US housing market finally improving?

Charles Biderman makes some pretty alarming predictions in that article:

So if the Yen doesn't touch 200 to the dollar by, say, year end can we say that maybe he was either mistaken or indulging in hyperbole ?

lol no? thats another thread? but on the subject, year-end no, Kyle Bass has given the same long term Yen target, but he also regularly says:

"It would be naive of me, or anybody, to think they can accurately predict the when or how, of the end of a 70 year debt supercycle"

but that it will end is not in doubt.

but in this thread can we discuss the benefits of monitoring the state of the economy using after tax income vs "GDP" and whether it was a one off illusory spike caused by changing tax laws (it was) instead please? :)
 
Okay so taking what he said:

April income tax payments sent in by individuals are surging, up by more than $50 billion over April 2012 and higher by $63 billion year to date. That means to me that year end 2012 income from asset sales and bonuses had to have spiked by around $300 billion to generate that $63 billion in bigger tax payments. I know, this is a lot of numbers and some of you should read the transcript instead of this video. To go back, in other words anticipation of this year’s higher taxes created a one time 10 percent pop in income over those few months the $300 billion became income!

That seems like speculation on his part. He attributes all of the additional tax take to asset and bonuses taken to avoid higher taxes later and none of it to higher incomes and more people paying taxes.

The CBO states that it's because of higher rates being paid by richer people and higher payments to fund Social Security:

Tax receipts are surging largely because the payroll taxes employees pay to fund Social Security rose in January and because rates rose on the richest Americans.

http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-505123_162-57584449/feds-u.s-goverment-deficit-is-plunging/
 
Okay so taking what he said:

That seems like speculation on his part. He attributes all of the additional tax take to asset and bonuses taken to avoid higher taxes later and none of it to higher incomes and more people paying taxes.

The CBO states that it's because of higher rates being paid by richer people and higher payments to fund Social Security:

http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-505123_162-57584449/feds-u.s-goverment-deficit-is-plunging/

ok fair point. for reference this is his after tax income tracking service

announced here http://charlesbiderman.com/2013/01/02/after-tax-income-showing-possible-recession-to-start-2013/ with his arguments for why it is a superior measure to GDP.

with regards the difference between his conclusions and the CBO's this will be at least be fairly quickly shown by whether we continue (economy, not housing particularly) or resume slump now, won't it?
 
Okay so taking what he said:



That seems like speculation on his part. He attributes all of the additional tax take to asset and bonuses taken to avoid higher taxes later and none of it to higher incomes and more people paying taxes.

The CBO states that it's because of higher rates being paid by richer people and higher payments to fund Social Security:



http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-505123_162-57584449/feds-u.s-goverment-deficit-is-plunging/

Indeed. It is true that capital gains tax rates rose for some people (those with income over $400K) in January and some of those people might have realized capital gains before the end of the year to avoid paying the higher rate. I don't know what the specific numbers were for that though or how they compare with previous years.
 
but in this thread can we discuss the benefits of monitoring the state of the economy using after tax income vs "GDP" and whether it was a one off illusory spike caused by changing tax laws (it was) instead please? :)

So, using after tax income instead of GDP would make it appear that countries like the Scandinavian countries or the UK with higher taxes but which also provide their citizens with things like universal health care would fare worse under that measure than GDP. If you think that government is generally a bad thing, I suppose it makes some sense.
 
Last edited:
So, using after tax income instead of GDP would make it appear that countries like the Scandinavian countries or the UK with higher taxes but which also provide their citizens with things like universal health care would fare worse under that measure than GDP. If you think that government is generally a bad thing, I suppose it makes some sense.

inter country comparisons could give that impression, (as can everybody calculating GDP differently I would assume?) but within each country we are really just looking at relative growth MOM & YOY aren't we?

edit, do we agree is it feasible to track the health or otherwise of an economy in this way? obviously it doesnt track the black or grey economies, but they are not paying tax either.
 
Last edited:
I don't know why he's chosen such an arbitrary measure and then chosen such a bizarre way to calculate it. He only includes federal payroll taxes and none of the state, local, asset, transactional or indirect taxes, I suppose it's because he can calculate it but it's pretty meaningless.

GDP is an attempt to calculate the total output of the economy. It takes into account government, corporate and individual output. It's a flawed measure, only an estimate and presumably inaccurate but at least it's comprehensive.

Individuals' income after federal income taxes doesn't really provide a measure of much of anything. If he wanted to assess how much money people had in their pockets to go out and but goods and services then disposable income would be a better measure.


He seems to have selected this measure because it supports his views and because it's easy to calculate.
 
I don't know why he's chosen such an arbitrary measure and then chosen such a bizarre way to calculate it. He only includes federal payroll taxes and none of the state, local, asset, transactional or indirect taxes, I suppose it's because he can calculate it but it's pretty meaningless.

are these not all costs to a consumer that would need to be paid from their gross (after tax) income?

I would have thought that it should follow, that if the population are earning more after tax, things are on the up? if they are earning less, (whether more tax or less income) then things are declining?
GDP is an attempt to calculate the total output of the economy. It takes into account government, corporate and individual output. It's a flawed measure, only an estimate and presumably inaccurate but at least it's comprehensive.

comprehensively nonsense, IMO. would it be possible for these 2 measurements, GDP and after tax income to go in different directions for long?

I like the simplicity as a real on the ground measurement as opposed to the alternative (which I have explained the faults of, up to 15% per year made up) many times.

Individuals' income after federal income taxes doesn't really provide a measure of much of anything. If he wanted to assess how much money people had in their pockets to go out and but goods and services then disposable income would be a better measure. He seems to have selected this measure because it supports his views and because it's easy to calculate

you dont see any correlation between overall spendable money by the population and the general health of the economy?
 
Last edited:
are these not all costs to a consumer that would need to be paid from their gross (after tax) income?

I would have thought that it should follow, that if the population are earning more after tax, things are on the up? if they are earning less, (whether more tax or less income) then things are declining?

IF you think that the measure for a country's economic health is income after tax then it should at least be calculated correctly and not in the sloppy easy way. It needs to include local taxes (local income tax can be significant in the U.S.) and should also probably include all aspects of tax because it would otherwise miss a move from direct to indirect tax or vice-versa.

comprehensively nonsense, IMO. would it be possible for these 2 measurements, GDP and after tax income to go in different directions for long?

I like the simplicity as a real on the ground measurement as opposed to the alternative (which I have explained the faults of, up to 15% per year made up) many times.

Just because it's easy to calculate doesn't mean that it's a good measure. GDP takes into account all aspects of the economy and not just a narrow view of income after taxation. In the past taxation has been use as means to put a brake on an overenthusiastic economy - in fact under Keynesian rules tax should rise during periods of economic growth to pay off past debts and to allow a surplus for future dips. Under these circumstances incomes after tax could grow less quickly (or even shrink) because the economy is doing so well.

you dont see any correlation between overall spendable money by the population and the general health of the economy?

Overall spendable money would be one of many indicators that can indicate the health or otherwise of the economy. There are many others. If overall spendable money is the chosen measure then let's keep track of disposable income rather than just income after federal income tax.

GDP is a way of keeping track of the economy as a whole rather than just the narrow view of consumer income after tax.
 
The numbers you initially stated (20%) were shown to be a gross overestimate.

If anything, they were a bit low, given the factor that even I had overlooked, and that's the issue of Full Time Equivalents made up of cut hours.

The ones you provided with at least some kind of backing (11.7%) were also an overestimate.

See above.

Look at the economic indicators, house sales, car sales, consumer spending, they're on the up.

But is it sustainable, or people being FORCED into temporary spending (for worn-out product replacement, for example)

Of course there are large numbers of families in severe financial difficulties but there are larger numbers of families who are rubbing along nicely thank you. Of course "family makes end meet comfortably" does not make a compelling headline.

Far more of the former than the later. The false perception of some that "things are looking up" is a matter of locale bias. If you live in the Hamptons, for example, you won't see much economic distress. If you travel with the Jet Set, you won't see much of the homeless and starving on the streets.

Employment is a lagging indicator.

It's been "lagging" further and further behind for decades now as corporate profits soar every time 100,000 workers are sent into destitution.

Well that's your claim but the objective measures (including the deficit reduction) seem to be indicating that a recovery is under way.

Oh yes, let's cut funding for poor people then claim that the resulting "smaller deficit" means that things are getting BETTER... :rolleyes:
 
It's on the Internet! It must be true!



:dl:

(I set this straight in the other thread for anyone interested.)


No you put NOTHING straight. Instead you tried to skate around the issue with semantics.

Here's the pertinent part (using US Government BLS statistics):

The average workweek for all employees on private nonfarm payrolls decreased by 0.2 hour in April to 34.4 hours. Within manufacturing, the workweek decreased by 0.1 hour to 40.7 hours, and overtime declined by 0.1 hour to 3.3 hours. The average workweek for production and nonsupervisory employees on private nonfarm payrolls decreased by 0.1 hour to 33.7 hours. (See tables B-2 and B-7.)

This is a problem. If we look at the “employed” figure of 143,724,000 people a drop of 0.2 hours is a full-time-equivalent decrease of 1/2%. Applied to the employed population this amounts to an imputed economic decrease of 718,620 jobs!

That is, the loss of work-week hours of just 0.2 is the same economic impact as firing 700,000 people!

There is a huge problem coming this year and into next in this regard as the trend of cutting hours back to get under Obamacare limits is picking up steam and will continue.

Do not underestimate the economic impact of those hours-worked changes — you’d have to post up a +700k jobs figure to offset just this one month’s change in hourly workweek!

You’ll be told this is a “good report” and it is, on the surface. But I bet not one of the talking heads on CNBC runs the math on what the workweek means in terms of economic impact.

You heard it here first, and later this summer and into the fall when the jobs report continues to post up mid-100k numbers but consumer spending collapses into the toilet at a rate that is roughly identical to when we’re losing 600-700,000 jobs a month and people are scratching their heads trying to figure out why it’s happening as the stock market crashes, you will be one of the few who understands what has happened and why.

http://www.shtfplan.com/headline-ne...onth-that-have-been-hidden-from-view_05072013

It's the same thing as the "supermarket shrink ray": hide the loss by spreading it out in a way that the average, uninformed person will miss.
 
No you put NOTHING straight. Instead you tried to skate around the issue with semantics.

Here's the pertinent part (using US Government BLS statistics):



http://www.shtfplan.com/headline-ne...onth-that-have-been-hidden-from-view_05072013

It's the same thing as the "supermarket shrink ray": hide the loss by spreading it out in a way that the average, uninformed person will miss.

You claimed that this is happening "every month" but I showed that actually the average workweek is little changed from a year ago. I'll add that the change is probably within the margin of error for sampling. It's not true that it goes down by a similar amount every month.
 
If anything, they were a bit low, given the factor that even I had overlooked, and that's the issue of Full Time Equivalents made up of cut hours.

As Puppycow pointed out, that my have been an aberration in the statistics. Year on year the employment hours are unchanged (and if they have decreased month on month it means that they must have increased at some point in the last year).

You claim is now that un/underemployment is more than 20% which you have completely failed to back up. Please remember that the 11.7% figure (which I think is still an overstatement for the reasons I explained) includes people working fewer than 30 hours a week who want to work more and so would include a sizeable proportion of people who have had hours cut (it this is the case).

I understand that you want to retain the perspective that the Western economies are in the process of going down the toilet. This may be the case but currently in the U.S. the economic indicators like GDP, employment, consumer spending, consumer confidence, the housing market, corporate profits and so forth indicate that the economy is recovering.
 
Oh yes, let's cut funding for poor people then claim that the resulting "smaller deficit" means that things are getting BETTER... :rolleyes:

A larger deficit is hardly an indicator that the economy is getting better.

The significant reduction in the deficit is down to two factors. The most significant factor is the increase in tax tax which according to the CBO is due to increased taxes on the rich and increased Social Security contributions for those in work. The other major factor are the reductions in spending. In part this is because the welfare bill is coming down as people go back into work but mostly it's down to the across the board expenditure reduction, not just measures to cut finding for poor people.
 
I understand that you want to retain the perspective that the Western economies are in the process of going down the toilet. This may be the case but currently in the U.S. the economic indicators like GDP, employment, consumer spending, consumer confidence, the housing market, corporate profits and so forth indicate that the economy is recovering.

yes, they do seem to, don't they? :confused:

while all kinds of other indicators, not so much..
 
Zerohedge again hmmm ?

Well let's plough through the mire:

The first link which relates to industrial output and capacity utilisation - fair enough that's accurate but as the fed points out, it's still higher than a year ago and the largest drops were in mineral output (reflecting lower commodity prices), energy output (reflecting lower energy costs and lower usage). Let's see the longer term trend

The second link contains a graph that I think shows demand for multi family units returning to 2006 levels and still being 150% higher than at the depths of 2009. The drop seems consistent with other years - in the US is there typically a drop in the housing market in March-May ?

The third link shows a reduction in producer prices. Looking at the report it says In April, over eighty percent of the decrease in the finished goods index can be traced to a 2.5-percent drop in prices for finished energy goods. so it's a drop in energy prices that's the cause. For the record By contrast, prices for finished goods less foods and energy advanced 0.1 percent in April. . Maybe it's not the end of the world after all.

The fourth link shows an increase in auto loan delinquencies from historically low levels back to levels last seen in 2004 and still half the rate a couple of years later. it also shows a drop in the most recent month.

The fifth link relates to Walmart Q1 figures. Zerohedge paint it as a disaster and yet Walmart reports a 4.6 percent increase for Q1 EPS of $1.14; U.S. businesses forecast positive comp sales for Q2.

The final link relates to housing starts and gets conniptions from a single month drop in housing starts (still 60% above the low and the graph indicates that there's a lot of volatility in the number), a drop in CPI (relating to energy costs) and a bump in the number of initial claims (for unemployment). The again w.r.t. the initial claims data Despite the increases in claims, both the most recent week's number and the moving average clock in solidly below 400,000, a cutoff point that economists consider a sign of an improving labor market.


If ever I went out drinking with the Zerohedge guys and gals I'd be very careful when it was their round - they seem to like their glasses resolutely half-empty :D
 
I understand that you want to retain the perspective that the Western economies are in the process of going down the toilet. This may be the case but currently in the U.S. the economic indicators like GDP, employment, consumer spending, consumer confidence, the housing market, corporate profits and so forth indicate that the economy is recovering.

You don't even see the cognitive dissonance in that statement, do you?

You acknowledge at least the possibility that the West (the US specifically) is tanking badly, but then again point to phony numbers (and you know full well that they are phony) that indicate the we're supposedly NOT tanking badly.

Wal Mart just posted ANOTHER bad sales report (the 2nd this year):

http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/business/2013/05/wal-mart-kohls-nordstrom-sales-drop/

When Wal Mart is losing sales, you know things are bad. Not that I needed to see those numbers. I have eyes. I see my friends and neighbors struggling to pay the bills, buy food, pay for car repairs, etc on shrinking paychecks (if they're lucky enough to have jobs at all). I can read the stories all over the place that show that it is NOT limited to my local area.

I trust what my eyes see and my ears hear and my reason discerns, not the lies of people whose job involves playing tricks with numbers.
 
You don't even see the cognitive dissonance in that statement, do you?

You acknowledge at least the possibility that the West (the US specifically) is tanking badly, but then again point to phony numbers (and you know full well that they are phony) that indicate the we're supposedly NOT tanking badly.

No cognitive dissonance at all. I'm not in a position to say whether or not capitalism will eventually come crashing down but at the moment the objective figures seem to indicate that for the present at least things are improving.

I have no idea whether there'll still be an economy in 10, 20 or 50 years time but at the moment there seems to be a steady recovery under way.

Wal Mart just posted ANOTHER bad sales report (the 2nd this year):

http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/business/2013/05/wal-mart-kohls-nordstrom-sales-drop/

When Wal Mart is losing sales, you know things are bad. Not that I needed to see those numbers. I have eyes. I see my friends and neighbors struggling to pay the bills, buy food, pay for car repairs, etc on shrinking paychecks (if they're lucky enough to have jobs at all). I can read the stories all over the place that show that it is NOT limited to my local area.

According to the report you linked to, the drop in sales is small - hardly the end of the world.

I trust what my eyes see and my ears hear and my reason discerns, not the lies of people whose job involves playing tricks with numbers.

..and I see things are OK with my eyes and ears maybe in both our cases it's confirmation bias so maybe we should rely on the objective numbers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom