Not all differences in opinion are because someone is wrong. Some differences in opinion are just that.
Of course, but in this case I've found that the differences of opinion do not arise from different values or different starting principles (axioms, if you will), which would all be well and good. They arise because, in almost all cases I've seen - especially here - those who believe the free market couldn't or shouldn't apply to health care resources have done no more than a skin-deep analysis. They don't appear to understand that the vast majority of health care resources produced and consumed are not urgent and life-saving and no more crucial to human happiness and comfort than resources for which we accept free market allocation. Furthermore, they don't appear to understand that there are non-health care related resources which are urgent and life-saving, for which we accept free market allocation.
Many people believe that all people are equal and have an inalienable right to live. In some circles of US-American thinking this is a hugely important tenet.
What do you mean by an inalienable right to live? You don't have an inalienable right to live if you are starving and the only food available belongs to me. Or if you need shelter from the freezing cold, and my house is the only one available. As we become richer and develop more health care resource capacity, we can guarantee more and more health care to those who need it, but we will never be able to guarantee an unlimited amount. Or even the amount that the richest 1% of the population can afford. Right now, thanks to our wealth, we can afford (without putting too much of a burden on others) to treat a traumatic injury in the emergency room regardless of the ability of the victim to pay. But we can't provide state-of-the-art cancer treatment or the fanciest robotic brain tumor surgery to everybody who needs it.
More importantly, those resources wouldn't be available to anyone, even Bill Gates, if we hadn't allowed the free market to work to some extent in health care. I have argued here before that the US ends up carrying the lion's share of the R&D burden in health care because we have largely avoided price controls on health care whereas other developed countries have not. Even worse, we have to hear the ungrateful wretches from other countries talk down to us and brag about the health care that we effectively subsidize.
Those who believe that, will not accept that life-extending treatment is withheld based on an individual's economic performance.
You use the word "withheld" to put a moral spin on your claim. But it is not withheld any more than the car dealer withholds the fully-loaded BMW with all of the newest and fanciest driver assist and safety features from somebody who can't afford it. If life-extending treatment for some ailment is available in limited quantities, then rationing has to be done in some manner. Would you rather it be by who has the best political connections? That's how it is done, in the end, in most countries with socialized health care. Or by queue? Maybe the guy at the head of the queue got there by pulling some strings. Or by going abroad to get a diagnosis first. Or by racing to the clinic in his BMW while the poor schlub behind him had to take the bus.
That does not mean that they do not understand the price argument. It is simple enough: If it costs more wealth to save someone than his labor is worth, then letting him die leaves more resources for the rest of us. We can use those resources for something better, like luxuries or waging war.
Well, given what you just wrote, it does appear you don't understand the price argument. That is not how the pricing system works in any free market. Nobody measures how productive you are when you come in to buy something.
The question is simply what someone values. A right to live, the glory of the nation, or luxuries.
I value human utility. But everybody has their own utility function. Some people value their own life or the lives of their friends and family members more than others. Some people value certain qualities of life, or health, or the ability to do certain physical things, more than others. If I'm not active, then perhaps I don't need to get that knee surgery so I can keep playing tennis. But, hell, if it's free, I'll take it.
(Of course, where luxuries are concerned we have the additional question of who gets to enjoy those. The people doing the early dying and the people doing the consuming tend not to be the same.)
Everything is a luxury from a certain point of view. I do not decide for other people how to rank their luxuries. If somebody enjoys smoking cigarettes more than living a few extra healthy years, who am I to judge?