So, this may sound stupid and uninformed, but what are the fundamentals of recovery of the housing market?
I mean, assuming most people live in one home, are we underbuilt or overbuilt for the existing population?
To me it seemed like legalizing all the illegal immigrants, thus encouraging them to buy houses, would have taken care of the oversupply. (The Economist backed this up).
But, if we have more houses than we have people who can afford to live in them, isn't there a fundamental supply-and-demand issue? Builders went gangbusters before the bubble burst, riding a wave of speculation. I bought a house before prices went through the roof but I never assumed it was a piggy bank. Housing market recovery doesn't seem like an unmitigated blessing to me - it makes houses more expensive. Bad if I'm the buyer, good if I'm the seller, but even then, I need to live somewhere.
Some excellent questions. I'm not an expert in any way, shape or form (as my posts show) but from my perspective the housing market is driven by supply, demand and the ability to connect the two.
From a demand perspective, demand is rising due to a rising population and a decrease in average household size. Where, maybe 100 years ago, it would have been quite usual for three generations to share a single house (like the Waltons in TV perhaps) these days it could be that each parent has their own house following a marriage break-up and the grandparents could have two, three or four houses (depending on their marital status and survival), older children may have left home and have their own apartment or be sharing it. In most Western countries the demand for housing is increasing. Demand is also elastic. I may be prepared to share a house with roommates but I'd prefer to have my own place. I may have a perfectly serviceable house but I might like a ski condo/lake house/beach cabana as well.
From a supply perspective, I think you're right. The house builders tend to over-build in the good times and then under-build in the bad times. There are many other factors at work of course. Planning regulation in the US seems to be much more flexible than here in the UK. One of the many reasons for the stupidly high house prices in the UK is that it's very difficult to get permission to build anything anywhere. Of course it's also regional. It doesn't matter how many houses you build in rural Alabama, it's unlikely to have a significant impact on demand for housing in Manhattan.
The third part is being able to put people in houses. Before the crash it was very easy to get loans to buy houses, too easy. Low or zero downpayments and escalating interest rates meant that people ended up buying houses they could not afford. After the crash it is much more difficult to get a home loan. Here in the UK you can only get the best interest rates if you can afford to put 40% down and it's almost impossible to get a loan if you can't put up at least 10%.
The question about the market sustainability rests, IMO, on whether the current demand for housing is driven by the fact that there are more people in jobs who can afford houses and that home loans are available by responsible lenders to people with good credit risk or whether the economy is awash with cheap money and that housing speculators are taking advantage, buying up properties and creating a house price bubble.
I tend towards the former view, that the market is being driven by economic fundamentals (although I recognise that there is a very real risk of the latter). I believe that kevsta tends towards the latter (but could eventually be convinced by the former). I think we both agree that the crunch point will come when the supply of cheap money (through low interest rates and Quantitative Easing) dries up.
