Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
Given that it is entirely unacceptable for there to be any such thing as a 'lifetime limit', I interpret the above as meaning that some insurance companies just can't afford to be in the healthcare business.

Is it your opinion that end-of-life care that extends a person's life for two weeks at a cost of $5,000,000 should never be curtailed? Just want to get a handle on why you deem it "entirely unacceptable", and what your view is on the situations in which it might come in to play. Once we've nailed that down, then we can talk about the statistics involved in insurance.
 
I don't disagree with the importance of the anesthesiologist, not at all. It's the impact to the customer when the anesthesiologist is out of network (so the patient is responsible for virtually the entire billed cost) but the facility and the surgeon are in network (so the patient pays only a portion of the discounted cost). Especially since in many cases, the patient isn't able to select their anesthesiologist, and has no reasonable way to verify that they are in network.

This is almost a bait-and-switch[wikipedia.org] tactic. The bait: "Sure the surgeon is in-network." The switch: "We're not going to tell you about the anaesthetist." In Canada and the UK, bait-and-switch is illegal.
 
This is almost a bait-and-switch[wikipedia.org] tactic. The bait: "Sure the surgeon is in-network." The switch: "We're not going to tell you about the anaesthetist." In Canada and the UK, bait-and-switch is illegal.

The underlying problem is that there are so many hands in the till. It should be possible for a patient to be told "Your heart surgery/cancer treatment/whatever will cost $XX,000," and let the providers divvy it up among themselves. But when everybody bills separately for services and for every bandaid and aspirin, it's impossible for patients and even insurers to understand costs, let alone control them.

Journalist Stephen Brill wrote a lengthy, much discussed Time magazine article about hospital prices that he turned into a book. Short summary: Nobody understands them, they make no sense, and everybody's taking as much as they can get.
http://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/11/books/review/americas-bitter-pill-by-steven-brill.html?_r=0
https://www.amazon.com/Americas-Bitter-Pill-Politics-Healthcare-ebook/dp/B00LYXY05S
 
GOP strategy: Trump announces publicly the IRS should not pursue people who refuse to purchase health insurance.

Is it any wonder then that insurers will pull out?

Or that premiums will go through the roof if insurers are covering people with big medial needs?
 
Last edited:
GOP strategy: Trump announces publicly the IRS should not pursue people who refuse to purchase health insurance.

Is it any wonder then that insurers will pull out?
The decisions to pull out of the ACA market would have been made long before Trump's announcement. Rate and contract filings are around April. The business decisions would have been made between Feb and Mar of 2016. Most of those decisions had a lot more to do with some of the complex instabilities in the market dynamic than anything else.

Or that premiums will go through the roof if insurers are covering people with big medial needs?
Well heck, we knew that was going to happen back in 2010. That was a completely expected outcome of ACA. Actually, the increase has generally been viewed as being not as bad as initially expected. Of course, the initial expectation was pretty big, and ACA didn't actually shift Individual enrollment levels all that much... so it still went up a lot - just not by as much as we thought it was going to be!

*** By "we" in this context, I'm speaking generally on behalf of the health actuarial community in the US.
 
The decisions to pull out of the ACA market would have been made long before Trump's announcement. Rate and contract filings are around April. The business decisions would have been made between Feb and Mar of 2016. Most of those decisions had a lot more to do with some of the complex instabilities in the market dynamic than anything else.


Well heck, we knew that was going to happen back in 2010. That was a completely expected outcome of ACA. Actually, the increase has generally been viewed as being not as bad as initially expected. Of course, the initial expectation was pretty big, and ACA didn't actually shift Individual enrollment levels all that much... so it still went up a lot - just not by as much as we thought it was going to be!

*** By "we" in this context, I'm speaking generally on behalf of the health actuarial community in the US.
EC, as an Obamacare user, I'm interested in your opinion as to when exactly I'll lose my health insurance. I'm thinking that 2018 is probably safe, but how about 2019?
 
EC, as an Obamacare user, I'm interested in your opinion as to when exactly I'll lose my health insurance. I'm thinking that 2018 is probably safe, but how about 2019?

I wouldn't make any bets.

My desperate hope is that they back off from this foolhardy path to destruction, and actually put in the thought and planning that is needed.

Even if they don't, if we're realistic... ACA passed in March 2010, but didn't truly go into effect until Jan 2014. And there was a LOT of stuff in ACA that was either purposefully incomplete or poorly thought out. So I'd say that you've probably got 3 years from when they draft and pass a replacement.

But with this leadership... I'm not putting money on any of it. :cool:
 
My desperate hope is that they back off from this foolhardy path to destruction, and actually put in the thought and planning that is needed.


My observations of the leadership team that the president has assembled lead me to believe that there is little desire and little ability to achieve such nuanced thinking.
 
Is it your opinion that end-of-life care that extends a person's life for two weeks at a cost of $5,000,000 should never be curtailed? Just want to get a handle on why you deem it "entirely unacceptable", and what your view is on the situations in which it might come in to play. Once we've nailed that down, then we can talk about the statistics involved in insurance.

This isn't about life time maxiumums. When do you let someone die from a disorder that costs say $10,000 a month to keep them a healthy productive citizen, they are going to hit that lifetime maximum of $5,000,000? That kind of chronic illness was certainly an issue with the kinds of lifetime maximums we had before the ACA, which was a hell of a lot less than 5 million.
 
Is it your opinion that end-of-life care that extends a person's life for two weeks at a cost of $5,000,000 should never be curtailed? Just want to get a handle on why you deem it "entirely unacceptable", and what your view is on the situations in which it might come in to play. Once we've nailed that down, then we can talk about the statistics involved in insurance.


Each case should be examined on its own merits.

I agree that end of life, palliative care can be expensive and, lets face it, not cost effective.

I think lifetime care limits should absolutely not be applied in cases where the patient can continue treatment and achieve a decent standard of living.

End of life decisions are difficult, yes. What I condemn is someone on their third course of Chemo, at the age of 45 being told that the insurance company that took their money isn't going to finance the treatment any more because they've hit the lifetime limit.

I doubt it comes into play particularly often but for those effected it's unacceptable.


ETA: I think, upon reflection that the difference is that in one instance decisions are made on how much the treatment will cost and in the other, part of the equation is considering how much the patient has already cost. The former absolutely must be considered. The latter should be of no note.
 
Last edited:
Each case should be examined on its own merits.

I agree that end of life, palliative care can be expensive and, lets face it, not cost effective.

I think lifetime care limits should absolutely not be applied in cases where the patient can continue treatment and achieve a decent standard of living.

End of life decisions are difficult, yes. What I condemn is someone on their third course of Chemo, at the age of 45 being told that the insurance company that took their money isn't going to finance the treatment any more because they've hit the lifetime limit.

I doubt it comes into play particularly often but for those effected it's unacceptable.


ETA: I think, upon reflection that the difference is that in one instance decisions are made on how much the treatment will cost and in the other, part of the equation is considering how much the patient has already cost. The former absolutely must be considered. The latter should be of no note.

But it has to be of note; "should," is idealism. There are limited resources to spend. The average per capita spend on healthcare in the US is $9403 as of 2014. Now consider that patients pay (through premiums, copays, employer contributions, etc) about $4290/year in healthcare expenditures and it is easy to see that the amount patients pay into the system does not cover the amount each patient consumes, on average. Insurance companies and taxpayers make up the difference.

The solution obviously cannot be to limit premiums but not cap expenditures.
 
Last edited:
But it has to be of note; "should," is idealism. There are limited resources to spend. The average per capita spend on healthcare in the US is $9403 as of 2014. Now consider that patients pay (through premiums, copays, employer contributions, etc) about $4290/year in healthcare expenditures and it is easy to see that the amount patients pay into the system does not cover the amount each patient consumes, on average. Insurance companies and taxpayers make up the difference.

The solution obviously cannot be to limit premiums but not cap expenditures.



I imagine any country with UHC has a system to limit expenditure. It simply has to happen in any reasonable system.

https://www.nice.org.uk/
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom