USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

I wasn't using a broad brush. In fact you have to tell a major lie to say that the GOP wants to pay for any government at all - except maybe military and anything their friends will get the contracts for and subsidies for their friends' industries. (And they don't really want to PAY for that, they just want to spend and borrow. Then they can dump the bill on the next Democratic administration.)

RandFan, I agree that Obama used the right strategy when he points out that what is happening right now is Class Warfare. (Of course, the GOP will try to say that WE are the ones waging the Class Struggle, but if we were we have lost every engagement so far, and we can dismiss that malarky.)

It is time to recognize that fact; either the rich are our natural superiors, and we should give all that we have to them by right of nobility, or we start making them pay their share for running this country, and start reconstructing the social safety net that they have been dismantling.
 
Hell, if you won't stop giving rich people help owning luxury jets is there ANYTHING you will do?

By "giving rich people help"

do you mean "not taking more from them"?

Is that fair to say?


RandFan, I agree that Obama used the right strategy when he points out that what is happening right now is Class Warfare. (Of course, the GOP will try to say that WE are the ones waging the Class Struggle, but if we were we have lost every engagement so far, and we can dismiss that malarky.)

It is time to recognize that fact; either the rich are our natural superiors, and we should give all that we have to them by right of nobility, or we start making them pay their share for running this country, and start reconstructing the social safety net that they have been dismantling.
How much should you get?

What are you entitled to?
 
Last edited:
do you mean "not taking more from them"?
How is closing a tax loop hole "taking more from them"? They live in a society. They benefit from that society. How much money could they make running a business in Somalia?

Is that fair to say?
Frame it any way you want. I don't give a damn.

How much should you get?

What are you entitled to?
I want to live in a flourishing society. I don't want to live in Somalia. Nations with a large middle class and high Human Development Index numbers take steps to care of their citizens. None of the nations high in HDI practice Social Darwinism. It's not a controversial subject. We can have incentive and reward initiative, industry, thrift, stewardship and personal responsibility AND take care of people, build infrastructure and educate the citizens. Oh, and we can have a military also. I'm guessing you are all for that, am I right?

You can stop with the right-wing propaganda. I'm 50. I'm a registered Republican and have been since I was 18. I'm a fan of Ayn Rand (see user name) I've read Locke and Hume, the Fountain Head and Atlas Shrugged, Friedman and Sowell. Not to mention I was a Limbaugh fan for two decades. I know the rhetoric. It's wasted on me. Stick with argument. It's far more compelling.
 
So now that we have lost are triple A credit-rating, what are we going to do to get it back?

Are we all willing to give a little and compromise in order to show the credit-agencies that we can work together?

Digging in your heals will not solve this problem. It will in fact make it worse.
 
Tell that to the people who lost their life savings. It shouldn't have happened at all.

Tell it to the regulatory agencies, Taibbi's piece demonstrates that when it comes to the SEC the cops and the robbers are the same guys switching hats. I agree that repealing things like Glass-Steagall is bad, but even when you do have sound regulations in place enforcement is in question.

For instance, let's look at how the SEC was spending their time during the crisis. (Anyone know if this actually stopped after the news broke?) The problem here isn't that these individuals have poor work ethic, but that the agency was doing so little actual regulating they had this kind of time on their hands in the first place. Look here, none of them were fired. We might still be paying the same guys to surf porn as you're reading this.

We can't just give regulators the authority to regulate and expect them to do it. Especially if, according to the Taibbi article, many of the regulators intend/hope to move to the companies they're supposed to be regulating, and vice versa. There need to be mandatory criminal penalties for gross negligence in certain occupations, and IMO regulatory authority is one of them. (edit)Otherwise, every incentive the regulators have is to do exactly what they're doing, which is not much. Write all the regulations you want, they'll only be useful to anyone if you print crossword puzzles or sudoku on the backs so long as there's no "or else" clause for the regulators themselves.


Randfan said:
Hardly difficult. And no NOT contradictory at all. Who do you think has the most income? That's right, the most wealthy. The point ISN'T that the wealthy don't work. It's that the wealthy can afford to pay taxes.

My point was that you were right, they don't have to work. If taxes on top earners rise significantly the rich have the option of simply not bothering to make as much money, their accumulated wealth allowing them to do so with no change in lifestyle. The middle class is the easiest to tax because they have little choice but to seek income and pay whatever tax rate the govt wishes them to, or stop being middle class.

Not saying that increasing taxes on the top couple percent isn't at least worth a shot, but to put that forth as the solution to our problems is silly. The rich don't/won't make enough by themselves to fix our budget and for the reasons I put forth earlier middle class taxation or spending cuts in any combination that leads to any significant deficit reduction is almost a guaranteed recession (or depression).

Cutting the borrowing, which is around 12% (and rising) of our yearly GDP, amounts to putting the brakes on the main avenue of government intervention against the ongoing recession/depression. Is it a good idea? Maybe.. Is it politically feasible? I don't believe so. (edit)For this reason I agree with S&P's assessment of our finances.

------

For reference here's the Taibbi bit I'm referring to when I say "the same guys switching hats":

http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/why-isnt-wall-street-in-jail-20110216?page=6
Matt Taibbi said:
All of this paints a disturbing picture of a closed and corrupt system, a timeless circle of friends that virtually guarantees a collegial approach to the policing of high finance. Even before the corruption starts, the state is crippled by economic reality: Since law enforcement on Wall Street requires serious intellectual firepower, the banks seize a huge advantage from the start by hiring away the top talent. Budde, the former Lehman lawyer, says it's well known that all the best legal minds go to the big corporate law firms, while the "bottom 20 percent go to the SEC." Which makes it tough for the agency to track devious legal machinations, like the scheme to hide $263 million of Dick Fuld's compensation.

"It's such a mismatch, it's not even funny," Budde says.

But even beyond that, the system is skewed by the irrepressible pull of riches and power. If talent rises in the SEC or the Justice Department, it sooner or later jumps ship for those fat NBA contracts. Or, conversely, graduates of the big corporate firms take sabbaticals from their rich lifestyles to slum it in government service for a year or two. Many of those appointments are inevitably hand-picked by lifelong stooges for Wall Street like Chuck Schumer, who has accepted $14.6 million in campaign contributions from Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley and other major players in the finance industry, along with their corporate lawyers.

As for President Obama, what is there to be said? Goldman Sachs was his number-one private campaign contributor. He put a Citigroup executive in charge of his economic transition team, and he just named an executive of JP Morgan Chase, the proud owner of $7.7 million in Chase stock, his new chief of staff.
 
Last edited:
.....I'm 50. I'm a registered Republican and have been since I was 18. I'm a fan of Ayn Rand (see user name) I've read Locke and Hume, the Fountain Head and Atlas Shrugged, Friedman and Sowell. Not to mention I was a Limbaugh fan for two decades. I know the rhetoric. It's wasted on me. Stick with argument. It's far more compelling.
But are you a Looter?

:rolleyes:
 
Eye roll indeed.

What's the matter? Couldn't you find any snazzy Youtube videos to make your point?

Snazzy?

Oh, I see. You don't know the story of Wimpy?

Well...

Wimpy was a stereotyped freeloader in the Popeye cartoons, the old, black and white ones, and the comic strip.

Wimpy is the stereotype of all the people who advocate borrowing money the country does not have and cannot pay back.

Wimpy, is very jovial and friendly, and can be quite persuasive.

A recurring joke involves Wimpy's attempts to con other patrons of the diner into buying his meal for him. His best-known catchphrase started in 1931 as "Cook me up a hamburger. I'll pay you Thursday." In 1932, this then became the famous "I'll gladly pay you Tuesday for a hamburger today".[5] This phrase is now commonly used to illustrate fiscal irresponsibility[6][7][8]​
 
Last edited:
So now that we have lost are triple A credit-rating, what are we going to do to get it back?

Are we all willing to give a little and compromise in order to show the credit-agencies that we can work together?

Digging in your heals will not solve this problem. It will in fact make it worse.

I have given up on the notion of "compromise" on this regard. The moment Obama agreed that the debt ceiling should be the subject of a deal, he lost. The debt ceiling needs to be a separate discussion from fiscal policy, and he weakly agreed to tie them together. That is why we are where we are.

There is no compromising with people willing to torpedo their own submarine in the name of religion. I lowered the grunion credit rating when I saw how the debate was going, thus see no reason that S&P, Moody and all the rest of those wretched clowns wouldn't do the same.
 
Second, Reagan significantly cut top tax rates. So did Bush. Whereas Obama is has talked and talked and talked about raising them.


What you ignore—and I suspect quite deliberately—is the comparative rates of taxation between the time periods. High growth achieved in the 1980s and 1990s with tax rates higher than those seen in the 2000s, yet that last period scored the worst in terms of overall average growth rate as measured by Presidential tenures.


Well, first, note the sudden jump of about a percent in growth that took place in 1996 and thereafter? You don't suppose that has something to do with republicans taking over Congress and forcing tax cuts and cuts in spending through, do you?


What you ignore—and I suspect quite deliberately—is that the U.S. also began posting budget surpluses from the mid-1990s onwards. Fairly substantial surpluses in a couple of cases. If expenses are dropped then it's not hard to drop revenue via tax cuts is it?


And this combination appears to have worked the best, if the overall average growth rate is the metric. It would seem the relative level of taxation and government spending achieved in the 1990s led to the best sustained period of economic growth.

But during Bush 43's years there was a return to budget deficits (substantial deficits, in fact) and the continued lowering of tax rates did not lead to even better GDP growth. Indeed, the combination of increased expenses and decreased revenue appears to have led to anemic GDP growth overall. Clinton: 3.9%. Reagan: 3.5%. Bush 41: 2.2%. Bush 43: 2.0%.

Since, however, you are an ideologue first and foremost, and will only accept evidence that fits your preconceived notions, I don't expect you to acknowledge any of this. I personally have no dog in this fight, so it doesn't matter one whit to me whether things were generally better under a Republican president or a Democratic one; it doesn't matter to me at all if growth was better under Reagan or Clinton or either Bush.

But the data points to what it points, and I accept what it tells me. I don't go looking for every excuse in the book to dismiss evidence that is politically/ideologically uncomfortable. (I leave that task to you, as you will no doubt engage in after reading this post.)
 
Last edited:
I have given up on the notion of "compromise" on this regard. The moment Obama agreed that the debt ceiling should be the subject of a deal, he lost. The debt ceiling needs to be a separate discussion from fiscal policy, and he weakly agreed to tie them together. That is why we are where we are....

Indeed, the whole goal of a debt-reduction plan was to protect our credit-rating and to be able to pay our bills.

We negotiated a deal that no one likes and failed to protect our credit-rating. Now Obama knows exactly what happens when he caves to Tea-Bagger & GOP intransigence.

But I fear Obama may not have learned a thing from this whole experience.

All the GOP & the Tea-Party cares about is 2012 and I guess 2016 as well. They are willing to take down this nation in order to achieve this goal. Obama should call their bluff every time from now on, and let them do their worst. Then the American people shall truly understand what we are up against.
 
Last edited:
What am I entitled to?

I'm entitled to laugh at people who so obviously come from positions so extreme that they are indistinguishable from a parody.
This is how condescendingly arrogant ignorance uses personal insult to avoid the truth of themselves in a simple, valid and legitimate question.

What "position so extreme"? Unless the truth doesn't matter near as much as attacking the other, because you care so much.
 
Last edited:
Yeah I know. Too much kool-aid and not enough book learning.

Says the guy(?) who went into hiding when the going got tough.

Say, maybe RF learned that there's the "before" real GDP deflator and the "after" real GDP deflator in one of his *books*? :rolleyes: :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom