Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
The latest lie told by some Congressman last night on the news: the increase in numbers of people covered was because of the improved economy and not because of the ACA.

Obviously. See, the improved economy mainly happened in those states where the governors accepted the medicaid expansion. Just a coincidence that they were far and away states led by democratic governors.

What's the lesson? That GOP governors were detrimental to economic improvement in their states.

Nice to see him admit that.

PS I thought the economy didn't actually improve all that much under Obama?
 
You seem to be brushing aside the idea that the USA is a different country with a different population makeup.
We're not Klingons mate. (I stole that line).

There is no guarantee that in the US, prevention+treatment for all = less money with better outcomes. And better outcomes is debateable. What criteria? This has been argued about in the literature for awhile now.
What literature? This isn't a gotcha, I just want to see the citations. If the literature is aimed at clinics, insurers or doctors, it might be biased.

How do you require people to attend these things? You can't find them or jail them obviously. So what if they don't go and don't listen?
Delicious pizza with a salad center and fat-free ranch? A doctor's order for paid hours off so they get out of work to attend? Change is often incremental. Years ago no one wore seat belts, now everyone does.

I don't see it as me stigmatizing anyone.
I know that.

Let's take smoking for example. It's a completely voluntary activity that everyone knows is very bad for your health.
Yes, and it ALREADY requires a higher premium so it's not the best example. It is based on the honor system BTW.

The sad fact is that any ill effects are indeed "your own damn fault." Same goes for the diets some people eat and other lifestyle choices that are bad for your health.

I recognize the personal responsibility thing, but I also see the interplay of many confounding factors. For one thing, obesity is a medical condition in itself. I have an uncle who got up to 400 pounds and developed Type 2 diabetes. When it became clear that lifestyle alone was not going to fully relieve his condition, maybe bariatric surgery would have been cheaper for all.

I don't find the "people are fallible" argument very convincing. How far should we take this argument?
All the way.

No need for lifestyle police. Answer a few questions, take some lab tests, get a physical. You'll still get insurance but you'll pay for your risks. Incentivize healthy lifestyles.
People who fell short would have a black mark on their record forever. The potential for abuse is enormous if we go back to the bad old days like Congress wants.

If you have more auto accidents or traffic tickets or if you drive certain types of risky car or if you are young, you pay more for auto insurance. If you smoke or don't pass a physical/lab tests you pay more for life insurance. If you make claims on your homeowners policy you pay more. You pay for your risk profile in the insurance industry.

Keep it simple. Risk.
Risk isn't simple. It's complicated. With health care, the top exposure is practically infinite - different than being burglarized or totaling a car. And it has historically been very difficult to get the information needed for an individual to assess risks. One factor is a pricing structure that nobody understands. In a pool? Appendectomy $7K. Uninsured? Appendectomy $35K. How do you budget for infinite risk? There is an actuary on this thread who questions some of your assumptions and has good data. Be open to that. You want to put it "in a nutshell." Not sure that works
 
Last edited:
I recommend having the government pay for a massive number of scholarships for doctors that ensure the doctors can graduate without debt and contain a rider that they must work for a reasonable rate at a government hospital for, say, seven years after completing their residency.



Just, in the parlance of my US friends, spitballing, really.

We do this already. The Feds have the National Health Service Corp where if you agree to up to 4 years of service, they will pay for up to 4 years of med school. Or you can apply for up to $50,000 in loan forgiveness for 2 years of service. There's also a program where if you work for the government (Fed, state, local, tribal) and make 120 payments towards your loans, they will forgive the rest.
 
We do this already. The Feds have the National Health Service Corp where if you agree to up to 4 years of service, they will pay for up to 4 years of med school. Or you can apply for up to $50,000 in loan forgiveness for 2 years of service. There's also a program where if you work for the government (Fed, state, local, tribal) and make 120 payments towards your loans, they will forgive the rest.

Yep, the problem is the bottleneck of only allowing a certain number of graduates become doctors by limiting the number of residencies.

Lawyers only wish we could limit the number of people who passed a bar exam in the same way.
 
BTW I'm not sure the huge billing discrepancies are still legal. The point is many patients have no reasonable baseline for comparison of hospital costs.

ETA: It's ironic that the politician who I think could accomplish UHC might be Trump, if he weren't so combative. Reform is a massive business deal. Properly structuring the transition would be yuge. If he really has the business chops.
 
Last edited:
Yep, the problem is the bottleneck of only allowing a certain number of graduates become doctors by limiting the number of residencies.

Lawyers only wish we could limit the number of people who passed a bar exam in the same way.
Can't you?
 
Yep, the problem is the bottleneck of only allowing a certain number of graduates become doctors by limiting the number of residencies.

Lawyers only wish we could limit the number of people who passed a bar exam in the same way.

Wait a minute. Are you saying there are graduates of medical schools who can't become doctors (excluding the ones who choose to do research or management instead of patient care) because there aren't enough residencies? How can that be? Residents are cheap labor. Most hospitals would want as many as they could get. I suspect the real bottleneck is the number of places in med schools; that's why Americans go off to the Caribbean and other foreign schools.
 

But it’s important to remember that overall, the contribution of genes to obesity risk is small, while the contribution of our toxic food and activity environment is huge. As one scientist wrote, “Genes may co-determine who becomes obese, but our environment determines how many become obese.” (20) That’s why obesity prevention efforts must focus on changing our environment to make healthy choices easier choices, for all.
This is still not saying fat people should be charged more. Instead of genes as destiny, it's "our toxic food and activity environment" as destiny. We were born into an unprecedented global glut of food, coupled with an unprecedented degree of convenience. It's larger than an individual's willpower, so I would rather not penalize individuals.

This is a crude comparison, but to me blaming a person for being fat is about as useful as blaming a dog for being fat.
 
Wait a minute. Are you saying there are graduates of medical schools who can't become doctors (excluding the ones who choose to do research or management instead of patient care) because there aren't enough residencies? How can that be? Residents are cheap labor. Most hospitals would want as many as they could get. I suspect the real bottleneck is the number of places in med schools; that's why Americans go off to the Caribbean and other foreign schools.

Nah. They go to Baby Doc Haitian Medical School because they couldn't get into an accredited program onshore.

I think the residency bottleneck is well documented. Keep in mind that as cheap as they are, they're still paid a lot of money (my wife's 5th year residency salary was $200K), need supervision, need to be insured.

Also: many positions are being filled by people who completed their medical degrees in other countries. They're very competitive.
 
Last edited:
This is still not saying fat people should be charged more. Instead of genes as destiny, it's "our toxic food and activity environment" as destiny. We were born into an unprecedented global glut of food, coupled with an unprecedented degree of convenience. It's larger than an individual's willpower, so I would rather not penalize individuals.

This is a crude comparison, but to me blaming a person for being fat is about as useful as blaming a dog for being fat.
A dog can't choose it's food; they eat what's available. Dogs in the wild aren't fat and I don't think it's possible for wild dogs to get fat. Wild humans, on the other hand . . . well, we see where we are now. Humans have choices. We choose to make our lives easier so we don't have to move around much to get things done and we are capable of creating food that is tasty. Those are our choices. I don't read the way the article uses the word "environment" as meaning some natural habitat we have no choice but to succumb to. We do have choice, we just make bad ones.
 
A case study of why U.S. health care costs are out of control:
After his recent herniated-disk surgery, Peter Drier was ready for the $56,000 hospital charge, the $4,300 anesthesiologist bill, and the $133,000 fee for orthopedist. All were either in-network under his insurance or had been previously negotiated. But as Elisabeth Rosenthal recently explained in her great New York Times piece, he wasn't quite prepared for a $117,000 bill from an “assistant surgeon"—an out-of-network doctor that the hospital tacked on at the last minute.
https://www.theatlantic.com/health/...mericans-are-drowning-in-medical-debt/381163/
https://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/21/us/drive-by-doctoring-surprise-medical-bills.html
 
There is now a lobbying campaign to bring back lifetime limits.

Dye plans to come to Washington next month to lobby in favor of lifetime limits. He’ll target the delegation from South Carolina, his home state.

Dye believes lifetime limits will allow insurers to offer more affordable plans, which would appeal to the low-income workers who typically use his company’s plans. He understands there will be trade-offs for families like the Morrisons, but, he says, that’s true with any policy debate.

“You cannot design something that is going to solve every individual’s problem or situation,” he said when asked about what would happen to those who especially intense medical needs. “It can’t be unlimited or else you will have a tragic circumstance; a child will circuit the math for everyone else that is trying to operate within actuarial parameters.”

Seems like you could these death panels.
 

Of course. They are just appealing to the tyranny of the majority. The sell is that we get cheaper insurance, and MOST of us don't have to worry about maxing out. So they want most of the people to support it.

And what about those who will suffer? **** em. They are just a small fraction, so who cares what happens to them.

They are emboldened by the lack of compassion and common decency demonstrated by the American electorate.
 

I would refuse to pay for the assistant surgeon if it wasn't clearly disclosed to me that he/she was out of network and why their services were even medically necessary. In any case, Medicare and most insurances pay an assistant surgeon at 16% of the regular surgeon. So, if it was medically necessary to have one and they disclosed to me that they would be present, I would negotiate a rate at 16% of what the surgeon got paid by my insurance. If they refused, I would tell my surgeon he either finds an assistant that is in network or I will find a surgery team that will work with my insurance.

It's also worth noting that the surgeon for a herniated disc surgery isn't getting paid anywhere near $116,000 by the insurance company. It's probably around 50 - 60% of that.

What happened in this case is abuse. It's like going to the grocery store and being told your grocery bill is almost double because they automatically added extra stuff at the end. We shouldn't tolerate it but we also have to be informed consumers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom