USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

Van Jones, Cynthia McKinney. "Members of their party" also includes anyone registered to the respective parties-- plenty of nuts in the rank and file as well.
Well, you are still stuck with the birfers and Creationists.
 
Van Jones, Cynthia McKinney. "Members of their party" also includes anyone registered to the respective parties-- plenty of nuts in the rank and file as well.

So two people who don't currently hold political office and some undetermined number of random "others"?

:rolleyes:

"False equivalency" doesn't even begin to describe it.
 
Ratings agencies are concerned with the safety of our debt, not the overall health of our economy.
I don't like to argue ad smilie but I can't help it. :eek:

Dude, I hate to break the news to you but if the country crashes the bonds will be good for wall paper. I have confederate currency. Guess how much that was worth after the South lost? (it's worth a bit now). The overall health is crucial.
 
Untrue. The economy has responded to cuts in taxes in a positive way.
.75% is hardly positive.

And YES, I can and have proven it. I posted my numbers. You refuse to. You don't even know what your numbers are. You can't post a single year's GDP. That's rather sad.

Hell if I was in your position and I had a chance to prove myself correct I damn sure would post the numbers. You don't. Things that make you go hmmmm.....
 
Please, anyone who disagrees with my numbers please post different ones.

You can use the this site enter your Initial year and Ending year. Click enter. Or, use your own site.

 
Originally Posted by BeAChooser
Untrue. The economy has responded to cuts in taxes in a positive way.

.75% is hardly positive.

This is a dishonest characterization of what happened after the Bush Tax cuts. Since you insist or repeating this lie on three threads, I have no choice but to show your dishonesty on all three threads.

You posted these figures from your source on one the other threads:

Year Real GDP
2001 11,347,200
2002 11,543,100
2003 11,836,400
2004 12,246,900
2005 12,623,000
2006 12,958,500
2007 13,206,400
2008 13,161,900
2009 12,703,100

They match the numbers you just posted on this thread.

Now, go ahead, divide the Real GDP figure for 2002 by that for 2001. What percent growth do you get? The answer is 1.7%.

Divide 2003 by 2002 and you get 2.5%.

Divide 2004 by 2003 and you 3.5%.

Divide 2005 by 2004 and you get 3.1%.

Divide 2006 by 2005 and you get 2.7%.

Every one of those is a far cry from the 0.75% that you claimed characterized the Real GDP growth rate after the Bush tax cuts.

And the calculation of those numbers INCLUDES the periods of relatively low GDP growth rate that occurred during the periods right before the tax cuts were passed.

If one were to only look at the growth that occurred after the tax cuts, the average percentages would be even be higher … NOT 0.75%.
 
Watching CNN's coverage of this today, I was struck by the reaction of the Republican presidential candidates-to-be. Essentially all of them said, "it's Obama's fault. He didn't show enough leadership."
Nothing about T-Party intransigence, nothing about the essential causation of the financial mess, nothing in the way of a proposed fix... "here's what I would do!".
Nope. Just finger-pointing and partisan politics.
Rather sad.
 
Watching CNN's coverage of this today, I was struck by the reaction of the Republican presidential candidates-to-be. Essentially all of them said, "it's Obama's fault. He didn't show enough leadership."
Nothing about T-Party intransigence, nothing about the essential causation of the financial mess, nothing in the way of a proposed fix... "here's what I would do!".
Nope. Just finger-pointing and partisan politics.
Rather sad.

This is why the Tea-Baggers & the GOP will lose in 2012.
 
You posted these figures from your source on one the other threads:

Year Real GDP
2001 11,347,200
2002 11,543,100
2003 11,836,400
2004 12,246,900
2005 12,623,000
2006 12,958,500
2007 13,206,400
2008 13,161,900
2009 12,703,100

They match the numbers you just posted on this thread.
Proving that I put my numbers out there from day one AND YOU DIDN'T!

If one were to only look at the growth that occurred after the tax cuts, the average percentages would be even be higher … NOT 0.75%.

FACTS YOU IGNORE:

  1. These numbers render a 1.4% averaGe NOT 3.5%
  2. These numbers don't take into account the deflator.
 
So two people who don't currently hold political office and some undetermined number of random "others"?

:rolleyes:

"False equivalency" doesn't even begin to describe it.
Just what part of "35% of Dems thought Bush knew beforehand about 9/11 and and 26% are not sure" is random and undetermined?

I know it's really difficult and presents significant cognitive dissonance, but the dems do have nutters in their midst.

leftysergeant said:
Well, you are still stuck with the birfers and Creationists.
And you now want a pissing contest to determine where the most nutters call home? Both sides have their share of radicals, tards, and violence prone wackos. We've debated the anecdotes endlessly in other threads. Start a new thread if you want to go there.
 
Year Real GDP
2001 11,347,200
2002 11,543,100
2003 11,836,400
2004 12,246,900
2005 12,623,000
2006 12,958,500
2007 13,206,400
2008 13,161,900
2009 12,703,100

They match the numbers you just posted on this thread.

Now, go ahead, divide the Real GDP figure for 2002 by that for 2001. What percent growth do you get? The answer is 1.7%.

Divide 2003 by 2002 and you get 2.5%.

Divide 2004 by 2003 and you 3.5%.

Divide 2005 by 2004 and you get 3.1%.

Divide 2006 by 2005 and you get 2.7%.

Every one of those is a far cry from the 0.75% that you claimed characterized the Real GDP growth rate after the Bush tax cuts.

And the calculation of those numbers INCLUDES the periods of relatively low GDP growth rate that occurred during the periods right before the tax cuts were passed.

If one were to only look at the growth that occurred after the tax cuts, the average percentages would be even be higher … NOT 0.75%.


What do you stop your calculations at 2006? Continuing on from that year:

Divide 2007 by 2006 and you get 1.9%.
Divide 2008 by 2007 and you get -0.3%.
Divide 2009 by 2008 and you get -3.5%.

Now, let's take those individual annual growth rates and average them over the years involved.

Average growth rate for 2002-03: 2.1%
Average growth rate for 2002-04: 2.6%
Average growth rate for 2002-05: 2.7%
Average growth rate for 2002-06: 2.7%
Average growth rate for 2002-07: 2.6%
Average growth rate for 2002-08: 2.1%
Average growth rate for 2002-09: 1.4%
 
Let's take a look at how things stacked up against in the 1980s and 1990s, starting with the year the President in question took office and ending with the year of the election:

Reagan

1982 compared to 1981: -1.9%
1983 compared to 1982: 4.5%
1984 compared to 1983: 7.2%
1985 compared to 1984: 4.1%
1986 compared to 1985: 3.5%
1987 compared to 1986: 3.2%
1988 compared to 1987: 4.1%

Average growth rate in real GDP over 1982-1988: 3.5%

Bush (41)

1989 compared to 1988: 3.6%
1990 compared to 1989: 1.9%
1991 compared to 1990: -0.2%
1992 compared to 1991: 3.4%

Average growth rate in real GDP over 1989-1992: 2.2%

Clinton

1993 compared to 1992: 2.8%
1994 compared to 1993: 4.1%
1995 compared to 1994: 2.5%
1996 compared to 1995: 3.7%
1997 compared to 1996: 4.5%
1998 compared to 1997: 4.4%
1999 compared to 1998: 4.8%
2000 compared to 1999: 4.1%

Average growth rate in real GDP from 1993-2000: 3.9%

What conclusions about taxation and other fiscal policy, if any, should one draw from the above?
 
Last edited:
What do you stop your calculations at 2006? Continuing on from that year:
It doesn't fit his thesis. The Democrats didn't raise taxes (by his theory that is what is needed). He doesn't give a reason he just states that Democrats took office (as if this is really a valid reason). Oh well.
 
Please, anyone who disagrees with my numbers please post different ones.

Now subtract each year's deficit from the GDP, feel free to ignore multipliers which would just make it worse, and you'll see why we need to keep the deficit spending at least at current levels if we want to be able to pretend we have a growing economy.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom