USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

A question about this issue of whether to raise taxes or not.

Suppose the congress wasn't a collection of cynical guys whose main goal was to get reelected by sucking up to the special interests that got them their jobs.

Could the congress cut enough to not raise taxes?

Suppose the congress did this:
1. Gradually re-instituted the agricultural subsidy reforms that Bush undid and eliminated ethanol subsidy programs.
2. Reduced federal wages across the board by some reasonable amount.
3. Substantially reduced military spending
4. Undid or substantially reformed the Bush medicare drug plan designed to enrich Republican crony corporations.
5. Instituted reforms in the American health care system designed to reduce costs while maintaining the quality of health care.
6. Stopped funding counterproductive and corrupt ideas like the car company bailout scams.
7. Maximized federal revenues from the leasing of federal resources, particularly oil fields.

If that wasn't enough could the shortfall be made up by getting rid of some of the special interest driven tax breaks?

And if that still wasn't enough would the winding down of the Iraq war and the probable winding down of the Afghanistan war suffice to eliminate the US deficits?

Those are good points worth discussing. Prepare to be branded a socialist by the partisan morons who have no interest in actually tackling the problem.
 
Those are good points worth discussing. Prepare to be branded a socialist by the partisan morons who have no interest in actually tackling the problem.

Yes, but it's sooo much easier to just sit around, point fingers, and whinge about it...
 
A question about this issue of whether to raise taxes or not.

Suppose the congress wasn't a collection of cynical guys whose main goal was to get reelected by sucking up to the special interests that got them their jobs.

Could the congress cut enough to not raise taxes?

Suppose the congress did this:
1. Gradually re-instituted the agricultural subsidy reforms that Bush undid and eliminated ethanol subsidy programs.
2. Reduced federal wages across the board by some reasonable amount.
3. Substantially reduced military spending
4. Undid or substantially reformed the Bush medicare drug plan designed to enrich Republican crony corporations.
5. Instituted reforms in the American health care system designed to reduce costs while maintaining the quality of health care.
6. Stopped funding counterproductive and corrupt ideas like the car company bailout scams.
7. Maximized federal revenues from the leasing of federal resources, particularly oil fields.

If that wasn't enough could the shortfall be made up by getting rid of some of the special interest driven tax breaks?

And if that still wasn't enough would the winding down of the Iraq war and the probable winding down of the Afghanistan war suffice to eliminate the US deficits?
Thanks Dave,

So often these threads devolve into silly childish squabbles. I note you are often, if not always, above the fray. I wish there was more substance and less bickering. Ego, ain't it a bitch? I include myself in the too much bickering crowd.

Having grown up conservative I believe there are real and valid issues that the right raises. Unfortunately those are often lost amongst all the rhetoric. And the same is true for the left.

Regardless of one's politics your list is substantive and should be considered and not dismissed out of hand. I think they are great ideas. A great start anyway. What's interesting is that it's easy to talk about stopping cash from flowing from the govt to groups that want that money and who know how to lobby for it.

I've been railing on sugar subsidies for decades now. If it's supposed to be a free market but the govt has to prop you up then you are doing it wrong.
 
Last edited:
5. Instituted reforms in the American health care system designed to reduce costs while maintaining the quality of health care.

You touched on a good point here. The standard for Medicare and Medicaid should be to maintain or improve patient care. And there are ways to do this while lowering overall spending.

Some reforms of this nature were part of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act. One that became political fodder during the last election was cutting back on the Medicare AdvantageWP program. Patients under this program cost the government about 17% more than those with traditional Medicare coverage and the results were no better.

A change that just went into effect is that Medicare and Medicaid will no longer pay hospital bills resulting from hospital mistakes. This gives hospitals a clear incentive to reduce their error rate. The Checklist Manifesto details a rather simple and proven way to reduce medical errors that has yet to be widely adapted.

Another promising area is medical hot spotting. Camden, New Jersey implemented a program that focused on the 1% of patients that were running up the highest medical bills. They hired nurses to coordinate care fro these patients who were responsible for one third of the cities medical bills. The result was a drastic reduction in hospital stays and emergency room visits and markedly improved patient health. Read The Hot Spotters to see how this program was developed and how it works.

Politicians like solutions that can fit on a bumper sticker. Effective solutions are often far more complex and less obvious.
 
We have a Liz or two, but nobody named Libbie.
"If it says Libby's, Libby's, Libby's on the label, label, label. You will like it, like it, like it on your table table table".

Or not.

Wrong spelling? Whatever, sue me.
 
Okay wiseguy, cite the people in this thread or in American politics that want to destroy capitalism.

In American politics, that would include, for example, Michael Moore (who got a place of honor in the DNC, next to Jimmy Carter); Saul Alinsky (the #1 "community organizer" in Chicago, whose rabble-rousing policies Obama followed to gain national prominense); Bill Ayers (one of Obama's pals); Jeremiah Wright (pastor of a Church the Obamas attended for decades without managing to find out he's a radical); Wallace Smith; Bernadine Dohrne, Rshaid Khalidi (more longtime associates of Obama); etc., etc.

Obama is an 60s left-winger in his views, with all that comes with that -- deep suspicion of America in general, hatred of capitalism (oops -- sorry -- only of Capitalism's "excesses", which by a curious coincidence, "require" government to take over the economy, all for the country's own good, of course), and self-abasing spinelessness in the face of tin-pot dictators (Syria, Libya, Iran, Egypt -- where the Muslim brotherhood is poised to take over -- etc., etc.)
 
Last edited:
In American politics, that would include, for example, Michael Moore (who got a place of honor in the DNC, next to Jimmy Carter); Saul Alinsky (the #1 "community organizer" in Chicago, whose rabble-rousing policies Obama followed to gain national prominense); Bill Ayers (one of Obama's pals); Jeremiah Wright (pastor of a Church the Obamas attended for decades without managing to find out he's a radical); Wallace Smith; etc., etc.
Oh, I can play that game.

People who want to destroy capitalism.

  1. Mitt Romney.
  2. Rick Perry.
  3. Michele Bachmann.
  4. Rick Santorum.
  5. Tim Pawlenty.
  6. Ron Paul.
  7. Jon Huntsman.
I'm going to let you in on a little known secret. All are members of Mensa. All have won Nobel Prizes and all are gay. Except Michel Bachmann who is married to a heterosexual man.

See, it's easy to just assert things if you don't have to demonstrate your assertion.
 
I've been railing on sugar subsidies for decades now. If it's supposed to be a free market but the govt has to prop you up then you are doing it wrong.

In the last few years, sugar subsidies have been sitting at zero. Not sure if this is due to policy changes or simply market conditions. In 2010 we spent $3.5 billion on corn subsidies, $1.7 billion on wheat, $1.5 billion on soybeans and $800 million on cotton. Numbers are from the EWG database on farm subsidies.

Is there a reason for our nation to subsidize these crops, or are we doing it just to keep a powerful lobby happy?
 
In the last few years, sugar subsidies have been sitting at zero. Not sure if this is due to policy changes or simply market conditions. In 2010 we spent $3.5 billion on corn subsidies, $1.7 billion on wheat, $1.5 billion on soybeans and $800 million on cotton. Numbers are from the EWG database on farm subsidies.

Is there a reason for our nation to subsidize these crops, or are we doing it just to keep a powerful lobby happy?
Bingo.

If you are rich you are entitled to be on the public dole. Welfare is for the wealthy. Capitalism is for suckers. Banks and businesses want high returns without risk. Read your Constitution. Hell, read your Declaration of Independence. Some corporations (those with good lobbyists) are endowed by fat cat politicians to the right to all the public money god will allow. Since Republican politicians speak for god they get to dictate how much god will allow.

Michele Bachmann Has Benefited From Federal Funds, Farm Subsidies
 
In American politics, that would include, for example, Michael Moore (who got a place of honor in the DNC, next to Jimmy Carter); Saul Alinsky (the #1 "community organizer" in Chicago, whose rabble-rousing policies Obama followed to gain national prominense); Bill Ayers (one of Obama's pals); Jeremiah Wright (pastor of a Church the Obamas attended for decades without managing to find out he's a radical); Wallace Smith; Bernadine Dohrne, Rshaid Khalidi (more longtime associates of Obama); etc., etc.

Obama is an 60s left-winger in his views, with all that comes with that -- deep suspicion of America in general, hatred of capitalism (oops -- sorry -- only of Capitalism's "excesses", which by a curious coincidence, "require" government to take over the economy, all for the country's own good, of course), and self-abasing spinelessness in the face of tin-pot dictators (Syria, Libya, Iran, Egypt -- where the Muslim brotherhood is poised to take over -- etc., etc.)

gosh....for a minute there i thought that there really was a chance to destroy ca[pitalism.
then i saw whose post i was reading and then i woke up.:(
 
In American politics, that would include, for example, Michael Moore (who got a place of honor in the DNC, next to Jimmy Carter); Saul Alinsky (the #1 "community organizer" in Chicago, whose rabble-rousing policies Obama followed to gain national prominense); Bill Ayers (one of Obama's pals); Jeremiah Wright (pastor of a Church the Obamas attended for decades without managing to find out he's a radical); Wallace Smith; Bernadine Dohrne, Rshaid Khalidi (more longtime associates of Obama); etc., etc.

Obama is an 60s left-winger in his views, with all that comes with that -- deep suspicion of America in general, hatred of capitalism (oops -- sorry -- only of Capitalism's "excesses", which by a curious coincidence, "require" government to take over the economy, all for the country's own good, of course), and self-abasing spinelessness in the face of tin-pot dictators (Syria, Libya, Iran, Egypt -- where the Muslim brotsherhood is poised to take over -- etc., etc.)

Not a complete description. I don't know of any "60s left-wingers" who would have bowed to Arab tyrants. Further, most "60s left-wingers" were not anti-capitalist, and were not socialist or communist. They were largely united in opposition to Vietnam, and in support of what would today be considered a libertarian view of individual freedom and rights.

Yes, there was as there has always been, a militant minority of radicals in the 60s. It was a tiny minority, and it was hugely radical compared to the rank and file of the left.

Is this faction anti-capitalist?

You betcha.
 
BTW, by "anti-capitalist" do you mean "socialist" or have we cured you of your equivocation?
No, I mean exactly what I said.

Although in propagandic method, demonization and stereotyping of the opponent is used routinely. that's largely what this is.

For example, work to demonize Bush and stereotype Republicans. Infect minds with these memes. If you are successful, what do they do?

They look around and finds something that's not Bush and Not Republican.

Duhh....

For more details on these methods, including the important role of useful idiots, may I suggest you read up on Noam Chomksy?

It would be very useful to understand the utility of using useful idiots.
 
Although in propagandic method, demonization and stereotyping of the opponent is used routinely. that's largely what this is.

For example, work to demonize Bush and stereotype Republicans. Infect minds with these memes. If you are successful, what do they do?

They look around and finds something that's not Bush and Not Republican.

Duhh....

For more details on these methods, including the important role of useful idiots, may I suggest you read up on Noam Chomksy?

It would be very useful to understand the utility of using useful idiots.
:rolleyes:

Epic fail. Not a single premise in support of any conclusion. Fallacy, tu quoque. Personal attack. I've read Noam Chomsky and he'd be rather disappointed in your little obfuscation.

Try again.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom