US housing market finally improving?

All I know is that yesterday we got the preliminary plans for the new house we are building. Got some minor tweaking to do (gotta find 60 ft to cut), but we are pretty close. Breaking ground in about 3 weeks.

We ended up building because the supply of existing houses is so low that we haven't been able to buy anything. We keep getting letters from local realtors saying that there is a shortage of houses like ours for sale right now and so it is a great time to sell. Hopefully by mid-summer we can get that done.

Local prices are up something like 17% from last year, too.
 
Do these sales figures include banks buying homes? In my neighborhood, housing "bottomed out" about a year ago in terms of prices, but then some banks bought everything. Like, 90% or more of the houses, and have just been sitting on them, not putting them on the market. When they DO go up for sale, the prices are roughly doubled.

Not sure what's going on here...
Why would banks buy houses when they have so many they don't want due to foreclosures?
 
"All signs looked good" for the tulip bulb market right up until the bubble burst. Same with tech stocks, comic books, any number of stock market bubbles, and housing (round 1).

But now that we're seeing the stirrings of Housing Bubble Round 2, "this time it will be different"....

Once again: massive unemployment/underemployment, continued offshoring/outsourcing, etc. That is not the basis for a sustainable housing market, or any OTHER kind of market.
 
"All signs looked good" for the tulip bulb market right up until the bubble burst. Same with tech stocks, comic books, any number of stock market bubbles, and housing (round 1).

But now that we're seeing the stirrings of Housing Bubble Round 2, "this time it will be different"....

Once again: massive unemployment/underemployment, continued offshoring/outsourcing, etc. That is not the basis for a sustainable housing market, or any OTHER kind of market.

The highlighted part - sez you.
 
The highlighted part - sez you.

hmm. me too.

one in 5 households on foodstamps http://cnsnews.com/blog/joe-schoffstall/record-number-households-food-stamps-1-out-every-5

As CNSNews.com previously reported, food stamp rolls in America recently surpassed the population of Spain. A record number 47,692,896 Americans are now enrolled in the program and the cost of food stamp fraud has more than doubled in just three years.

participation rates at late 70's early 80s levels

even CNBC - "real" unemployment rate still above 10% in most states

and counting it like we used to back the last time we had these participation levels its about 23%

http://www.shadowstats.com/alternate_data/unemployment-charts

The seasonally-adjusted SGS Alternate Unemployment Rate reflects current unemployment reporting methodology adjusted for SGS-estimated long-term discouraged workers, who were defined out of official existence in 1994. That estimate is added to the BLS estimate of U-6 unemployment, which includes short-term discouraged workers.
 
But claims about how unemployment and the economy suck, even if true, do not preclude the possibility of the housing market improving. Improvement is a relative term. Improvement means better than it was in 2009, and does not imply that it was as good as 2002.

Telling us what unemployment is now is a non-sequitor
 
Case-Shiller confirms the recovery:

Home Prices in U.S. Rise by Most Since 2006 in March

And for those who argue that all this can't possibly be real because the economy is still in the crapper, how do you explain this:

Consumer Confidence in U.S. Climbs to Highest in Five Years

Confidence among U.S. consumers climbed in May to the highest level in more than five years as views on the economy and labor market improved.

The Conference Board’s index rose to 76.2, the strongest since February 2008 and exceeding the highest estimate in a Bloomberg survey of economists, from a revised 69 in April, data from the New York-based private research group showed today. The median forecast called for an increase to 71.2.

The gain in sentiment coincides with rising property values and stocks that are providing a boost for household balance sheets at the same time the job market heals. Further improvement in Americans’ outlooks may encourage a pickup in consumer spending, which accounts for about 70 percent of the economy.

The Dow and S&P 500 are both up on the news.
 
The whole dynamic changes when prices are rising instead of falling.

They could have also just come to terms with the fact that they were going to be stuck holding a vast majority of the over-supply of houses one way or another, and decided to use a "slow release with raised prices" strategy to offset/correct the financial losses and get prices back up.

Sort of like an alternative to this:
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748703950804575242433435338728.html
 
And for those who argue that all this can't possibly be real because the economy is still in the crapper, how do you explain this:

Consumer Confidence in U.S. Climbs to Highest in Five Years

cant answer for any others, but see contrarians look at this

Consumer confidence climbed to the highest level in more than five years
and think, hmmm, so the highest levels of herd confidence since 2008.. ..and were they right then?

The Dow and S&P 500 are both up on the news.

the DOW & S&P are both up, and this is the news. Correlation isn't so easy to prove. it is MUCH easier to prove they're up because it's Tuesday in fact.

Traders taunted with 20/20 Turbo Tuesday POMO

..well, if 20 out of 20 Tuesdays in a row means anything statistically, anyway :D
 
more comparisons with "the good old days" - median new homeprice / real income per capita.

Zerohedge and their dangerously large drinking vessels again :rolleyes:

A better graph is affordability. I'm sure you remember in the 1980s, house prices were comparatively low but the mortgage payments were excruciatingly high because interest rates were more than 10%. I distinctly remember a day when base rates hit 15%.

Here are some graphs for the UK (especially the "Affordability of Mortgage Payments"), I cannot easily find something similar for the US.

http://www.economicshelp.org/blog/5568/housing/uk-house-price-affordability/

People tend to focus on the monthly payment so if interest rates are low they can borrow more for a given monthly payment which will tend to drive up prices. As you've said before, and I agree, the litmus test will come when interest rates start to rise. IMO if the rise comes as a natural part of the economic cycle then it won't be so bad but if rates have to rise to counter rampant stagflation then that's a different kettle of fish.
 
and think, hmmm, so the highest levels of herd confidence since 2008.. ..and were they right then?

In a world where the green shoots of consumer confidence indicate an impending crash then we're screwed in perpetuity.

To put the confidence in some context, although it's higher than it has been in recent years, it's still lower than:

  • Lower than it has been for 90% of the time since 1967
  • A little over half its level prior to the 2008 crash

So IMO it doesn't seem dangerously high

Source: http://www.tradingeconomics.com/united-states/consumer-confidence - I changed the date range on the graph
 
Zerohedge and their dangerously large drinking vessels again :rolleyes:

facts are facts, we're only discussing the slant we want to put on them here, and that charts implies two things

1. that homes are the most unaffordable they have ever been for "the average man"

2. that the cheap credit propping up the housing market is bigger than it has ever been in history, and at the ZLB, servicing costs have only one way to go from here.

A better graph is affordability.

better for who?

I'm sure you remember in the 1980s, house prices were comparatively low but the mortgage payments were excruciatingly high because interest rates were more than 10%. I distinctly remember a day when base rates hit 15%.

yes, I remember that, post bubble bursts in the past used to come with rising interest rates :)

Here are some graphs for the UK (especially the "Affordability of Mortgage Payments"), I cannot easily find something similar for the US.

http://www.economicshelp.org/blog/5568/housing/uk-house-price-affordability/

People tend to focus on the monthly payment so if interest rates are low they can borrow more for a given monthly payment which will tend to drive up prices. As you've said before, and I agree, the litmus test will come when interest rates start to rise. IMO if the rise comes as a natural part of the economic cycle then it won't be so bad but if rates have to rise to counter rampant stagflation then that's a different kettle of fish.

the point of the chart above being to show that fundamentally the situation is once again at extremes of the range, higher even than the peak of the 2007 bubble burst, right now.
 
better for who?

A better indication about how affordable current house prices are and hence how resilient they may be to changes in circumstances.


edited to add.

The reasons why zerohedge have chosen the "real disposable income" vs. house prices IMO are:

  • Disposable income is an indication as to how much money people actually have so it is an indication of affordability
  • It makes for a nice alarming graph - and zerohedge are in the Chicken Little business

Any true indication of affordability should IMO take into account how expensive the mortgage payments are so mortgage payment vs. disposable income would be a fairer assessment (but less alarming).
 
Last edited:
In a world where the green shoots of consumer confidence indicate an impending crash then we're screwed in perpetuity.

To put the confidence in some context, although it's higher than it has been in recent years, it's still lower than:

  • Lower than it has been for 90% of the time since 1967
  • A little over half its level prior to the 2008 crash

So IMO it doesn't seem dangerously high

Source: http://www.tradingeconomics.com/united-states/consumer-confidence - I changed the date range on the graph


no, not dangerously high, but it's all relative.

in conjunction with everything else as part of the (my) overall picture..

on it's own the number doesn't mean much, and under different circumstances could of course be seen positively (by me). in this instance, it seems to show the same levels of financial foresight "consumers" are traditionally renowned for, "Consumer's Misplaced Confidence Survey" might be a better name :D

confidence.png
 
That assumes that the customer confidence cycle is 4 years long. The last one was but the one before that was 9 years long, the one before that was 7-8 years long.
 
That assumes that the customer confidence cycle is 4 years long. The last one was but the one before that was 9 years long, the one before that was 7-8 years long.

I don't think the Zero Hedge goldbugs perform such deep analysis.

Look, a pretty graph!!! And it goes up and down!!!11!1!1!!

Every rational observer I've seen or read acknowledges that housing and businesses are on the rebound.
 
Last edited:
So, this may sound stupid and uninformed, but what are the fundamentals of recovery of the housing market?

I mean, assuming most people live in one home, are we underbuilt or overbuilt for the existing population?

To me it seemed like legalizing all the illegal immigrants, thus encouraging them to buy houses, would have taken care of the oversupply. (The Economist backed this up).

But, if we have more houses than we have people who can afford to live in them, isn't there a fundamental supply-and-demand issue? Builders went gangbusters before the bubble burst, riding a wave of speculation. I bought a house before prices went through the roof but I never assumed it was a piggy bank. Housing market recovery doesn't seem like an unmitigated blessing to me - it makes houses more expensive. Bad if I'm the buyer, good if I'm the seller, but even then, I need to live somewhere.
 
So, this may sound stupid and uninformed, but what are the fundamentals of recovery of the housing market?

I mean, assuming most people live in one home, are we underbuilt or overbuilt for the existing population?

To me it seemed like legalizing all the illegal immigrants, thus encouraging them to buy houses, would have taken care of the oversupply. (The Economist backed this up).

But, if we have more houses than we have people who can afford to live in them, isn't there a fundamental supply-and-demand issue? Builders went gangbusters before the bubble burst, riding a wave of speculation. I bought a house before prices went through the roof but I never assumed it was a piggy bank. Housing market recovery doesn't seem like an unmitigated blessing to me - it makes houses more expensive. Bad if I'm the buyer, good if I'm the seller, but even then, I need to live somewhere.

Isn't this the truth. All of the Bernanke bucks benefit some elite bankers, with the second order effect of boosting the nominal wealth of real-estate, stock, and bond market investors, while everybody else on fixed income, or living off of meager savings gets relatively more poor. In addition to being economically polarizing and socially destabilizing, the monetary system is patently unfair.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom