USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

Straw man.
Really? Explain the difference between "not relevant" and "neither here nor there".

What really angers me is that if you ask what the rate should be most cannot give you an answer.
Back at you. What should the tax rate be raised to?

I think RandFan already agreed with you here. Why do you keep saying the same thing that nobody has disagreed with? RandFan was fairly clear that he advocates spending cuts in addition to tax increases.
I have yet to see him acknowledge that RADICAL cuts need to be made, not just the ones the parties already agreed to, otherwise more than DOUBLING the tax rates will be needed, and if he is okay with more than doubling the tax rates, he needs to say so.

If the goal is a balanced budget, do you disagree that spending cuts would need to be deeper without any tax increases or with tax decreases than they would with tax increases?
Of course, but I keep repeating myself because I still see no acknowledgment of the scope of the problem. Taxes will have to increase and massive entitlement cuts/changes will have to be made to fix this long term. Again, closing loopholes and getting rid of the Bush tax cuts won't fix it. That's not to say they shouldn't be done, but that's all I keep hearing as the solution.

bikerdruid said:
besides raising taxes and cutting spending, there has to be a fundamental shift in attitude.
the nauseatingly wacky right has to take some ownership of the problem.
interesting that those that oppose raising taxes, are also staunch supporters of the wars in afghanistan and iraq.
Agreed, as long as the nauseatingly wacky left takes ownership of the entitlements that need to be cut before the country is bankrupt. That shift in attitude includes the public stop demanding ever increasing government benefits.
 
It's a religious like devotion.
This. It is dogma. They attribute it to the "great thinkers" like Reagan and Adam Smith without even looking at what Reagan and Adam Smith actually advocated. It is beyond reproach, beyond compromise, much as the words of Jesus or Mohammed or L. Ron Hubbard are fundamental truths from which every other policy decision sprouts. Taxes are defined as theft by some extraneous entity called Government. Theft is wrong.

They must be educated, and if they (as I suspect) are ineducable they must be shunned.
 
Agreed, as long as the nauseatingly wacky left takes ownership of the entitlements that need to be cut before the country is bankrupt. That shift in attitude includes the public stop demanding ever increasing government benefits.

entitlements?
you mean like education, social security and healthcare?
sure...screw the sick, the old and the young.....let 'em work!
 
Really? Explain the difference between "not relevant" and "neither here nor there".
Because:

  • I don't claim that entitlements are not a problem.
  • I don't claim that spending shouldn't be cut.
  • Your links support the idea that entitlements need to be cut (conceded).
  • Your links support the idea that spending needs to be cut (conceded).
None of that is relevant to my point.

Back at you. What should the tax rate be raised to?
We should begin to take them back to the Clinton rates. 100% is too much. 0% is too little. There is no way to know exactly what is right. We know what has worked and we know what isn't working.

I have yet to see him acknowledge that RADICAL cuts need to be made, not just the ones the parties already agreed to, otherwise more than DOUBLING the tax rates will be needed, and if he is okay with more than doubling the tax rates, he needs to say so.
Oy vey. No. I don't.

Of course, but I keep repeating myself because I still see no acknowledgment of the scope of the problem.
It's a big problem.

Taxes will have to increase...
THANK YOU! :) Finally.

...and massive entitlement cuts/changes will have to be made to fix this long term.
I don't know how much. It might very well be massive. Let's get off of stupid (no tax rate increases) and come up with a reasonable comprehensive plan. To date the Dems are willing to cut spending (not enough but they are moving in the right direction). The GOP? Yeah, you guessed it. God and no new taxes. Yesterday they held a prayer rally in Texas. I'll bet a months salary someone prayed for no new taxes.
 
Last edited:
this. It is dogma. They attribute it to the "great thinkers" like reagan and adam smith without even looking at what reagan and adam smith actually advocated. It is beyond reproach, beyond compromise, much as the words of jesus or mohammed or l. Ron hubbard are fundamental truths from which every other policy decision sprouts. Taxes are defined as theft by some extraneous entity called government. Theft is wrong.

They must be educated, and if they (as i suspect) are ineducable they must be shunned.

bingo!
 
...Back at you. What should the tax rate be raised to?...

Returning the highest FIT rate to 40% should be adequate. And it would still be significantly lower than it has been during most of the 20th century.
 
RandFan; We need to raise taxes.
Neally: Raising taxes alone won't solve the problem.
RandFan: Agreed but raising taxes is very important.
Neally: Raising taxes alone won't solve the problem.
RandFan: That's correct. We need a balanced approach.
Neally: Raising taxes alone won't solve the problem.

{sigh}


BeAChooser: Bush's Tax cuts helped the economy.
RandFan: No they didn't.
BeAChooser: GDP grew 3.5% after his second tax cut.
RandFan: No, it grew 0.75%. The economy never grew at 3.5%.
BeAChooser: Well you'd better tell these folks (posting graphs).
RandFan: Dude, I'm posting the facts. Average GDP increase was .75%. It was NEVER 3.5%.
BeAChooser: Here are some more graphs. They ALL show average real gdp growth rates of 3.0-3.5% for many quarters after the 2003 cut.
RandFan: You got caught lying. Run away.
BeAChooser: Divide the Real GDP that you just posted for 2004 by the one you posted for 2003. You get 3.5%.
RandFan: Never mind I'm right. You didn't use the GDP deflator. Average growth is 1.4% without the deflator. With the deflator? .75%.
BeAChooser: You have no idea what the deflator is or does. You don't even know what REAL GDP is, do you?
RandFan: There is "REAL GDP" before the deflator and "REAL GDP" after the deflator.
BeAChooser: Just keep posting. This is getting more hilarious by the moment. And you don't even know it.
RandFan: Good day sir and welcome to my ignore list.

{sigh}
 
Last edited:
entitlements?
you mean like education, social security and healthcare?
As suspected. Yep those and more entitlements. The nauseatingly wacky left can only think about taxing the disgusting wealthy and ending the wars and won't see that the entitlements are the piece that will do us in. In fact, the S&P Chief Beers said, "The key thing is, yes, entitlement reform is important because entitlements are the biggest component of spending, and the part of spending where the cost pressures are greatest,"


Returning the highest FIT rate to 40% should be adequate. And it would still be significantly lower than it has been during most of the 20th century.
No, sorry, that won't do it. Tax rates have to DOUBLE across ALL brackets just to cover Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security unless those are drastically cut.
 
No, sorry, that won't do it. Tax rates have to DOUBLE across ALL brackets just to cover Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security unless those are drastically cut.
You asked him what the rate should be. He didn't say that 40% would obviate spending cuts.

BTW: Military spending is very significant and a huge variable we can control and should not ignore. There should be nothing sacred.
 
Military spending is very significant and a huge variable we can control

Actually, RF, it's only a variable you can control if you can control how the other guy thinks and behaves. And when have we been able to do that? Hmmmmm?
 
As suspected. Yep those and more entitlements. The nauseatingly wacky left can only think about taxing the disgusting wealthy and ending the wars and won't see that the entitlements are the piece that will do us in. In fact, the S&P Chief Beers said, "The key thing is, yes, entitlement reform is important because entitlements are the biggest component of spending, and the part of spending where the cost pressures are greatest,"


No, sorry, that won't do it. Tax rates have to DOUBLE across ALL brackets just to cover Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security unless those are drastically cut.

Loadhandler to Pilot: The plane is too heavy! It won't get off the ground.

Pilot: Increase the ticket prices! Add more fuel!

:rolleyes:
 
entitlements?
you mean like education, social security and healthcare?
sure...screw the sick, the old and the young.....let 'em work!
That's correct. If you are spending the money of our children to fund these giveaways today, then you are cheating tomorrows, sick, old and young in favor of today's sick, old and young.

If you are just spending today's money that's another matter.

But you are not...

That will get a lot of people really, really angry at you. Like all those people in a few years that won't get what they were promised.

Do you care about that? Or do you just care about today's party?
 
Last edited:
That's correct. If you are spending the money of our children to fund these giveaways today, then you are cheating tomorrows, sick, old and young in favor of today's sick, old and young.

If you are just spending today's money that's another matter.

But you are not...

That will get a lot of people really, really angry at you. Like all those people in a few years that won't get what they were promised.

Do you care about that? Or do you just care about today's party?

false.
that is only the case if your country continues it's current stupidity.
strong priority on good education is an investment, not a liability.
the old have built the country, and are very deserving of it's support, when they are no longer able to work.
canadians spend less per capita for healthcare than you folks do, and have universal coverage, because we have eliminated the private sector from the equation.

education, pensions, and healthcare are rights, not entitlements, in any civilized country.
 
Loadhandler to Pilot: The plane is too heavy! It won't get off the ground.

Pilot: Increase the ticket prices! Add more fuel!

:rolleyes:

Planning dept: Cargo is trending up.
CFO: Get bigger planes. We will raise rates to meet the demand. However the market won't bear enough of an increase to meet all of the demand. Put a cap on cargo growth.

:)

It's not that difficult folks if you avoid the silly analogies.
 
They pass laws and set policy to ensure that their wealth is protected.
Examples so I know exactly what you're referring to?

Since the banks melted many small time crooks have been caught, prosecuted and sentenced to prison. The a-holes that caused material harm to many through fraud? BTW: It's not like we don't know who they are.
Non sequitur.

I'm not going to get into arcane tax code. Those are not insoluble problems.
If you're proposing to tax assets you have to demonstrate a practical way to do that.
 
Last edited:
Examples so I know exactky what you're referring to?

  • Laws that allow predatory lending practices (charging usurious rates) and giving loans to people that are likely to result in the confiscation of their assets because of bad credit knowing Uncle Sam will back the gamble.
  • Deregulation
  • Eliminating and refusing oversight
Non sequitur.
No.

If you're proposing to tax assets you have to demonstrate a practical way to do that.
I'm not proposing to do so. I'm saying we have sufficient wealth to justify increased rates on income.
 
Last edited:
Except for tax expenditures, which are essentially just spending programs hidden in the tax code so they look like reduced taxes (Republicans love these since they look like tax cuts but are really spending programs). They tend to benefit only certain groups of people or companies.

http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/background/expenditures/

-Bri
Did you happen to look at what the largest tax expenditures are? Number 1 on that list, accounting for $131 billion per year, is excluding employer's portion of health care benefits from the income of workers for tax purposes. I have long advocated eliminating this tax deduction and am on record here as such.

Number 2, at $117.7 billion, is deduction of pension contributions from income. I also think this one should be eliminated.

All compensation from an employer should be subject to income tax IMHO, because it is actually income.

Number 3, at $88 billion, is mortgage interest deductions. As this is built into the price of homes I don't see how this could be eliminated without further disrupting, and in a major way, already depressed real estate prices. I see no benefits to eliminating this deduction. The only people who benefitted frm it were mortgage holders when it was first passed generations ago, but we're stuck with it now. Eliminating it will cost more than it benefits.
 
You should stop sourcing that rag.


How about NBC? You trust them?

http://www.nbc12.com/story/10826743...ides-free-cell-phone-services?redirected=true

Jul 31, 2009

Government program provides free cell phone services

RICHMOND, VA (WWBT) - 90 percent of low-income families in Virginia are missing out on a chance to get a free cell phone with free minutes every month.

How about the NY Times?

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/15/technology/15cell.html

Providing Cellphones for the Poor

June 14, 2009

… snip …

Since November, the number of customers receiving free or subsidized wireless service has doubled to 1.4 million, he said. To be eligible for the program, known as Lifeline, a person must meet federal low-income guidelines or qualify for one of a handful of social service programs, including food stamps or Medicaid.

And the numbers keep growing:

http://blog.heritage.org/2010/01/18/government-welfare-cell-phones-for-the-poor/

January 18, 2010

Welfare recipients in approximately 20 states–with more to follow– are currently eligible to receive a free cell phone with a limited number of monthly minutes. All individuals that qualify for state or federal welfare–food stamps, Medicaid, etc.–and have an income at or below 135% of the poverty level, are eligible. According to a Fox News report, the cell phone service is currently the fastest growing welfare program in the country.

In 2008, the fund that foots the bill for this program contributed $819 million to subsidize low-income telephone services. The fund is projected to grow to over $1 billion this year. That’s $1 billion of over $800 billion the United States will spend on welfare in 2010.

And growing ...

http://news.yahoo.com/3-000-000-middle-class-americans-eligible-free-070445755.html

July 12, 2011

Thanks to a little-noticed clause in the nation’s new healthcare law, up to three million middle-class Americans will qualify for free cell phones under the government’s popular Lifeline phone service program.

Wow. Even Snopes gets this right:

http://www.snopes.com/politics/taxes/cellphone.asp

TRUE: A federal program subsidizes providers who supply cell phones and essential cellular services to low-income consumers.

So I ask again, are free cell phones a right? An entitlement? Hmmmm? :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom