US housing market finally improving?

Here's the shorter version:

:dl:

I mean, it's your time, and if you want to spend it rebutting a gold bug nutter site, that's up to you. However, whether you take the short or long route, you always end up at the laughing dog. :)

I like it when the dumb dog turns up in threads, it usually leads to hilarity a post or two later when the facts destroy the dumb dog's arguments and he disappears again.

but because it's a website you don't like, reporting the official declining macro figures, feel free to just ignore the facts as usual.
 
so, a housing "recovery" while lumber enters a bear market huh?

if a particular website had three times previously shown the "recovery" wasn't real in advance, in 2010, 2011 and 2012, and been right every time before (as defined by more money-printing required to prevent further collapse)

..well, this time is different huh?

(insert laughing dog etc)
 
Regarding the US lumber market...

Looks like it was really heating up in March..

North American mills are sawing lumber at the fastest pace in six years after a recovering U.S. housing market, a beetle infestation in Canada and increasing Chinese demand drove the biggest price surge in two decades.

Source: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-...-prices-rise-most-since-1993-commodities.html

and then cooled off in May:

PHILADELPHIA (MNI) - U.S. lumber prices are falling in response to a late, cold spring in some parts of the country, and to a sharp first-quarter production increase by mills that may have overestimated gains in housing starts, lumber industry participants said.

By early May, industry benchmark prices were off their highs for the year so far although much stronger than year-ago levels amid growing evidence of increasing demand for construction of single-family homes and especially multi-family buildings.

Source: https://mninews.marketnews.com/inde...eck-us-lumber-prices-highs-after-supply-surge

So prices are off their peak but better than a year ago. Those zerohedge boys do like their half-empty glasses.

I also find it interesting that a year-long recovery in house prices is a short-term blip which cannot be used to infer anything for the economy but a one or two month dip in lumber prices is indicative of long term trend ;)
 
Regarding the US lumber market...

Looks like it was really heating up in March..

Source: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-...-prices-rise-most-since-1993-commodities.html

and then cooled off in May:

Source: https://mninews.marketnews.com/inde...eck-us-lumber-prices-highs-after-supply-surge

So prices are off their peak but better than a year ago.

http://www.cmegroup.com/trading/agricultural/lumber-and-pulp/random-length-lumber.html (sorry link not originally working, you need to press the July 2013 chart and select weekly to see the view Im looking at)

prices back to Aug 2012 levels. (S&P 1400 not 1700)

Those zerohedge boys do like their half-empty glasses.

:D yes and the MSM do like their glasses half full, plus some froth (spin) too.

I personally want to hear the full and worst case counter argument and attempt to make my own mind up about where in-between exactly, the truth lies, ..to attempt to work out what we're actually dealing with at least ;)

I also find it interesting that a year-long recovery in house prices is a short-term blip which cannot be used to infer anything for the economy but a one or two month dip in lumber prices is indicative of long term trend ;)

For multiple reasons I believe the house price rise is false (happening, but not based on sound economic fundamentals) same as the Equities markets.

Cat North America sales back to 2009/2010 levels - http://www.caterpillar.com/cda/files/4350908/7/2013 (April) Monthly History.pdf

CitiGroup Macro Data

so if a "recovery" is based on a fallacy, (printing money is a viable way forwards to wealth) is it really a recovery at all?

what happens when (assuming ever, which I doubt) it ever stops? or have we all just got used to the new normal (print as you go) now, and are going to assume henceforth that rising markets based on continually rising centrally planned liquidity are a sustainable way forwards?
 
Last edited:
Zerohedge usually post Year on Year change % rather than the raw figures because it makes things look more alarming. I cannot (easily) find the raw figures but I'd be interested to see if they're as alarming.

That Citigroup surprise macro data is another interesting measure. If I understand it, it measures performance against expectation rather than the raw data itself.

So in 2012 actual figure 10, expectation 9 result, Citigroup macro looking positive
In 2013 actual figure 20, expectation 21 result, Citigroup macro looking negative even though the actual figure itself is much better.

A negative surprise reflects poor performance and/or higher expectation. It's also highly volatile and seasonally cyclical

http://www.riskreversal.com/2013/01/24/chart-of-the-day-citigroup-surprise-index/
 
Zerohedge usually post Year on Year change % rather than the raw figures because it makes things look more alarming. I cannot (easily) find the raw figures but I'd be interested to see if they're as alarming.

or in this case perhaps because the data the article is based on from Cat themselves also uses YOY? :D

Machines Retail Statistics 1 - by marketing region for the 3-month rolling period compared with the same months of the prior year


http://www.caterpillar.com/investors/financial-information/dealer-statistics

http://www.caterpillar.com/cda/files/4350908/7/2013 (April) Monthly History.pdf

That Citigroup surprise macro data is another interesting measure. If I understand it, it measures performance against expectation rather than the raw data itself.

So in 2012 actual figure 10, expectation 9 result, Citigroup macro looking positive
In 2013 actual figure 20, expectation 21 result, Citigroup macro looking negative even though the actual figure itself is much better.

A negative surprise reflects poor performance and/or higher expectation. It's also highly volatile and seasonally cyclical

http://www.riskreversal.com/2013/01/24/chart-of-the-day-citigroup-surprise-index/

but it's just one of many, many, all saying the same thing. the only thing that disagrees with the market indicators are the official government figures, which being as they'll be revised next month anyway to make the next lot look better, and are looking at imaginary (mostly made up) data from months ago don't really inspire much confidence round here.

Goldman were on form again yesterday, on the one hand their leading indicators are also confirming a global slump,

Goldman notes, "the decline in momentum was a bit more substantial in May than many had expected."

Goldman's Leading Indicator momentum (blue) suggests global industrial production's short-term pick up will fade rapidly...

but on the other hand they are advising the muppets the S&P is going to 1750 on it's way to 2100. GS original

this can only happen if QE ∞ never stops, so perhaps they know something we dont, or.. ?

anyway, Fed's Dudley said for the second time (Bernanke said "decrease or increase" for the first time a few days back)
Here is a funny one:

DUDLEY SAYS HE CAN'T BE SURE IF NEXT QE MOVE WILL BE UP OR DOWN

if they *suddenly* decide that exit (tapering lol) is as unpalatable now as every previous year and they might have to further increase, are you still going to be claiming that rising prices is due to a real recovery?

I promise you, when (if) they ever actually start exiting, not just talking about the theory for years on end, if things then continue upwards, I will rethink my position. :D
 
It's a shame that not all of the zerohedge links provide the original source. The Goldman Sachs GLI graph is interesting but I cannot see the actual values only the zerohedge interpretation.
 
It's a shame that not all of the zerohedge links provide the original source. The Goldman Sachs GLI graph is interesting but I cannot see the actual values only the zerohedge interpretation.

they attribute wherever they can but some of their stuff comes from internal systems (like GS) or private subscriber info Bloomberg terminal, bank email updates etc

I believe Francesca also has access to some of these, GS and BB anyway, but shes not around much lately.
 
Existing home sales just announced. Sales are up 0.6% M/M and 9.7% Y/Y.

Sales of Previously Owned U.S. Homes Rise to Three-Year High

Sales of previously owned U.S. homes rose in April to the highest level in more than three years as housing continued to gain momentum.

Purchases (ETSLTOTL) of existing houses increased 0.6 percent to an annual rate of 4.97 million, the most since November 2009, the National Association of Realtors reported today in Washington. The median forecast of 79 economists surveyed by Bloomberg called for a pickup to a 4.99 million pace.

Housing has gained strength as borrowing costs near record lows and job gains rebuild confidence, spur demand and stabilize prices. The effects are rippling through the economy to give a boost to retailers including Home Depot Inc. (HD), builders, real estate brokers and mortgage lenders.

“The housing recovery remains intact,” Dean Maki, chief U.S. economist at Barclays Plc in New York, said before the report. “We believe it’s on a solid foundation.”

Home Depot’s First-Quarter Earnings Exceed Expectations

Home Depot’s first-quarter net income rose 18 percent, with help from the housing recovery, despite a chilly and wet spring.

The company, the world’s biggest home improvement chain, on Tuesday posted quarterly results that topped Wall Street expectations and increased its full-year earnings and revenue forecasts. Shares rose more than 2.5 percent, to $78.71.

“While weather negatively impacted our seasonal and exterior businesses, our core interior project business remained strong throughout the quarter,” Frank Blake, the chief executive, said. “This was encouraging and consistent with the views that the housing market is starting on the path to recovery.”
 
A couple more bullish details from the above article:

The median price of an existing home climbed 11 percent to $192,800 last month from $173,700 a year earlier, today’s report showed.
The median number of days on the market dropped to 46 in April from 62 the prior month, Yun said. That is the least since they began tracking the data in May 2011, and compares to an average of about 90 days, he said.

Foreclosures and other distressed sales accounted for 18 percent of the total, the lowest share in data going back to October 2008.
 
I guess the answer is that one year on from the OP it seems like the U.S. housing market is improving and has done so now for a year.

Some posters here think that the recover is illusory and/or solely fueled by QE.

Personally I think that there is an economic recovery under way in the U.S. which underpins the housing market but I am concerned that the economic recovery is comparatively frail and that softness in the global economy, especially in Europe may cause this recovery to stall.
 
I guess the answer is that one year on from the OP it seems like the U.S. housing market is improving and has done so now for a year.

Some posters here think that the recover is illusory and/or solely fueled by QE

Personally I think that there is an economic recovery under way in the U.S. which underpins the housing market but I am concerned that the economic recovery is comparatively frail and that softness in the global economy, especially in Europe may cause this recovery to stall.

do you think it would would look the same currently had we not doubled up the QE in Dec? and what would happen if they had a revelation and stopped it all right now?
 
do you think it would would look the same currently had we not doubled up the QE in Dec? and what would happen if they had a revelation and stopped it all right now?

I can honestly say that I do not know what things would look like if QE hadn't continued in December. In the UK there hasn't been an extension to QE for a few months and the recovery has been very feeble indeed. Of course the UK economy is not the US economy so I'm not sure what conclusions can be drawn.
 
I can honestly say that I do not know what things would look like if QE hadn't continued in December.

truth told, that's the only absolutely accurate thing either of us can say, so we're definitely in the land of "IMO" and speculation.

In the UK there hasn't been an extension to QE for a few months and the recovery has been very feeble indeed. Of course the UK economy is not the US economy so I'm not sure what conclusions can be drawn.

housing is slow moving and slow to react, I'm not certain what the housing market would have done had they switched the printing off in Dec instead of doubling down.

but I am fairly sure the "Markets" wouldn't all be at all time highs worldwide.
 
New home sales just announced.
Combined with yesterday's existing home sales, all signs look positive.

Builders sold more U.S. new homes than projected in April as cheaper borrowing costs and job gains drew more buyers into the market.

Sales (NHSLTOT) climbed 2.3 percent to a three-month high of 454,000 homes at an annualized pace from a 444,000 rate in March that was faster than first estimated, the Commerce Department said today in Washington. The median estimate of 76 economists surveyed by Bloomberg called for a gain to 425,000. The data included revisions back to January 2011. The median selling price rose to a record on sales of more expensive properties.
The median selling price increased 14.9 percent in April from the same month last year to a record $271,600, today’s report showed. The gain reflected increases in sales of homes costing $400,000 or more. Purchases (ETSLTOTL) of homes priced less than $300,000 decreased.
The supply of homes at the current sales rate held at 4.1 months.
Mortgage Rates
The average rate on a 30-year fixed mortgage was 3.59 percent this week, down from 3.78 percent a year earlier, according for data from Freddie Mac. The rate reached a record low of 3.31 percent in November.
Record monetary stimulus from the Federal Reserve is helping keep borrowing costs low.
 
One more thing to add: The article doesn't seem to mention it but the figure reported in the comparable report for the same period last year was 343,000 homes, which is 454,000 this year. That's 32% higher than the originally reported figure a year ago (although the article says that those figures have since been revised going as far back as 2011).
 
Do these sales figures include banks buying homes? In my neighborhood, housing "bottomed out" about a year ago in terms of prices, but then some banks bought everything. Like, 90% or more of the houses, and have just been sitting on them, not putting them on the market. When they DO go up for sale, the prices are roughly doubled.

Not sure what's going on here...
 
Do these sales figures include banks buying homes? In my neighborhood, housing "bottomed out" about a year ago in terms of prices, but then some banks bought everything. Like, 90% or more of the houses, and have just been sitting on them, not putting them on the market. When they DO go up for sale, the prices are roughly doubled.

Not sure what's going on here...

These are existing homes? Yeah those would be included in yesterday's report, although not unless that happened last month.

Sounds like what's going on here is that banks saw a business opportunity when the market bottomed out. Buy low, sell high. If you own a house it may help your property value too. Keeping the supply limited by not selling them all at once helps the value increase.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom