USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

Now subtract each year's deficit from the GDP, feel free to ignore multipliers which would just make it worse, and you'll see why we need to keep the deficit spending at least at current levels if we want to be able to pretend we have a growing economy.
Now look at the figures for Clinton and Reagan. Both had much higher tax rates. Both had much better economic figures. Both in the stock market and GDP. It really blows me away that people can look at the stark difference and argue that raising taxes just can't work. I don't get that. What kind of dissonance must that create?
 
Now look at the figures for Clinton and Reagan. Both had much higher tax rates. Both had much better economic figures. Both in the stock market and GDP. It really blows me away that people can look at the stark difference and argue that raising taxes just can't work. I don't get that. What kind of dissonance must that create?

I haven't said a thing about taxes myself, just deficits. Economic contraction would come whether we cut spending or raised taxes. GDP is only growing at all now because we're borrowing and spending an increasing share of said GDP every year. Simply failing to increase the deficit might be enough to bring GDP growth to a halt, let alone actually reducing it.
 
I haven't said a thing about taxes myself, just deficits. Economic contraction would come whether we cut spending or raised taxes. GDP is only growing at all now because we're borrowing and spending an increasing share of said GDP every year. Simply failing to increase the deficit might be enough to bring GDP growth to a halt, let alone actually reducing it.
I think you should look at taxes. It's fairly simple. Reagan lowered taxes and the economy did not rebound. So, he raised taxes. The economy rebounded. Now, you can argue, and I'd concede, post hoc proctor hoc. My point is that under both Regan and Clinton increased tax rates is negatively correlated to a bad economy. Perhaps it's time we started looking at tax rate increases. Yes, I know that you didn't say anything about taxes.

IMO, you should.
 
Sorry to burst your bubble, but one poll showed 35% of Dems thought Bush knew beforehand about 9/11 and and 26% are not sure. http://www.rasmussenreports.com/pub...lieve_bush_knew_about_9_11_attacks_in_advance]
Yeah, that's more than I remember but I dispute the notion that everyone who was suspicious of Bush was a birther. I use birther to denote someone who actively pursued the idea, subscribed to Loose Change, etc. Not someone who wouldn't give Bush the benefit of doubt but just walked away because the whole thing wasn't worth pursuing.

So I'll stick by my assertion.


ETA: This is pretty far off topic. If you want to pursue the issue, please start a new thread.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, that's more than I remember but I dispute the notion that everyone who was suspicious of Bush was a birther. I use birther to denote someone who actively pursued the idea, subscribed to Loose Change, etc. Not someone who wouldn't give Bush the benefit of doubt but just walked away because the whole thing wasn't worth pursuing.

So I'll stick by my assertion.


ETA: This is pretty far off topic. If you want to pursue the issue, please start a new thread.

'Birther' or 'truther'?
 
Perhaps it's time we started looking at tax rate increases.
That still does solve the entitlement disaster on the horizon. You'd have to DOUBLE the tax rates for all tax brackets just to cover Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security. Those programs will consume ALL tax revenues by 2049 leaving no funds for anything else. We are heading for a Greece like meltdown unless the public changes it's entitlement mindset and puts the pressure on to cut and restructure the programs.
 
That still does solve the entitlement disaster on the horizon. You'd have to DOUBLE the tax rates for all tax brackets just to cover Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security. Those programs will consume ALL tax revenues by 2049 leaving no funds for anything else. We are heading for a Greece like meltdown unless the public changes it's entitlement mindset and puts the pressure on to cut and restructure the programs.
Without debating the merits of the links, they are neither here nor there.

  1. I did NOT say raise taxes only.
  2. I said, raising taxes is a very, very important part of the solution and we have to stop throwing the baby out with the bath water.
  3. Lowering taxes has been irresponsible. It needs to stop.
Arguing that "raising taxes only isn't a solution", is a straw man.
 
Watching CNN's coverage of this today, I was struck by the reaction of the Republican presidential candidates-to-be. Essentially all of them said, "it's Obama's fault. He didn't show enough leadership."
Nothing about T-Party intransigence, nothing about the essential causation of the financial mess, nothing in the way of a proposed fix... "here's what I would do!".
Nope. Just finger-pointing and partisan politics.
Rather sad.

Bachmann said that the president "destroyed" the credit rating of the United Stated through his "inability to control government spending by once again raising the debt ceiling."

So according to Bachmann, if Obama had just allowed the country to go into default as she wanted, our credit rating would be just fine. Never mind that's the opposite of what the credit agencies said would happen if we failed to raise the debt ceiling.

-Bri
 
Bachmann said that the president "destroyed" the credit rating of the United Stated through his "inability to control government spending by once again raising the debt ceiling."

So according to Bachmann, if Obama had just allowed the country to go into default as she wanted, our credit rating would be just fine. Never mind that's the opposite of what the credit agencies said would happen if we failed to raise the debt ceiling.

-Bri
It strikes me as fairly clear that this is about politics. Winning the white house at all costs. Though I don't doubt that they comfort themselves with notions that what they are doing is also good for the Country.
 
Without debating the merits of the links, they are neither here nor there.
The entitlements are hardly not relevant unless you are part of the mindset that most people are in which all they care about is their next entitlement check being in the mailbox.
  1. I did NOT say raise taxes only.
  2. I said, raising taxes is a very, very important part of the solution and we have to stop throwing the baby out with the bath water.
  3. Lowering taxes has been irresponsible. It needs to stop.
Arguing that "raising taxes only isn't a solution", is a straw man.
And I never made that claim, but even if taxes were raised as you continuously urge, that wouldn't fix things unless you are urging to more than double the tax rates. We get that you want taxes increased, but you need to see that even with the push to up the high income bracket taxes, close the loopholes, etc. the system is still broken.
 
I didn't read every post in the thread, so I apologize if this has already been said:

From what I saw, S&P's hand in lowering the rating was pretty much forced. If the leader of a company offering AAA bonds had publicly announced, "Depending on how things go this month, we can't say for sure that we're going to be able to make all our bond payments.", it would seem to be pretty negligent for any bond rating agency to keep that company's bond's rating at AAA. I think, after the president made a similar statement about paying our debts, S&P had to take that action. I would expect others to follow.
 
And I never made that claim....
Oh for crying in the dark.

Contrast and compare.

but even if taxes were raised as you continuously urge, that wouldn't fix things unless you are urging to more than double the tax rates.
ONLY IF THERE WERE NO CUTS TO SPENDING!

Are you going to keep at this?
 
What conclusions about taxation and other fiscal policy, if any, should one draw from the above?

Well let's see.

Here's what you say about Reagan's term:

Reagan

1982 compared to 1981: -1.9%
1983 compared to 1982: 4.5%
1984 compared to 1983: 7.2%
1985 compared to 1984: 4.1%
1986 compared to 1985: 3.5%
1987 compared to 1986: 3.2%
1988 compared to 1987: 4.1%

For that to happen, what did Reagan do?

First, unlike Obama, he didn't massively interfere during a deep recession. And as a result, GDP did what it's always done (till now and during Hoover's term) … shown high growth rates after a deep recession. Whereas growth rates from the 2008-2009 recession have been anything but.

Second, Reagan significantly cut top tax rates. So did Bush. Whereas Obama is has talked and talked and talked about raising them.

Then, Reagan kept growth going by keeping the taxes low, trying to reduce government spending, and in general getting government out of people's lives. Which the last Bush emulated during his term in office, if not to the degree of Reagan. Now contrast that with Obama's term so far?

Maybe the lesson is that we need more of that keeping taxes low, reducing government spending and getting government out of people's lives … you know … the Tea Party agenda. :D

And what about Clinton? You say this:

Clinton

1993 compared to 1992: 2.8%
1994 compared to 1993: 4.1%
1995 compared to 1994: 2.5%
1996 compared to 1995: 3.7%
1997 compared to 1996: 4.5%
1998 compared to 1997: 4.4%
1999 compared to 1998: 4.8%
2000 compared to 1999: 4.1%

Well, first, note the sudden jump of about a percent in growth that took place in 1996 and thereafter? You don't suppose that has something to do with republicans taking over Congress and forcing tax cuts and cuts in spending through, do you?

Second, Clinton never had to face a serious war (and certainly one that he didn't start), a serious recession, and enjoyed the benefit of the internet boom … the last time US technology was really preeminent in any industry. So maybe that's not a fair comparison to the last Bush either. Hmmmmm?

And third, Clinton did try to manage the deficit. So did Bush II for that matter. Whereas Obama has let the deficit as a percent of GDP get completely out of hand, as well as spending as a percent of GDP. Wouldn't it have been nice if Obama had learned something from Clinton besides how to abuse illegal foreign campaign contributions? :rolleyes:

How do you like those conclusions? :D
 
And I never made that claim, but even if taxes were raised as you continuously urge, that wouldn't fix things unless you are urging to more than double the tax rates. We get that you want taxes increased, but you need to see that even with the push to up the high income bracket taxes, close the loopholes, etc. the system is still broken.

I think RandFan already agreed with you here. Why do you keep saying the same thing that nobody has disagreed with? RandFan was fairly clear that he advocates spending cuts in addition to tax increases.

If the goal is a balanced budget, do you disagree that spending cuts would need to be deeper without any tax increases or with tax decreases than they would with tax increases?

-Bri
 
Last edited:
I think RandFan already agreed with you here. Why do you keep saying the same thing that nobody has disagreed with? RandFan was fairly clear that he advocates spending cuts in addition to tax increases.

If the goal is a balanced budget, do you disagree that spending cuts would need to be deeper without any tax increases or with tax decreases than they would with tax increases?

-Bri

RandFan; We need to raise taxes.
Neally: Raising taxes alone won't solve the problem.
RandFan: Agreed but raising taxes is very important.
Neally: Raising taxes alone won't solve the problem.
RandFan: That's correct. We need a balanced approach.
Neally: Raising taxes alone won't solve the problem.

{sigh}
 
RandFan; We need to raise taxes.
Neally: Raising taxes alone won't solve the problem.
RandFan: Agreed but raising taxes is very important.
Neally: Raising taxes alone won't solve the problem.
RandFan: That's correct. We need a balanced approach.
Neally: Raising taxes alone won't solve the problem.

{sigh}

besides raising taxes and cutting spending, there has to be a fundamental shift in attitude.
the nauseatingly wacky right has to take some ownership of the problem.
interesting that those that oppose raising taxes, are also staunch supporters of the wars in afghanistan and iraq.
they can't have it both ways.
someone has to pay for the madness of the last decade or so.
 
besides raising taxes and cutting spending, there has to be a fundamental shift in attitude.
the nauseatingly wacky right has to take some ownership of the problem.
interesting that those that oppose raising taxes, are also staunch supporters of the wars in afghanistan and iraq.
they can't have it both ways.
someone has to pay for the madness of the last decade or so.
Agreed!

We have to stop this idiotic religious like dogma that lowering taxes is always good and raising taxes is always bad.

Seriously, stop it.

What really angers me is that if you ask what the rate should be most cannot give you an answer. They only know that the current rate at best can't be raised. Why? It will slow economic growth. Evidence? We don't need no stinkin evidence.

It's antithetical to everything skeptics and critical thinkers hold dear. It's a religious like devotion. Stop it!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom