Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's still the cost of the care that drives this whole mess. We keep attacking the wrong problem.

It doesn't matter how accessible insurance is or what cost they assign to premiums as long as the cost of care keeps increasing exponentially.

"Affordable insurance" just leaves more out of pocket expenses for deductibles, co-insurance, and co-pays. Regardless of how much insurance pays, there is still an allowable cost that the doctors and hospitals expect to have covered. In part, I get it. They leave school with $200,000 in student loan debt and want to be rewarded for their 10 - 12 years of effort. Pharmaceutical companies that patent new treatments want to be reimbursed (and profit) from all the research money spent that didn't lead to anything or led to the drug being released. Of course hospitals need big fancy fountains in their lobby and architectural masterpiece facilities so their patients are more comfortable and think, "Look at that fountain. They must be a great facility!".

It's cost, cost, and cost that is the issue. "Fixing" insurance won't change a thing if they can't control costs.

I know someone very well who works in a hospital setting. It's ridiculous the things they do to drive revenue. If I have a maintenance drug, the hospital won't let me bring it with me and self administer while under their care. No problem if I take it at home, but I have to get it from them at their hospital prices if I'm under their care. Not all hospitals do this, but it is being done by some and looked at by many others. $5 a pill for a drug that I can fill a 90 day supply for $10 cash (without insurance).
 
Last edited:
Some people thought the Affordable Care Act was going to create "Death Panels", groups of bureaucrats with no medical training who would decide if people received medical treatment or not. They obviously didn't realize that we already have them, but they're called insurance companies.

Personally I was bitterly disappointed that there were no government Death Panels. I had hoped to be appointed to one if they ever formed. There are some people I know who I would have loved to have come before my panel...

More seriously, your point about insurance companies is absolutely accurate. In most cases, even when the insurance company ultimately agrees to pay for very costly therapy, that only happens after a great deal of phone tag and long discussions/much paper work and repeated discussion between the patient, the doctor, the insurance company, the pharmacy, and the hospital billings department. It involves whether the insurance company will cover the expense at all, and if they finally agree the expense is indeed part of their obligatory contract, what the co-pay will be (these various interpretations can involve the patient paying anywhere from hundreds of hundreds of thousands of dollars to a few thousand dollars). In all reality the insurance company not only has the power to determine if a patient must co-pay $5 or $20 more for an antibiotic, but in the most serous cases, if a patient will live or die. And if the insurance company continues to deny overage, ultimately the final resort of the patient is civil litigation, with the outcome likely to be way too late to help the patient obtain the treatment needed when they needed it.

I cannot image how an elderly or very sick person living alone can handle all the red tape, or even understand what is going on. I suspect a lot of these people, when first told that the insurance did not cover a major medical need of theirs, simply accept it and either exhaust their savings or do without.

All of this is enormously expensive for everyone involved, including the insurance company. Yet another augment for single payer or universally available health care.
 
Persuading "Teh ebul drugz companees" to charge less (though how this will be done is a mystery) will magically-schmagically achieve all this :rolleyes:

It's pretty easy, we just get them to charge you Limey's more. :D
 
Who do you have to deny service then? It's an important part of any health care system - the authority able to ration care.

As a rule, service is never denied. In Aus there is a co payment for GPs and specialists. Hospitals are free.

In the UK we have full access to GPs, specialists and hospitals. Prescription medication is 'free', except for a dispensing fee.

In reality there may be waiting lists for some treatments, and expensive medication is controlled.

You can also take out private insurance, so you can get a nice private room with a TV, access to non NHS specialists, and shorter queues.

But in an emergency, anyone can go to a hospital and be treated immediately for nothing. And you stay there until the problem is sorted.
 
I cannot image how an elderly or very sick person living alone can handle all the red tape, or even understand what is going on. I suspect a lot of these people, when first told that the insurance did not cover a major medical need of theirs, simply accept it and either exhaust their savings or do without.

All of this is enormously expensive for everyone involved, including the insurance company. Yet another augment for single payer or universally available health care.

Why? How do you decide what burdens we need to accept as adults and what burdens the government should manage?
 
I know someone very well who works in a hospital setting. It's ridiculous the things they do to drive revenue. If I have a maintenance drug, the hospital won't let me bring it with me and self administer while under their care. No problem if I take it at home, but I have to get it from them at their hospital prices if I'm under their care. Not all hospitals do this, but it is being done by some and looked at by many others. $5 a pill for a drug that I can fill a 90 day supply for $10 cash (without insurance).
That has nothing to do with the cost of the pills, and everything to do with not getting sued because you OD'd on goofballs under their watch. If they're responsible for you taking a medication, it'll be their medication. Full stop. Even in situations where the rule is completely silly, it's just not worth the risk of something going wrong otherwise.

The in-house cost of everything is so high for you because you're already subsidizing healthcare for the uninsured. And not in the cheapest way.

If you don't have health insurance and you can't pay for treatment, you have to wait until it's a real emergency and then go to the ER. They have to treat you, and you'll rack up a hundred times more charges than if you had health insurance and could have gotten your problem fixed months ago.

Now, like I said, you can't pay those exorbitant bills. So the hospital gives the bill to some debt collection agency to collect on you, with all the scum-of-the-earth that entails, and resigns itself to handling a major loss of revenue by boosting the prices for everything else across the board. Again.


The solution is to insure everyone. Not to have insurance "available," but actual freakin' insurance you can actually afford and depend on. For everyone. It'll be expensive at first, because - surprise! - there are a LOT of people out there nursing serious medical problems they can't afford to treat. But, as the next batch of serious problems gets nipped in the bud by preventative care, costs will gradually drop and we'll get to enjoy having cheap, first-world health care like the rest of civilized society.
 
Last edited:
It's still the cost of the care that drives this whole mess. We keep attacking the wrong problem.

It doesn't matter how accessible insurance is or what cost they assign to premiums as long as the cost of care keeps increasing exponentially.

"Affordable insurance" just leaves more out of pocket expenses for deductibles, co-insurance, and co-pays. Regardless of how much insurance pays, there is still an allowable cost that the doctors and hospitals expect to have covered. In part, I get it. They leave school with $200,000 in student loan debt and want to be rewarded for their 10 - 12 years of effort. Pharmaceutical companies that patent new treatments want to be reimbursed (and profit) from all the research money spent that didn't lead to anything or led to the drug being released. Of course hospitals need big fancy fountains in their lobby and architectural masterpiece facilities so their patients are more comfortable and think, "Look at that fountain. They must be a great facility!".

It's cost, cost, and cost that is the issue. "Fixing" insurance won't change a thing if they can't control costs.

I know someone very well who works in a hospital setting. It's ridiculous the things they do to drive revenue. If I have a maintenance drug, the hospital won't let me bring it with me and self administer while under their care. No problem if I take it at home, but I have to get it from them at their hospital prices if I'm under their care. Not all hospitals do this, but it is being done by some and looked at by many others. $5 a pill for a drug that I can fill a 90 day supply for $10 cash (without insurance).
Insurance companies still make enough money to build the tallest buildings in downtown cities. I suspect that they represent a significant part of the problem.

But yes, the cost of treatment is extraordinarily expensive and from outside the system (and I am outside it- I do basic research in a non-clinical teaching department) it appears that much of the current expensive is inflated. But whenever I've looked into a specific high cost item, it gets more complicated. First of all, things were much cheaper when there was nothing really significant the doctors could do for you. But now they have ways of really helping you, but they can cost big time. No doubt the drugs I take are billed at many fold what the chemicals in them cost. Probably several fold more than the actual cost of the research to specifically develop those drugs. Yet the research to explore a lot of parallel drugs that never worked well enough to be sold also cost a lot of money, and someone has to pay for those too. On the other hand, pharmaceutical firms benefit for free from the drug research the government pays as NIH grants, etc. I honestly don't know how this all balances out, but I think that the pricing structure has to be re-examined, made more open, and reformed. And of course IMO there are many cases of truly and purely obscene greed (epipen anyone?).

Much of the cost in hospitals/doctors offices includes dealing all the red tape in dealing with insurance and some government regulations, as well as fear of litigation. Probably this is why patients are not allowed to bring in their own drugs- it represents a loss of control but not a loss of liability for the hospital. Even if they trusted that you brought in the correct drugs your use of them would still need to be supervised by the staff (which is a major component of why the in-house drug delivery is so expensive). Believe me- I am certain that you would take them correctly but a very large percent of patients would not be able to do so. Particularly when they were very ill.

[added} Plus what Beelzebuddy posted. What he/she listed greatly add to the hospital's costs. As already brought up in this thread, we all pay for others health costs even minus Obamacare. Often in obscure ways, and often very inefficiently, but we all pay.
 
Last edited:
Why? How do you decide what burdens we need to accept as adults and what burdens the government should manage?

You and I disagree on this and many broader points as a philosophical issues. But for me a simple line to draw is when an elderly or sick individual is mentally or physically unable to save their life (or is doomed to severe pain and suffering) without the assistance of the government, then the government (which in a democracy hopefully is the collective representation of the majority of the people in the society as a whole) should do so. I basic on my own moral code, in which helping others is very high in the listing of my ethical obligations. I see it as not very different from the city fire department throwing a life preserver to a man who fell into a lake and can't swim- should we just say that everyone should learn how to swim and to hell with him?

Obviously you are free to disagree if indeed you do. But given the basic difference originates in differing philosophies, I don't see that I could convince you otherwise.

Regards!
 
I'll pass. The level of discourse here is going downhill fast, and I think it's long past time to invest elsewhere. I guess it's one of the downsides of Trump getting elected. At first, it was quite enjoyable to see liberal heads explode. Now it's just depressing.

Admit it: you only read the Cliffs Notes version, too.
 
Another point in regards to the cost of health care and its availability:

Three options as I see it:
1. No rationing at all: the society is willing to commit enough money (private insurance or government run) to pay for any medical treatment the patient wants and a doctor is willing to do. I am unaware of any society willing to do this, and I believe most people would agree that the society as a whole should not pay for just every procedure a patient might want (e.g. purely cosmetic operations).

In real life no society is willing to operate under #1. So health care delivery must be rationed:

2. In government-run health services the rationing is done by panels of appropriate experts based on the money they do have versus the potential benefit to the patient. The health service can afford to pay for one hip replacement: A person with a disease likely to kill them in 6 months will be denied the artificial hip operation (by the government program) to make that money available for a 19 year old with the same hip problem Seems sensible to me.

3. In the USA and similar systems, there still very much is rationing, but done primarily by the wealth of the patient or/and the willingness of their insurance company. A wealthy person likely to die of another disease in 6 months will probably be able to get a hip replacement from some doctors somewhere and a poor 19 year old is likely to be denied it.

Both #2 and #3 are absolutely rationing. I think that #2 is much more logical, moral and fair.
 
Both #2 and #3 are absolutely rationing. I think that #2 is much more logical, moral and fair.
Yes, but it doesn't have the abdication of social responsibility for the well-being of others.

There's still an undercurrent of Social Darwinism in American politics; an unspoken but nastily implied assumption that the problems one suffers from must be somehow one's fault, and any consequences therefrom justly deserved; a whisper of old Scrooge's "well if they'd rather die they'd better do it, and decrease the surplus population!"
 
This is a curious strategy.
Why do they not want to talk about the details of their ACA replacement plan?

There is no ACA replacement plan. There never has been. Republicans have used the ACA as a hammer against Obama since it was passed, encouraging the clueless public to blame every single problem they have with health care -- premiums, deductibles, choice of doctors, prescription costs, etc., etc. -- on Obama. The House voted 60+ times to repeal it knowing that the Democratic Senate would not go along. The Republicans never really expected to have to produce their own plan. Paul Ryan -- the alleged policy wonk -- has never offered a plan except in the vaguest terms. But they could claim they were trying to help their constituents and that nasty Kenyan Communist was standing in the way. Now that 22+ million people -- some with severe conditions, and all of whom vote -- are in danger of losing coverage, the Republicans have to acknowledge that the ACA has complex interlocked provisions that can't easily be pulled apart. But now they can't blame Obama.

The number of people without insurance would grow to about 32 million within the first decade if congressional Republicans follow a 2015 plan to repeal the health-care law without an alternative, the new report says. It also estimates that health insurance premiums for people buying individual non-group coverage would double in a decade, further complicating GOP promises that people will not lose coverage under their plan.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/...ement-cbo-report-says/?utm_term=.cbb0caad08d7
 
Last edited:
Different things. It was not that hard to win as these presidencies go back and forth, and there was no other Republican who had a fan base.

Being president is entirely different. Watch a few episodes of West Wing.

We have a record of Trump saying pretty much anything so until there is a concrete plan there is nothing.

Trump healthcare and Trump tax plan are not compatible.

False, and The West Wing was leftist trash. You don't get to be as rich as Donald Trump because you inherited a little bit of money. He's going to deliver superior health-care ahead of schedule and under budget.

Everyone will have access, but 30 million won't be able to afford it.

Trump should build a beautiful hospital atop Mt. McKinley: free care for anyone who makes it through the doors. He should also spend tens of thousands of dollars playing Powerball in the off-chance that a win would make lib heads explode.
 
You're right, if Donald had just invested the little bit he inherited he would be far richer.

Yes- many analyses suggest that he did considerably worse-off using his brain than if he had invested his inheritance in a stock index fund. Plus ripping off a lot of people along the way (how many people hurt in his repeated bankruptcies alone?). It doesn't promise well for his ability to construct a good health insurance/availability plan, does it! I will also mention not only the money given to him by his family, but all the contacts and friendships with important and/or wealthy people. Probably more important than just cash.

One of the skills I do recognize in Trump is his ability to convince other people that he has done anything extraordinary. I guess it is easy if you simply feel no obligation to sticking to facts. A trait of a good film-flam con artist.
 
Last edited:
False, and The West Wing was leftist trash. You don't get to be as rich as Donald Trump because you inherited a little bit of money. He's going to deliver superior health-care ahead of schedule and under budget.

1) While The West Wing depicted a Democratic administration, on more than one occasion Sorkin pushed misleading right-wing talking points as fact, notably the “Social Security is going bankrupt” dross.

2) The low end of estimates for his inherited wealth says $40 million minimum, not including the $200 million company he helped run for years before his father’s death. $40 million is not a little bit of money.

3) Nixon went to China, maybe Trump can fix US healthcare, although I can’t see how. If you want to provide affordable healthcare to all Americans and keep the profit margins of the healthcare industry nice and fat, you pretty much end up with Obamacare by default. If there is a different way of doing it, no one has really figured one out in the quarter century since Bill Clinton first proposed fixing US healthcare.
 
There is no ACA replacement plan. There never has been.

Obviously.

I mean, come on! Think about it! There is no Sooper Sekrit Solution to health care that covers everyone and cuts costs. Anything that could possibly be done has already been suggested and discussed extensively. If it were as easy as having some people of Trump's transition team sitting down over the course of 2 months and getting it done, it would have been done years ago.
 
Obviously.

I mean, come on! Think about it! There is no Sooper Sekrit Solution to health care that covers everyone and cuts costs. Anything that could possibly be done has already been suggested and discussed extensively. If it were as easy as having some people of Trump's transition team sitting down over the course of 2 months and getting it done, it would have been done years ago.

Well, it is possible that the lobbyists and corporate overlords have prevented congress from fixing it, and Trump's drain-the-swamp transition team can come up with a reasonable solution that helps (most of) the people and just screws over the bloated corporate execs of the drug and insurance companies.

But somehow I doubt it's that simple... or even if it was Trump's plan would get through congress because we're back to the lobbyists and overlords who own congress.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom