I don't buy Schilling's arguments. I think the other guy is right.
1) Banks are not going to dump all this shadow inventory on the market all at once and drive prices down another 20% because doing that would be slitting their own throats. They lose money on short sales. There will be foreclosures of course, but it's in their interest to find ways to work with people to refinance when they can.
2) There's a reason why foreclosed houses typically cost 20% less than similar houses that aren't foreclosed. They are often damaged goods in various ways. The previous residents have no incentive to make it attractive to buyers. They may even damage things out of spite. So most people will still prefer a new house or an existing house that was well-cared for by it's owner.
3) In the worst-hit areas, cities are demolishing abandoned houses.
4) Schilling is contradicted by the most recent housing reports.
You are correct.
I'm in FL and have been in the housing business for nearly 20 years. We recently bought a house in very poor condition, but in a solid area and with various features with great potential. After a full renovation, taking about 3 months, we had the house listed for two days and received 10 offers, of which 6 were above asking price.
Late last year we sold a high price house that we lived in, for asking price.
The most common comment heard is that people have been looking for a long time, meaning to find something decent and ready to move in.
I would add that it is very hard for people like us to find a good potential renovation house because the stiffest competition is coming from hedge fund investors who pay a premium, in cash, for anything that can be quickly fixed up and rented. They are not looking to flip, but to hold.
In other words, there is a housing shortage for well qualified and discriminating buyers and there are distinct differences between something that has holes in the roof and what a family wants to live in, which any appraiser will take into account.
It seems to me that much of the under water properties, or pending foreclosures, are really not properties that are on the market at all, in other words unsaleable in current condition and therefore not a part of the real market.
I do however wonder to what extent the hedge fund cash people are driving current pricing.