Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not really, NICE decides if a treatment should be available on the NHS, it does not decide how many people can have a treatment.

Rationing is not just deciding how many people can have a treatment. It includes all controlled distribution of scarce resources.
 
Triage is the rationing of finite resources.

In terms of the NHSs in the UK triage would mean an emergency situation, not everyday practice.

Remember there is only a finite number of people requiring a particular treatment so finite resources doesn't necessarily mean people won't be treated.
 
https://www.pri.org/stories/2010-12-17/how-uk-rations-health-care

"We have a limited budget for health care, voted by Parliament every year, and we have to live within our means," said Michael Rawlins, chairman of a government agency called the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE).

NICE decides which drugs and other treatments can be prescribed by NHS doctors.

NICE was created in 1999 to clarify the reasons why certain drugs are approved and others are rejected. "In the old days it used to be done in secret, behind closed doors, in smoke-filled rooms," Rawlins said. "Now it's explicit. Everybody knows what the rules are."

Edited by Agatha: 
Trimmed for rule 4
 
Last edited by a moderator:
By the way I don't think adopting a UK style NHS would be a good idea for the USA. There are many other current successful systems for providing universal medical care and I would say the USA would probably be better with something like the German model.

The system best-known in the U.S. is Medicare. If you're not on Medicare yourself, your parents, grandparents, neighbors etc. are. Quite a number of people think expanding Medicare to include everyone would be the most practical road for the U.S. Private providers, one payer. An alternative would be to allow anyone under 65 to choose to buy into Medicare for reasonable premiums with low-income subsidies. That would become the "public option." People could still buy private policies directly if they wanted to, as they can buy Medicare Advantage plans now, but the competition from the public option would hold down the private premiums.
 
Nice refusing to approve okambi for cystic fibrosis is rationing.

Then every single medical procedure in every country in the world is "rationed". People just don't use the word as you are trying to do.

NICE is a gatekeeper of which treatments are available via our universal health care systems. But once it has decided a treatment can be provided it has no input into how many people can have that treatment, it doesn't ration the number of people who can have a procedure.
 
Then every single medical procedure in every country in the world is "rationed". People just don't use the word as you are trying to do.

NICE is a gatekeeper of which treatments are available via our universal health care systems. But once it has decided a treatment can be provided it has no input into how many people can have that treatment, it doesn't ration the number of people who can have a procedure.

Trying to do? I'm using how rationing is used. The Head of NICE describes how care is rationed. And since the vast majority of the world does not use market clearing prices to determine quantity supplied, the vast majority of healthcare services are rationed.
 
Trying to do? I'm using how rationing is used. The Head of NICE describes how care is rationed. And since the vast majority of the world does not use market clearing prices to determine quantity supplied, the vast majority of healthcare services are rationed.

Tell me how NICE rations the number of broken bones that can be treated in the NHSs of the UK?
 
Sorry, but although I think that your health care is very, very good, I would be surprised if there was NO rationing.

In Australia there is of course rationing (unless you also have Private Insurance above the compulsory 2% Medicare levy), based in general on the following:

Life threatening - free and immediate and available to everybody. (e.g., a car accident, a Heart Attack, a Stroke, even a broken leg)

Semi-elective - Defined as a potentially future life threatening illness which requires monitoring but is not immediately life threatening (e.g., Bladder Cancer, some tumours) where you may be checked out once every 6 - 12 Months depending on the change in status of your illness. All free under the Universal Health Care system.

(However if you start peeing blood again, you move up the list awfully quickly - you are back to life threatening)

Elective Still free, but the waiting lists can be quite long. Hip replacement, Cataract operations again free, fall under this header. The waiting list can be years long.

Cosmetic As far as I know, not covered at all.

And as I mentioned above, Private Health Insurance is readily available in Australia to either reduce/eliminate co-payments or get that Cataract operation next week instead of waiting 2 years.

Oh, and anybody on a health care card - aged pensioners, unemployed, Disability Pension, Carers - pay no ambulance fees, pay scripts at around $6 each with an annual cap, and can often go to Medical Centres who Bulk Bill Government and do not ask for the co-payment ("the gap"). And of course, you can also buy Ambulance Insurance at quite low rates.

Norm
 
Last edited:
Tell me how NICE rations the number of broken bones that can be treated in the NHSs of the UK?

That is a "when did you stop beating your wife" question because you are trying to take one narrow type of rationing and call it the whole thing.

Rationing is the controlled distribution of scarce resources. In this case, they ration care by setting limits on which services they will purchase.
 
I like how we're supposed to look to Canada, the UK, and Australia as better health-care systems when those people can't even properly use the word "hospital" in a sentence.
 
You were already told this is only approved under breakthrough therapy with a priority review by the FDA and only 18 months ago. Try something which has a normal approval. But nice try repeating that one.

Which isnt relevant to anything I said then or now.
 
Which isnt relevant to anything I said then or now.

It *is* highly relevant, as experimental or breakthrough therapy take time to get approved in nearly all EU countries. Everybody remember Thalidomide. Furthermore drugs have to prove they are effective, (and frankly seeing Lumacaftor/ivacaftor for what it does, it does not seem really that effective - add 3% lung function and provide a reduced hospitalization time in 1/3 of case of hospitalization).

The only exception are usually national programs for life saving drugs, e.g. cancer drugs which may sometime be used also as a breakthrough therapy.

You may refuse that, but it is quite clear for everybody how wrong you are.
 
It *is* highly relevant, as experimental or breakthrough therapy take time to get approved in nearly all EU countries. Everybody remember Thalidomide. Furthermore drugs have to prove they are effective,.

They choose to do those things.
 
Not 92, but in his early eighties my dad was considered eligible to have his worn out hip replacements re-done. He chose not to do it, but it would have been done and covered if he had wanted it.

ETA: I think both you and Beelzebuddy might be confusing "rationing" with prioritizing.

Whatever it is called I am happy that enough money is provide to allow fairly wide accessibility to the very best health care. Not true in the USA, and somewhat limited in some other countries.
 
Are hip replacements done in a more timely fashion in the US?

I don't know about hip replacements, but I do know that you don't even need to bother trying to get an appointment with dermatology (can be 3 months with a doctor referral; that's a long time to deal with a rash).

Heck, getting a well-patient physical exam with her PCP takes more than 2 months for my wife.

Waiting times in the US suck, too.

Absolutely, but somehow people in the US still can be convinced by politicians that this is only true of "socialized" medicine...
 
Nice refusing to approve okambi for cystic fibrosis is rationing.

Orkambi is a mildly effective, very new drug that works only for 3% of CF patients. It is enormously expensive. I can understand the NHS being cautious about approving this drug. It is made up of two separate components- are these approved individually?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom