Health care encompasses physical therapy and massage and psychotherapy and elective surgery and getting medicines to reduce back pain or knee pain or allergic reactions or to have sex without getting pregnant or to get an erection in order to have sex. There is so much to health care than just preventing a gunshot victim from bleeding to death. Health care spending is 17% of our GDP, and only 2% of health care spending is for emergency room treatment. It is a myth that health care spending primarily involves a tradeoff between saving a life and saving money.
Myth would imply that it is widely believed. Is it?
Furthermore, there are many areas of the rest of the economy which do involve tradeoffs between life and health and money. A poor person who has to live in a crime-ridden neighborhood is incurring a greater risk of injury or death because of his poverty. Likewise for a poor person who can only afford a crappy, old car with bald tires and without the latest safety features. Or for a poor person who has to work a dangerous, physically exhausting job in order to make ends meet (e.g. taxi driver or coal miner). Trading health and health risk for money is far more common in our economy than most people understand. We all do it, almost all the time. There is nothing inherently special about the consumption decisions we make which are considered "health care."
I see what you are saying. The underlying motivation of health and safety and health care regulations is the same.
I agree.
Not sure what you mean by a "right."
Let's put it in practical terms: If you have a right to something, that means that you can call in help from the government, if someone tries to deny that something to you.
For example, if someone is on your property and won't leave, then you can ask the police to remove them. They will use violence if necessary. That is because you have a right to enjoy your property.
Or say, someone will not let you vote. Then, again, you can call the police.
You do not have a right to live if your body is riddled with terminal cancer. You do not have a right to live if you've been stabbed or shot, and nobody around can stop the bleeding before you succumb. You do not have a right to live if you are stuck in a blizzard without adequate shelter. As we get wealthier as a society, we feel compelled to declare more luxuries to be "rights" but it doesn't mean that they are inalienable or immutable. And it's impossible, by definition, to grant somebody a right (at least in a meaningful way) to a limited resource, when the supply of that resource is less than the demand.
I think you are confusing the right to do something and the means to do something.
It's called logic. Either follow it or don't, but you'll have to do it on your own.
It does not follow from first principles that it is impossible to provide state-of-the-art medical to every citizen because of resource constraints. Obviously that depends on a variety of factors which are not constant in time.
It's only a positive externality because the US lets it be. If we go the same route as everybody else, it will cease to exist. And the fact that everybody else has gone the route they have has created a negative externality for us. So you can look at it either way. Either they should be grateful that we still pay absurdly more for our health care than they do, or we should be pissed about it.
That's just not how it works. You could say that the US should be grateful that other countries let it shop on (dubious) credit but obviously it isn't.
And, yes, it is the case. Look to some of the Obamacare threads and search for posts by me. I am already tired of repeating myself over and over again here and seeing the same posters stick their heads in the sand (not you - never seen you here before).
Fair enough but I can't give credit to an unsourced statement.
At some level I do, but it depends upon whether I think something is being withheld for immoral reasons. I don't think it's immoral for a BMW dealer to withhold a BMW from somebody who can't pay for it. Likewise, I don't think it's immoral for a brain surgeon to withhold 10 hours of his labor from somebody who can't pay for it. I do think it's immoral for somebody to withhold a glass of water from somebody dying of thirst (as long as you have plenty for yourself). I also think it's immoral to leave somebody to die of a heart attack in the street rather than call an ambulance. We can all disagree about the point at which certain altruistic actions transition from moral obligation to optional, but there is no question that such a point exists for each of us and for society on average, and that point is constantly moving towards more aggressive intervention as our society gets wealthier and we develop more health care resources.
Sounds quite reasonable. Thanks for clearing that up.
But it's crazy to think that somebody is entitled to consume unlimited health care resources just because he has a need. Because we have limited health care resources, his consumption inevitably means that somebody else will have to do without.
Any evidence for that assertion?
I can see how it is obviously true for a wide definition of health care resources. We can't have everyone praying 24/7 for someone's recovery.
But is it true for a more common sense definition?
There is only so much one can do, that is really known to be beneficial to health.
It is inevitable that when you have a system where money is not the medium of exchange, then something else will be used. In the case of socialized economies, that becomes political clout. If you think the allocation of health care resources in countries like UK and Canada is strictly based on formula-determined need, then I might have some property in Florida to sell you. In any case, formula-determined need is a stupid way of allocating resources. It neglects the fact that each individual has a different utility curve.
Still don't get it. The UK and Canada are not socialized economies.
I also don't see how using money would prevent corruption. What do you actually mean by "money is not the medium of exchange"?
You're talking about business competition. I'm talking about consumption. You don't need to be currently productive to consume. You just need to have financial resources. You might have acquired that by being productive in the past, or by being frugal. Or by being lucky. Doesn't really matter to me.
Yes, people win the lottery but that doesn't change the logic.
If health care is provided by the same general system as everything else then it will be focused on the most productive members of society.
Ok, as you point out above, there will be people with political clout, or connections, or luck, but those are exceptions. If that weren't the case, market economies would not work.
What matters is that the individual makes a cost-benefit decision for himself.
The individual cost-benefit decision matters to what?
If you are worried that poor people won't be able to consume enough, well, we have programs for that. I would prefer to just give them money and let them make their own spending decisions. If they'd rather spend it on a new car rather than getting the knee surgery they "need," it's fine with me.
Interesting idea but on second thought fatally flawed. If you offer people money for having injuries, some people will take that offer. That's probably not an intended consequence.
Insurance companies have made that experiences with certain types of disability insurance.
By allowing people to buy the health care resources they need want. You can have health insurance become what insurance is supposed to be - financial protection against a catastrophe - rather than a prepaid health care program. For poor people, you can give them money to spend as they see fit.
You mean like a wage subsidy? Why wouldn't the employer just cut the wage until new wage+subsidy is equal to the pre-subsidy wage. After all, that is what the employee is willing to work for.
I think as a wealthy society, we probably could provide a guarantee of slightly less than state-of-the-art health care at the Medicaid level for everybody. Medicaid for all might work. Anybody who wants something better (and almost everybody middle class or higher would) would have to pay for that out-of-pocket.
Isn't that basically how they do it in the UK?