Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
I would refuse to pay for the assistant surgeon if it wasn't clearly disclosed to me that he/she was out of network and why their services were even medically necessary. In any case, Medicare and most insurances pay an assistant surgeon at 16% of the regular surgeon. So, if it was medically necessary to have one and they disclosed to me that they would be present, I would negotiate a rate at 16% of what the surgeon got paid by my insurance. If they refused, I would tell my surgeon he either finds an assistant that is in network or I will find a surgery team that will work with my insurance.

It's also worth noting that the surgeon for a herniated disc surgery isn't getting paid anywhere near $116,000 by the insurance company. It's probably around 50 - 60% of that.

What happened in this case is abuse. It's like going to the grocery store and being told your grocery bill is almost double because they automatically added extra stuff at the end. We shouldn't tolerate it but we also have to be informed consumers.

Did you read the links? This is apparently a typical practice. The patient -- who, after all, is in the hospital because he's really sick -- gives unknowing permission for this stuff in the stack of papers he has to sign. We can't be informed consumers if the information we need is concealed. And unless you're terribly unlucky, you might have major surgery a couple times in your life. Hospitals deal with this every hour of every day. They are the experts, and they routinely sue people who don't pay up.

Unlike many consumer purchases, health care is an urgent necessity. A patient doesn't get to decide whether or not he needs cancer treatment or a heart bypass. The providers hold all the cards.
 
Last edited:

Of course. They are just appealing to the tyranny of the majority. The sell is that we get cheaper insurance, and MOST of us don't have to worry about maxing out. So they want most of the people to support it.

And what about those who will suffer? **** em. They are just a small fraction, so who cares what happens to them.

They are emboldened by the lack of compassion and common decency demonstrated by the American electorate.

Lifetime limits are more important for smaller insurance companies than for larger ones. The incidence rates are low, but if you don't have a large enough underlying pool of covered lives, they're potentially disastrous to the company. I know there's a tendency to cast insurance companies as evil money-grubbers, but at the end of the day if a small number of extremely large claims forces a company into insolvency, all of their policyholders are at risk of not being covered.

That said, the impact varies by state. *Most* states had pretty large minimums on lifetime maxes prior to ACA, so for *most* states, the impact of making them unlimited was marginal. Not negligible, but not nearly as large an impact on price as most of the other elements of ACA. For example, my states all had a minimum of $2,000,000 lifetime max. It's pretty hard to get to that level, and most of them are extension of terminal life situations - persistent life support for people who are otherwise dead. My personal view is that we should not extend life in that way int he first place... but that is my opinion, and is heavily based on my own beliefs of what constitutes compassion.

Aside form that blanket *most*, there were previously some states with extremely low lifetime limits for their individual market, where ACA's removal of those limits would have had a much more significant impact on price. I don't have as much sympathy for those states as they might like.

At the end of the day, this isn't a straightforward issue. It's not just cost, there are social implications as well. It intersects heavily with social views on end of life treatment and medical ethics. It's not black and white.
 
Did you read the links? This is apparently a typical practice. The patient -- who, after all, is in the hospital because he's really sick -- gives unknowing permission for this stuff in the stack of papers he has to sign. We can't be informed consumers if the information we need is concealed. And unless you're terribly unlucky, you might have major surgery a couple times in your life. Hospitals deal with this every hour of every day. They are the experts, and they routinely sue people who don't pay up.

Unlike many consumer purchases, health care is an urgent necessity. A patient doesn't get to decide whether or not he needs cancer treatment or a heart bypass. The providers hold all the cards.

There have been a lot of cases lately that center around the anesthesiologist for surgeries. I believe there've even been some discussions of legislation on it.

Here's the basic situation: A policyholder schedules a surgery. They receive prior approval for the surgery, at a contracted hospital facility, with a contracted in-network surgeon. From the perspective of the policyholder, they've done all the right things and been as responsible as they should be expected to be. Post surgery, they find out that the anesthesiologist (who they did not choose and had no interaction with prior to the day of the surgery) was not contracted, and gets billed as out of network. Surprise!

It is my opinion that all ancillary practitioners involved in the service are the responsibility of the facility. If the patient does their part by making sure that both the surgeon and the facility are in-network, then the patient shouldn't be held responsible for the supporting practitioners that they had no say about, and in many cases no prior knowledge of. If the facility provides an out of network anesthesiologist or assistant surgeon, the financial impact of that should be on the facility.
 

A question here. What would be the impact on the health care industry if the federal government indemnified insurers against unlimited costs in exchange for controls on the prices providers could charge? Something like "We'll cover all the costs above $1 million ($2 million, whatever), provided that you do not pay providers more than the Medicare-approved fees (or some suitable percentage above them)." In other words, trade loss limits for price controls. This is not too different from what other countries do when their systems provide universal coverage through private insurers. Possible? Practical?
 
I hear this term a lot and can't quite wrap my head around it. What's the cliffs notes version?

One version is mentioned in my signature.

Other options are probably more appropriate for the US.
 
A question here. What would be the impact on the health care industry if the federal government indemnified insurers against unlimited costs in exchange for controls on the prices providers could charge? Something like "We'll cover all the costs above $1 million ($2 million, whatever), provided that you do not pay providers more than the Medicare-approved fees (or some suitable percentage above them)." In other words, trade loss limits for price controls. This is not too different from what other countries do when their systems provide universal coverage through private insurers. Possible? Practical?

The problem is getting the providers to agree.

As long as providers can simply say "no, I'm not going to accept that payment, and I won't contract with you for that low a rate", it won't work.

Now, if the government indemnified insurers for those excess costs*, AND also dictated payment rates that providers were obligated to accept, that would be peachy. Heck, if the government simply dictated the rates that providers were obligated to accept, there wouldn't necessarily be a need for that indemnification.

*FYI, there's actually a term for that: reinsurance. There's even a whole industry built around reinsurance - insurance for the excess risk that insurers take. It's kind of meta in a very geeky way.
 
Yep, the problem is the bottleneck of only allowing a certain number of graduates become doctors by limiting the number of residencies.

Lawyers only wish we could limit the number of people who passed a bar exam in the same way.

Actuaries manage this by constantly tinkering with the exams. If the pass rate is too high, they make it harder the next round; if it's too low they make it a little bit easier. Keeps us in short supply and high demand. It's very lucrative for me! :p


ETA, I have no idea how I ended up bounced back several days for the post I was looking at.
 
The problem is getting the providers to agree.

As long as providers can simply say "no, I'm not going to accept that payment, and I won't contract with you for that low a rate", it won't work.

Now, if the government indemnified insurers for those excess costs*, AND also dictated payment rates that providers were obligated to accept, that would be peachy. Heck, if the government simply dictated the rates that providers were obligated to accept, there wouldn't necessarily be a need for that indemnification.

*FYI, there's actually a term for that: reinsurance. There's even a whole industry built around reinsurance - insurance for the excess risk that insurers take. It's kind of meta in a very geeky way.

Well, a lot of providers take Medicare, which generally means accepting Medicare rates. Insurance companies could say they will only include in their networks the providers that will accept the established rates, which is basically what they do now, except the insurer sets the rates, not a government agency.

And I understand the concept of reinsurance: Companies share the risks among themselves. But the costs are ultimately paid by the insurance companies. I'm talking about a system where the government would tell insurers "No patient will ever cost you more than X as long as you don't pay providers more than Y."
 
It's actually pretty simple: make it illegal to add on extra services insurance doesn't cover without the patient's explicit consent. Since this practice is pretty much how Medicare defines fraud and abuse it isn't much of a stretch. For example, doctors and hospitals aren't allowed to bill patients for services they don't pay for unless the patient signs an Advance Beneficiary Notice form which spells out the cost and why Medicare won't cover it. We still have to bill it to Medicare with a code that tells Medicare that we notified the patient. They deny it and we can collect from the patient. If we fail to disclose with an ABN, it is fraud/abuse to bill the patient.
 
It's actually pretty simple: make it illegal to add on extra services insurance doesn't cover without the patient's explicit consent. Since this practice is pretty much how Medicare defines fraud and abuse it isn't much of a stretch. For example, doctors and hospitals aren't allowed to bill patients for services they don't pay for unless the patient signs an Advance Beneficiary Notice form which spells out the cost and why Medicare won't cover it. We still have to bill it to Medicare with a code that tells Medicare that we notified the patient. They deny it and we can collect from the patient. If we fail to disclose with an ABN, it is fraud/abuse to bill the patient.

When a hospital patient is handed that form with other paperwork, particularly in an emergency, does he know what he's signing? And if he doesn't sign it, can the hospital refuse treatment? Does he also sign some kind of blanket form that says something like "I authorize such care and treatment as the hospital deems necessary?" It sounds like there's plenty of room for some shady business.
 
When a hospital patient is handed that form with other paperwork, particularly in an emergency, does he know what he's signing? And if he doesn't sign it, can the hospital refuse treatment? Does he also sign some kind of blanket form that says something like "I authorize such care and treatment as the hospital deems necessary?" It sounds like there's plenty of room for some shady business.

When my cat needed emergency care I signed anything they put in front of me without reading it all carefully and getting on the phone to my solicitor to get her to check it over! If it was me or a relative or friend I'd sign anything to get the treatment needed, and worry about the bills afterwards - which seems to be what actually happens in the USA as well.
 
It's actually pretty simple: make it illegal to add on extra services insurance doesn't cover without the patient's explicit consent. ...snip...

Your partner is giving birth, the care etc. is part of your insurance package so you are happy with the cost. Sadly during birth there are unforeseen life threatening complication for your partner and baby, are you really going to say that the hospital must immediately provide you with an agreement that covers what they will now do and indicate what won't be paid for your insurers so you can sign it before they try to save the lives of your partner and newborn?
 
There have been a lot of cases lately that center around the anesthesiologist for surgeries. I believe there've even been some discussions of legislation on it.

Here's the basic situation: A policyholder schedules a surgery. They receive prior approval for the surgery, at a contracted hospital facility, with a contracted in-network surgeon. From the perspective of the policyholder, they've done all the right things and been as responsible as they should be expected to be. Post surgery, they find out that the anesthesiologist (who they did not choose and had no interaction with prior to the day of the surgery) was not contracted, and gets billed as out of network. Surprise!

It is my opinion that all ancillary practitioners involved in the service are the responsibility of the facility. If the patient does their part by making sure that both the surgeon and the facility are in-network, then the patient shouldn't be held responsible for the supporting practitioners that they had no say about, and in many cases no prior knowledge of. If the facility provides an out of network anesthesiologist or assistant surgeon, the financial impact of that should be on the facility.

To defend anaesthetists as they are called in the UK it is worth remembering it is they that make the surgery possible, they keep you alive whilst the surgeon is poking around (pretty literally in the case of neuro-surgery - not one of the most delicate specialities). You probably want to pay your anaesthetist pretty much what you pay your surgeon. i grant there are easy anaesthetics for easy ops in well people, but the you should not be paying a surgeon much either.
 
Well, a lot of providers take Medicare, which generally means accepting Medicare rates. Insurance companies could say they will only include in their networks the providers that will accept the established rates, which is basically what they do now, except the insurer sets the rates, not a government agency.

And I understand the concept of reinsurance: Companies share the risks among themselves. But the costs are ultimately paid by the insurance companies. I'm talking about a system where the government would tell insurers "No patient will ever cost you more than X as long as you don't pay providers more than Y."

This is even an issue in the NHS. The NHS has local health providers, in a small population e.g. an island or rural area, a single expensive patient can bankrupt the provider, so they have to go to central government / national NHS to get special funds - a form of re-insurance.
 
Lifetime limits are more important for smaller insurance companies than for larger ones. The incidence rates are low, but if you don't have a large enough underlying pool of covered lives, they're potentially disastrous to the company. I know there's a tendency to cast insurance companies as evil money-grubbers, but at the end of the day if a small number of extremely large claims forces a company into insolvency, all of their policyholders are at risk of not being covered.


Given that it is entirely unacceptable for there to be any such thing as a 'lifetime limit', I interpret the above as meaning that some insurance companies just can't afford to be in the healthcare business.
 
To defend anaesthetists as they are called in the UK it is worth remembering it is they that make the surgery possible, they keep you alive whilst the surgeon is poking around (pretty literally in the case of neuro-surgery - not one of the most delicate specialities). You probably want to pay your anaesthetist pretty much what you pay your surgeon. i grant there are easy anaesthetics for easy ops in well people, but the you should not be paying a surgeon much either.

The issue isn't the cost of the anesthesiologist, but who pays for it.

Here in the US we have private insurance, and most insurance companies have a "network". The network consists of people contracted by the insurance companies who agree to charge a certain amount to any patient using the insurance. When you submit a claim to the insurance companies, they will provide full reimbursement if you used an "in network" provider, the insurance company pays. If you use an "out of network" provider, you pay. (And like everything else in American health care, details vary widely. The point is that if you go out of network, you owe a lot more money out of pocket.)

So, a common problem is that you go to your doctor, who is in network, and get a test done. You pee in a cup, but the doctor doesn't do the test himself. He sends it to a lab. Well, the lab is out of network, and you pay the full bill for the lab work. You didn't choose the lab. You didn't know what lab was being used. No one asked you anything about labs. But you get a $400 bill in the mail, and you have to pay it out of pocket for something you thought was covered by insurance. If the doctor had chosen a different lab, it would have been.

The same thing can happen with the anesthesiologist. You go to an in network hospital using an in network surgeon. You're covered. Except that they use an out of network anesthesiologist, and those guys aren't cheap.
 
Well, a lot of providers take Medicare, which generally means accepting Medicare rates. Insurance companies could say they will only include in their networks the providers that will accept the established rates, which is basically what they do now, except the insurer sets the rates, not a government agency.

Well, yes and no. Many providers take Medicare, but many don't. And of those that do take Medicare, most of them will only take a certain volume of patients at Medicare rates - they expect significantly higher rates for their commercial aged patients. There's a degree of cost-shifting that occurs in the US with respect to Medicare and Medicaid pricing.

Currently, the insurer's don't "set" the rates (if we did, they'd be a LOT lower than they are ;)). It's a negotiation. The providers, especially hospital-based groups, have a lot more negotiating power than you might realize. There are many regions where there is only one hospital in a given area. To be an insurer, you have to be able to prove geographically appropriate access to care... so there's not really a choice. If the insurer wants to be licensed to sell coverage in that area, they *must* have that hospital in their network. Then you get the really large provider organizations where hospitals and physicians have banded together under one umbrella - there are many cases where those provider organizations have near-monopoly power over the marketplace.
 
To defend anaesthetists as they are called in the UK it is worth remembering it is they that make the surgery possible, they keep you alive whilst the surgeon is poking around (pretty literally in the case of neuro-surgery - not one of the most delicate specialities). You probably want to pay your anaesthetist pretty much what you pay your surgeon. i grant there are easy anaesthetics for easy ops in well people, but the you should not be paying a surgeon much either.

I don't disagree with the importance of the anesthesiologist, not at all. It's the impact to the customer when the anesthesiologist is out of network (so the patient is responsible for virtually the entire billed cost) but the facility and the surgeon are in network (so the patient pays only a portion of the discounted cost). Especially since in many cases, the patient isn't able to select their anesthesiologist, and has no reasonable way to verify that they are in network.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom