Ward Churchill

As for Churchill's reply, what did he say, really, besides "they're out to get me" and "everyone else does it"?

Which, you'll notice, is more or less the content of Cyphermage's attempts to whitewash.
 
The issue of not permitting politically motivated witch hunts against tenured academics with unpopular views is orders of magnitude more important than the issue of not catching your publisher deleting an attribution, or the issue of whether you can include a paper you have ghostwritten under another name in the bibligraphy of one you've authored under your own name.

Absolutely. But this is not a politically-motivated witchhunt, despite your attempts to paint it as such. It's a meticulously conducted, detailed examination into the works of an immensely prolific author, and they find a strong and continuous record of academic misconduct.

Let me see if I can summarize some of the committee's findings in brief. He has been accused (Allegation A)of knowingly putting forth demonstrably incorrect statements ("gross historical inaccuracies") in multiple forums. He has further been accused of gross violation of accepted research standards and practices in arriving at these gross historical inaccuracies, for example a "general reference to an apparently independent source in its entirety constitutes an unconventional referencing style frequently employed by Professor Churchill to create the appearance of independent support for his claims, while simultaneously discouraging or, at least, making far more difficult, any effort by other researcher to check his claims." Furthermore, he cited two of these as independent sources when he had, in fact, ghost-written them. From the committee's report : "Were Professor Churchill a scientist,... the equivalent would be (1) the misstatement of some underlying data ... and (2) the total fabrication of other data to support his hypothesis." Furthermore, he has repeated this act of misstatement supported by fabrication no less than eleven separate times.

Allegation B further supports this. He has both misrepresented the content of data, and fabricated data in support of his misrepresentation.

Allegation C addresses areas where Churchill has significantly misrepresented the contents of cited works and essentially made up his theories of out whole cloth -- again, falsification, based upon fabricated evidence.

Etc., etc.

The committee report is very clear about the nature of academic freedom. "Professor Churchill is entirely free to present his own reading of the evidence. Like scholars in all fields, however, he is expected to present an account that is built upon and supported by that evidence." (46)

In allegation D, for example, they cleared Churchill of academic misconduct "with respect to his general claim that [...]," because it was supported by native oral traditions, which are a valid (if not especially reliable) form of evidence. However, at the same time, he has not respected those traditions, has not cited them, and in fact, "raised the possiblity that he had drawn on oral material only in an attempt to produce after-the-fact justification for his claims." In other words, he made stuff up and relied on the goodwill of the committee to find evidence for it and give him credit for evidence he didn't even know existed.

In the words of the report, "Professor Churchill has created myths under the banner of academic scholarship."

With respect to Allgation E, that's a straight-up plagiarism case, pure and simple, a plagiarism case repeated three separate times. And in two of those times, Churchill can't even blame the copy-editor, because he himself edited the volume in which his plagiarized work appears.

I don't think I need to continue in this vein. The Committee has, as far as I can tell from my uncomfortably close reading of the report, been bending over backwards to give Ward Churchill every possible benefit of the doubt, including digging up independent evidence of which Churchill himself was not aware.
 
Oh come now. The US bombs civilians all the time. We just don't "deliberately target" them. They just happen to be there in large numbers in the vicinity of something else we want to strike. What's the civilian death toll in Iraq? 30,000 admitted by Bush, and probably closer to 100,000 according to human rights groups.

We bomb houses. We bomb neighborhoods. We bomb pretty much anything we feel like bombing.

You are, I suspect, trying to divert the argument from your original and rather poorly thought out point.

What's the civilian death toll in Iraq? Are you asking how many civilians have died overall or how many were killed in the hypothetical bombings you were talking about? Perhaps this would be a good point to draw a distinction between terrorism - where a car full of explosives is driven up to a Mosque and innocent people are TARGETED and war where a bomb is accidentally dropped on the wrong target and innocent people are killed.

AS for the "whatever we feel like bombing" once ago you exagerrate and obfuscate and I do not understand the reason for it. The US could, indeed bomb almost anything anywhere but it does not, even if it sometimes puts the lives of its own servicement and women at risk. Why you seem to think that this somehow ha an eqquivalence to terrorists targettnig innocent peole as a matter of strategy is very strange.
 
Yes, you are a bit confused.
You could help me get unconfused by answering the simple questions I've posed to you. See posts #15 and #19.

The ability to understand an opponent's argument is not a defense of it.
I agree! And yet you are doing just that -- you are defending WC's insane statement based on a vague proclamation that you "understand" it.
 
You are, I suspect, trying to divert the argument from your original and rather poorly thought out point.

What's the civilian death toll in Iraq? Are you asking how many civilians have died overall or how many were killed in the hypothetical bombings you were talking about? Perhaps this would be a good point to draw a distinction between terrorism - where a car full of explosives is driven up to a Mosque and innocent people are TARGETED and war where a bomb is accidentally dropped on the wrong target and innocent people are killed.

AS for the "whatever we feel like bombing" once ago you exagerrate and obfuscate and I do not understand the reason for it. The US could, indeed bomb almost anything anywhere but it does not, even if it sometimes puts the lives of its own servicement and women at risk. Why you seem to think that this somehow ha an eqquivalence to terrorists targettnig innocent peole as a matter of strategy is very strange.


That's part of the Neoconservative doctrine of moral superiority. When we do something, it isn't the same as someone else doing the same thing, because we are doing it for a more noble purpose.

Dead people are dead people. There is fundamentally little difference between someone with few technically advanced military assets blowing something up, and us flying overhead in a billion dollar plane, at no risk to ourselves, and blowing something up.
 
While I'm at it, I should mention that it wouldn't ruin my day in the least if the United States were rendered incapable of projecting military force beyond its own borders for the next 50 years, forced to resign permanent membership on the UN Security Council, and Bush, Blair, and the 20 most prominent Neocons were hanged after being found guilty and sentenced by an excruciatingly fair War Crimes trial conducted according to the highest international standards.

The age of Superpowers is over. Splitting the US and China into geopolitical entities the size of Denmark would be a great gift to future generations.
 
Last edited:
While I'm at it, I should mention that it wouldn't ruin my day in the least if the United States were rendered incapable of projecting military force beyond its own borders for the next 50 years

Well no, it probably wouldn't ruin your day. But the South Koreans probably wouldn't be very thrilled about it. But you know, I guess I just feel that way because I actually know a lot of non-Americans who have little desire to see the U.S. disintegrate, and have some appreciation for the U.S., in spite of its flaws.

The age of Superpowers is over. Splitting the US and China into geopolitical entities the size of Denmark would be a great gift to future generations.

Yeah, that would be awesome! China was doing so well when it was a bunch of quasi-states run by regional warlords. But what about Japan? Russia? The EU? Why stop at the U.S. and China. Why not break up any country or organization over, say, 100 million people. Let's Balkanize the whole world. Then, much like the Balkans, we can go back to having good old fashioned regional wars. Hundreds of them. Tribalism is definitely the way to go.
 
That's part of the Neoconservative doctrine of moral superiority. When we do something, it isn't the same as someone else doing the same thing, because we are doing it for a more noble purpose.

Dead people are dead people. There is fundamentally little difference between someone with few technically advanced military assets blowing something up, and us flying overhead in a billion dollar plane, at no risk to ourselves, and blowing something up.


So intent is totally irrelevant? If the US threw darts at a map blindfolded to pick their targets, you would find this equivalent to identifying terrorist bunkers?
 
Yeah, that would be awesome! China was doing so well when it was a bunch of quasi-states run by regional warlords. But what about Japan? Russia? The EU? Why stop at the U.S. and China. Why not break up any country or organization over, say, 100 million people. Let's Balkanize the whole world. Then, much like the Balkans, we can go back to having good old fashioned regional wars. Hundreds of them. Tribalism is definitely the way to go.

You've certainly convinced me! When do we start?
 
I've already started. My plans to secede and create my own country shall soon come to fruition.... very soon. It shall be called "ARubberChickenWithaPulleyintheMiddloria."

President for life.
 
So intent is totally irrelevant? If the US threw darts at a map blindfolded to pick their targets, you would find this equivalent to identifying terrorist bunkers?

The US blows up anything it claims a "terrorist" ran into, or is having dinner at, or someone was shot at out of, without much concern for who else is in the building.

According to press accounts of the latest "marine massacre" that are beginng to come out, the US indiscriminately slaughters entire households full of people because one of their precious soldiers was killed.

The only times these things get prosecuted, is when the press gets ahold of them, and then the subtext is that the perpetrators "embarrassed the military" by getting caught.
 
I've already started. My plans to secede and create my own country shall soon come to fruition.... very soon. It shall be called "ARubberChickenWithaPulleyintheMiddloria."

President for life.

Back in the early days of public access to the Internet, I recall plans to create a new libertarian country called "Oceania", by lashing together floating platforms in the ocean somewhere. They even had their own Web site, as I recall.

Guess they never got to the implementation phase. A pity.
 
The US blows up anything it claims a "terrorist" ran into, or is having dinner at, or someone was shot at out of, without much concern for who else is in the building.

According to press accounts of the latest "marine massacre" that are beginng to come out, the US indiscriminately slaughters entire households full of people because one of their precious soldiers was killed.

The only times these things get prosecuted, is when the press gets ahold of them, and then the subtext is that the perpetrators "embarrassed the military" by getting caught.

There is some truth here, but the extent of criminal activity by US Soldiers is something you or I do not know. I think that in any conflict involving thousands of soldiers over a prolonged period, there would be numerous instances of wrongful killing- intentional or not. I'm not sure this invalidates the purpose of the conflict; although it certainly reveals certain weaknesses in planning and frontline discipline.
 
The US blows up anything it claims a "terrorist" ran into, or is having dinner at, or someone was shot at out of, without much concern for who else is in the building.

According to press accounts of the latest "marine massacre" that are beginng to come out, the US indiscriminately slaughters entire households full of people because one of their precious soldiers was killed.

The only times these things get prosecuted, is when the press gets ahold of them, and then the subtext is that the perpetrators "embarrassed the military" by getting caught.
And this gives Ward Churchill carte blanche to lie on his resume in order to take a position reserved for minorities and plagiarize papers. Yes, it's all crystal clear now... :rolleyes:
 
According to press accounts of the latest "marine massacre" that are beginng to come out, the US indiscriminately slaughters entire households full of people because one of their precious soldiers was killed.

Whoa, hold up a minute here. You are using one incident to make a blanket statement about millions of US servicemembers. That is not US policy at the tactical level or otherwise, and it is rather insulting to suggest that U.S. troops are regularly massacring innocent families in retaliation for attacks on U.S. soldiers. It is not only insulting, but completely, flat-out incorrect.

The only times these things get prosecuted, is when the press gets ahold of them, and then the subtext is that the perpetrators "embarrassed the military" by getting caught.

Nonsense. How long have you been in the military? Soldiers get court-martialed all the time, and rarely do they make the news. Even Soldiers court-martialed for battlefield misconduct/war crimes only make headlines if it is a particularly large incident, like the current one. There have been plenty of cases where Soldiers have faced court-martial for their conduct on the battlefield, and they have received just minor press attention, if any. Just after a 5 minute Google search, here are a few:

http://www.pittsburghlive.com/x/pittsburghtrib/s_165511.html

http://www.wjla.com/headlines/0705/246190.html

http://www.politicalgateway.com/news/read/11876


http://the.honoluluadvertiser.com/article/2004/Jun/17/br/br02p.html


Court-martials, especially for murder, can take a long time. Soldiers do have the right to a fair trial. It is hard to prosecute murder cases that occur during an operation because it can be extremely difficult to collect evidence. CID can't just walk into a hot area and remove evidence with the type of care that they can during a peacetime mission. But to claim that crimes only get prosecuted when they are given attention by the media is badly mistaken, and I am not convinced you are doing anything other than making a wild assumption. If you have some experience, then feel free to share it. Otherwise, no offense, but you're just talking out of your posterior.
 
As far as I am concerned, Churchill is a proven liar, plagiarist, art forger, and hate speaker, many times over.

He would never have been hired had he not lied, imo.

Jail is what he deserves, imo.
 
Whoa, hold up a minute here. You are using one incident to make a blanket statement about millions of US servicemembers. That is not US policy at the tactical level or otherwise, and it is rather insulting to suggest that U.S. troops are regularly massacring innocent families in retaliation for attacks on U.S. soldiers. It is not only insulting, but completely, flat-out incorrect.

The entire Iraq war is a crime. It is an illegal war of aggression, in violation of international law, planned long in advance, sold with lies, and excuted in defiance of the UN and the will of the world community with the help of a "coalition" of the coerced and the bribed.

The rules of war apply to soldiers fighting in a foreign land, but they do not apply to homeland defense. International law considers homeland defense so important, that any means is justified to repel an unlawful invader, including terrorism, and chemical and biological weapons.

Indeed, it is for this very purpose that the US stockpiled such weapons until recently.

For this reason, we should regard all Iraqis dead at the hands of the US military as murder victims, and dead US soldiers, by whatever means produced, as the lawful act of citizens resisting an illegal occupation of their homeland.

The puppet stooge "democracy" installed by the illegal occupiers notwithstanding.

When they were selling the war, the canonical talking point of the Neocons was "Who is more dangerous to world peace? George W. Bush, or Saddam Hussein." If you take "dangerous" to mean each leaders goofiness multiplied by the assets they command, it is clear to any sane person that the correct answer to this question has always been "George W. Bush."
 
And this gives Ward Churchill carte blanche to lie on his resume in order to take a position reserved for minorities and plagiarize papers. Yes, it's all crystal clear now... :rolleyes:

The only relation between the US/Iraq War and Ward Churchill is that the latter is being harrassed because of his views on the former.

If we had held Dr. Martin Luther King to the same plagiarism standards that are being applied to Ward Churchill, he'd be Mr. Martin Luther King, and bus stations would still have two drinking fountains and four restrooms.

Sometimes you have to think of the greater good for the greater number, even if it means cutting an imperfect activist a bit of extra slack.
 
The entire Iraq war is a crime. It is an illegal war of aggression, in violation of international law, planned long in advance, sold with lies, and excuted in defiance of the UN and the will of the world community with the help of a "coalition" of the coerced and the bribed.

The rules of war apply to soldiers fighting in a foreign land, but they do not apply to homeland defense. International law considers homeland defense so important, that any means is justified to repel an unlawful invader, including terrorism, and chemical and biological weapons.

You may want to re-read parts of the LOAC there, ace. Can you cite me the part where "homeland defense" forces are exempted from the laws and customs of war.

You might want to start with Geneva III; Article 4. All they get is a very temoparary relaxation of the uniform requirement.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom