through everything he has ever done with a fine-toothed comb, but he has successfully refuted everything they've thrown at him so far.

In the end, they'll probably manage to get rid of him, one way or another.
 
Last edited:
Actually, the allegations of research misconduct have been around for a long time. But apparently no one at the university paid attention until his politically unpopular statements made news. He did indeed respond to the 125-page report, but he did not actually refute any of the allegations, as far as I can see. For example, the report said that he used papers that he wrote himself but that he claimed were written by others to support his own otherwise unsupported research. His response: yes, I did that, but ghostwriting is a common practice. Well, no; it isn't. It is research misconduct.

So one interesting question that comes out of this is: Is it OK to punish a person for research misconduct that came to be investigated only because he exercised his free-speech rights in support of an unpopular opinion? (And how come they ignored it before, anyhow?)
 
One line in the book refers to some of the beancounters in the WTC as "Little Eichmanns", an allusion to Eichmann's administrative role in the Holocaust.
Where does "some of the beancounters" come from?

And what is your opinion about this one line?

Churchill: Well, really. Let's get a grip here, shall we? True enough, they were civilians of a sort. But innocent? Gimme a break. They formed a technocratic corps at the very heart of America's global financial empire – the "mighty engine of profit" to which the military dimension of U.S. policy has always been enslaved – and they did so both willingly and knowingly. Recourse to "ignorance" – a derivative, after all, of the word "ignore" – counts as less than an excuse among this relatively well-educated elite. To the extent that any of them were unaware of the costs and consequences to others of what they were involved in – and in many cases excelling at – it was because of their absolute refusal to see. More likely, it was because they were too busy braying, incessantly and self-importantly, into their cell phones, arranging power lunches and stock transactions, each of which translated, conveniently out of sight, mind and smelling distance, into the starved and rotting flesh of infants. If there was a better, more effective, or in fact any other way of visiting some penalty befitting their participation upon the little Eichmanns inhabiting the sterile sanctuary of the twin towers, I'd really be interested in hearing about it.

edit: fix quote
 
Last edited:
Where does "some of the beancounters" come from?

"Beancounter" is a euphemism for financial analyst.

And what is your opinion about this one line?

I really don't have an opinion. Is the global financial nexus of a superpower which has, as the global situation has changed to make it more difficult for it to exert hegemony over the rest of the world through financial intimidation, resorted more and more to direct military force, a legitimate military target?

Ward Churchill apparently feels it is. He's entitled to his opinion.

The civilian deaths at the WTC were less than the civilian deaths from the most minor of the many US military adventures abroad. While I would probably stick to military targets and dual-use infrastructure and work hard to minimize civilian casualities if I were fighting a war, I recognize not everyone has my high standards.

As Lenin would have said. "Broken eggs."
 
Oh - and Ward Churchill's explanation of his use of the term "Little Eichmanns," if anyone is interested.

* Finally, I have never characterized all the September 11 victims as "Nazis." What I said was that the "technocrats of empire" working in the World Trade Center were the equivalent of "little Eichmanns." Adolf Eichmann was not charged with direct killing but with ensuring the smooth running of the infrastructure that enabled the Nazi genocide. Similarly, German industrialists were legitimately targeted by the Allies.

* It is not disputed that the Pentagon was a military target, or that a CIA office was situated in the World Trade Center. Following the logic by which U.S. Defense Department spokespersons have consistently sought to justify target selection in places like Baghdad, this placement of an element of the American "command and control infrastructure" in an ostensibly civilian facility converted the Trade Center itself into a "legitimate" target. Again following U.S. military doctrine, as announced in briefing after briefing, those who did not work for the CIA but were nonetheless killed in the attack amounted to no more than "collateral damage." If the U.S. public is prepared to accept these "standards" when the are routinely applied to other people, they should be not be surprised when the same standards are applied to them.

* It should be emphasized that I applied the "little Eichmanns" characterization only to those described as "technicians." Thus, it was obviously not directed to the children, janitors, food service workers, firemen and random passers-by killed in the 9-1-1 attack. According to Pentagon logic, were simply part of the collateral damage. Ugly? Yes. Hurtful? Yes. And that's my point. It's no less ugly, painful or dehumanizing a description when applied to Iraqis, Palestinians, or anyone else. If we ourselves do not want to be treated in this fashion, we must refuse to allow others to be similarly devalued and dehumanized in our name.
 
Ward Churchill apparently feels it is. He's entitled to his opinion.

The civilian deaths at the WTC were less than the civilian deaths from the most minor of the many US military adventures abroad. While I would probably stick to military targets and dual-use infrastructure and work hard to minimize civilian casualities if I were fighting a war, I recognize not everyone has my high standards.

There've been lots of US military operations abroad which caused far fewer civilian casualties than the events of 9/11/2001 - to pick an example pretty much at random, one could take the missile attack on the Al Shifa factory in Sudan. Of course, that doesn't mean these operations were justified and isn't much comfort to those who *were* killed...

If Chuchill did plagarise work (or assist others in plagiary) that's well within the scope of what an academic might get fired for. Certainly, students can get expelled for plagiary - and it is seen as very serious academic misconduct. If this was brought to light because he made some particularly insensitive remarks about the events of 9/11, that's Churchill's bad luck...
 
"Beancounter" is a euphemism for financial analyst.
No, it means accountant, not that it matters one way or the other.

I really don't have an opinion ... The civilian deaths at the WTC were less than the civilian deaths from the most minor of the many US military adventures abroad.
On the one hand you don't have an opinion on Churchill's statement, but then you seem to be excusing the 911 attack using logic similar to Churchill's.

As Lenin would have said. "Broken eggs."
I'm not sure what you mean here.
 
Actually, the allegations of research misconduct have been around for a long time. But apparently no one at the university paid attention until his politically unpopular statements made news. He did indeed respond to the 125-page report, but he did not actually refute any of the allegations, as far as I can see. For example, the report said that he used papers that he wrote himself but that he claimed were written by others to support his own otherwise unsupported research. His response: yes, I did that, but ghostwriting is a common practice. Well, no; it isn't. It is research misconduct.

So one interesting question that comes out of this is: Is it OK to punish a person for research misconduct that came to be investigated only because he exercised his free-speech rights in support of an unpopular opinion? (And how come they ignored it before, anyhow?)

Well, the allegations of misconduct were not so severe that the university was even compelled to investigate them. The university itself solicited some complaints from the alleged complaining party. The head of the committee was a person who wanted to get rid of him. He wasn't even given the courtesy of being informed of the investigation, and learned about it in the press. There were numerous other procedural things which definitely send the impression that "The Fix Was In" vis a vis the committee's conclusions.

In one case where they said he plagiarized an old phamplet, the attribution was actually removed by the publisher, and he cited the source every other time he used the material.

Some of the quibbling was over a claim that the US killed indians with smallpox infected blankets, certainly widely reported by other academics who aren't getting investigated.

As for citing a ghostwritten paper in one of his own, I'm not sure a substantial body of evidence exists one way or another on whether that is a horrible offense, if it is not the sole support for a conclusion one is reaching.

So while there are certainly errors in his scholarship, they are being magnified and represented as deliberately done enormous falsifications, and this is being done with clearly political motives.
 
No, it means accountant, not that it matters one way or the other.

On the one hand you don't have an opinion on Churchill's statement, but then you seem to be excusing the 911 attack using logic similar to Churchill's.

I'm not sure what you mean here.

I am not excusing 911. I am simply saying that I wouldn't have selected it as a target if I were on the other side, but that I understand the reasons put forth by those who argue that it was one.

If Saddam had had a World Trade Center with some command and control infrastructure in it, would we have bombed it? Probably.

We were bombing bridges, power plants, and water treatment facilities in Iraq claiming they were "dual use infrastructure." I don't see the WTC as more sacrosanct than those.

Lenin said "You can't make an omlet without breaking eggs."
 
Actually, the allegations of research misconduct have been around for a long time. But apparently no one at the university paid attention until his politically unpopular statements made news. He did indeed respond to the 125-page report, but he did not actually refute any of the allegations, as far as I can see. For example, the report said that he used papers that he wrote himself but that he claimed were written by others to support his own otherwise unsupported research. His response: yes, I did that, but ghostwriting is a common practice. Well, no; it isn't. It is research misconduct.

So one interesting question that comes out of this is: Is it OK to punish a person for research misconduct that came to be investigated only because he exercised his free-speech rights in support of an unpopular opinion? (And how come they ignored it before, anyhow?)


Well no - because the only reason he had a podium to make his odious little speech from was because of that same self serving misconduct.

If he had not been a "tenured professor at CU" would his paper have even been published? I doubt it. There are reams of revisionist conspiracy theory nutters out there.

So if Churchill wants to claim the position then he should be ready to find out if he genuinely earned it.
 
Well, the allegations of misconduct were not so severe that the university was even compelled to investigate them. The university itself solicited some complaints from the alleged complaining party. The head of the committee was a person who wanted to get rid of him. He wasn't even given the courtesy of being informed of the investigation, and learned about it in the press. There were numerous other procedural things which definitely send the impression that "The Fix Was In" vis a vis the committee's conclusions.

In one case where they said he plagiarized an old phamplet, the attribution was actually removed by the publisher, and he cited the source every other time he used the material.

Some of the quibbling was over a claim that the US killed indians with smallpox infected blankets, certainly widely reported by other academics who aren't getting investigated.

As for citing a ghostwritten paper in one of his own, I'm not sure a substantial body of evidence exists one way or another on whether that is a horrible offense, if it is not the sole support for a conclusion one is reaching.

So while there are certainly errors in his scholarship, they are being magnified and represented as deliberately done enormous falsifications, and this is being done with clearly political motives.

Having (sadly) had a look at the report, I'm not sure whether the plagiarism of the dams leaflet would be serious misconduct for an academic - this is a sufficiently basic mistake I don't think it often comes up. A student who used a source word for word (without making clear that they were quoting directly) in a piece of coursework, even if they footnoted the source, would be penalised - at least in all the universities I've had experience of.

If one academic is writing articles for other academics and fictional figures, without making clear that this is what they're doing, it certainly isn't a good thing - can make their work appear unduly influential (esp as one way to assess how influential an article is is to see how often it has been cited by others...)
 
Some of the quibbling was over a claim that the US killed indians with smallpox infected blankets, certainly widely reported by other academics who aren't getting investigated.
Again you are cutting Churchill slack, this time for willfully passing fiction as fact as documented here.

And who specifically are these other academics?
 
I am not excusing 911. I am simply saying that I wouldn't have selected it as a target if I were on the other side, but that I understand the reasons put forth by those who argue that it was one.

If Saddam had had a World Trade Center with some command and control infrastructure in it, would we have bombed it? Probably.

We were bombing bridges, power plants, and water treatment facilities in Iraq claiming they were "dual use infrastructure." I don't see the WTC as more sacrosanct than those.

Lenin said "You can't make an omlet without breaking eggs."

Lenin may well have used the quote - but I have seen no citation of it but he was not the originator of it. It comes from that precursive blood letting revolutionary, Robespierre

AS for the rest of your thesis - you first of all assume that the "we" would have bombed a WTC type place if it had command control in it - an unwarranted assumption indeed.

Then you use unmanned targets - such as bridges, power plants and water treatment as somehow equivalent to bombing an office building full of people. Hmm.

You have not advanced one shred of evidence that, for example, the US (or any western government) would suddenly decide to attack an office center in let's say Pyong-Yang by using three or four cruise missiles merely because they wanted to terrorize North Korea.

The terrorists did what they did with one aim in mind - to terrorize.

As your fatuous quotee actually did say "The purpose of terrorism is to terrorize"
 
Lenin may well have used the quote - but I have seen no citation of it but he was not the originator of it. It comes from that precursive blood letting revolutionary, Robespierre

AS for the rest of your thesis - you first of all assume that the "we" would have bombed a WTC type place if it had command control in it - an unwarranted assumption indeed.

Then you use unmanned targets - such as bridges, power plants and water treatment as somehow equivalent to bombing an office building full of people. Hmm.

You have not advanced one shred of evidence that, for example, the US (or any western government) would suddenly decide to attack an office center in let's say Pyong-Yang by using three or four cruise missiles merely because they wanted to terrorize North Korea.

The terrorists did what they did with one aim in mind - to terrorize.

As your fatuous quotee actually did say "The purpose of terrorism is to terrorize"


Oh come now. The US bombs civilians all the time. We just don't "deliberately target" them. They just happen to be there in large numbers in the vicinity of something else we want to strike. What's the civilian death toll in Iraq? 30,000 admitted by Bush, and probably closer to 100,000 according to human rights groups.

We bomb houses. We bomb neighborhoods. We bomb pretty much anything we feel like bombing.
 
I really don't have an opinion
...
I am not excusing 911. I am simply saying that I wouldn't have selected it as a target if I were on the other side, but that I understand the reasons put forth by those who argue that it was one.
You understand Churchill's statement. You defend his statement. But you don't have an opinion about it. I'm a bit confused.

Churchill:
If there was a better, more effective, or in fact any other way of visiting some penalty befitting their participation upon the little Eichmanns inhabiting the sterile sanctuary of the twin towers, I'd really be interested in hearing about it.
I'd like to know if you agree with this, but first I'll remove the weasel words:
Churchill less weasel words:
There was no better, more effective, or in fact any other way of visiting some penalty befitting their participation upon the little Eichmanns inhabiting the sterile sanctuary of the twin towers.
 
So one interesting question that comes out of this is: Is it OK to punish a person for research misconduct that came to be investigated only because he exercised his free-speech rights in support of an unpopular opinion?

Yes, it's appropriate to punish a person for research misconduct.

I don't see what the rest of the quotation has to do with it, or in what way this question is at all "interesting."

If Churchill committed research misconduct, he should be punished for it. The motivations of the investigators are irrelevant as long as their findings are factually adequate.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom