Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why is dental separate anyway? In the veterinary field, there is no distinction. Dental health is absolutely part of, well, health.
 
Of course there are limits. But here we have a good, free safety net. If you want elective surgery, dental, optometry, a private hospital room and so on, you either pay the fee, or take out private insurance, as I have. It costs around $50 a week to cover me, my wife and the remaining dependent child.

If I want to go to a doctor or have to go to an ER, it is cost free. Surgery in a public hospital is free, as are emergency medical treatments.

I could do without private insurance, but I choose not to. What's wrong with a system like this?

Wrong with it? Nothing jumps out. I was just trying to explain the difference between what was described an the US system. Both have limits, it's just that the limits kick in in different places.

The question was what happens when a limit is hit. I claimed the same thing happens in either country - you pay for it yourself or you do without. Is my claim correct? I don't live in Australia, so maybe I'm wrong.

The "kicks in in different places" comes from my experience under various health care systems in the US. Over the years I've been a) without health care b) under a government low-income plan c) in the military health care system d) privately insured. All of those systems paid different amounts for different things.
 
Last edited:
Trump also says he will negotiate drug prices for Medicare. His HHS proposed secretary Tom Price voted against that when he was in congress.
 
Wrong with it? Nothing jumps out. I was just trying to explain the difference between what was described an the US system. Both have limits, it's just that the limits kick in in different places.

The question was what happens when a limit is hit. I claimed the same thing happens in either country - you pay for it yourself or you do without. Is my claim correct? I don't live in Australia, so maybe I'm wrong.

The "kicks in in different places" comes from my experience under various health care systems in the US. Over the years I've been a) without health care b) under a government low-income plan c) in the military health care system d) privately insured. All of those systems paid different amounts for different things.

There is no limit on Medicare covered health care. If you want care above that covered by Medicare you pay for it.

And to Tsukasa, you can get free emergency dental care through public dental hospitals, but non-emergency preventative care you pay for.

I have no problem with this. Funding elective health care, private rooms, cosmetic surgery and so on across the nation would be a huge drain on Australia's budget. We have a generous welfare system as it is.
 
there is no limit on health care in australia as such...the whole elective issue is a shady one, People don't go without on the whole.

if you are ill you go to the doctor, as many times as you need,
if i was terribly ill, or a nut, i could go once a week, i would still be covered, the doctors may hide from me..
if you need a specialist you get referred to one,
if you need hospital you go to one.
in the country at least, there appears to be little tangible benefit to the cost of health insurance. the city may well be different.
 
Last edited:
There is no limit on Medicare covered health care. If you want care above that covered by Medicare you pay for it.

And to Tsukasa, you can get free emergency dental care through public dental hospitals, but non-emergency preventative care you pay for.

I have no problem with this. Funding elective health care, private rooms, cosmetic surgery and so on across the nation would be a huge drain on Australia's budget. We have a generous welfare system as it is.

agree re private rooms, but in the country you generally get them anyway...
 
It's magic! Trump has a magical health care plan. Everyone gets coverage, copays are less, premiums are less. Magic I tell you, he's a magic man.

Persuading "Teh ebul drugz companees" to charge less (though how this will be done is a mystery) will magically-schmagically achieve all this :rolleyes:
 
there is no limit on health care in australia as such...the whole elective issue is a shady one, People don't go without on the whole.

if you are ill you go to the doctor, as many times as you need,
if i was terribly ill, or a nut, i could go once a week, i would still be covered, the doctors may hide from me..
if you need a specialist you get referred to one,
if you need hospital you go to one.
in the country at least, there appears to be little tangible benefit to the cost of health insurance. the city may well be different.

They use that language in the US too. Sometimes an insurance company will deny payment because "you don't need it." They say it a bit nicer though: "not medically justified."

Sometimes they have turf wars over it. Your doctor might say you need it and their staff doctors say not. It can become a mess. It can become, "care delayed is care denied." Sometimes lawyers get involved.
 
no, not like that... non life saving surgeries are classified as elective, but good surgeons gwr around that,
nothing like that could ever happen in australia, we have a right to that medical care.
 
They use that language in the US too. Sometimes an insurance company will deny payment because "you don't need it." They say it a bit nicer though: "not medically justified."

Sometimes they have turf wars over it. Your doctor might say you need it and their staff doctors say not. It can become a mess. It can become, "care delayed is care denied." Sometimes lawyers get involved.

Insurance companies in Australia do not decide these things.
 
This is a curious strategy.

But he may not want to talk about that much when he testifies before Congress this week as President-elect Donald Trump's nominee for Health and Human Services secretary.

Price, a Georgia congressman and orthopedic surgeon, does not want the sole focus of his appearance before the Senate Health Committee on Wednesday to be his own proposal to repeal and replace Obamacare, according to a Trump transition official. He wants to avoid signaling that he is asking fellow lawmakers to endorse his plan to reform the country's health care system.

In the lead-up to his confirmation hearings, Price has been kept out of the Trump transition team's efforts to craft an Obamacare replacement plan. According to a senior transition official, the incoming administration wants Price to be inoculated from questions about what Trump's alternative to the Affordable Care Act looks like when he faces probing senators this week.

Why do they not want to talk about the details of their ACA replacement plan?
 
They use that language in the US too. Sometimes an insurance company will deny payment because "you don't need it." They say it a bit nicer though: "not medically justified."

Sometimes they have turf wars over it. Your doctor might say you need it and their claims staff doctors say not. It can become a mess. It can become, "care delayed is care denied." Sometimes lawyers get involved.
ftfy
 
They use that language in the US too. Sometimes an insurance company will deny payment because "you don't need it." They say it a bit nicer though: "not medically justified."


Some people thought the Affordable Care Act was going to create "Death Panels", groups of bureaucrats with no medical training who would decide if people received medical treatment or not. They obviously didn't realize that we already have them, but they're called insurance companies.
 
Some people thought the Affordable Care Act was going to create "Death Panels", groups of bureaucrats with no medical training who would decide if people received medical treatment or not. They obviously didn't realize that we already have them, but they're called insurance companies.

Yeah, this was always my argument. Every time people talk about the supposed evils of having the government involved in paying for health care, I just think "But... that problem already exists. It's built into the insurance companies, and they are motivated by profit".

My wife is PA and because a particular disease that makes up the bulk of her patient's problems is cured by an insanely expensive drug, she has to argue with insurance companies constantly. Sometimes they are still denied despite her and her supervising physician spelling out why the treatment is necessary. And they try anything to deny the treatment - one insurance company had extremely limited hours in which she could call and she'd be on hold for hours. It once took her 2+ weeks to get in contact with the person who could do the approval.

Another example is my sister. She moved to the UK years ago and moved from one side of town to another. The move meant that she couldn't use the doctor she liked because she moved to a different catchment or whatever. To my parents this was a complete indictment of the NHS and absolute proof of how horrible it is. To which I responded "Didn't you JUST have to change primary physician because he's no longer in your insurance network?" They STILL bring this up years later as evidence of the evils of socialized medicine, despite my sister being a vehement supporter of the NHS, despises the US model, and now actually works for the NHS.
 
Persuading "Teh ebul drugz companees" to charge less (though how this will be done is a mystery) will magically-schmagically achieve all this :rolleyes:


Medicare and Medicaid are not currently allowed to bargain with drug companies over prices, even though private insurance companies are. Combined, they insure over 100,000,000 Americans. They could negotiate far better prices for medicines.

This wouldn't change the copays for the insured, though. They'd still be spending the same amount of money. But the government would see savings. That savings would be, maximum, $16B a year. That's not nearly enough to pay for anything Trump wants to do. It won't lower taxes. It'll lower the federal deficit by only 3.2%.

So, in sum, the US could "magically" get drug companies to lower their prices but Trump is wrong wrong wrong that this money would magically make a damn bit of difference to any consumer or the government's budget.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom