Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's not free. You pay for it in taxes and in cuts to other areas where the government might spend money: infrastructure, defense, etc. Let's not pretend that other developed nations are utopias. They have problems in other areas than health care and even health care isn't the perfect model. I believe we can do better.

Not in terms of healthcare, the same percentage of GDP goes to cover the entire population as we cover with only medicare and medicaid. So hitting those levels of efficiency in the system as a whole would not require cuts in other areas.
 
Roads: You benefit from roads even if you don't personally drive. Without them, you couldn't get supplies to your home. Roads are essential for modern life and, as part of infrastructure is one of the primary roles of the government.

Schools: I'm with you on that. I think education should be privatized. Eliminate the property tax levies for school and let people spend that money for their own kid's education as they see fit. Government should have as little to do with education as possible because they aren't particularly good at it.

But we need to do something to disenfranchise the uneducated serfdom classes that such systems create.
 
Yep the ideal customer is healthy until they suddenly drop dead. Like how smoking lowers health care costs and so really insurance companies should be encouraging their customers to smoke.

In a way that's the ideal life. Though a brief illness is sometimes desirable.

Yes indeed, that would be a life well lived. Imagine if you lived a long healthy life, needed very little medical care and then just one day died in your sleep of old age. I hope that's the way I go. If we all could live like that, we would spend so much less on health care. Isn't that the goal? Health care should be something you don't need to use very often. But that's not the way it works. We continue to live unhealthy lives and develop debilitating chronic diseases that require wheelchairs, multiple medications, pacemakers, amputations, oxygen tanks, etc. That leads to much lower quality of life and a long, slow, painful, expensive death.

So, while I realize that ponderingturtle was trying to be ironic, he/she's actually right on the nose.
 
This link provides the relevant data. It's got nothing to do with whether prevention is cheaper than a cure. Other developed countries have universal health care, spend far less on health care and have better outcomes. It's flat-out cheaper to just take care of everybody. The data is with me.
That article doesn't really cover what you are discussing. It isn't about whether or not universal treatment is cheaper than universal prevention; it's about the plain fact that other countries spend much less than the US for healthcare than we do. The million dollar question is: Why? The article attempts to explain:

A 2013 report from the Institute of Medicine reviewed the literature about the health disadvantages of Americans relative to residents of other high-income countries. It found the U.S. performed poorly on several important determinants of health.14 More than a third of adults in the U.S. were obese in 2012, a rate that was about 15 percent higher than the next-highest country, New Zealand. The U.S. had one of the lowest smoking rates in 2013, but one of the highest rates of tobacco consumption in the 1960s and 1970s. This earlier period of heavy tobacco use may still be contributing to relatively worse health outcomes among older U.S. adults.15 Other potential contributors to the United States’ health disadvantage include the large number of uninsured, as well as differences in lifestyle, environment, and rates of accidents and violence.

The article also lists a table showing that 68% of Americans have 2 or more chronic diseases and 35.3% are obese, which are both higher than any other compared country by a significant margin. Obesity and Chronic disease are both primarily caused by lifestyle factors. The article also points out that the US has more adverse effects from diabetes, which is directly driven by patient non-compliance to medical treatment; we see it every day in our clinic -patients who have Medicare, are prescribed insulin and other meds but don't change their lifestyle. The disease just keeps killing them despite the efforts of our doctors to get them to adhere to the treatment protocol. I think the data is clearly with me: The US's problem with lifestyle related disease is the big driver of the US's healthcare spending.



How 'bout one from Column A, two from Column B?

Are they, though? Can you provide data? Also, what about my questions re: genetics? Why is it OK to ignore genetic components in obesity, alcoholism, cancer and heart disease?
I'm not saying to ignore genetic components. I'll let this article (relating to obesity but mirrors other research for other diseases) from Harvard School of Public Health sum up for me:

What’s increasingly clear from these early findings is that genetic factors identified so far make only a small contribution to obesity risk-and that our genes are not our destiny: Many people who carry these so-called “obesity genes” do not become overweight, and healthy lifestyles can counteract these genetic effects.

And so how much of a person's cancer treatment should be covered if they have also abused alcohol? Does that apply to all cancers, or just certain ones? Do they get a credit if they got sober before they got cancer? Etc.
No need to get so detailed. Obese smokers who abuse drugs and/or alcohol should just pay more for their healthcare/insurance than people who are fit, active, don't smoke and don't abuse alcohol and drugs. Simple.

Look: "Nothing we can do" is pretty cheap. Lung cancer used to be pretty cheap! And, blaming people for pigging out, it's just not that simple. People seek solace where they can find it, and in the U.S. that often means grease, sugar, salt and starch. Most of us get sick and all of us die. I don't see the utility of blaming the patients.
The utility is in the simple fact that the lifestyle choices made by the patient directly affect their health outcomes. Thus, those that lead risky lifestyles should pay more for their risks. It works in every other facet of the insurance industry, why not health insurance?
 
So I've been sitting here at my desk for most of the day listening to my co-worker try and figure out the awesomeness that is the US healthcare system. I've been getting a play by play as well as hearing her side of the conversation.

She has insurance from our company which is a PPO and it's decent insurance. She was referred by her primary care doctor for an ultrasound.

- Doctor suggested going to spot X, but wait... we're not sure if that's in network... I mean it should be, but it's not showing up in our system. *waits a while* Nope, can't get it to show up, but it SHOULD be in network. Call your insurance company to be sure.
- Calls insurance company. Ok, it is in network. And she's responsible for an $850 deductible? huh? How much could this ultrasound cost? Shouldn't that be covered? How do I find out how much this will cost?
- Calls doctor back. Insurance says it's in network, how much will this cost? Insurance will cover it? That didn't sound like what they said.
- Calls ultrasound office. Verify it is in network. Asks for cost. No I am not going to have the procedure then wait for a bill. I don't want a surprise $800 bill from you. Someone has to be able to tell me how much this is going to cost. *waits for call back*
- Call back comes $235 out of pocket. Other coworkers with same plan say that can't be right - they've never been charged for an ultrasound outside of a small copay.

It's not like she wasn't asking the right questions. It's been 3+ hours and she still isn't sure if this is going to cost her $200+ (which is a LOT for her) or next to nothing.
 
......
It's not like she wasn't asking the right questions. It's been 3+ hours and she still isn't sure if this is going to cost her $200+ (which is a LOT for her) or next to nothing.

I have no idea how much her ultrasound should cost. But I note that this kind of confusion and conflict and multi-level negotiation is a big part of why 25% of total U.S. health care expenditures go to administration. In universal health care systems, that number is as low as 10%.
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/artic...alth-care-is-so-expensive-insurance-companies
 
yep. My other coworker, who is originally from Canada, was just laughing.

When I was still living in Canada, I had my now wife visit me. We were planning a nice vacation. She spent a week with me, we were going to spend a week driving across the country, and then I would spend a week out with her in Seattle.

Well, when we were packing up the car, I slipped, and ended up breaking my foot. We did a trip to the ER. 3 hours later, Xrays, a cast, and I was handed crutches to be sent on my wife. My (now) wife, being an American, asked where we went to pay. I looked at her like she had grown a second head, and said 'Pay? You don't pay for health care...'
 
No need to get so detailed. Obese smokers who abuse drugs and/or alcohol should just pay more for their healthcare/insurance than people who are fit, active, don't smoke and don't abuse alcohol and drugs. Simple.
It's not simple by any stretch of the imagination. If you can get people to change habits by threatening to punish them, I don't really know. They are already being punished to some extent by poor decisions/poor genetics. Does society have to add to that? Do we need insurance companies to appoint lifestyle police when as a matter of public policy, single-payer UHC is cheaper in both prevention and cure? In the aggregate.

Thus, those that lead risky lifestyles should pay more for their risks. It works in every other facet of the insurance industry, why not health insurance?
Because the potential bill for health care is orders of magnitude greater than the maximum liability in other situations.

I knew a family with a $3 million health-care bill for a son who later died very young of a freak accident. Their assets have been permanently attached, and they are OK with this. They are both retired USAF veterans. Many Americans don''t have that kind of coverage.

This kid, Chris, ended up getting cared for as an indigent part of the time, because the care made him indigent PDQ. (This was before he could have been insured under his parents' plans.) Lots of effort to save his leg after he was smacked, flipped and dragged 250 yards by a drunk driver while he was crossing the street - on foot and buzzed. He tried to stand up with bones sticking out of his legs, but he was entangled somewhat with the car whose driver hadn't noticed hitting him.

Maybe too much effort was expended on saving his leg which ultimately was amputated due to hospital-acquired MRSA. His mom ended up stressed to the max trying to cope and her Type 2 diabetes got out of control and she became both insulin dependent and obese. Then Chris died anyway in a different freak accident.

And during this whole time she was a foster mom who adopted 2 young boys, a social good, probably, but still, is her insulin dependence her own fault? Yes according to you.

I asked for numbers regarding nature vs. nurture in maintaining health. If I find you have posted them, I will take a look.
 
Last edited:
When I was still living in Canada, I had my now wife visit me. We were planning a nice vacation. She spent a week with me, we were going to spend a week driving across the country, and then I would spend a week out with her in Seattle.

Well, when we were packing up the car, I slipped, and ended up breaking my foot. We did a trip to the ER. 3 hours later, Xrays, a cast, and I was handed crutches to be sent on my wife. My (now) wife, being an American, asked where we went to pay. I looked at her like she had grown a second head, and said 'Pay? You don't pay for health care...'
Man, you should have been more careful. It's your own damn fault you slipped and it's a pity that taxpayers had to fork up dough for your own carelessness.

At least that's one argument here ...

I am assuming you were sent on your way and not on your wife ...
 
Man, you should have been more careful. It's your own damn fault you slipped and it's a pity that taxpayers had to fork up dough for your own carelessness.

At least that's one argument here ...

I am assuming you were sent on your way and not on your wife ...

.. Damnit. Yes. Ahh well.
 
Yes indeed, that would be a life well lived. Imagine if you lived a long healthy life, needed very little medical care and then just one day died in your sleep of old age. I hope that's the way I go. If we all could live like that, we would spend so much less on health care. Isn't that the goal? Health care should be something you don't need to use very often. But that's not the way it works. We continue to live unhealthy lives and develop debilitating chronic diseases that require wheelchairs, multiple medications, pacemakers, amputations, oxygen tanks, etc. That leads to much lower quality of life and a long, slow, painful, expensive death.

So, while I realize that ponderingturtle was trying to be ironic, he/she's actually right on the nose.

*grumble* Or one develops life-threatening fibroids that hemorrhage and land one in the ER with blood transfusions, 4 months of incredibly expensive specialty drugs to keep one from dying, and a very expensive surgery so one can keep on living. Or maybe one goes on to develop frequent migraines that interfere with quality of life overall. Or maybe ends up with a diagnosis of epilepsy later in life that has massive impacts to how one goes about everything in one's life.

Or, hey novel idea, maybe one is unlucky enough to end up with all three of those happening. That would be me.

I suppose I'm just not taking good enough care of myself. Maybe it's righteous and appropriate that I either die from lack of care or face bankruptcy to cover the bills. That seems perfectly reasonable and compassionate. :rolleyes:


******

Look, I get your point, and there is some validity to it. But I also feel that you're glossing over a significant amount of things that are completely outside of the control of the individual. You seem to approach it as if the huge majority of medical costs are from easily avoided chronic conditions... and that's not really true. I've said it before, and I'll say it again. Over half of the cost of care in the US is from non-chronic acute conditions, congenital illnesses (some of which are extremely costly like hemophilia), neonatal complications, and cancers. If you add in trauma events, and the repertoire of injuries and contagion, you end up with around 65% to 70% of the costs being non-avoidable, non-chronic instances.

So you've got 30% to 35% of the costs that are from *both* lifestyle-related chronic conditions, mental health conditions, *and* preventive & routine care. And of those chronic conditions, not all of them are perfectly avoidable. Just eating well and exercising won't prevent someone with a genetic predisposition from developing diabetes. Just exercising and avoid smoke won't perfectly prevent COPD.

Short story: please stop over-simplifying this quite so much ;)
 
Last edited:
Man, you should have been more careful. It's your own damn fault you slipped and it's a pity that taxpayers had to fork up dough for your own carelessness.

At least that's one argument here ...

I am assuming you were sent on your way and not on your wife ...

.. Damnit. Yes. Ahh well.

I just assumed he needed "comforting" ;)
 
Not my business, and feel free to tell me so... what happened over the weekend that leads you to believe that throwing the baby out with the bathwater is a more palatable approach?

Trump's Muslim ban has me questioning whether "we're compassionate humans whose empathy emerged at the proper stage of cognitive development".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom