US housing market finally improving?

Sorry, I don't read articles on Zerohedge. I tried clicking a link once, and I was denied. It said my IQ was too high.

In other words, you have no intention whatsoever of actually addressing facts, information and data and would rather just play stupid word games.

Not surprising. You can't win on facts so you stonewall with BS.
 
No, you didn't. You changed evidence-based statements into mere "claims"

I posted my proof...care to pony up some proof that those facts are wrong?

I already did in the other threads where you made those claims.

Of course you denied it but I stand by what I wrote earlier.
 
And "official" numbers NEVER lie, right Don? The government NEVER massages those numbers to make them say what it wants them to say, right Don? And housing markets, etc are always rationally based indicators that always reflect underlying reality.

By your definition, our economy during the mega-bubble that burst in 08 really WAS a sustainable and robust economy...until it wasn't...

See how that works?

"All signs look good" at the present...just like tulip bulbs, comic books, stock markets prior to crashes, real estate, etc...

The statistics themselves do not lie, the inferences drawn from those statistics can be wrong.

The question posed in the OP over a year ago was whether the US housing market was finally improving. A year on it's pretty clear that the market is improving given that it has done so for the last 12 months.

What we're now discussing is whether the improvement in the housing market is underpinned by an improvement in the economy as a whole or whether it's just a factor of so much cheap money sloshing around and property speculators and "flippers" driving the market.

You've clearly nailed your colours to that latter mast but you're not helping yourself too much by making up statistics (claiming that the true un/underemployment rate is over 20% when even the most pessimistic figures put it around 12%) and by using zerohedge and other metal maniac sites as your primary source. You'll be right eventually, sooner or later the steam will eventually run out the economic recovery and you be able to say "see, the bubble has finally burst" but if that's in 3-5 years time then it's not that much of an insight and frankly not helpful from an investment perspective.

On the other hand most of the statistics show an improving economy. There are more people in work, GDP is growing, consumer confidence is improving and a series of consumption measures (demand for housing, cars and so on) indicate increased demand in the economy. It's true that these statistics aren't back to height of boom level (or even back to long term average) but they are better than they were 2-3 years ago and are consistent with what we are seeing in the property market, rising demand and rising prices and this is borne out by the anecdotal evidence on this thread.

The recovery isn't uniform geographically, some housing markets where there are jobs and growth are going gangbusters (and may even be overheating) and I'm sure that there are other parts of the country which are in recession where the housing market is still in the doldrums.
 
http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2013/06...rices-wall-street-buyers/?partner=rss&emc=rss

The last time the housing market was this hot in Phoenix and Las Vegas, the buyers pushing up prices were mostly small time. Nowadays, they are big time — Wall Street big.

Large investment firms have spent billions of dollars over the last year buying homes in some of the nation’s most depressed markets. The influx has been so great, and the resulting price gains so big, that ordinary buyers are feeling squeezed out. Some are already wondering if prices will slump anew if the big money stops flowing.

“The growth is being propelled by institutional money,” said Suzanne Mistretta, an analyst at Fitch Ratings. “The question is how much the change in prices really reflects market demand, rather than one-off market shifts that may not be around in a couple years.”

Wall Street played a central role in the last housing boom by supplying easy — and, in retrospect, risky — mortgage financing. Now, investment companies like the Blackstone Group have swooped in, buying thousands of houses in the same areas where the financial crisis hit hardest.

Blackstone, which helped define a period of Wall Street hyperwealth, has bought some 26,000 homes in nine states. Colony Capital, a Los Angeles-based investment firm, is spending $250 million each month and already owns 10,000 properties. With little fanfare, these and other financial companies have become significant landlords on Main Street. Most of the firms are renting out the homes, with the possibility of unloading them at a profit when prices rise far enough.

The Don said:
You've clearly nailed your colours to that latter mast but you're not helping yourself too much by making up statistics (claiming that the true un/underemployment rate is over 20% when even the most pessimistic figures put it around 12%) and by using zerohedge

is it acceptable to post the source articles that ZH cover? apart from anything else, they pick up and pre-screen everything I might be interested in from everywhere round the web, all in one place.

however they DO NOT MAKE THINGS UP. :D while they may apply their spin (like the MSM) their articles are based upon other articles, data or events in the markets.

So my question, if they are just re-presenting other articles / data from elsewhere, is linking to the source acceptable? because we really ought to get this straight once and for all, as this argument is really very lame.

I GUARANTEE YOU that the Fed & the ECB read it daily along with any other influential sites. Draghi even answered a direct question from them in a press conference.

When he answers a question from JREF I might start assigning posters here with similar credibility.
 


That's in interesting article and the graph they provide shows that investors currently buy 22% of houses in the US as opposed to 17% back in 2010 (at least according to CampellHousingPulse who survey 6,000 realtors). Unfortunately the graph only goes back to 2010, I'd love to see earlier figures to see whether what we have is an investor fueled boom or a return to business as usual.

is it acceptable to post the source articles that ZH cover? apart from anything else, they pick up and pre-screen everything I might be interested in from everywhere round the web, all in one place.

however they DO NOT MAKE THINGS UP. :D while they may apply their spin (like the MSM) their articles are based upon other articles, data or events in the markets.

So my question, if they are just re-presenting other articles / data from elsewhere, is linking to the source acceptable? because we really ought to get this straight once and for all, as this argument is really very lame.

I GUARANTEE YOU that the Fed & the ECB read it daily along with any other influential sites. Draghi even answered a direct question from them in a press conference.

When he answers a question from JREF I might start assigning posters here with similar credibility.

Of course it's acceptable to source articles from zerohedge but it's important to acknowledge that they has a specific agenda, that (like most other sources and poeple) they do cherry pick, quote mine and put particular interpretations on things. If a poster only provides articles from zerohedge it indicates to me that they buy into the massage that zerohedge are providing. If they do so uncritically and without acknowledging the zerohedge bias then I think that demonstrates rigid adherence to that message.

As for Draghi answering a question, they were in the press conference and asked the question it would have been remarkable if he had not responded.
 
Of course it's acceptable to source articles from zerohedge but it's important to acknowledge that they has a specific agenda, that (like most other sources and poeple) they do cherry pick, quote mine and put particular interpretations on things. If a poster only provides articles from zerohedge it indicates to me that they buy into the massage that zerohedge are providing. If they do so uncritically and without acknowledging the zerohedge bias then I think that demonstrates rigid adherence to that message.

ok, just wanted to get that clear, because (am sure you are aware) there is another poster here who uses the excuse that if ZH found some Fed data, analysed and published it, its not valid because ZH found it.

also bear in mind along with their own work, it is an agregator site, republishing articles from multiple other financial sites too. Not everything there is written by ZH / Tyler, not by a long way, although it is all republished by "Tyler" For example one of their regular contributors is a guy called Bruce Krasting

Bruce is taken seriously enough to have Fed officials come and discuss his posts in his comments at times, he is republished on ZH continually. Ignore it because it's ZH?

As for Draghi answering a question, they were in the press conference and asked the question it would have been remarkable if he had not responded.

I gather it was by proxy, somebody who was allowed in there, (you dont think they'd give ZH passes do you? :) ) asked on their behalf. The best part was the brunette girl sat near him trying not to giggle, it was clearly "a bit naughty" :D

edit. I deleted the last sentence here because actually its not clearly proven he knows who they are from just looking at the words. to me the look on his face was the tell as he struggled to answer it. but anyway that's not the point, the point is that it is a voluminous and diverse source of information and each individual post should be taken on it's own merits.
 
Last edited:
is it acceptable to post the source articles that ZH cover? apart from anything else, they pick up and pre-screen everything I might be interested in from everywhere round the web, all in one place.
It is helpful to find corroborating sources.

In fact, considering how many of the posters here believe that critical thinking means "ZH = woo", it might be better not to mention ZH.
 
By the way, zerohedge have a message, not a massage (as far as I am aware) - stupid fingers and terrible typing :o
 
It is helpful to find corroborating sources.

In fact, considering how many of the posters here believe that critical thinking means "ZH = woo", it might be better not to mention ZH.

The proportion of zerohedge articles which, on further examination turn out to be not exactly what it say on the tin, or a very limited interpretation of the information presented leads me to think that this is a valid first order approximation.

Actually that's not right, as kevsta points out, zerohedge typically have the facts right, it's their interpretation and conclusions that can be questioned in a high proportion of cases and then again sometimes they are bang-on.

All of the above of course IMO.
 
I personally think the liklihood of stimulus ending is laughable. there is no exit strategy.

even *talk* of "tapering" which does not mean ceasing, nor heaven forbid actually reversing, but just very slightly slowing, the stimulus has the markets all very nervous.

with QE1 and 2, they did actually stop temporarily, if not reverse, and we immediately found out the green shoots were merely a liquidity driven illusion.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/...ey-printing-was-at-an-end-Dont-bet-on-it.html

We’ve been here before. Since the crisis began, there have been several apparent economic springs, prompting the Fed to cease asset purchases, only to be forced back to the printing press again when the economy flagged. What may be different this time is that central bankers as a breed are losing their nerve in the pursuit of unconventional monetary policy. Some now openly question its effectiveness in stimulating the real economy. Others worry about its distributional consequences, with debtors favoured at the expense of savers. Still others worry about the re-emergence, in the hunt for yield, of asset price bubbles. They also worry about loss of independence, with QE now quite widely seen as a form of government financing. In almost all cases, there is growing concern about the sheer scale of balance sheet expansion.
Are these worries well founded? Most certainly. But are they enough to justify a return to a more normal interest rate environment? Not as long as deflation and a weak economy remain the primary risks for many advanced economies.
Central banks seem caught on a treadmill of money printing, where even the merest hint of exit threatens another financial crisis. This, in turn, would require a further dose of money printing to blow away the consequent economic fallout. There’s no escape

IMO, we are approaching check mate, and ultimately it is inevitable.
 
Regarding housing market improvement, underlying fundamentals, and sustainability, etc...there's probably a case to be made that improving the housing market improves the fundamentals themselves, since so many people work in construction.
 
I already did in the other threads where you made those claims.

Of course you denied it but I stand by what I wrote earlier.

You can stand by erroneous misinformation all you want, but I posted links to the proof of my statements.

More proof just released:

http://smallbusiness.yahoo.com/advi...oyees-declines-most-since-1947-185038378.html

How can consumer spending in the U.S. economy rise under these circumstances…

In the first quarter of 2013, hourly compensation of Americans employed in non-farm businesses fell 3.8%. This was the biggest drop since the Bureau of Labor Statistic started to measure this statistic in 1947. (Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, June 5, 2013.)

Consumer spending is not rising as one would expect in a real economic recovery. In fact, real personal consumption expenditures (excluding food and energy) adjusted for price changes rose less than one percent in the first four months of 2013! (Source: Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis web site, last accessed June 6, 2013.)

And inventories of businesses in the U.S. economy also paint a grim picture of consumer spending. In March, manufacturing and trade inventories stood at $1.64 trillion, up five percent from March 2012. (Source: Ibid.) In an improving economy, like the one that the majority of media outlets and politicians tell us we are in, business inventories are supposed to decline—not rise!

No, businesses building up inventories are not a good sign.

Another good article just released puts the psuedo-growth in the housing market into perspective:

http://smallbusiness.yahoo.com/advi...ousing-market-recovery-ve-seen-162530153.html

The average American Joe isn’t participating in the U.S. housing market. As a matter of fact, according to the Campbell/Inside Mortgage Finance HousingPulse Tracking Survey, investors purchased 69% of “damaged” properties in April 2013, while first-time home buyers accounted for only 16% of “damaged” purchases.

It is very well documented in these pages how home prices in the U.S. economy are being driven upward by institutional investors. Affirming my stance on the U.S. housing market, Suzanne Mistretta, an analyst at Fitch Rating Services, was quoted this week as saying, “The [housing price] growth is being propelled by institutional money… The question is how much the change in prices really reflects the market demand, rather than one-off market shifts that may not be around in a couple of years.” (Source: Popper, N., “Behind the Rise in House Prices, Wall Street Buyers,” New York Times Dealbook, June 3, 2013.)

Later (Same article):

Looking forward, I don’t hold a very optimistic view on the U.S. housing market for four very specific reasons: first-time home buyers (desperately needed in any housing recovery) are missing from the action; investors who are buying homes to rent them are pushing prices higher; new homebuilder stocks are down 14% in the past month, according to the Dow Jones U.S. Home Construction Index; and long-term interest rates are moving upward!

Consider Colony American Homes Inc. This company delayed its initial public offering, which would have brought in roughly $230–$260 million, due to what the company says are “market conditions.” This company was formed last year, and it purchased homes in mid- and upscale neighborhoods in the U.S. housing market. On April 30, Colony held 9,931 homes in nine states. (Source: Wall Street Journal, June 4, 2013.)

For institutional investors, at the end of the day, it’s all about the profit; they are buying homes and renting them out all in search of a higher return on their money. But institutional buying of American homes will not sustain a recovery in the U.S. housing market.

We need the average American to be involved in the U.S. housing market because he/she provides liquidity and pushes up consumer spending. Increasing home prices right now don’t mean the U.S. housing market has recovered; actually, it’s far from it when first-time home buyers are missing from the action.
 
You seem to be having trouble getting it. The house I bought in 1991 vs the value of said house now was the discussion. The first house I bought in the 80s was $45K, the second one $95K and both sold for more than double. If you want to calculate from 1980 then start with $45K and end at $600K.

Bought first house in early 1980's for 79K, sold it for 145, bought for 279, sold for 385, bought for 425 sold for 640 and bought in 2002 for 470. Now modulo 700, give or take.

Real estate agents across the street lament that they can't sell any houses because there aren't any on the market.

Here today, sold tomorrow.

That's how it is in western Washingtoon right now. YMMV of course.
 
We need the average American to be involved in the U.S. housing market because he/she provides liquidity and pushes up consumer spending. Increasing home prices right now don’t mean the U.S. housing market has recovered; actually, it’s far from it when first-time home buyers are missing from the action.

Obviously this "expert" wasn't around in 1980.
 
Sales of Existing U.S. Homes Rise More Than Forecast

Sales of previously owned U.S. homes climbed more than forecast in May to the highest level since November 2009 and prices jumped, indicating more progress for residential real estate.

Purchases (ETSLTOTL) of existing houses increased 4.2 percent to an annualized rate of 5.18 million from 4.97 million in April, the National Association of Realtors figures showed today in Washington. The median forecast in a Bloomberg survey called for a 5 million rate of sales. The median selling price surged from a year ago by the most since October 2005, the group said.
. . .
“The residential real-estate market in the U.S. is on fire,” said Brian Jones, senior U.S. economist in New York at Societe Generale, who projected a 5.17 million annual rate for home sales. “Ultimately, I think it’s a sign of confidence in the U.S. economy.”

Factories in Philadelphia Fed Region Rise at Faster Pace

Manufacturing in the Philadelphia region unexpectedly grew in June at the fastest pace in two years as factories showed resilience in the face of slowing overseas markets.

The Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia’s general economic index climbed to 12.5, exceeding all forecasts in a Bloomberg survey and the highest since April 2011, from minus 5.2 in May. Readings greater than zero signal expansion in the area, which covers eastern Pennsylvania, southern New Jersey and Delaware.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom