Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
Or is a comprehensive solution a gordian knot that cannot be solved in American culture and political climate?

The political climate aside, it can be solved in American culture... but just copying what a different country did without consideration for the actual industry and environment isn't the best solution.
 
Color me not surprised. The Republicans admit they have no way to replace the ACA in conversation behind closed doors secretly recorded.

Behind closed doors, Republican lawmakers fret about how to repeal Obamacare
The recording reveals a GOP that appears to be filled with doubts about how to make good on a long-standing promise to get rid of Obamacare without explicit guidance from President Trump or his administration.
I think I posted that somewhere, the fools never had a plan, and now they think Trump has one. :sdl:
Senators and House members expressed a range of concerns about the task ahead: how to prepare a replacement plan that can be ready to launch at the time of repeal; how to avoid deep damage to the health insurance market; how to keep premiums affordable for middle-class families; even how to avoid the political consequences of defunding Planned Parenthood, the women’s health-care organization, as many Republicans hope to do with the repeal of the ACA.
They just lie lie lie, say repeal Obamacare, say defund Planned Parenthood over and over until the masses believe the ACA and PP are evils the US must be rid of.
 
I love how people say Trump can't provide health-care for everyone. These are the same naysayers who said he "couldn't" win. He's going to prove so many of you wrong again and again and again that eventually you're going to get tired of being proven wrong.

I have given up asking you people for proof of your statements. I now ask that you provide proof you are not posting from a mental institution.
 
Yeah, that's the odd thing about it. We understand for car insurance that our goal is to never use it. But when it comes to health insurance, we feel we have to "win" and get more out of it than we put in. We understand other insurance, but don't treat health insurance that way.

I think it's more that some people don't want to see other people 'win' ("I've paid in but never been ill but that person paid the same as me and got $100,000s in cancer treatment! I want my money back.").
 
I've never understood that myself (UK).

A dentist once talked to me about that. Apparently until the '50s or so, most Americans didn't have health insurance, and health care wasn't as complex or expensive as it is today. You paid your doctor or dentist or hospital bill yourself if you could, or depended on charity otherwise. But as insurance became more common, doctors associated themselves with each other and with hospitals as part of one health care system. But dentists had always functioned basically as proprietors of small, independent businesses, and they elected to keep doing so. They didn't want to give up their independence to contract with insurance companies. I'm sure it's more complicated than that, but it sounds like it makes sense.

And in the U.S., unless your employer provides it as a benefit, dental insurance isn't a very good buy. Coverage limits are low, and premiums are usually pretty high for what you get.

Some history here:
http://www.theatlantic.com/health/a...eat-teeth-like-the-rest-of-our-bodies/380703/
 
Last edited:
This article is ancient (2008), which puts it right at the start of the reform that became Obamacare. It's a pretty good explanation, or starting point.

How the American Health Care System Got That Way
In 1942, the US set up a National War Labor Board. It had the power to set a cap on all wage increases. But it let employers circumvent the cap by offering "fringe benefits" - notably, health insurance. The fringe benefits created a huge tax subsidy; they were treated as tax-deductible expenses for corporations, but not as taxable income for workers.
 
How would it be cheaper to just provide the health care?
This link provides the relevant data. It's got nothing to do with whether prevention is cheaper than a cure. Other developed countries have universal health care, spend far less on health care and have better outcomes. It's flat-out cheaper to just take care of everybody. The data is with me.

Do you smoke? Are you obese? Do you use abuse drugs/alcohol?
How 'bout one from Column A, two from Column B?

Those questions are much better predictors of an individual's risk for future health problems than genetics.
Are they, though? Can you provide data? Also, what about my questions re: genetics? Why is it OK to ignore genetic components in obesity, alcoholism, cancer and heart disease?

We know that abuse of alcohol can lead to liver problems, cancer, etc.
And so how much of a person's cancer treatment should be covered if they have also abused alcohol? Does that apply to all cancers, or just certain ones? Do they get a credit if they got sober before they got cancer? Etc.

Look: "Nothing we can do" is pretty cheap. Lung cancer used to be pretty cheap! And, blaming people for pigging out, it's just not that simple. People seek solace where they can find it, and in the U.S. that often means grease, sugar, salt and starch. Most of us get sick and all of us die. I don't see the utility of blaming the patients.
 
Removing the state boundaries and the independent regulations within each state actually would help.

Yep then we can get rid of terrible regulations like no preexisting conditions as no state would be able to implement it after the ACA is pulled. A race to the bottom in terms of what counts and how easy it is to get rid of sick people.
 
[actuarial lecture]

Actually, preventive care is only less expensive when you're looking post-hoc at a person who contracted the condition. That is to say, the cost of a colonoscopy is less than the cost of chemotherapy and surgery for colon cancer. The problem is in the aggregations, and colonoscopies are a really good example.

These are made up numbers - I don't have real numbers easily accessible without having to do a lot of work AND there's a degree of confidentiality involved. The made up numbers are illustrative and directionally appropriate. appropriate.

Let's say that an average colonoscopy costs $250, and is recommended to all men age 50 and older, every 5 years. That equates to about 20% of men in that age range per year. Let's say that works out to 10,000 men in that risk pool. So that's a cost of $2,500,000 per year in colonoscopy costs.

Let's say colon cancer has an incident rate of 1 in 100,000. If colon cancer is identified early, it costs $250,000 to treat. If it is not identified early, it has a cost of $500,000 to treat. For the moment, we're going to ignore the survival rates - they add a high degree of computational complexity that is irrelevant to the pint I'm demonstrating.

The expected cost of early-diagnosis colon cancer treatment in a group that is all receiving preventive care is (incidence rate) * (number of people) * (cost to treat) = (1/100,000) * (10,000) * ($250,000) = $25,000.

The expected cost of late-diagnosis colon cancer treatment us (1/100,000) * (10,000) * ($500,000) = $50,000.

So even though the cost to treat is much higher than the cost to screen for an individual who is identified with colon cancer... the cost to screen everyone is massively higher.

Most preventive care is covered by insurers as goodwill. It's expected, it's the right thing to do, and it makes policyholders feel safer. But it's very rarely financially sound.

Childhood vaccinations, flu shots, and a handful of other immunizations are an exception. These are things that actually *prevent* an illness, and are generally low-cost to administer. Most of the other things that we call "preventive care" don't prevent anything, they're just early detection... and they're often not at all cost-effective.

[/actuarial lecture]

Exactly killing people is far more profitable, but by their good graces they refrain from doing that too much.
 
Thalidomide is a lot more complicated than that. This off topic, I know, but thalidomide's right-handed isomer was tested, was safe, and was very good at controlling morning sickness. At that point in time we didn't even know that chirality *could* be a problem. It wasn't until the left-handed isomers got in the mix that we saw problems.

Yes, 100% testing is important. But you can't test for a thing you don't know is a thing.

So keeping it out of the US really was an abuse of governmental oversight then?
 
Hey! Here's a novel idea! Why don't we take a look at the profit margins being made by those doctors, hospitals, pharmaceutical companies, and device manufacturers? Maybe we take a step back and question whether it's ethical for a medical supply company to make 40% profit year over year on something that can save lives. Maybe instead of just pumping more and more money into the system, maybe we take a look at whether or not the costs are reasonable. I mean, yes, medical school is expensive, but I'm not really convinced that my neurologist needs to me to pay the $800 per hour "protection" money to get her to write the Rx I need so I don't fry my brain in an epileptic seizure. Maybe she could get by with one fewer Mercedes and only a 3600 sf house... Worth a thought maybe?

How dare you question the free market!
 
In my view, the challenge in the US is one of infrastructure. It's that the industry itself has evolved in a for-profit environment, and the insurance mechanism evolved with it. Insurance invariably disrupts the supply-demand curve, because the financial intermediary explicitly protects the consumer of the good from the true cost of the good. The net effect of this is that the presence of a protective financial intermediary invariably increases the cost of the good sold. What we've ended up with is a highly entwined system. The number of people working in the medical industry (not just nurses and doctors, but the encompassing system of devices, orderlies, drug chemists, insurance agents, etc.) is very large, because the cost of the product is high... which is high because the industry exists in the form it does.

If you change that structure too quickly (a sudden shift to single-payer universal health care) without due consideration of the intricacies... you create many other subsidiary problems. How much of a spike in unemployment is acceptable in order to reduce the health care cost burden? If we switch it all to single-payer, how many people will be out of work, and how much will that increase the financial burden in other areas?

Intellectually I can argue for single-payer universal coverage... but only if I compartmentalize it and ignore all of the secondary impacts.

Exactly we are stuck with these massive and increasing costs because the pain of switching to a more efficient system is too high.

Though of course as your job is an example of one that going to universal health care would like drive out of the job market you are not exactly an unbiased individual.
 
:confused: You snipped everything include the thread linky button. I'm not sure which post you're referring to. I'm guessing you're referring to the preventive care one?

The positive externalizes still don't outweigh the cost for most early-detection screenings. The incidence rate is still very low for the things being screened for, and the prevalence of screening is very high.

It unquestionably has high value to the individuals impacted. That's obvious. But taken from a policy perspective, it's not effective and the externalizes don't offset the increased cost burden.

But as I said, it's goodwill and it's the right thing to do. It's just not at all cost effective, no matter how you slice it up.

Yep the ideal customer is healthy until they suddenly drop dead. Like how smoking lowers health care costs and so really insurance companies should be encouraging their customers to smoke.
 
Schools: I'm with you on that. I think education should be privatized. Eliminate the property tax levies for school and let people spend that money for their own kid's education as they see fit. Government.

It’s not just the individuals that benefit, employers also benefit greatly from having a large pool of qualified individuals. We have no examples of a high wealth nation that doesn’t first provide education to its citizens so it’s actually pretty reasonable to attribute all the benefits of living in a wealthy country in part to the cost of education so there is a real and significant benefit to everyone.

Police: Security is one of the primary roles of the government. We all benefit from a ready and able police force regardless if you personally ever use them or not.

Police – There are significant segments of American society that do get much of a sense of security from current policing. There is also a big difference in the value of property protected, so someone with $1 billion in property being protected is receiving a much greater benefit than someone with $20 in their pocket.
Military – US military spending is vastly greater than security requires. The US spends as much as everyone else in the world combined and the US and it’s direct allies are responsible for about 85% of all global military spending. Like law enforcement, even the security benefits inherently skew towards those with more valuable property to protect.

None of these are a good comparison to health care. The need for health care is largely dictated by lifestyle choices and thus is highly personalized.
While there is some lifestyle component, the largest part of healthcare cost is luck of the draw. There are also large society wide benefits in having a more mobile work force not ties in place due to healthcare reasons. There is also a large benefit to employers in having less to worry about wrt loosing man hours for health reasons.

You should pay for your own risks.
The largest risks are already socialized either from medical bankruptcy, Medicare, “free” care in emergency rooms that need to be passed on to other patients, or care provided by charitable contribution.
 
Exactly we are stuck with these massive and increasing costs because the pain of switching to a more efficient system is too high.

Though of course as your job is an example of one that going to universal health care would like drive out of the job market you are not exactly an unbiased individual.

:rolleyes:

I've never claimed to be unbiased, but the content of my many, many, many posts on this topic should demonstrate that I am objective.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom