Split Thread War in Afghanistan

I didn't say they were beaten, or that they would never make gains again, I said that they would never win, and that most people hate the Taliban. Get a life.
 
I didn't say they were beaten, or that they would never make gains again, I said that they would never win, and that most people hate the Taliban. Get a life.

Yeah...that's what the Russians said. Unfortunately, even as Pathological as the Taliban may be, it appears to me that they are the "Home Boys"...the local favorites.

Afghanistan is so screwed up.
 
Last edited:
I guess so. I mean, these people are so bad that even Genghis Khan refused to conquer them.

How many people have completely failed to beat them to date?

Given three in the last century and a bit, there must have been a few attempts overall. Generation after generation of insanely violent xenophobis people. I guess it shows the virtues of a closed group.

Probably make an interesting genetic study for someone.
 
300 Walmarts. That's my proposal to conquer and pacify Afghanistan. 300 Walmart stores across the nation, filled with products that meet the local needs.

Why 300? That would bring Afganistan up to the stores per capita of Idaho.
 
Yeah...that's what the Russians said. Unfortunately, even as Pathological as the Taliban may be, it appears to me that they are the "Home Boys"...the local favorites.

Afghanistan is so screwed up.
It "appears to me" that I am judging whether or not the Afghani population supports the Taliban by polling data, and you are going on your intuition and "deep knowledge" of international intelligence operations.
 
Yeah...that's what the Russians said. Unfortunately, even as Pathological as the Taliban may be, it appears to me that they are the "Home Boys"...the local favorites.

Afghanistan is so screwed up.

Past immediate family and tribe, there aren't really any Afghan "Home Team."

It took major money to get various personalities to join the Northern Alliance and very little of what cooperation that did take place was from any notion of building a nation, it occurred because a local warlord wanted his turn.

Our biggest mistake first time around was leaving the Muj high and dry after the Sovs left, and the second biggest mistake was believing this time around that Afghanistan had any chance of becoming a functioning democracy.
 
Past immediate family and tribe, there aren't really any Afghan "Home Team."

It took major money to get various personalities to join the Northern Alliance and very little of what cooperation that did take place was from any notion of building a nation, it occurred because a local warlord wanted his turn.

Our biggest mistake first time around was leaving the Muj high and dry after the Sovs left, and the second biggest mistake was believing this time around that Afghanistan had any chance of becoming a functioning democracy.

Exactly, the place is very tribal. Hatfields and McCoys.
 
I guess so. I mean, these people are so bad that even Genghis Khan refused to conquer them.

Not so. Genghis Khan was actually the last invader to successfully conquer Afghanistan.
His legacy is still evident, in the form of the Hazaras. These are an ethnic group that live in the area of Bamiyan (where the big Buddhas were, that the Taliban blew up). They have almond-shaped eyes, a result of interbreeding with Genghis' Mongol warriors.
Because of their ethnic, religious (they are Shia), and cultural differences from the largely Pashtun Taliban, they suffered horribly when Mazar-i-Sharif fell to the Taliban.
 
I opposed the Russian invasion of Afghanistan in about 1980, which resulted in an American boycott of the Moscow Olympics. Historically, the Afghans in Victorian times were really wild and corrupt from top to bottom, and they gave the British Army at the time a lot of grief and trouble. Then the Americans and British, of course, with no sense of history and no war plan, had to make the same mistakes all over again in the 2000s.

The Afghans and Isis and Taliban believe in the death penalty, and not in gay marriage. They don't like foreigners, and they are very nationalistic with religious fanaticism. They are Sunni Islamic extremists and they want to suicide bomb Shia Muslims. They are very dangerous killers.
 
The Afghans and Isis and Taliban believe in the death penalty, and not in gay marriage. They don't like foreigners, and they are very nationalistic with religious fanaticism. They are Sunni Islamic extremists and they want to suicide bomb Shia Muslims. They are very dangerous killers.

In fairness, this quote can be easily modified, and still be true:

The Republicans and Evangelists believe in the death penalty, and not in gay marriage. They don't like foreigners, and they are very nationalistic with religious fanaticism. They are Christian extremists and they want to suicide bomb Shia Muslims. They are very dangerous killers.
 
Crescent, you are invited to take that to another thread. This one is about Afghanistan.
 
We may need a political revolution in Afghanistan, perhaps making use of the CIA to help prop up a liberal leader.
 
Clovis, are you from Afghanistan? Getting the CIA to prop up a liberal leader ... OK, in the unlikely event that this is proposed, it still requires a definition of "what is a liberal leader in Afghanistan" and "how many potential liberal leaders have a sufficiently developed network of influence and friends to be effective?"

You got any answers for that?
 
Nice to see this thread still alive - I was about to come and post another "How's the war going in A'stan?' post after the recent attacks and this piece:

The Taliban have an open and constant presence in 70 percent of Afghanistan, according to an extensive study undertaken by the BBC, which was conducted over several months in every corner of the country.
 
Nice to see this thread still alive - I was about to come and post another "How's the war going in A'stan?' post after the recent attacks and this piece:

That's depressing reading :(

The Taliban seems to be very persistent which IMO means that it enjoys a significant level of public support in parts of Afghanistan.
 
So we will bomb them until they love us.

Sadly that seems to be the approach - after all it worked so well for the Russians and the British Empire - twice :rolleyes:

Having declared the Taliban beyond the pale (probably quite rightly), it's difficult know what to do especially when what we want to offer, a unified country under a liberal democracy seems not to be what a large chunk of Afghan society wants.
 
So we will bomb them until they love us.

And yet - what few protections women have in Afghanistan are are result of the U.S./Coalition presence. The few protections for non-Sunni Muslims are a result of the U.S./Coalition presence.

It's a real no-win situation. We can't win, but if we leave, a whole lot more innocent people get killed or are consigned to lives of utter misery.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom