Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
Paying for health care in one way or another is essential, yet quite complicated. Devising a useful system in the USA will require much compromise and an absolute minimum of political posturing. It will also causes significant shifts in financial obligations among patients, insurance companies, and government. And it will be imperfect even when there are large net gains for society as a whole. Finally as health care itself gets more expensive the cost of paying for it will increase, even if changing the system saves money compared to what it might have cost otherwise. Looking at the current political situation I expect a successful manned mission to Jupiter before these requirements are met.

Honestly if Trump succeeds in this I will definitely give him enormous credit. But for now I am not holding my breath (and not only because I am slightly anemic).
 
Well, it is possible that the lobbyists and corporate overlords have prevented congress from fixing it, and Trump's drain-the-swamp transition team can come up with a reasonable solution that helps (most of) the people and just screws over the bloated corporate execs of the drug and insurance companies.

But somehow I doubt it's that simple... or even if it was Trump's plan would get through congress because we're back to the lobbyists and overlords who own congress.

I await the Trump plan first. He has announced great goals. Many have. But what is his plan to achieve them? Let's see.
 
Well, it is possible that the lobbyists and corporate overlords have prevented congress from fixing it

But even in that case, the plan would have been discussed elsewhere. I mean, this is the internet. Everything gets discussed somewhere.
 
But even in that case, the plan would have been discussed elsewhere. I mean, this is the internet. Everything gets discussed somewhere.

The real plan is to go back to the pre-ACA situation, where people who have group insurance from a large employer (which coincidentally pretty much includes all of the decision-makers in the matter) are in good shape, but insurance companies can reject individual applicants with pre-existing conditions, look for excuses to cancel clients who file expensive claims, and set annual and lifetime limits on payouts. A lot of people will be hurt, but a lot more are in a position to say "I don't care, this doesn't affect me."
 
The real plan is to go back to the pre-ACA situation, where people who have group insurance from a large employer (which coincidentally pretty much includes all of the decision-makers in the matter) are in good shape, but insurance companies can reject individual applicants with pre-existing conditions, look for excuses to cancel clients who file expensive claims, and set annual and lifetime limits on payouts. A lot of people will be hurt, but a lot more are in a position to say "I don't care, this doesn't affect me."

Hey, hey, hey. They won't be allowed to reject applicants with pre-existing conditions. They will just make it prohibitively expensive. As I said the other day, this way, it is the patient's fault if they don't have insurance.
 
Who do you have to deny service then? It's an important part of any health care system - the authority able to ration care.

my god, no one. our health care is not rationed.

if you are sick you get treated.
end of.

and that's the difference....I think my real surprise showed through in that first response. I really didn't realise that the u.s. system is that bad...

so i become ill and have no insurance, do I just die? or hope to get better.....
 
Last edited:
That has nothing to do with the cost of the pills, and everything to do with not getting sued because you OD'd on goofballs under their watch. If they're responsible for you taking a medication, it'll be their medication. Full stop. Even in situations where the rule is completely silly, it's just not worth the risk of something going wrong otherwise.

The in-house cost of everything is so high for you because you're already subsidizing healthcare for the uninsured. And not in the cheapest way.

If you don't have health insurance and you can't pay for treatment, you have to wait until it's a real emergency and then go to the ER. They have to treat you, and you'll rack up a hundred times more charges than if you had health insurance and could have gotten your problem fixed months ago.

Now, like I said, you can't pay those exorbitant bills. So the hospital gives the bill to some debt collection agency to collect on you, with all the scum-of-the-earth that entails, and resigns itself to handling a major loss of revenue by boosting the prices for everything else across the board. Again.


The solution is to insure everyone. Not to have insurance "available," but actual freakin' insurance you can actually afford and depend on. For everyone. It'll be expensive at first, because - surprise! - there are a LOT of people out there nursing serious medical problems they can't afford to treat. But, as the next batch of serious problems gets nipped in the bud by preventative care, costs will gradually drop and we'll get to enjoy having cheap, first-world health care like the rest of civilized society.
and this says a lot about the mentality, should i go to hospital tomorrow, i would be expected and expect to continue to take my mantainace dose of meds,
 
my god, no one. our health care is not rationed.

if you are sick you get treated.
end of.

and that's the difference.

Whose? In the U.S., nobody says "rationed," but access to health care is limited first by whether or not someone has insurance, then by what your insurance company is willing to cover, including what doctors and hospitals are in that company's particular network, then by what you can afford for co-pays and deductibles. You get the care you can pay for, either with insurance or your own savings.
 
my god, no one. our health care is not rationed.
Of course it is. You just haven't seen the rationing personally.

Consider elective procedures. Can you decide, one day, to get cost-free cosmetic surgery? A boob job? Facial reconstruction to look like Hatsune Miku?

I assume not.

But that raises the question: what is an "elective" treatment? Is cosmetic surgery after a disfiguring accident elective? Are prosthetic limbs elective? Is a sex change elective? Replacement organs? Replacement organs in a terminally-ill cancer patient?

Wherever you choose to draw the line, you've got to draw it. Otherwise tell me where you live, because I am moving in next door tomorrow.
 
You and I disagree on this and many broader points as a philosophical issues. But for me a simple line to draw is when an elderly or sick individual is mentally or physically unable to save their life (or is doomed to severe pain and suffering) without the assistance of the government, then the government (which in a democracy hopefully is the collective representation of the majority of the people in the society as a whole) should do so. I basic on my own moral code, in which helping others is very high in the listing of my ethical obligations. I see it as not very different from the city fire department throwing a life preserver to a man who fell into a lake and can't swim- should we just say that everyone should learn how to swim and to hell with him?

Obviously you are free to disagree if indeed you do. But given the basic difference originates in differing philosophies, I don't see that I could convince you otherwise.

Regards!

My question was more broad. How do you test a hardship to determine which ones people must endure and which ones the government should intervene?
 
My question was more broad. How do you test a hardship to determine which ones people must endure and which ones the government should intervene?

Sorry-I thought I had answered by providing one of my criteria- a life or death situation that a person cannot deal with alone and which the government can help by intervening. This is a moral and ethical test as would apply it.

But are you asking how do we test if the person actually requires outside help to survive and if the government intervention can deliver that help? In specific, terms? Or how deep must the hardship be? From my own experience and observations of relatives and friends, I am absolutely convinced that being elderly, ill, and/or ignorant of even basic medical and legal issues, does result in people being unable to obtain essential support from their insurance companies to allow them key life extending care. Not that it takes them a just extra hour on the phone. Instead I have observed that they simply cannot negotiate the many steps, forms, discussions, transfers to other representatives that are required and they simply give up end assume what they were initially told by the first insurance rep must be the truth.

Also remember that the very people who are ill enough to require expensive treatments are often weak, worried, not thinking too clearly, and feel miserable; not a good basis for astutely arguing their case with 4 different entities (insurance company. doctor, pharmacy, hospital billing), multiple phone trees, multiple company representatives, each telling them different things, etc. For success one must be insistent, understand how to present the problem clearly using the correct medical terms, be very patient yet alert, understand what each person on the phone is telling you, and use that information for working out the next person you should contact. This took enormous effort for my spouse and me, and we are reasonably well versed in biology and basic medical concepts/terminology. From my observations of my elderly relatives, I cannot imagine how they could possibly can do so- they often can't even accurately explain there medical problem ("Oh the doctor said it was some kind of growth, but not a cancer. I think he called it a cannanoma or something like that."). They have just given up.
 
my god, no one. our health care is not rationed.

if you are sick you get treated.
end of.

and that's the difference....I think my real surprise showed through in that first response. I really didn't realise that the u.s. system is that bad...

so i become ill and have no insurance, do I just die? or hope to get better.....

Sorry, but although I think that your health care is very, very good, I would be surprised if there was NO rationing. If you are 92 and have arthritic hips, I have no doubt that you would be treated in some reasonable fashion. But you would probably be treated with physical therapy and a cane, not with being given an artificial hip (whereas a 19 year old would get the artificial hip). It is great if both the 19 and 92 year old would get the hip operation (presuming the 92 year old was a reasonable candidate for surviving the operation)- I don't know enough to say this wouldn't happen. But I would be very (pleasantly) surprised.
 
Of course it is. You just haven't seen the rationing personally.

Consider elective procedures. Can you decide, one day, to get cost-free cosmetic surgery? A boob job? Facial reconstruction to look like Hatsune Miku? I assume not.
None of those are health care issues so they are not rationed under Canada's health care plan. They are just not covered.

But that raises the question: what is an "elective" treatment? Is cosmetic surgery after a disfiguring accident elective? Are prosthetic limbs elective? Is a sex change elective? Replacement organs? Replacement organs in a terminally-ill cancer patient?
None of those are elective. They are all considered medically necessary and are covered. None are rationed. A terminally ill cancer patients would, in all likelihood, not be considered for an organ transplant.

you choose to draw the line, you've got to draw it. Otherwise tell me where you live, because I am moving in next door tomorrow.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, but although I think that your health care is very, very good, I would be surprised if there was NO rationing. If you are 92 and have arthritic hips, I have no doubt that you would be treated in some reasonable fashion. But you would probably be treated with physical therapy and a cane, not with being given an artificial hip (whereas a 19 year old would get the artificial hip). It is great if both the 19 and 92 year old would get the hip operation (presuming the 92 year old was a reasonable candidate for surviving the operation)- I don't know enough to say this wouldn't happen. But I would be very (pleasantly) surprised.

Not 92, but in his early eighties my dad was considered eligible to have his worn out hip replacements re-done. He chose not to do it, but it would have been done and covered if he had wanted it.

ETA: I think both you and Beelzebuddy might be confusing "rationing" with prioritizing.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, but although I think that your health care is very, very good, I would be surprised if there was NO rationing. If you are 92 and have arthritic hips, I have no doubt that you would be treated in some reasonable fashion. But you would probably be treated with physical therapy and a cane, not with being given an artificial hip (whereas a 19 year old would get the artificial hip). It is great if both the 19 and 92 year old would get the hip operation (presuming the 92 year old was a reasonable candidate for surviving the operation)- I don't know enough to say this wouldn't happen. But I would be very (pleasantly) surprised.

Where is Mikado from? If the UK then NICE is the rationer (so is wait times).
 
Sorry, but although I think that your health care is very, very good, I would be surprised if there was NO rationing. If you are 92 and have arthritic hips, I have no doubt that you would be treated in some reasonable fashion. But you would probably be treated with physical therapy and a cane, not with being given an artificial hip (whereas a 19 year old would get the artificial hip). It is great if both the 19 and 92 year old would get the hip operation (presuming the 92 year old was a reasonable candidate for surviving the operation)- I don't know enough to say this wouldn't happen. But I would be very (pleasantly) surprised.

Hip replacements are not rationed in the UK, they are decided on clinical need and of course such things as survivability, quality of life etc. That does not mean you will not have to wait, thanks to the last and current governments waiting times are once again becoming a shameful matter for the NHSs in the UK.
 
Hip replacements are not rationed in the UK, they are decided on clinical need and of course such things as survivability, quality of life etc. That does not mean you will not have to wait, thanks to the last and current governments waiting times are once again becoming a shameful matter for the NHSs in the UK.

Triage is the rationing of finite resources.
 
Hip replacements are not rationed in the UK, they are decided on clinical need and of course such things as survivability, quality of life etc. That does not mean you will not have to wait, thanks to the last and current governments waiting times are once again becoming a shameful matter for the NHSs in the UK.

Are hip replacements done in a more timely fashion in the US?

I don't know about hip replacements, but I do know that you don't even need to bother trying to get an appointment with dermatology (can be 3 months with a doctor referral; that's a long time to deal with a rash).

Heck, getting a well-patient physical exam with her PCP takes more than 2 months for my wife.

Waiting times in the US suck, too.
 
By the way I don't think adopting a UK style NHS would be a good idea for the USA. There are many other current successful systems for providing universal medical care and I would say the USA would probably be better with something like the German model.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom