Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
So, let's take a look at one example. You are responsible for your own lifestyle, are young, fit and well. You are doing your usual afternoon jog, when a driver loses control of his car, runs you over, and turns you into a quadriplegic.

You require medical care for the rest of your life. Under the USA system, who pays for the initial and on-going medical costs?

For the sake of this, I am assuming that the driver of the car has not got any money, so a law suit is useless.

Norm

The auto insurance of the driver, primarily. A catastrophic health insurance policy, could also pick up those costs. What you have described is an extremely rare occurance, at least as compared to the more common scenario: you eat a high-sugar, high-calorie diet that contains few fruits and veggies and lots of processed food and red meat. You inevitably develop health issues as a result. Who should bear the financial responsibility of your health care?
 
"You can't be hungry, because I have a sandwich!"

It's more like "we could share a dollar to buy 2 sandwiches, but I will take that dollar and buy a burger because sandwiches are below par....and I'll eat the whole burger myself."
 
The auto insurance of the driver, primarily. A catastrophic health insurance policy, could also pick up those costs. What you have described is an extremely rare occurance, at least as compared to the more common scenario: you eat a high-sugar, high-calorie diet that contains few fruits and veggies and lots of processed food and red meat. You inevitably develop health issues as a result. Who should bear the financial responsibility of your health care?

Proctor and Gamble, maybe McDonalds.
 
Police: Security is one of the primary roles of the government. We all benefit from a ready and able police force regardless if you personally ever use them or not.

I feel exactly the same way about healthcare.

It's almost incomprehensible to me that people can feel the opposite of this, but then I grew up in a world with UHC and it's just what happens here.

The nation as a whole benefits from a 'free at the point of use' healthcare system with the government running the system. Ours is very far from perfect, but I'll take what we have over the USA system hands down.

The single biggest benefit to UHC in my opinion is that it keeps the prices for healthcare in check. Anyone arguing that the "free market" is better at doing that needs to explain the discrepancy between healthcare costs in the USA and every other developed nation that has UHC available.
 
and I largely feel that way about education. I'm glad that my tax contribution gets spent on education, but I don't have kids - I'm just glad that someone else's kids get the opportunity for an education.

let people spend that money for their own kid's education as they see fit.

Absolutely not. No child should be subjected to the whims of their parents. Not only does that model simply result in education for the rich and neglect for the poor, education can be the springboard to so many other things that should be possible for everyone, not just those that can afford it.

There is no doubt that state education systems can and must be improved, but you don't improve those systems by scrapping them. It's hard, but nobody said life was easy.
 
Roads: You benefit from roads even if you don't personally drive. Without them, you couldn't get supplies to your home. Roads are essential for modern life and, as part of infrastructure is one of the primary roles of the government.

Schools: I'm with you on that. I think education should be privatized. Eliminate the property tax levies for school and let people spend that money for their own kid's education as they see fit. Government should have as little to do with education as possible because they aren't particularly good at it.

Police: Security is one of the primary roles of the government. We all benefit from a ready and able police force regardless if you personally ever use them or not.

None of these are a good comparison to health care. The need for health care is largely dictated by lifestyle choices and thus is highly personalized. You should pay for your own risks. I could get behind government funding of broad public health initiatives: immunizations, infectious disease control, etc. But it really has no place trying to dictate a cookie cutter approach to health care.
How do ill people build those roads?
 
I don't think you are interpreting these studies correctly. Sure, if we didn't treat the problems that arise with smoking, it might be cheaper. But we can't have it both ways: keep smoking, insist that smokers be treated for the inevitable problems that arise and then expect to save money. It makes no sense.

I know this is uncomfortable but you will die. It does not matter what life-style choices you make. We are all going to die.
You cannot chose to stay healthy forever. You can only chose to get different health problems later in life.
 
I feel exactly the same way about healthcare.

It's almost incomprehensible to me that people can feel the opposite of this, but then I grew up in a world with UHC and it's just what happens here.

The reason it is incomprehensible to you is because you can't comprehend the American attitude: better that 99 deserving and needy people go without than to let one undeserving person have anything.

Using a self-serving definition of "deserving"
 
and I largely feel that way about education. I'm glad that my tax contribution gets spent on education, but I don't have kids - I'm just glad that someone else's kids get the opportunity for an education.



Absolutely not. No child should be subjected to the whims of their parents. Not only does that model simply result in education for the rich and neglect for the poor, education can be the springboard to so many other things that should be possible for everyone, not just those that can afford it.

You highlight exactly the objection to school vouchers. Our taxes do not go toward any single student, but pay for the system.

Just to throw out hypothetical numbers: suppose you pay $1000 in taxes to support the school, and the school has 2000 students total. Now, if you don't have any kids in the school, where does that money go to? Certainly not toward the education of any single individual student. Basically, you are paying $.50 toward each student.

That doesn't change when you have kids in the school. Your tax dollars do not only pay for your child, but pay equally for everyone else. So if I also pay $1000 but have a child in the school, that $1000 still does not go toward my own child, it is distributed among all 2000. My child gets 50 cents of it.

Another reason we know that our money does not go toward the education of our child is because you don't pay more if you have more kids. If I have two kids in school, one, or none, I still pay the same tax. I don't have to pay more with more kids. Because I am not paying for my kids' schooling.

So if you want a voucher, I'm happy to give you a voucher for that 50 cents that you are providing to pay for each of your children. But don't you don't get the full value, not at all. The rest of the education is being paid by everyone else, not by you. We aren't just going to give you that money.
 
Roads: You benefit from roads even if you don't personally drive. Without them, you couldn't get supplies to your home. Roads are essential for modern life and, as part of infrastructure is one of the primary roles of the government.

The shops that I buy things from should pay for that. They're using the roads, not me.

Schools: I'm with you on that. I think education should be privatized. Eliminate the property tax levies for school and let people spend that money for their own kid's education as they see fit. Government should have as little to do with education as possible because they aren't particularly good at it.

That's awesome. It'll stop those pesky poor people from thinking they deserve to go to college - they'll never be able to get the high school education that's a prerequisite. Society as a whole will definitely be better off once they really know their place.

Police: Security is one of the primary roles of the government. We all benefit from a ready and able police force regardless if you personally ever use them or not.

No, it's fine. I'd rather have a gun and a pitbull.

You should pay for your own risks.

You should pay for your own road usage, education and security.
 
It's not exactly a straight-forward calculation. I don't really fault anyone for getting it wrong. But hey - if he thinks it's going to be a $5000 penalty, then he's more likely to buy insurance. It'll likely be in his best interests in the long run. And if he lives in my state, there's some small chance it might benefit my company ;)

If you were without healthcare for the whole year, it is a fairly straightforward calculation.

You either are charged 2.5% of your AGI ($1200 for a person with an AGI of $48000) up to the value of the average bronze plan.
OR you are charged on a per person basis - $695 per adult and $347.50 for each child not to exceed $2085.

You get charged whichever value is higher. So based on this person's income, the absolute worst case scenario is $2085.

If you were only without healthcare for part of the year, you take that value and multiply it by X/12 where X is the number of months you were without insurance (granted it gets a bit more complicated if different people in the household were without insurance for different periods of time).
 
Last edited:
Is it a uniquely US thing to talk of provision of health insurance like that's the point and not simply a tool to achieve healthcare?
 
If you were without healthcare for the whole year, it is a fairly straightforward calculation.

You either are charged 2.5% of your AGI ($1200 for a person with an AGI of $48000) up to the value of the average bronze plan.
OR you are charged on a per person basis - $695 per adult and $347.50 for each child not to exceed $2085.

You get charged whichever value is higher. So based on this person's income, the absolute worst case scenario is $2085.

If you were only without healthcare for part of the year, you take that value and multiply it by X/12 where X is the number of months you were without insurance (granted it gets a bit more complicated if different people in the household were without insurance for different periods of time).

Oh I understand the calculation - I don't need it explained to me ;)

The majority of people, however, aren't really all that good at max, and nested max/min functions are often confusing to a large number of people.
 
Is it a uniquely US thing to talk of provision of health insurance like that's the point and not simply a tool to achieve healthcare?

I think it is, more or less. There's a historical evolution in there that makes it a different discussion. At a minimum (setting aside all the various small influences that come in to play), Other countries decided that health care should be a social program a long time ago - long before insurance gained solid footing. It didn't get roots in, it didn't grow as a large industry, and it didn't employ hundreds of thousands of people. In the US, we missed that memo. If we'd been paying attention back in the 40s, or heck even the 60s, we wouldn't be in this boat today. We would have been ahead of the majority of technological improvements that have skyrocketed the underlying cost of care. We would have been ahead of the drug innovations that have compounded that cost. And we would have been ahead of comprehensive medical coverage (including routine maintenance and actual insurable events) becoming de rigeur as an employment benefit.

No we have to figure out a way to unravel that knot that doesn't crash the whole thing.
 
Health is like education: the rising water lifts all boats and pays dividends in excess of the original investment. This makes is a good model for a public service, which most countries have figured out.

Roads: You benefit from roads even if you don't personally drive. Without them, you couldn't get supplies to your home. Roads are essential for modern life and, as part of infrastructure is one of the primary roles of the government.

Schools: I'm with you on that. I think education should be privatized. Eliminate the property tax levies for school and let people spend that money for their own kid's education as they see fit. Government should have as little to do with education as possible because they aren't particularly good at it.

Police: Security is one of the primary roles of the government. We all benefit from a ready and able police force regardless if you personally ever use them or not.

None of these are a good comparison to health care. The need for health care is largely dictated by lifestyle choices and thus is highly personalized. You should pay for your own risks. I could get behind government funding of broad public health initiatives: immunizations, infectious disease control, etc. But it really has no place trying to dictate a cookie cutter approach to health care.

Funny how someone who benefits form public health care being widely available is better able to see that benefit than you are.
 
I used to think that, but I'm taking on a Trumpian view now. If it doesn't work why shouldn't we just crash the whole thing?

I've sort of wondered the same thing. What percentage of the population has to be uninsured or with very insecure health care before there is a more comprehensive push to deal with coverage and cost issues?

Or is a comprehensive solution a gordian knot that cannot be solved in American culture and political climate?
 
You guys consistently overlook one of the benefits of our patchwork system vs. universal health-care: more people end up dying.
 
I used to think that, but I'm taking on a Trumpian view now. If it doesn't work why shouldn't we just crash the whole thing?

Wait. If what doesn't work? And if it doesn't work perfectly, is that a reason to crash it? Something like 22 million people got health insurance coverage under the ACA that they couldn't get previously. They might not be happy about their premiums and deductibles, and that should be dealt with, but "crashing" it takes them all back to ground zero. One of the premises of the ACA was that state Medicaid programs would be expanded, but a majority of Republican governors refused to allow it in their states. So a lot of people didn't get lower-cost coverage that should have been available. And there are no controls on the prices providers can charge. Etc.

If you crash it, you need to come up with an alternative, or a lot of people will die, literally. The Repubs have only gotten to the first step and don't really have much interest in the second.
 
You guys consistently overlook one of the benefits of our patchwork system vs. universal health-care: more people end up dying.

That's right, its all part of the leftists plan. Pass the ACA to get the republicans to repeal coverage and argue against health care for real red blooded Americans and leave them die so the swarms of foreigners can take over the country filling the voide left behind by overweight diabetic dead americans.

Brilliant!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom