Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
In Australia there is of course rationing (unless you also have Private Insurance above the compulsory 2% Medicare levy), based in general on the following:

Life threatening - free and immediate and available to everybody. (e.g., a car accident, a Heart Attack, a Stroke, even a broken leg)

Semi-elective - Defined as a potentially future life threatening illness which requires monitoring but is not immediately life threatening (e.g., Bladder Cancer, some tumours) where you may be checked out once every 6 - 12 Months depending on the change in status of your illness. All free under the Universal Health Care system.

(However if you start peeing blood again, you move up the list awfully quickly - you are back to life threatening)

Elective Still free, but the waiting lists can be quite long. Hip replacement, Cataract operations again free, fall under this header. The waiting list can be years long.

Cosmetic As far as I know, not covered at all.

And as I mentioned above, Private Health Insurance is readily available in Australia to either reduce/eliminate co-payments or get that Cataract operation next week instead of waiting 2 years.

Oh, and anybody on a health care card - aged pensioners, unemployed, Disability Pension, Carers - pay no ambulance fees, pay scripts at around $6 each with an annual cap, and can often go to Medical Centres who Bulk Bill Government and do not ask for the co-payment ("the gap"). And of course, you can also buy Ambulance Insurance at quite low rates.

Norm

I used the word rationing deliberately to be provocative. Given the many views of it in posts upthread, perhaps it was too ambiguous as well. I simply mean that what therapies are reasonable to use to treat certain conditions is always going to be a decision that must be made, and it is not only based on the preferences of the individual patient/doctor. Nor, I venture, on pure medical considerations, but on larger public health decisions and yes the finances available. It has to be. And frankly I don't think that is wrong. I applaud the Gates foundation for funding third world vaccinations ( a cheap intervention that saves many millions of lives) rather than funding ways of helping first-country 100 year olds to more likely live to 101.
 
They choose to do those things.

Of course any action people take is because they choose to do it. Choosing to carefully test drugs before widely using them is a good choice. As mentioned, thalidomide provided an except example of what happens if one chooses to do otherwise.
 
Of course any action people take is because they choose to do it. Choosing to carefully test drugs before widely using them is a good choice. As mentioned, thalidomide provided an except example of what happens if one chooses to do otherwise.

I wasnt commenting on the goodness of the choice.
 
Obviously.

I mean, come on! Think about it! There is no Sooper Sekrit Solution to health care that covers everyone and cuts costs. Anything that could possibly be done has already been suggested and discussed extensively. If it were as easy as having some people of Trump's transition team sitting down over the course of 2 months and getting it done, it would have been done years ago.

Obama only had the democrats to work with. He needed every single vote which means that every representative who demanded pork for his constituents had to be paid off.
I don't know to what a degree that happened, though.
I doubt the democrats will put the party ahead of the country, as well. Having more potential votes available should, in theory, make it easier to bring down costs.
 
Organ transplants are probably a good area to see how services are rationed in your health care system. Finite supply, variable need.

This isn't rocket science - you get what you are willing to pay for.
 
That is just completely wrong.

Case in point: immunizations. The MMR vaccine doesn't treat early stages of those three diseases, it prevents them from occurring.

Oh sure, I should have included immunizations as the one big example of preventive medicine that actually prevents a disease from occurring. However, I kind of think of immunizations as more of a public health issue; yes, there is an individual benefit but the larger benefit is a public benefit. I'd support making those free through a government program to encourage more people to use them and thus reduce the risk to the general public.

But you skipped over the larger point being made in the rest of the post. Any comment on that?
 
I get your point, but my point was that just pulling a tooth is much cheaper than, say, a root canal and crown. Of course routine preventative treatment earlier would have been better.

And what would have that consisted of? Brushing and flossing twice daily. If you don't do that bare minimum then there's nothing your dentist can do to prevent squat. The onus of prevention is on the patient.
 
And what would have that consisted of? Brushing and flossing twice daily. If you don't do that bare minimum then there's nothing your dentist can do to prevent squat. The onus of prevention is on the patient.

If you think that's all it takes to avoid serious dental problems you've been very lucky.
 
Obama only had the democrats to work with. He needed every single vote which means that every representative who demanded pork for his constituents had to be paid off.I don't know to what a degree that happened, though.
...
What evidence do you have for the highlighted claim? You admit you don't know in the next sentence. Looks like you have a self-made version of reality there.
 
If you think that's all it takes to avoid serious dental problems you've been very lucky.

Well, I did say it was the bare minimum. Someone who does that everyday is much less likely to develop cavities, periodontal disease, etc. Add regular professional cleaning and the risk is negligible. But take away brushing and flossing and what happens? No professional preventive measures will prevent problems. The point is that the patient, in all realms of health care, has the primary responsibility to do preventive care on themselves. If we don't take care of ourselves, no doctor or dentist in the world can save us from ourselves.

This is the thing that gets me. If we just took care of ourselves we wouldn't need doctors anywhere near as much as we do now. But we don't. We want to smoke, drink, sit on our asses, eat all the tasty garbage we want ... and then we whine that we can't afford to pay the bill for the diabetes, heart disease, cancer etcthat results from our lifestyle. To my mind, that is the definition of "crazy."

And just to be clear, yes, I understand that not all disease is the result of lifestyle. However, is venture to say that a significant portion of it is directly tied to our lifestyles. If we take care of ourselves and limit the lifestyle related problems it would significantly lower our utilization of healthcare as a whole.
 
And just to be clear, yes, I understand that not all disease is the result of lifestyle. However, is venture to say that a significant portion of it is directly tied to our lifestyles. If we take care of ourselves and limit the lifestyle related problems it would significantly lower our utilization of healthcare as a whole.

Hard to say off the cuff. Maybe you just shift the dollars to end-of-life care or pay for more hip replacements and cataract surgeries. No one gets out alive.
 
That is a "when did you stop beating your wife" question because you are trying to take one narrow type of rationing and call it the whole thing.

Rationing is the controlled distribution of scarce resources. In this case, they ration care by setting limits on which services they will purchase.
No I am not, I am trying to help you understand what NICE's role is. It is to determine what treatments are available in NHS England and what constitutes good practice. What "rationing" takes place in the NHSs are at a different point.
 
Organ transplants are probably a good area to see how services are rationed in your health care system. Finite supply, variable need.

This isn't rocket science - you get what you are willing to pay for.
Organ transplant isn't a matter of you get what you pay for, at least in the UK it isn't. You can't buy organs for transplant in the UK.
 
Organ transplant isn't a matter of you get what you pay for, at least in the UK it isn't. You can't buy organs for transplant in the UK.

But if you have the money, you can travel and get one. (Or so I've heard.)

Someone in your government probably isn't allowing human organ imports. But the idea of rationing the ones you have arises. Unless the UK has enough to meet all the demand? If not, then someone has to sort out who gets one and who doesn't. I would call that rationing, but I understand it may go by a different term. No matter, it's a finite limit like any other.

ETA: This is from an article on the NHS site (from 2015):
Almost 49,000 people in the UK have endured the wait for an organ transplant in the last 10 years and over 6,000, including 270 children, have died before receiving the transplant they desperately needed, new statistics reveal.
https://www.organdonation.nhs.uk/ne...-to-wait-for-a-transplant-in-the-last-decade/
 
Last edited:
But if you have the money, you can travel and get one. (Or so I've heard.)

I'm sure you can but that's really outside the scope of this part of the discussion.


Someone in your government probably isn't allowing human organ imports.
No, it's just there isn't the availability.

But the idea of rationing the ones you have arises. Unless the UK has enough to meet all the demand? If not, then someone has to sort out who gets one and who doesn't. I would call that rationing, but I understand it may go by a different term. No matter, it's a finite limit like any other. ...snip...

There are finite resources so of course there are limits on what can be done. In the UK NHSs' organ transplants are "rationed" according to clinical need, and often it can also be a matter of where you are geographically because (for most) organs there is a very tight window of opportunity to use an organ. Outside of that the organ may as well go into making a pie. (And of course having a suitable match with the donor etc.)

My objection to how Bob is using "rationing" is that he is using it so broadly that anything could be described as being rationed. Given the breadth of his useage it would be accurate to say that food is rationed in the USA and the UK. I don't think people would recognise that useage.

In my opinion he is also not understanding what NICE's role in the NHS is - i.e. a gatekeeper. That's why asking what rationing does NICE impose on the treatment of broken bones is entirely on topic and relevant to the discussion because such treatments are "rationed" in the exact same way as the latest cancer treatment.

NICE sets what is clinically "best practice" in NHS England, it reviews the evidence of a treatment's clinical effectiveness and cost and decides if it should be provided by the NHS or not.

Also NICE's decisions are not binding, what treatments are actually funded is down to "clinical commissioning groups" (don't get me started on the stupidity of the change to "clinical commissioning groups" that's a separate discussion entirely.) Individuals can also challenge NICE's recommendations even via the courts.
 
Last edited:
My objection to how Bob is using "rationing" is that he is using it so broadly that anything could be described as being rationed. Given the breadth of his useage it would be accurate to say that food is rationed in the USA and the UK. I don't think people would recognise that useage.
Would you prefer "budgeting?"
 
My objection to how Bob is using "rationing" is that he is using it so broadly that anything could be described as being rationed. Given the breadth of his useage it would be accurate to say that food is rationed in the USA and the UK. I don't think people would recognise that useage.

My objection to your objection is that I am using it correctly. In the social sciences it is far more broadly used. While the food market as a whole isn't rationed, every single individual purchasing food is rationing.
 
Would you prefer "budgeting?"

Not if referring to NICE's role.

Money and availability of treatment is of course a limiting factor in all health systems, don't think anyone would deny that and there is rationing in the UK NHSs, but what NICE does is not the rationing that happens in the UK NHSs, NICE has no control over budgets etc. It's simply not what it does.

From the NICE website:
...snip....

NICE's role is to improve outcomes for people using the NHS and other public health and social care services. We do this by:

  • Producing evidence-based guidance and advice for health, public health and social care practitioners.
  • Developing quality standards and performance metrics for those providing and commissioning health, public health and social care services.
  • Providing a range of information services for commissioners, practitioners and managers across the spectrum of health and social care.

...snip...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom