US housing market finally improving?

Neither of the graphs you provided look anything like my understanding of a DCB (which, given that it aligns with the graphic provided in post #49 seems to be the same as yours).

The shadowstats graph shows a continuing decline - so no DCB indicative rise.

The inflation adjusted house prices (cannot tell which country this was) doesn't include the prices adjustment period.

That's not to say that there isn't a large downward price adjustment in the offing (I cannot judge either way) but IMO that prices aren't following a DCB profile

By definition, if there is a price rise in the face of continuingly declining fundamentals it's a DCB. It's not sustainable.

And Kevesta is 100% correct. There is NO improvement in the real economy that justifies this housing run up. It's the return of "flippers" and people looking to pick up rental properties on the cheap.
 
So an arbitrary definition of un/underemployment you've pulled out of the air (together with the actual value). It's also somewhat misleading.

No, it's the HONEST definition, and one we used to use before they started all this "statistical" BS that keeps the real number from being reported.

If you do not have a job and would like one you are unemployed, no matter if you receive UE benefits or not. No matter if you have stopped actively looking or not. You. Are. Unemployed.

Here's one good calculation. It comes in a little under my estimate, but also makes the point that it doesn't include things like early retirees who went on SS because they couldn't find work, etc.

http://jobs.aol.com/articles/2013/04/05/real-unemployment-rate/
My parents retired early from teaching in the 1990's. They signed on for unemployment in order to continue to receive their National Insurance "stamp". They were classified as unemployed and I suppose would have accepted a job if exactly the right one came along with the right hours for the right pay. They'd have been classed as unemployed by your measure but in truth they were retired on a comfortable pension.

I would say that they would not count because they don't really want jobs. They are fully retired.

I have another friend who is a midwife and she currently works 3 shifts a week. She'd like to work a 4th shift but cannot find one with the correct hours to suit her schedule. She'd be classed as underemployed.

How many hours total is she currently working. Full-time (40 hrs) plus workers are full time employed, even if it is a composite of multiple jobs (which by the way is it's own problem and is part of the overall bad employment situation)

I have another friend who graduated from Oxford University with a first in Natural Sciences. Although he is very highly qualified, for the last 20 years he has chosen to work as a secondary school lab technician because the hours and holidays are good for his travel plans. You'd classify him as underemployed.

For every one of those, there are dozens of college grads with good degrees schlepping coffee at Starbucks (if thbecasue they can't find jobs in their fields of endeavor.

http://www.theatlantic.com/business...rads-are-jobless-or-underemployed-how/256237/

http://www.nbcnews.com/business/poll-nearly-half-us-college-grads-are-underemployed-6C9692836
 
By definition, if there is a price rise in the face of continuingly declining fundamentals it's a DCB. It's not sustainable.

I guess time will tell. How long does the market improvement have to continue before you think that it's not a DCB ?

- 1 month
- 6 months
- 12 months

I personally think that DCB rises tend to be quite short lived (a few weeks or a couple of months at best). So far the US house price index has been rising since the middle of 2012 so IMO it's not a DCB (but it could be some other kind of false dawn I suppose).

And Kevesta is 100% correct. There is NO improvement in the real economy that justifies this housing run up. It's the return of "flippers" and people looking to pick up rental properties on the cheap.

At the risk of sounding like a character from the Life of Brian, there's no improvement in the real economy except:

  • Unemployment is down to 7.6 % from a peak of 10 %
  • Hundreds of thousands of net jobs have been created
  • GDP has risen for the last 15 quarters
  • Corporate profits and dividends are up

Now it could be the renters and the flippers coming into the market but the flippers need to be selling to someone and the renters are providing accommodation for those moving to find jobs.

I can see that you're convinced that the economy is going to hell in a handcart but pretty much every indicator is instead indicating a steady improvement. The gradual recovery of the housing market is an indicator of that.
 
No, it's the HONEST definition, and one we used to use before they started all this "statistical" BS that keeps the real number from being reported.

If you do not have a job and would like one you are unemployed, no matter if you receive UE benefits or not. No matter if you have stopped actively looking or not. You. Are. Unemployed.

Here's one good calculation. It comes in a little under my estimate, but also makes the point that it doesn't include things like early retirees who went on SS because they couldn't find work, etc.

http://jobs.aol.com/articles/2013/04/05/real-unemployment-rate/

That linked article which includes:

- The discouraged
- People who would like more hours
- The disabled

Comes in at 11.7%

The thing is that they calculate someone as 100% underemployed even if they have 90% of their desired hours.

The purpose of that article is to provide as big a figure as possible but it still undershoots your figure by close to 50%

I know you want the picture to be as bleak as possible and although the economy isn't in great shape it's not all that bad either.

I would say that they would not count because they don't really want jobs. They are fully retired.

They'd have been included in your figures.

How many hours total is she currently working. Full-time (40 hrs) plus workers are full time employed, even if it is a composite of multiple jobs (which by the way is it's own problem and is part of the overall bad employment situation)

30 hours a week.

For every one of those, there are dozens of college grads with good degrees schlepping coffee at Starbucks (if thbecasue they can't find jobs in their fields of endeavor.

http://www.theatlantic.com/business...rads-are-jobless-or-underemployed-how/256237/

http://www.nbcnews.com/business/poll-nearly-half-us-college-grads-are-underemployed-6C9692836

It's sad that some graduates cannot get jobs they feel are commensurate with their qualifications but as the articles you link show, not all graduates are equal.

If you graduate with a low GPA in a useless subject from a bad school then you're not going to be as able to find a job in your preferred field as someone with an excellent GPA in an in demand subject from a good school.

As the first linked article points out, there are 38% more graduates these days than there were in 2000. Even then, at the height of the dotcom boom, there was 41% underemployment for graduates which makes the current 52% look better than trend.
 
I guess time will tell. How long does the market improvement have to continue before you think that it's not a DCB ?

- 1 month
- 6 months
- 12 months

it is not a matter of time, it is a matter of whether it is fundamentally real or not, and will play out on a longer timeframe than a few months.

all those who thought RE was in trouble from 2004, 2005, 2006, they were not wrong, even all the time the RE market continued to rise.

it's pretty simple, lets switch the unprecedented, open-ended GLOBAL MONEY PRINTING off and see where "markets" go then?

in the meantime it's all just illusory, and this is not the recovery you are looking for
http://www.sacbee.com/2013/05/02/5388968/homeowners-dismayed-as-property.html

As corporate America sops up the remnants of the real estate crash, it's not only more difficult for the traditional buyer with financing to find a home. It also has planted a niggling concern about how it could change the fabric of the American community.

Wall Street hedge funds and multibillion dollar companies, such as the Connecticut-based Starwood Property Trust, the Blackstone Group in New York and Canada's Tricon Capital, got into the single-family home business about a year ago. The idea is to buy and rent until prices increase enough to make selling profitable.

edit.
At the risk of sounding like a character from the Life of Brian..

:D ..I might come back to this from my side of the fence.
 
Last edited:
it is not a matter of time, it is a matter of whether it is fundamentally real or not, and will play out on a longer timeframe than a few months.

For it to be a DCB it is a matter of time:

In finance, a dead cat bounce is a small, brief recovery in the price of a declining stock. Derived from the idea that "even a dead cat will bounce if it falls from a great height", the phrase, which originated on Wall Street, is also popularly applied to any case where a subject experiences a brief resurgence during or following a severe decline.

(my highlighting)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dead_cat_bounce

It's been going on for a year now. It may be may things (including a mini-bubble, false bull or whatever) if it's not a genuine recovery but after a year it's not a DCB.
 
For it to be a DCB it is a matter of time:

(my highlighting)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dead_cat_bounce

It's been going on for a year now. It may be may things (including a mini-bubble, false bull or whatever) if it's not a genuine recovery but after a year it's not a DCB.

I disagree with your definition of brief, as brief is relative to your timescale.

on charts looked at on larger timeframe the little uptick at the right hand end there could well turn out to be brief.
 
I disagree with your definition of brief, as brief is relative to your timescale.

on charts looked at on larger timeframe the little uptick at the right hand end there could well turn out to be brief.

And in geological terms it's shorter still. I think that a year is a pretty long time to be described as "brief".

Okay, in this context what is brief ?

- 1 year
- 2 years
- 5 years
- 10 years
- 20 years
- 50 years

If I were to say that "I was briefly in charge of pheasant plucking (even though I'm only the pheasant plucker's son)" most people would think that I held the post for a matter of weeks not a year - and that's in the context of a human lifetime let alone something as short as an economic cycle.
 
And in geological terms it's shorter still.

exactly. now youre getting it :D

I think that a year is a pretty long time to be described as "brief".

Okay, in this context what is brief ?

- 1 year
- 2 years
- 5 years
- 10 years
- 20 years
- 50 years

looking at the chart I linked to we've had similar size squiggles that have turned down again before that seem to be about a year up, and another down again.

it could well be putting in a little bottom here too anyway, but the question is, can it continue steadily upwards over the next 5 or 10 years really, isn't it?

if during this period the liquidity is ever shut off and interest rates ever normalize, the music stops, IMO. and if it isn't, and they don't, then the world has far bigger problems in store than US housing prices anyway.
 
looking at the chart I linked to we've had similar size squiggles that have turned down again before that seem to be about a year up, and another down again.

it could well be putting in a little bottom here too anyway, but the question is, can it continue steadily upwards over the next 5 or 10 years really, isn't it?

if during this period the liquidity is ever shut off and interest rates ever normalize, the music stops, IMO. and if it isn't, and they don't, then the world has far bigger problems in store than US housing prices anyway.

I'm not arguing with your analysis of the state of the housing market merely the fact that you've described it as a Dead Cat Bounce. If prices are wobbling around, bumping along the bottom or even having a period of false stability before plunging again it isn't a DCB. A DCB should be


D.....O.....W.....N.up.D.....O.....W....N

I agree that the key to establishing whether the housing market is in a period of recovery is what happens once interest rates return to their long term average. As I see it, the two most likely reasons why this will happen are:

  • Interest rates increase as a normal part of the economic cycle. Right now that seems unlikely any time soon because the economy is improving but hardly going gangbusters. If interest rates were increased right now the growth could easily be reversed as the financial taps are closed off. Commentators I've heard are looking in the 3-5 year range before this is likely to happen.
  • Central banks are forced to in order to quell inflationary pressures. By now QE should be stoing the fires of inflation but so far it seems not to be happening. Perhaps it's because the QE money is being used to improve the balance sheets of the banks rather than being pushed into the economy. The weak employment numbers have so far helped to stifle inflationary pressures becuase wages aren't rising. The inflation in the UK economy at the moment is mostly down to things like fuel where the price increases reflect world demand/uncertainlty and sterling's movement relative to the dollar. "Normal" inflation where we have too much money chasing too few goods doesn't seem to be a problem at the moment because we don't have too much money and there's plenty of spare capacity

Governments are also getting a helping hand keeping inflation under control from consumers who are paying down debt rather than going out and spending. The large deficits also mean that if the economy starts to overheat, the government could apply the brakes by increasing taxes and/or reducing spending.

I suppose the nightmare scenario would be if both the cyclical inflationary pressures and the negative consequences of QE hit at the same time. If the banks suddenly feel able to release the QE money into the wider economy AND economic growth picks up then we could have bad (5 or 10%+ ) inflation quite quickly but the government has other tools at its disposal to try to curb inflation.
 
I'm not arguing with your analysis of the state of the housing market merely the fact that you've described it as a Dead Cat Bounce. If prices are wobbling around, bumping along the bottom or even having a period of false stability before plunging again it isn't a DCB. A DCB should be


D.....O.....W.....N.up.D.....O.....W....N

ok, well I still you're being too literal with your interpretation of this, and that DCB is just another name for a bear market rally.

wiki DCB definition

Variations and usage [edit]

The standard usage of the term is: A short rise in price of a stock which already suffered a fall. In other instances the term is used exclusively to refer to securities or stocks that are considered to be of low value. First, the securities have poor past performance. Second, the decline is "correct" in that the underlying business is weak (e.g. declining sales or shaky financials). Along with this, it is doubtful that the security will recover with better conditions (overall market or economy).

Some variations on the definition of the term include:

A stock in a severe decline has a sharp bounce off the lows.[4]

A small upward price movement in a bear market after which the market continues to fall.[5][6]

Technical analysis [edit]

A "dead cat bounce" price pattern may be considered part of the technical analysis method of stock trading. Price patterns such as the dead cat bounce are recognized only with hindsight. Technical analysis describes a dead cat bounce as a continuation pattern that looks in the beginning like a reversal pattern. It begins with a downward move followed by a significant price retracement. The price fails to continue upward and instead falls again downwards, and surpasses the prior low.[7]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Market_trend

Another type of secondary trend is called a bear market rally (sometimes called "sucker's rally" or "dead cat bounce") which consist of a market price increase of only 10% or 20% and then the prevailing, bear market trend resumes. Bear market rallies occurred in the Dow Jones index after the 1929 stock market crash leading down to the market bottom in 1932, and throughout the late 1960s and early 1970s. The Japanese Nikkei 225 has been typified by a number of bear market rallies since the late 1980s while experiencing an overall long-term downward trend.

but if you would prefer I use the term bear market rally than DCB it makes no odds to me, its essentially the same thing.
 
So looking at the U.S. housing market, considering some of the underlying economic indicators (and discarding those that run counter to my thesis ;)) and being deliberately contrary towards kevsta, I think that the last 12 months are an indication of a 3-5 year period of relative stability and perhaps even modest growth in the U.S. housing market both in terms of volume (units sold) and selling price because:

  • There have been 15 quarters of US GDP growth. The growth has been modest but I think that's better because its' an indication of sustainable growth (actually i don't bit those are the figures I've got so I'll spin them how I can)
  • The U.S. employment numbers are up. Employment = People moving which in turn drives demand for retail and rental housing. If the emplment numbers continue to improve so will demand for housing
  • Housing is affordable. I know Muldur posted an article linking to a study which shows that moddle income families cannot afford a house in the most expensive cities but I don't think that's ever been the case. Over most of the U.S. there has been significant drops in house prices (bar some special cases line Boston, NY, SF) which, combined with low interest rates (3.24% 35 year fixed) means that houses are very affordable right now for most people in most cities
  • In the U.K. it is said that the housing market isn't so much driven by the supply and demand for houses (although these are factors) but much more by the supply of credit. Lenders have been running scared for the last 5 years and have been requiring lower LTV and smaller salary multiples. Before the crash credit was far too loose (self certification and 125% LTV) afterwards it has been too tight (minimum 75%, preferrably 60% LTV). There are signs of a gradual loosening of credit which will help to support the housing market
  • Sheer demographics, more people, smaller households will support demand for hosuing

IMO the key for the housing market is whether the government will have to raise interest rates to ward off stagflation in the next couple of years rather than merely responding to the economic cycle. If they do then my analysis is completely wrong. I see that as being more of a risk in the UK than the US due to the feebleness of our (non) recovery relative to that of the US.

I think there is enough in the underlying fundamentals to be cautiously optimistic for the next 3-5 years.
 
So looking at the U.S. housing market, considering some of the underlying economic indicators (and discarding those that run counter to my thesis ;)) and being deliberately contrary towards kevsta, I think that the last 12 months are an indication of a 3-5 year period of relative stability and perhaps even modest growth in the U.S. housing market both in terms of volume (units sold) and selling price because:

  • There have been 15 quarters of US GDP growth. The growth has been modest but I think that's better because its' an indication of sustainable growth (actually i don't bit those are the figures I've got so I'll spin them how I can)
  • The U.S. employment numbers are up. Employment = People moving which in turn drives demand for retail and rental housing. If the emplment numbers continue to improve so will demand for housing
  • Housing is affordable. I know Muldur posted an article linking to a study which shows that moddle income families cannot afford a house in the most expensive cities but I don't think that's ever been the case. Over most of the U.S. there has been significant drops in house prices (bar some special cases line Boston, NY, SF) which, combined with low interest rates (3.24% 35 year fixed) means that houses are very affordable right now for most people in most cities
  • In the U.K. it is said that the housing market isn't so much driven by the supply and demand for houses (although these are factors) but much more by the supply of credit. Lenders have been running scared for the last 5 years and have been requiring lower LTV and smaller salary multiples. Before the crash credit was far too loose (self certification and 125% LTV) afterwards it has been too tight (minimum 75%, preferrably 60% LTV). There are signs of a gradual loosening of credit which will help to support the housing market
  • Sheer demographics, more people, smaller households will support demand for hosuing

IMO the key for the housing market is whether the government will have to raise interest rates to ward off stagflation in the next couple of years rather than merely responding to the economic cycle. If they do then my analysis is completely wrong. I see that as being more of a risk in the UK than the US due to the feebleness of our (non) recovery relative to that of the US.

I think there is enough in the underlying fundamentals to be cautiously optimistic for the next 3-5 years.

Excellent analysis.
 
I guess time will tell. How long does the market improvement have to continue before you think that it's not a DCB ?

- 1 month
- 6 months
- 12 months

I personally think that DCB rises tend to be quite short lived (a few weeks or a couple of months at best). So far the US house price index has been rising since the middle of 2012 so IMO it's not a DCB (but it could be some other kind of false dawn I suppose).

It took us over a decade to inflate the bubble the first time, so I would say at least 12-18 months, barring a Black Swan event that kicks the bottom out early.

At the risk of sounding like a character from the Life of Brian, there's no improvement in the real economy except:

  • Unemployment is down to 7.6 % from a peak of 10 %
  • Hundreds of thousands of net jobs have been created
  • GDP has risen for the last 15 quarters
  • Corporate profits and dividends are up

The UE numbers are cooked, as anyone who holds to honest numbers knows. The facts are readily available online.

No they haven't. See my other thread for the 500,000+ job equivalents that are being lost every month due to hours cutbacks. Also see my point above about cooked numbers.

GDP is not the economy. Mom and Dad at the kitchen table trying to figure out how to pay the bills is the economy, and they're still hurting.

Since Corporate profits and dividends are so good, then obviously we must be at full employment and wages rising, because that's Capitalism, right? Rising tide lifts all boats, right?

Oh wait...there's that pesky reality again...millions of people out of work (over half of them long-term UE), hours cut, wages cut...so much for your theory...

I can see that you're convinced that the economy is going to hell in a handcart but pretty much every indicator is instead indicating a steady improvement. The gradual recovery of the housing market is an indicator of that.

When someone has rigged the indicators to not show true readings, you can't trust them.
 
Its not just the housing market improving.

The CBO just changed their estimate for FY2013's deficit from $850 billion to $642 billion.

That's a MAJOR decrease of 25%. This all looks very good for Obama's claims that the economy is improving and his strategies are working.

This also puts off the debt increase deadline to November.
 
It took us over a decade to inflate the bubble the first time, so I would say at least 12-18 months, barring a Black Swan event that kicks the bottom out early.

Well we're already 12 months into the improvement so only 6 months left.
 
The UE numbers are cooked, as anyone who holds to honest numbers knows. The facts are readily available online.

The numbers you initially stated (20%) were shown to be a gross overestimate. The ones you provided with at least some kind of backing (11.7%) were also an overestimate.

No they haven't. See my other thread for the 500,000+ job equivalents that are being lost every month due to hours cutbacks. Also see my point above about cooked numbers.

GDP is not the economy. Mom and Dad at the kitchen table trying to figure out how to pay the bills is the economy, and they're still hurting.

Look at the economic indicators, house sales, car sales, consumer spending, they're on the up. Of course there are large numbers of families in severe financial difficulties but there are larger numbers of families who are rubbing along nicely thank you. Of course "family makes end meet comfortably" does not make a compelling headline.

Since Corporate profits and dividends are so good, then obviously we must be at full employment and wages rising, because that's Capitalism, right? Rising tide lifts all boats, right?

Oh wait...there's that pesky reality again...millions of people out of work (over half of them long-term UE), hours cut, wages cut...so much for your theory...

Employment is a lagging indicator.

When someone has rigged the indicators to not show true readings, you can't trust them.

Well that's your claim but the objective measures (including the deficit reduction) seem to be indicating that a recovery is under way.
 
Well that's your claim but the objective measures (including the deficit reduction) seem to be indicating that a recovery is under way.

As understand it the deficit reduction is a "one -time" thing due to a Q4-2012 quarter spike to pay taxes because of an upcoming tax law change?

Biderman from Trimtabs http://trimtabs.com/global/ourteam.htm advocates tracking after tax income instead of GDP for a more realistic idea of whats happening, so he does

http://charlesbiderman.com/2013/05/01/fourth-quarter-spiked-income-and-boosted-taxes/

April income tax payments sent in by individuals are surging, up by more than $50 billion over April 2012 and higher by $63 billion year to date. That means to me that year end 2012 income from asset sales and bonuses had to have spiked by around $300 billion to generate that $63 billion in bigger tax payments. I know, this is a lot of numbers and some of you should read the transcript instead of this video. To go back, in other words anticipation of this year’s higher taxes created a one time 10 percent pop in income over those few months the $300 billion became income!

And all you GDP watchers out there will never see that pop. Why? The US Bureau of Economic Analysis, which puts the garbage in garbage out GDP number, in its infinite wisdom ignores capital gains as well as any and all real time data. Why? Who knows. You ask them, they won’t answer me.

So no wonder the economy looked great to start this year. The $300 billion income spike created a very rosy glow particularly since none but us at TrimTabs were saying that the year pop in income was a one time event. Checking my year end videos I was guessing $100 to maybe $200 billion in higher income, not $300 billion.

Right now, over the past three weeks, wage and salary growth has slowed to less then 3 percent year over year, and that is before inflation. In other words, anticipation of higher taxes boosted economic activity at the end of last year and to start this year. Now that all the new money has been spent, the US economy is back to no growth.
 
The UE numbers are cooked, as anyone who holds to honest numbers knows. The facts are readily available online.
It's on the Internet! It must be true!

No they haven't. See my other thread for the 500,000+ job equivalents that are being lost every month due to hours cutbacks.

:dl:

(I set this straight in the other thread for anyone interested.)
 
Charles Biderman makes some pretty alarming predictions in that article:

How will it end this time? My guess is that initially at some point in the next few months the Japanese currency will plunge to 200 to the dollar, much more then the Japanese Central Bank wants. That will create financial panic in the Japanese consensus based society. After that the Euro will be next then followed the US dollar, forcing all three economies into a sort of bankruptcy.

So if the Yen doesn't touch 200 to the dollar by, say, year end can we say that maybe he was either mistaken or indulging in hyperbole ?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom