Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
That article doesn't really cover what you are discussing. It isn't about whether or not universal treatment is cheaper than universal prevention;
Which wasn't my point. Both prevention and care are covered. I am not comparing "universal prevention to universal treatment." It's cheaper to do it all for everybody. The whole thing. Less money, better outcomes. There are fat Canadians, I'm sure, but they spend less to get better outcomes.

It's about the plain fact that other countries spend much less than the US for healthcare than we do. The million dollar question is: Why?
Possibly because we don't have single-payer UHC. The patient would be seen, maybe required to attend four classes about diabetes, or sign up for smoking cessation, or offered alternative ways of nicotine delivery.

Instead you very arbitrarily IMO say "it was your own damn fault, pay for it yourself." Why is stigmatizing people a higher priority in your view than UHC, which is cheaper and has better outcomes?

The article also lists a table showing that 68% of Americans have 2 or more chronic diseases and 35.3% are obese, which are both higher than any other compared country by a significant margin. Obesity and Chronic disease are both primarily caused by lifestyle factors.
Seriously? There are tons of chronic diseases not caused by lifestyle factors. Type 1 diabetes isn't, rheumatoid arthritis isn't, lupus isn't, ALS isn't; polycystic kidney disease isn't, high blood pressure isn't, totally. Wider use of bariatric surgery could help the obese. Do you think these people LIKE being sick? Maybe we have more chronic disease because the system sucks? Pause to consider the variables.

My mom has dementia and peripheral vascular disease. She's 92. Her fault? She was a smoker for about 20 years early in life - before people knew it was bad for you. I suspect she drank a bit after losing my father - is that why she has no short-term memory?

My father and his 2 brothers died of prostate cancer. He also developed Type 2 diabetes, then rapidly became insulin-independent as a result of a course of prednisone having to do with the cancer. So we've got at least 2 chronic diseases, prostate cancer and insulin dependence. This is a man who got his testicles removed to slow down prostate cancer. By all means, let's punish my parents. Even though all 3 sons in the family died of prostate cancer.

The article also points out that the US has more adverse effects from diabetes, which is directly driven by patient non-compliance to medical treatment; we see it every day in our clinic -patients who have Medicare, are prescribed insulin and other meds but don't change their lifestyle.
They are people. They are imperfect. Go figure. Read "The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down." Seriously.

No need to get so detailed. Obese smokers who abuse drugs and/or alcohol should just pay more for their healthcare/insurance than people who are fit, active, don't smoke and don't abuse alcohol and drugs. Simple.
Or we could make it simpler still: have UHC do all it can to prevent and treat diseases that have a behavioral component. No need to have second-class citizens, which you assume to insist on because - reasons? Don't know. My dad should have picked different parents, perhaps. You talk as if there would be no judgment calls; no shades of gray. You ignore who would make those decisions. We'd have to have some rationing system, which maybe could double as a death panel. I'm not totally against that concept.

That article doesn't really cover what you are discussing. It isn't about whether or not universal treatment is cheaper than universal prevention; it's about the plain fact that other countries spend much less than the US for healthcare than we do. The million dollar question is: Why? The article attempts to explain:
You are missing the main point: I am not comparing the cost of universal prevention and universal treatment. They're both health care. Other countries do more with less treatment which is that we could offer health care for all for less money with better outcomes. The patient would be seen, educated and maybe some of it would stick. Getting checkups would be a patriotic duty. Instead you very arbitrarily IMO say "it was your own damn fault, pay for it yourself." Why is stigmatizing people a higher priority in your view than UHC, which is cheaper and has better outcomes.?

The article also lists a table showing that 68% of Americans have 2 or more chronic diseases and 35.3% are obese, which are both higher than any other compared country by a significant margin. Obesity and Chronic disease are both primarily caused by lifestyle factors.
Wider use of bariatric surgery could help the obese. My mom has dementia and peripheral vascular disease. Her fault? She was a smoker about 40 years ago. I suspect she drank a bit after losing my father - is that why she has no short-term memory? Well, she is 92. My father and his 2 brothers died of prostate cancer. He also developed Type 2 diabetes, then rapidly became insulin-independent as a result of a course of prednisone having to do with the cancer. So we've got at least 2 chronic diseases, prostate cancer and insulin-dependent diabetes. This is a man who got his testicles removed to slow down the cancer.

By all means, let's punish both my parents. Even though all 3 sons in the family died of prostate cancer.

The article also points out that the US has more adverse effects from diabetes, which is directly driven by patient non-compliance to medical treatment; we see it every day in our clinic -patients who have Medicare, are prescribed insulin and other meds but don't change their lifestyle. The disease just keeps killing them despite the efforts of our doctors to get them to adhere to the treatment protocol. I think the data is clearly with me: The US's problem with lifestyle related disease is the big driver of the US's healthcare spending.

No. See highlighted. I refuse to let you get by with "I think the data is clearly with me." This took 2 minutes:

Forbes said:
The first area is technology. There is consensus among experts that technology is the most important driver of healthcare spending increases over time. Installing and implementing electronic health records is costly – often as much as $25,000 per doctor for a system and a monthly subscription fee on top of that – and requires significant resources.

then:
No need to get so detailed. Obese smokers who abuse drugs and/or alcohol should just pay more for their healthcare/insurance than people who are fit, active, don't smoke and don't abuse alcohol and drugs. Simple.
Or we could make it simpler still: have UHC do all it can to prevent and treat diseases that have a behavioral component. No need to have second-class citizens, which you assume to insist on because - reasons? Don't know. My dad should have picked different parents, perhaps. You talk as if there would be no judgment calls; no shades of gray. You ignore who would make those decisions. We'd have to have some system; maybe it can double as a death panel. End-of-life care often costs a ton.

The utility is in the simple fact that the lifestyle choices made by the patient directly affect their health outcomes.
So, even if we can offer prevention and treatment to all for less money, we should have what, lifestyle police to spy on people or force them away from fast-food windows? That's your "simple" solution? BTW we would STILL be overspending and STILL having worse outcomes.

It works in every other facet of the insurance industry, why not health insurance?
Please give some examples/citations of how it works in other facets of the insurance industry. I want to see how analogous these comparisons really are.

IMO, a lot of health care expense can be saved if the patient has a support system. Rides to PT if they don't drive. Getting Mom to walk more. Helping figure out if she needs to go to the ER (almost took her today then didn't). My mom's has more support than many people. She pays a higher Medicare premium based on means. But not based on smoking from age 25-40 and having a couple of drinks at night. How the hell would you draw the line?
 
Last edited:
Trump's Muslim ban has me questioning whether "we're compassionate humans whose empathy emerged at the proper stage of cognitive development".

Trump <> We

If Trump = We, then none of us would be objecting to the evisceration of ACA without a replacement. "We" oppose that evisceration because "we" developed empathy and compassion. I'm not including Trump in that "we".
 
When you make a stupid promise because it makes a great campaign slogan, no worries, you can just change the slogan when your bluff is called and pretend that's what you said all along. In a week, no one will notice.

"Repeal and replace" Obamacare has now become "repair" Obamacare. And, Paul Ryan is claiming, "you have to repeal and replace it in order to repair it."

No Senator Ryan, we're not that stupid, though maybe your base doesn't care that you've been lying to them for 6 years.
 
Last edited:
Trump <> We

If Trump = We, then none of us would be objecting to the evisceration of ACA without a replacement. "We" oppose that evisceration because "we" developed empathy and compassion. I'm not including Trump in that "we".
Some GOP congress members are using the word "repair."

There should be a broader choice of coverage IMO. There's no "shopping around" in my state and my BlueCross BlueShield coverage was dropped for something called Ambetter, which has 2 plans this year in my state, but no choice to pick a different company. This one has something to do with Health Net. I'm not sure the insurance-across-state-lines is a good idea.

I can afford a pretty high deductible, but my actual income is paltry. The 2 choices were essentially $600 or $700. I will probably get some money back because my income is so low. I don't want to go without insurance. In my state there are just 2 choices - both from the same company.

Ambetter has a monopoly and is subsidized by the government - I would like to see more transparency at least. At least my benefits are portable. I hope they're not crappy! I'm kind of afraid to look.
 
Last edited:
I had to get turned down for health insurance, than stay uninsured for 6 months, after which I was very simply covered by transitional Obama care. My state did not have a high-risk pool so I was directly insured by the federal government. And they wanted to keep me insured.

I would have even waived coverage for my biggest pre-existing condition, since treatment is not terribly effective. Just to get insured.

So now the premiums are much higher, but the Obamacare one was cheaper at $271 or something.

The stupid thing is I have put off the full physical I should be getting. Some bloodwork a couple of years ago was normal. So I'm part of the behavioral problem too. Not using the doc for too much, but for too little.
 
Which wasn't my point. Both prevention and care are covered. I am not comparing "universal prevention to universal treatment." It's cheaper to do it all for everybody. The whole thing. Less money, better outcomes. There are fat Canadians, I'm sure, but they spend less to get better outcomes.
. You seem to be brushing aside the idea that the USA is a different country with a different population makeup. There is no guarantee that in the US, prevention+treatment for all = less money with better outcomes. And better outcomes is debateable. What criteria? This has been argued about in the literature for awhile now.

Possibly because we don't have single-payer UHC. The patient would be seen, maybe required to attend four classes about diabetes, or sign up for smoking cessation, or offered alternative ways of nicotine delivery.
How do you require people to attend these things? You can't find them or jail them obviously. So what if they don't go and don't listen? You still have to treat. In our clinic anyway, we "require" our patients to attend free diabetes education. We offer smoking cessation classes through the hospital. The resources are there right now in the US for free or very low cost. People don't go.

Instead you very arbitrarily IMO say "it was your own damn fault, pay for it yourself." Why is stigmatizing people a higher priority in your view than UHC, which is cheaper and has better outcomes?
I don't see it as me stigmatizing anyone. Let's take smoking for example. It's a completely voluntary activity that everyone knows is very bad for your health. If there's a stigma, it's one voluntarily taken on by the person. All a medical system can do is say, "don't do that, you are killing yourself." The sad fact is that any ill effects are indeed "your own damn fault." Same goes for the diets some people eat and other lifestyle choices that are bad for your health.

Seriously? There are tons of chronic diseases not caused by lifestyle factors. Type 1 diabetes isn't, rheumatoid arthritis isn't, lupus isn't, ALS isn't; polycystic kidney disease isn't, high blood pressure isn't, totally. Wider use of bariatric surgery could help the obese. Do you think these people LIKE being sick? Maybe we have more chronic disease because the system sucks? Pause to consider the variables.
Reduce the number of chronic illnesses caused by lifestyle and we have more resources to spend on treating the ones that aren't.

My mom has dementia and peripheral vascular disease. She's 92. Her fault? She was a smoker for about 20 years early in life - before people knew it was bad for you. I suspect she drank a bit after losing my father - is that why she has no short-term memory?
Reduce lifestyle disease; have more resources to treat other disease.

My father and his 2 brothers died of prostate cancer. He also developed Type 2 diabetes, then rapidly became insulin-independent as a result of a course of prednisone having to do with the cancer. So we've got at least 2 chronic diseases, prostate cancer and insulin dependence. This is a man who got his testicles removed to slow down prostate cancer. By all means, let's punish my parents. Even though all 3 sons in the family died of prostate cancer.
I won't repeat myself.

They are people. They are imperfect. Go figure. Read "The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down." Seriously.
I don't find the "people are fallible" argument very convincing. How far should we take this argument?

Or we could make it simpler still: have UHC do all it can to prevent and treat diseases that have a behavioral component. No need to have second-class citizens, which you assume to insist on because - reasons? Don't know. My dad should have picked different parents, perhaps. You talk as if there would be no judgment calls; no shades of gray. You ignore who would make those decisions. We'd have to have some rationing system, which maybe could double as a death panel. I'm not totally against that concept.
We don't have to make those decisions; nature does a good job already.

<snip repetition >
So, even if we can offer prevention and treatment to all for less money, we should have what, lifestyle police to spy on people or force them away from fast-food windows?
No need for lifestyle police. Answer a few questions, take some lab tests, get a physical. You'll still get insurance but you'll pay for your risks. Incentivize healthy lifestyles. If economics has taught us anything it's that incentives work.
That's your "simple" solution?
In a nutshell.
BTW we would STILL be overspending and STILL having worse outcomes.
If people live healthier lives, we will have better outcomes and spend less than we do now.

Please give some examples/citations of how it works in other facets of the insurance industry. I want to see how analogous these comparisons really are.
If you have more auto accidents or traffic tickets or if you drive certain types of risky car or if you are young, you pay more for auto insurance. If you smoke or don't pass a physical/lab tests you pay more for life insurance. If you make claims on your homeowners policy you pay more. You pay for your risk profile in the insurance industry.

IMO, a lot of health care expense can be saved if the patient has a support system. Rides to PT if they don't drive. Getting Mom to walk more. Helping figure out if she needs to go to the ER (almost took her today then didn't). My mom's has more support than many people. She pays a higher Medicare premium based on means. But not based on smoking from age 25-40 and having a couple of drinks at night. How the hell would you draw the line?
Keep it simple. Risk.
 
When the tobacco industry, or the asbestos industry, or the mining industry (etc.) find themselves in court their primary tool for absolving themselves of responsibility is to argue that it couldn't be proven their product was responsible for any particular individual case of illness. That it could have come from other sources.

Why should it be different when contemplating responsibility for getting the illness? The same logic applies.

So. No need to look for blame when considering the cost of treatment. Just take care of them.
 
. You seem to be brushing aside the idea that the USA is a different country with a different population makeup. There is no guarantee that in the US, prevention+treatment for all = less money with better outcomes. And better outcomes is debateable. What criteria? This has been argued about in the literature for awhile now.

How do you require people to attend these things? You can't find them or jail them obviously. So what if they don't go and don't listen? You still have to treat. In our clinic anyway, we "require" our patients to attend free diabetes education. We offer smoking cessation classes through the hospital. The resources are there right now in the US for free or very low cost. People don't go.

I don't see it as me stigmatizing anyone. Let's take smoking for example. It's a completely voluntary activity that everyone knows is very bad for your health. If there's a stigma, it's one voluntarily taken on by the person. All a medical system can do is say, "don't do that, you are killing yourself." The sad fact is that any ill effects are indeed "your own damn fault." Same goes for the diets some people eat and other lifestyle choices that are bad for your health.

Reduce the number of chronic illnesses caused by lifestyle and we have more resources to spend on treating the ones that aren't.

Reduce lifestyle disease; have more resources to treat other disease.

I won't repeat myself.

I don't find the "people are fallible" argument very convincing. How far should we take this argument?

We don't have to make those decisions; nature does a good job already.

No need for lifestyle police. Answer a few questions, take some lab tests, get a physical. You'll still get insurance but you'll pay for your risks. Incentivize healthy lifestyles. If economics has taught us anything it's that incentives work. In a nutshell. If people live healthier lives, we will have better outcomes and spend less than we do now.

If you have more auto accidents or traffic tickets or if you drive certain types of risky car or if you are young, you pay more for auto insurance. If you smoke or don't pass a physical/lab tests you pay more for life insurance. If you make claims on your homeowners policy you pay more. You pay for your risk profile in the insurance industry.

Keep it simple. Risk.
Would you rather not (as a population) pay less for your healthcare?
 
. You seem to be brushing aside the idea that the USA is a different country with a different population makeup. There is no guarantee that in the US, prevention+treatment for all = less money with better outcomes.

In every other developed nation that has implemented UHC healthcare outcomes are better and healthcare costs are lower. You can't in all good conscience argue that the USA is a special snowflake country with special snowflake citizens. (well you could, but you'd be very wrong)

How do you require people to attend these things? [...] In our clinic anyway, we "require" our patients to attend free diabetes education. We offer smoking cessation classes through the hospital.

Smoking cessation is avoided like the plague because it doesn't work. I am an ex smoker. I know a lot of smokers and a few ex smokers and the general consensus among smokers that I know is that smoking cessation based on NRT is absolutely useless. There are studies that back that up as well.

“This study shows that using NRT is no more effective in helping people stop smoking cigarettes in the long-term than trying to quit on one’s own,” Alpert said. He added that even though clinical trials (studies) have found NRT to be effective, the new findings demonstrate the importance of empirical studies regarding effectiveness when used in the general population.
[...]
Smoking cessation medications have been available over the counter since 1996, yet U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention statistics show that the previous adult smoking rate decline and quitting rates have stalled in the past five years.
[source]

NRT is based on the premise that it's the mostly nicotine that's addictive. Which is fundamentally flawed Nicotine plays a part, but it's smoking that's addictive, it's a combination of nicotine and ritualistic behaviour and other things too.

Let's take smoking for example. It's a completely voluntary activity that everyone knows is very bad for your health. If there's a stigma, it's one voluntarily taken on by the person. All a medical system can do is say, "don't do that, you are killing yourself." The sad fact is that any ill effects are indeed "your own damn fault." Same goes for the diets some people eat and other lifestyle choices that are bad for your health.

If the primary funder of UHC is the government, then tax the lifestyle choices that lead to worse health outcomes higher to put more money into the pot used to treat patients suffering from the effects of those choices. In the UK smokers pay a hefty amount of tax on tobacco.
 
Looks like there are parts of ObamaCare that they want to keep. ("We like that part of the plan, we can keep it.")

I propose the combination be called either ObumpCare or TraumaCare.
 
Some GOP congress members are using the word "repair."

There should be a broader choice of coverage IMO. There's no "shopping around" in my state and my BlueCross BlueShield coverage was dropped for something called Ambetter, which has 2 plans this year in my state, but no choice to pick a different company. This one has something to do with Health Net. I'm not sure the insurance-across-state-lines is a good idea.

I can afford a pretty high deductible, but my actual income is paltry. The 2 choices were essentially $600 or $700. I will probably get some money back because my income is so low. I don't want to go without insurance. In my state there are just 2 choices - both from the same company.

Ambetter has a monopoly and is subsidized by the government - I would like to see more transparency at least. At least my benefits are portable. I hope they're not crappy! I'm kind of afraid to look.

Free markets do not guarantee that consumers have a lot of choice. In my area we only have two supermarket chains. Most retail segments are dominated by one or two big box stores. If I want cable TV service or high speed Internet the only choice is Comcast. On the other hand the highly regulated Obamacare exchange gives me seven choices for health insurance providers.

Your insurance costs are high because medical costs are high and people in your age group tend to require a lot of medical care. The only way to significantly lower the cost of comprehensive health insurance is to go after medical costs. The cost of prescription medications is clearly a problem. As are the costs of routine MRI scans and other testing. Hospital billing practices in the US are best described as insane. Even the people sending out the bills can't explain what is going on.

BTW: This http://kff.org/interactive/subsidy-calculator/ will give you a quick estimate of insurance costs and subsidies.
 
Your insurance costs are high because medical costs are high and people in your age group tend to require a lot of medical care. The only way to significantly lower the cost of comprehensive health insurance is to go after medical costs.


I recommend having the government pay for a massive number of scholarships for doctors that ensure the doctors can graduate without debt and contain a rider that they must work for a reasonable rate at a government hospital for, say, seven years after completing their residency.



Just, in the parlance of my US friends, spitballing, really.
 
He has no plan.

Too busy pissing off leaders around the world and replacing science with Jesus?
CNN
Fielding questions from Democratic Sen. Sherrod Brown, Price seemed to suggest that he has not been working with the new President on a plan to replace Obamacare.
"President Trump said he's working with you on a replacement plan for the ACA which is nearly finished and will be revealed after your confirmation. Is that true?" Brown asked.
"It's true that he said that, yes," Price said, an awkward response that drew laughter from the hearing room.
"Not that he's every done this before but did the President lie? Did the President lie about this, that he's not working with you?" Brown pressed. "Did he lie to the public about working with you?"
 
I recommend having the government pay for a massive number of scholarships for doctors that ensure the doctors can graduate without debt and contain a rider that they must work for a reasonable rate at a government hospital for, say, seven years after completing their residency.



Just, in the parlance of my US friends, spitballing, really.

Wasn't that the premise of Northern Exposure?
 
I recommend having the government pay for a massive number of scholarships for doctors that ensure the doctors can graduate without debt and contain a rider that they must work for a reasonable rate at a government hospital for, say, seven years after completing their residency.

Just, in the parlance of my US friends, spitballing, really.

Becoming a doctor in the US requires four years of college, three years of medical school and one year as a resident. From what I understand it doesn't take as many years in many other nations including the UK. And I have seen no evidence to suggest that UK doctors are less competent than those trained in the US.
 
Becoming a doctor in the US requires four years of college, three years of medical school and one year as a resident. From what I understand it doesn't take as many years in many other nations including the UK. And I have seen no evidence to suggest that UK doctors are less competent than those trained in the US.

I think your information is awry

In the UK it takes at least 5 years to become a GP after completing your medical degree (four years), and at least 7-9 years to become a hospital consultant.


Where did you get your info from?
 
"President Trump said he's working with you on a replacement plan for the ACA which is nearly finished and will be revealed after your confirmation. Is that true?" Brown asked.
"It's true that he said that, yes," Price said, an awkward response that drew laughter from the hearing room.
"Not that he's every done this before but did the President lie? Did the President lie about this, that he's not working with you?" Brown pressed. "Did he lie to the public about working with you?"

Wow. So did Price actually admit that he has not been working with the President?

Did Brown actually ask the appropriate question, "So have you been working with the President on a replacement plan that is nearly finished and will be revealed after your confirmation?"

I think it's pretty obvious that the answer is no, of course.

Then again, nowadays, the GOP is not talking about repeal, but "repair." And if that is the case, they oughta be slapped. Figuratively, too.

It's been 6 years. If there were a plan to "repair" ObamaCare that actually does fix the supposed problems, why haven't they brought it up? Why have they wasted all their time with meaningless repeal attempts, instead of actually trying to make it work? Because if there were some great way to make it better, and they deliberately did not try to implement it, it clearly demonstrates that they are not there to govern or to serve the people.

"We have a great plan to help the American people. However, we won't let anyone know about it because it would require admitting that the ACA is not completely evil, and it would mean that we were working with Obama. Since we can't have that, we see to America, **** you. Continue to suffer."
 
The latest lie told by some Congressman last night on the news: the increase in numbers of people covered was because of the improved economy and not because of the ACA.

Look for it coming soon to a Trumpette near you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom