Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
I did see what you meant, you meant to equate the HMO with the GP because you don't understand that an HMO is an entire health care system. A person making the mistake you made sees an HMO only in terms of the doctors and doesn't get it that it is a system.
Your response only makes sense if you read my posts in the most disingenuous way possible.

The mistake was yours in taking my posts out of context. I understand that an HMO is a "system." We were discussing a specific aspect of that system: Getting in to see your regular doctor and the wait times involved with an HMO employed doctor vs an independent doctor.
Your answers again suggest you do not work in health care.

I've never seen an ED turn a patient away
Oh, you've never seen it so it must not happen. And therefore, I must not work in health care.
with the exception they sometimes have to kick out malingerers. It doesn't matter what the EMTLA says, EDs treat everyone that walks in the door with few exceptions.
No, they don't.
Maybe they only give a cursory exam
Called "triage,"
and offer little treatment besides a referral,
Called, "Turning them away,"
but they still see the patient.
Yes, they see the patient with their eyes...

If you walk into the average ER with a cough and congestion, do you think the ER is going to give you a bed, a full exam and treatment? No, they aren't, for the most part. The triage team is going to determine you aren't an emergency and then the intake team is going to ask you for payment.

Some hospitals do indeed operate in the manner you suggest; indeed, I stated that the hospital I am invested in has decided to provide an attached urgent care center which will not turn people away for payment issues. But most hospitals do ask for payment for non-emergent conditions, your incredulity notwithstanding.

Otherwise you'd have to have triage nurses turning people away, and that's not within their scope of practice. So at a minimum the patient is checked in and evaluated by an NP/PA or an MD.

Or maybe you'd have the clerk decide who to turn away.
I would have a screening for emergency conditions by a triage team and then having the intake team collect payments before non-emergent conditions are admitted to the ER for treatment -exactly what happens all over the country right now.
 
...
Oh, you've never seen it so it must not happen. And therefore, I must not work in health care. No, they don't. Called "triage," Called, "Turning them away,"Yes, they see the patient with their eyes...

If you walk into the average ER with a cough and congestion, do you think the ER is going to give you a bed, a full exam and treatment? No, they aren't, for the most part. The triage team is going to determine you aren't an emergency and then the intake team is going to ask you for payment.

Some hospitals do indeed operate in the manner you suggest; indeed, I stated that the hospital I am invested in has decided to provide an attached urgent care center which will not turn people away for payment issues. But most hospitals do ask for payment for non-emergent conditions, your incredulity notwithstanding.

I would have a screening for emergency conditions by a triage team and then having the intake team collect payments before non-emergent conditions are admitted to the ER for treatment -exactly what happens all over the country right now.
This is like the Trump has a mental illness thread where you've read something online you don't understand and try to present yourself as knowledgeable.

What you don't understand about that is it is a means of increasing collections, it doesn't mean if you can't pay you are turned away.

Read the wording:
However, patients the hospital deems nonemergent will be charged with a $150 deposit through cash, credit or debit card for rendered services.
Or what? Do you see the or they will be sent packing? No. You don't see that anywhere in that article.

Here's the detailed statement from the "here's the Rockdale Citizen article":
The statement went on to say, "Per the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA,) all patients will continue to receive a medical examination and offered treatment. If a patient is determined to have an emergency, they will continue to receive care, regardless of ability to pay. However, if a patient is determined not to have an emergency, and still requests further treatment, they will be required to pay a $150 initial deposit via cash, credit or debit card for services rendered. Patients that choose to seek care elsewhere will be given a community resource guide for available services."
AKA they get initial treatment and, BTW, it is the provider who decides, not the triage nurse.

Here's the second link:
Newton Medical spokeswoman Moseley said the hospital's triage process (a medical term for an initial evaluation of a patient) will not change.
Hospitals are required to examine and offer treatment to any patient who comes to the emergency department under the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act. She said there are populations that are exempt, including the very young and the very old.
According to the American College of Emergency Physicians, the law, known as the "anti-dumping" law, was designed to prevent private hospitals from transferring uninsured or Medicaid patients to public hospitals without, at a minimum, providing a medical screening examination to ensure they were stable for transfer.
Imagine that, people who read something on the Net and think they know everything might not realize, they don't know the finer points of the law Don't feel bad, I Have to advise doctors sometimes that more than one law applies to some things as well.

And the third link:
If non-emergency patients can’t afford the fee, hospital officials said they will direct them in the right direction.

“We are also providing a community resource guide, so should they not qualify as having an emergency, we do provide them with options,” Komich said.

Bradford added, “There are primary care physicians and several doctors who work along with the hospital who are agreeing to see these patients at a lower cost.”
If you can't pay, and you've been initially evaluated (I can guarantee you the triage nurse does not decide. The hospital would accumulate lawsuits like candy if they did that), then they'll refer you to alternative resources. That is not the same as just sending you out the door. Though it would not surprise me if they did little to stop someone who chose to leave when asked to pay upfront without realizing they can be seen at least for an evaluation.


BTW, you don't get a bed in the ED like you get a bed in a hospital room. You get something akin to a very nice stretcher or maybe even just a stretcher. You are there to be evaluated, given initial care then a hospital bed if you need one.
 
Last edited:
I'm going to throw my hat in the ring and say that the neverending discussion of who is right and who is wrong one whether it's easy or hard to schedule an appointment for a moderately urgent condition with a PCP (with consideration for whether it is easier within an HMO system or not), as well as exactly what the distinction is between "screening and determining not emergent and sending away" and "not required to treat non-emergent/urgent conditions"...

...Is a massive derail that needs to go away now.
 
I wish they had quoted the sentence where he used the word "mean." Unless it's in there but I didn't see it.

I can't find it, and I've checked several different articles.

Honestly, I'm really tired of the one and two word "quotes" floating around out there, with no context. How hard is it to actually provide comprehensive information?
 
I wish they had quoted the sentence where he used the word "mean." Unless it's in there but I didn't see it.


There isn't going to be a transcript of a private meeting. It sounds like multiple people remembered and recounted the key word:

Their descriptions of Trump's words differed slightly.

One source said Trump called the House bill "mean, mean, mean" and said, "We need to be more generous, more kind." The other source said Trump used a vulgarity to describe the House bill and told the senators, "We need to be more generous."

Two other congressional GOP officials confirmed that the general descriptions of Trump's words were accurate.
http://abcnews.go.com/Health/wireStory/ap-sources-trump-tells-senators-house-health-bill-48015512
 
Lol.

OMG, Trump is now saying pretty much the same thing that we've all been saying about this bill. Bad Trump!

:confused:

The problem is that Trump was saying how great the bill is. Probably because he had no idea what was in it. He must have watched some TV and found out what was actually in the bill.
 
Last edited:
The problem is that Trump was saying how great the bill is. Probably because he had no idea what was in it. He must have watched some TV and found out what was actually in the bill.

A while back, my surface read of it didn't seem too bad. High level, it appeared not horrible, and if one had limited understanding of the market place, it could even have seemed like a decent approach. But then you get into the details. And yeah, it sucked. But if you don't get into the details it may not be obvious.

Especially if someone (Trump) is predisposed to think that Republicans are going to come up with something good. I'm not particularly surprised that he would assume positive intent and a more generous interpretation of the high level aspects of the bill. I assume that he was basing his opinions on what other people (Republicans) told him the bill would do, and a very surface level review of it (if any). Now he's seen it in more detail.

Maybe I'm jaded. I'm kind of at a "take what I can get" stage. So right now, I'm pretty content to say "Yay! He has recognized that this bill is a horrible idea!" I'm going to call this a victory. It's the only one I've got so far, and I'm not really anticipating any more in the next few years :(

ETA: There's still the game-theory part of my brain that thinks this whole thing is one enormous practical joke, and that Trump is playing the long con. Coming in with all of the Republican schtick, all of the party-line regurgitation and populism... knowing full well that he's not going to deliver that, and planning to gradually destroy the party from the inside. Because that can't really be any weirder than what's already happening, and at least that would make a really good screen-play that he could capitalize on in the future. :p
 
If congress is going to do something, then do it. We can't really move forward to sign up for much of anything in 2018 if we do not know costs. And the insurance companies can only offer "short term insurance" which somehow acts outside of Obamacare and does not have to follow its rules.
 
ETA: There's still the game-theory part of my brain that thinks this whole thing is one enormous practical joke, and that Trump is playing the long con. Coming in with all of the Republican schtick, all of the party-line regurgitation and populism... knowing full well that he's not going to deliver that, and planning to gradually destroy the party from the inside. Because that can't really be any weirder than what's already happening, and at least that would make a really good screen-play that he could capitalize on in the future. :p

I hate that your fevered dreams are the most hopeful scenario. We are in bizzarro world.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom