No need to get so detailed. Obese smokers who abuse drugs and/or alcohol should just pay more for their healthcare/insurance than people who are fit, active, don't smoke and don't abuse alcohol and drugs. Simple.
It's not simple by any stretch of the imagination. If you can get people to change habits by threatening to punish them, I don't really know. They are
already being punished to some extent by poor decisions/poor genetics. Does society have to add to that? Do we need insurance companies to appoint lifestyle police when as a matter of public policy, single-payer UHC is cheaper in both prevention and cure? In the aggregate.
Thus, those that lead risky lifestyles should pay more for their risks. It works in every other facet of the insurance industry, why not health insurance?
Because the potential bill for health care is orders of magnitude greater than the maximum liability in other situations.
I knew a family with a $3 million health-care bill for a son who later died very young of a freak accident. Their assets have been permanently attached, and they are OK with this. They are both retired USAF veterans. Many Americans don''t have that kind of coverage.
This kid, Chris, ended up getting cared for as an indigent part of the time, because the care made him indigent PDQ. (This was before he could have been insured under his parents' plans.) Lots of effort to save his leg after he was smacked, flipped and dragged 250 yards by a drunk driver while he was crossing the street - on foot and buzzed. He tried to stand up with bones sticking out of his legs, but he was entangled somewhat with the car whose driver hadn't noticed hitting him.
Maybe too much effort was expended on saving his leg which ultimately was amputated due to hospital-acquired MRSA. His mom ended up stressed to the max trying to cope and her Type 2 diabetes got out of control and she became both insulin dependent and obese. Then Chris died anyway in a different freak accident.
And during this whole time she was a foster mom who adopted 2 young boys, a social good, probably, but still, is her insulin dependence her own fault? Yes according to you.
I asked for numbers regarding nature vs. nurture in maintaining health. If I find you have posted them, I will take a look.