US housing market finally improving?

In a capitalist society select banks and corporations don't get unlimited free money from central banks, or have their losses perpetually socialized by currency holders and taxpayers. Clearly we don't live in a capitalist society, or socialist, for that matter, but something much worse than either is perceived to be.

Well that's your opinion.

The good news for tens or hundreds of thousands of people is that the anticipated wave of foreclosures has not yet happened and for now they still have a roof over their heads.
 
Well that's your opinion.

The good news for tens or hundreds of thousands of people is that the anticipated wave of foreclosures has not yet happened and for now they still have a roof over their heads.

It's clearly not my opinion at all. Capitalism is about profit and loss. Not privatized profit, and socialized loss.
 
It's clearly not my opinion at all. Capitalism is about profit and loss. Not privatized profit, and socialized loss.

You misunderstood me because I wasn't clear enough.

Your opinion is that

Clearly we don't live in a capitalist society, or socialist, for that matter, but something much worse than either is perceived to be

I personally think you can argue that we live in a capitalist society but whether what we have is much worse than either is perceived to be is certainly a matter of opinion on your part.
 
Neither of the graphs you provided look anything like my understanding of a DCB (which, given that it aligns with the graphic provided in post #49 seems to be the same as yours).

The shadowstats graph shows a continuing decline - so no DCB indicative rise.

here's a real dead cat bounce

also noted this in there, with regards other threads discussing mining.

Australian mining companies increased capital expenditures more than 50 percent while their profits declined 33 percent. This imbalance, which we believe occurred in other countries as well, has prompted mining companies to reduce capital spending. We expect this adjustment will continue throughout 2013.
 
I don't buy Schilling's arguments. I think the other guy is right.

1) Banks are not going to dump all this shadow inventory on the market all at once and drive prices down another 20% because doing that would be slitting their own throats. They lose money on short sales. There will be foreclosures of course, but it's in their interest to find ways to work with people to refinance when they can.

Not so much. They obviously gain money on short sale or any sale for that matter The problem is that they have to realize a loss and this impacts the books, profits and reserve reqs. So there are some motivations to hold the devalued asset rather than realize the loss.

Recent housing sales numbers look promising, but is in part based on Bernanke's "punch bowl" overflowing into mortgage securities since ~last September, and recent Japanese buying of US mortgage securities.

I'm cautiously optimist, but with an eye on the house-of-cards that underlies parts of the foundation.
 
I don't buy Schilling's arguments. I think the other guy is right.

1) Banks are not going to dump all this shadow inventory on the market all at once and drive prices down another 20% because doing that would be slitting their own throats. They lose money on short sales. There will be foreclosures of course, but it's in their interest to find ways to work with people to refinance when they can.

2) There's a reason why foreclosed houses typically cost 20% less than similar houses that aren't foreclosed. They are often damaged goods in various ways. The previous residents have no incentive to make it attractive to buyers. They may even damage things out of spite. So most people will still prefer a new house or an existing house that was well-cared for by it's owner.

3) In the worst-hit areas, cities are demolishing abandoned houses.

4) Schilling is contradicted by the most recent housing reports.

You are correct.

I'm in FL and have been in the housing business for nearly 20 years. We recently bought a house in very poor condition, but in a solid area and with various features with great potential. After a full renovation, taking about 3 months, we had the house listed for two days and received 10 offers, of which 6 were above asking price.

Late last year we sold a high price house that we lived in, for asking price.

The most common comment heard is that people have been looking for a long time, meaning to find something decent and ready to move in.

I would add that it is very hard for people like us to find a good potential renovation house because the stiffest competition is coming from hedge fund investors who pay a premium, in cash, for anything that can be quickly fixed up and rented. They are not looking to flip, but to hold.

In other words, there is a housing shortage for well qualified and discriminating buyers and there are distinct differences between something that has holes in the roof and what a family wants to live in, which any appraiser will take into account.

It seems to me that much of the under water properties, or pending foreclosures, are really not properties that are on the market at all, in other words unsaleable in current condition and therefore not a part of the real market.

I do however wonder to what extent the hedge fund cash people are driving current pricing.
 
I do however wonder to what extent the hedge fund cash people are driving current pricing.

They played a role in the run up of farmland prices over the past 5 years, so I suspect they may be playing a similar role in single family housing, as you suggested. I know they are investing in multi-family rentals.
 
The latest data for existing and new home sales seems like mainly good news. There is room for further improvement because of demand that is pent-up by various factors:

Existing home sales edge down, prices rise
Sales in March were 10.3 percent higher than the same month last year, and the median price for a home resale was up 11.8 percent, the biggest increase since November 2005, to $184,300.
. . .
SUPPLY CONSTRAINTS

The supply of existing homes on the market for sale rose 1.6 percent during the month to 1.93 million, which represented 4.7 months' supply at March's sales pace, up from 4.6 in February.

That's is way below the 6 months' worth normally considered as an ideal balance between demand and supply. A year earlier, the inventory of unsold homes was 2.32 million, a 6.2 months' supply.

New homes sales rise 1.5% in March

WASHINGTON (AP) — Sales of new homes rebounded in March to a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 417,000. The increase added to evidence of a sustained housing recovery at the start of the spring buying season.
. . .
Since the housing bubble burst more than six years ago, banks have imposed tighter credit conditions and required larger down payments. That has made it harder for first-time homebuyers to qualify for the super-low mortgage rates that have resulted from the Federal Reserve's efforts to ease credit.

Probably a good thing in the long term even if it keeps the housing recovery less robust in the short term than it would otherwise be. Start worrying if they start to slide back to the old loose credit and down-payment standards of the sub-prime era.
 
Would someone like to take a crack at explaining just how housing can be in "recovery" when the basic economy is still in the crapper? 15%+ real UE, continued offshoring of jobs, wage and benefit suppression, etc.

Just where are these "able and willing" buyers coming from that are snapping up those houses? Are they moving in w/their families, or is it the same-old "flip" BS that tanked us before?
 
Would someone like to take a crack at explaining just how housing can be in "recovery" when the basic economy is still in the crapper? 15%+ real UE, continued offshoring of jobs, wage and benefit suppression, etc.

Wage and benefit suppression has always been with us, one of the causes of the Peasants' Revolt in 1381 was unhappiness over wages and hours.

Offshoring jobs is a comparatively new thing, AFAIK it didn't happen too much before the 19th century but in the past it's been low skill jobs that have been offshored. Offshoring does have a major impact on small sections of some industries but in others it hasn't got much traction.

Here is a site which claims to have a statistical analysis of offshoring and I cannot comment on its accuracy but it claims that just under 2.3 million jobs have been outsourced:

http://www.statisticbrain.com/outsourcing-statistics-by-country/

The U.S. labour force is more than 150 million so while outsourcing isn't trivial the impact is probably much less than sick days.

So in short, enough people are doing well enough for the housing market to pick up, not least because prices are currently reasonable and interest rates are comparatively low.

Just where are these "able and willing" buyers coming from that are snapping up those houses? Are they moving in w/their families, or is it the same-old "flip" BS that tanked us before?

I don't know but I suspect that it will vary from place to place.
 
Would someone like to take a crack at explaining just how housing can be in "recovery" when the basic economy is still in the crapper? 15%+ real UE, continued offshoring of jobs, wage and benefit suppression, etc.

Just where are these "able and willing" buyers coming from that are snapping up those houses? Are they moving in w/their families, or is it the same-old "flip" BS that tanked us before?

I think I can explain part of it. New housing starts are still pretty low. Many builders went under and those that are left are not in a hurry to ramp up construction. The number of foreclosed properties are dropping meaning the really cheap (and poor condition) housing is drying up. Those of us that are underwater or have seen significant property value declines are not in a hurry to sell at a loss.

The end result is a housing shortage that starts prices moving up. But being in a recovery is not the same as being recovered. I just refinanced my home. Still massively underwater but the appraised value did go up. Prices in my condo complex are now up because all of the foreclosed units have been sold.

The supply is no longer greater than the demand. Note: I am in the Detroit suburbs. This situation is not the case everywhere.
 
The latest Case-Shiller is out:

http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-...-in-u-s-rose-more-than-forecast-in-april.html

The S&P/Case-Shiller index of home prices in 20 cities rose 9.3 percent in February from the same month in 2012, the biggest year-to-year advance since 2006.

“It’s pretty clear that housing is recovering,” said Jim O’Sullivan, chief U.S. economist at High Frequency Economics Ltd. in Valhalla, New York, and the second-best confidence forecaster for the past two years, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. “That’s a positive for growth. It boosts wealth and confidence.”

Rising home and stock prices are helping repair finances left in tatters by the recession, leading to gains in sentiment that may limit any slowdown in household spending, the biggest part of the economy.
 
Would someone like to take a crack at explaining just how housing can be in "recovery" when the basic economy is still in the crapper? 15%+ real UE, continued offshoring of jobs, wage and benefit suppression, etc.

Just where are these "able and willing" buyers coming from that are snapping up those houses? Are they moving in w/their families, or is it the same-old "flip" BS that tanked us before?

Maybe the real economy is actually doing better than you think.

What is your source for "15%+ real UE"?
 
The supply is no longer greater than the demand. Note: I am in the Detroit suburbs. This situation is not the case everywhere.

I'm surprised to hear that in a place like Detroit, which has become in many respects almost a ghost town according to the media.
 
Maybe the real economy is actually doing better than you think.

What is your source for "15%+ real UE"?

All persons not employed who would like to be employed, whether receiving benefits or not, measured against a STABLE Labor Participation rate.

Add in the "underemployed" (part time wanting full and those working beneath their skill level) and that rate goes up to probably 20% at a minimum.
 
All persons not employed who would like to be employed, whether receiving benefits or not, measured against a STABLE Labor Participation rate.

Add in the "underemployed" (part time wanting full and those working beneath their skill level) and that rate goes up to probably 20% at a minimum.

So an arbitrary definition of un/underemployment you've pulled out of the air (together with the actual value). It's also somewhat misleading.

My parents retired early from teaching in the 1990's. They signed on for unemployment in order to continue to receive their National Insurance "stamp". They were classified as unemployed and I suppose would have accepted a job if exactly the right one came along with the right hours for the right pay. They'd have been classed as unemployed by your measure but in truth they were retired on a comfortable pension.

I have another friend who is a midwife and she currently works 3 shifts a week. She'd like to work a 4th shift but cannot find one with the correct hours to suit her schedule. She'd be classed as underemployed.

I have another friend who graduated from Oxford University with a first in Natural Sciences. Although he is very highly qualified, for the last 20 years he has chosen to work as a secondary school lab technician because the hours and holidays are good for his travel plans. You'd classify him as underemployed.
 
I'm surprised to hear that in a place like Detroit, which has become in many respects almost a ghost town according to the media.

The city population has been drastically reduced. So has the number of available housing units.

Add to that most of the reporting ignores the larger Detroit metropolitan community. Those that left the city mostly moved to the suburbs up until about ten years ago. Then the whole state started to take a serious population hit. But this situation has started to stabilize.

The city is broke but There are business moving back into the city. The schools and public safety situations are still quite bad. I suspect if the schools could be fixed more of an urban pioneer thing might really get going. The 'burbs are mostly recovering nicely already.

News reporting on Detroit is always oversimplified. Local economic news and auto industry reporting even more so.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom