USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

More and more and more and more and more. Just look at this chart, can't you see the taxes rising? What's that? You can't? Look again. Put on your GOP goggles. It's there. Just have faith. It's there.

taxesi.jpg
That chart is meaningless as there were far more allowable deductons when the top rate was higher, nobody actually paid anywhere near those rates.

A better comparison would be the effective tax rate over the years, meaning the rate actually paid as opposed to the theoretical maximum.
 
That chart is meaningless as there were far more allowable deductons when the top rate was higher, nobody actually paid anywhere near those rates.

A better comparison would be the effective tax rate over the years, meaning the rate actually paid as opposed to the theoretical maximum.
Fair enough but I've one question, didn't Reagan do away with many of those allowable deductions?
 
if someone does not raise your taxes (hopefully on the rich), you are pretty much **********.
If taxes are only raised on the rich it won't even put a dent in the problem. Only the middle class has the income necessary for a tax hike that will eliminate the deficit.
 
That's true but misleading. The lion's share of the cuts did go to the top so my question to AlBell still stands.
Nope. More than even the lion's share went to the middle class.
 
OK, so we have lost our very prestigious credit-rating. We know who bears most of the responsibility. So what must we do to get our credit-rating back?

The Democrats and the GOP must decide that the loss of the AAA credit-rating should be seen as a wake-up call that the last two-years of political wrangling must cease. It makes us look bad in the eyes of banks and credit-rating agencies, & this threatens our economic health.

Then, the Democrats and the GOP must work on a plan that cuts our debt by at least one-third within the next 10 years. This should be done through a mixture of spending cuts, closing tax-loopholes & raising income tax rates on the wealthiest Americans.

If Congress can put partisanship and political goals aside, they can make this happen.

If Congress can not get past their short-term political goals and strict adherence to ideology, then our credit-rating may be lowered further.
 
If taxes are only raised on the rich it won't even put a dent in the problem. Only the middle class has the income necessary for a tax hike that will eliminate the deficit.

And doing either will put a dent in GDP growth which means in the end that Debt as a percent of GDP, the only parameter that really matters, won't go in the direction we want it to go.

RF is probably another of those folks who thinks (like Bri) that we can get revenues above 21% of GDP when in the last 65 years that has never happened.

He probably thinks, like Obama and his sychophants, that we can get revenue as a percent of GDP into the 24% range. Never mind what 65 years of history show.

But then, maybe he's using that deflator in his calculations. :p
 
  • Laws that allow predatory lending practices (charging usurious rates) and giving loans to people that are likely to result in the confiscation of their assets because of bad credit knowing Uncle Sam will back the gamble.
  • Deregulation
  • Eliminating and refusing oversight
You're not being specific enough. What do you consider "predatory lending practies"? What is a "usurious rate"? What deregulation? What oversight was eliminated?
And there is no federal law for usury, infact several of the things you mention aren't regulated by the feds at all but are subject to state regulations, such as lending laws.

Yes, unless you can find a connection between the laws and criminal activity.

Can you demonstrate a connection?

I'm not proposing to do so. I'm saying we have sufficient wealth to justify increased rates on income.
You still appear to be equating wealth with income. They are not the same. You can have little or no income despite being extremely wealthy.
 
Doesn't Standard and Poors realise how unpatriotic they're being?

How is what they have done unpatriotic?

They have analyzed America's ability to pay its bills and deal with its national-debt, and decided that we have regressed in both areas.

The AAA rating can be given back if/when Congress gets their house in order.
 
Then, the Democrats and the GOP must work on a plan that cuts our debt by at least one-third within the next 10 years.

Even that's not essential, if you grow the economy. It's debt as a percent of GDP that is the critical parameter. Do things that will make GDP bigger and you can have a big impact on that ratio in 10 years.

raising income tax rates on the wealthiest Americans.

Define wealthiest. You'd be surprised how low that is in many democrat's minds. And ask yourself how many small business owners are in that category even under YOUR (I would assume) more rational definition. That may surprise you, too. If you increase taxes on those people, it's self defeating. That will hurt GDP growth (history proves this time and again) which will make lowering the Debt to GDP ratio next to impossible.
 
Fair enough but I've one question, didn't Reagan do away with many of those allowable deductions?
Yes, when the rates were lowered under Reagan many deductions were eliminated, such as credit card interest. This is why you have to look at effective tax rates rather than the theoretical maximum rates.
 
Last edited:
How is what they have done unpatriotic?

They have analyzed America's ability to pay its bills and deal with its national-debt, and decided that we have regressed in both areas.

The AAA rating can be given back if/when Congress gets their house in order.

(I was poking fun at some of the reaction from some Americans in this thread)
 
I don't know if that's true. Perhaps. However real income adjusted for inflation demonstrates that the living standards for most in the middle class are shrinking. I don't know if it's desirable to have a middle class though. Some people think so.

The Middle Class in America Is Radically Shrinking. Here Are the Stats to Prove it
Doesn't change the fact that the middle class is where the money is, as far as income tax is concerned. Far more government income tax revenue was lost from the middle class than from the rich under the Bush tax cuts.
 
So... in other words, you're saying they can't do :rule10?

Politics is about compromise. If we have enough members of Congress who simply refuse to compromise in regards to spending or taxes then our nation is in serious danger.
 
Even that's not essential, if you grow the economy. It's debt as a percent of GDP that is the critical parameter. Do things that will make GDP bigger and you can have a big impact on that ratio in 10 years.

Doing anything is going to cost money, and borrowing it will just increase the interest payments. Better to claw it back from the dead beats who whined about needing a tax break so that they could grow jobs, but then grew them in China. Tax cuts to the investor class do not growe jobs unless there is a tight leash on the breaks. Building infrastructure, thus increasing demand for goods does. The New Deal worked, and only whiney baby paper entrepreneurs think it didn't.

Define wealthiest. You'd be surprised how low that is in many democrat's minds. And ask yourself how many small business owners are in that category even under YOUR (I would assume) more rational definition. That may surprise you, too. If you increase taxes on those people, it's self defeating. That will hurt GDP growth (history proves this time and again) which will make lowering the Debt to GDP ratio next to impossible.

Anybody making a million or more a year. You are quibbling and trying to induce Stockholm Syndrome by telling us that we have something in common with scum like the Koch bothers. Not buying it, dude.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom