Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
Really? You can't just admit to poor wording of your sentence calling a GP an HMO? :rolleyes:

See that period after HMO? See anything in the sentence that says one's GP within the HMO?

Because I don't.

Here's the full sentence falsely equating the GP with the HMO proper:

The HMO is not a GP. It is an entire medical care system that includes GPs as primary care specialists, specialists, clinics, labs, hospitals, and walk-in clinics.

HMO: Health Maintenance Organization.

I assumed that you were following the context of the conversation. We were talking about scheduling with your regular doctor -the GP as you put it (even though there really aren't many GPs in the US). But if it helps your understanding, I will correct my statement to the following: "It's still not easy to schedule an urgent visit with an HMO GP."
 
You can't walk in to your regular doctor 24/7, now can you? That's what we were discussing -scheduling a visit with your regular doc in an HMO environment vs an independent doc. I addressed the urgent care availability, which is available to patients of most any insurance product.

Maybe this is true now, but pre ACA there was “insurance” that essentially covered nothing at all.
 
Maybe this is true now, but pre ACA there was “insurance” that essentially covered nothing at all.

That's not true. Insurance coverage didn't magically change when ACA went into effect. What happened was that insurance was available to more people, theoretically. But people who had insurance before ACA still had access to urgent care facilities.
 

I think the problem that the republicans aren't considering is that they can't compel insurance companies to participate. We're already seeing multiple carriers exiting the individual and small group markets. If they make this plan worse, you'[ll see more dropping out.

And yes, I know, lots of people will complain about insurance company profits and all that, and insist that whatever the republicans propose is going to somehow line the pockets of insurers. But the exact same thing was said about ACA, and that didn't materialize either. So far, everything proposed by the republicans have made the market much less sustainable, and much less attractive to insurers in general.

So... yeah, it will suck in the short term and a lot of people will be without coverage. But where it used to be that some people with high cost medical conditions were excluded from coverage... now it will end up being the case that only larger employers will have access to coverage. How long do you think that will last before congress caves and moves toward some form of universal coverage? I'm betting not too long.

It's not my preferred approach. I don't care for throwing the baby out with the bathwater. I generally don't support short-term thinking without consideration for the impacts. But since our congresscritters seem pathologically (in the colloquial sense) unable to discuss things like rational human beings... this might be the best available path to that outcome.
 
I assumed that you were following the context of the conversation. We were talking about scheduling with your regular doctor -the GP as you put it (even though there really aren't many GPs in the US). But if it helps your understanding, I will correct my statement to the following: "It's still not easy to schedule an urgent visit with an HMO GP."

:rolleyes:

I was following it. You erroneously equated GP with HMO.

Look, I can't help it if you didn't keep your terms straight. Just admit it and move on, or don't and thread readers can draw their own conclusions.
 
That's not true. Insurance coverage didn't magically change when ACA went into effect. What happened was that insurance was available to more people, theoretically. But people who had insurance before ACA still had access to urgent care facilities.

Does not covering hospital care count as nothing do you consider that effective coverage?
 
That's not true. Insurance coverage didn't magically change when ACA went into effect.

Wrong. Certain dishonest practices by the insurance companies became illegal with the ACA such as canceling policies when patients developed expensive illnesses.

In addition certain preventative care has been mandated to be covered by all insurers with no copays.

What happened was that insurance was available to more people, theoretically. But people who had insurance before ACA still had access to urgent care facilities.
Not sure of your point here given no ED could then or can now turn a patient away. It's the followup care that is the problem with the uninsured.
 
:rolleyes:

I was following it. You erroneously equated GP with HMO.
No, you clearly weren't following it. xjx had no errors. You conflated an entirely different conversation into the mix. Here is the background:
It makes it difficult to get a timely appointment with a generalist, which complicates the whole "building a relationship" thing. You end up having to schedule your annual physicals and such two to three months ahead, and if you have something moderately urgent crop up, you're still often looking at a wait of several weeks.
This is the number one factor as to why adults don't go to the doctor. It takes so long to get in that by the time you actually are scheduled to see the doctor, you probably aren't sick anymore. We combat that problem by only scheduling half our slots in advance and leaving the other slots open for walk-in/urgent. Not all doctors operate that way, of course. The fear is: what if you don't get any walk-in/urgent patients? It's much safer to be fully booked every day.
Just a question here. How do HMOs schedule patients? The docs are usually salaried, so they don't have a financial incentive to fill every slot in advance; the parent company has to balance its financial considerations with customer satisfaction and quality of care. How hard is it to get a routine appointment at an HMO?
HMOs are a different animal. They can run things differently than an independent practice. Basically, their model depends on the idea of getting people NOT to come in for doctor visits. They employ a wide variety of methods to achieve this. They might hire more NPs and PAs to provide cheaper care while still increasing access. They might provide more telehealth. Sometimes they limit the number of visits that a patient can have per year without cost share.

Even so, in my experience, it's still not easy to schedule an urgent visit with an HMO. The number of HMO providers in a particular area is still rather small and there's too large a pool of patients for the number of providers willing to contract with an HMO. This is changing in that many HMOs are contracting with or creating their own urgent care centers

++++
Look, I can't help it if you didn't keep your terms straight. Just admit it and move on, or don't and thread readers can draw their own conclusions.
You might consider admitting that you mistook the context and errantly inserted your own version of reality here.

ETA: It might not go amiss for someone else to provide the genesis of this conversation to SG.
 
Last edited:
Wrong. Certain dishonest practices by the insurance companies became illegal with the ACA such as canceling policies when patients developed expensive illnesses.

You know that was illegal before ACA, right?

The only nuance is that related to pre-existing conditions. If a covered individual was dishonest on their application and didn't disclose a pre-existing condition, the insurer had the right to rescind coverage that they would not have approved had they known all the information.

On some occasions (not actually very many), an insurer has been found to have been overzealous, and abused the right to rescind for their own advantage. There are also many dishonest practices by patients mixed up in there too, though.
 
Wrong. Certain dishonest practices by the insurance companies became illegal with the ACA such as canceling policies when patients developed expensive illnesses.
That is true,; however lomiller replied to my comment specifically about urgent care, which was covered by insurance prior to ACA, just as it is now. lomiller seemed to be implying that before ACA, insurance did not cover urgent care, which is not true.

In addition certain preventative care has been mandated to be covered by all insurers with no copays.
OK. But this does not relate to urgent care coverage.
Not sure of your point here given no ED could then or can now turn a patient away. It's the followup care that is the problem with the uninsured.
:confused: EDs can and do turn away patients who are not experiencing emergency conditions; EMTALA does not apply to anything except emergency conditions. Non-emergency patients are directed to urgent care facilities instead which is the whole point. Urgent Care centers have been around for awhile now and have been covered under insurance plans -ACA did not affect that one bit.
 
Insurances have always covered hospital care; ACA didn't change that.

Sure but often only a couple of grand worth see

"
“I was aware that it wasn’t a great plan, but I wasn’t concerned because I wasn’t sick,” she says. But in July 2011 she was diagnosed with breast cancer, at which point the policy’s annual limits of $1,000 a year for outpatient treatment and $2,000 for hospitalization became a huge problem. Facing a $30,000 hospital bill, she delayed treatment. “Finally my surgeon said, ‘Judy, you can’t wait anymore.’ While I was waiting my tumor became larger. It was 3 centimeters when they found it and 9 centimeters when they took it out.” After a double mastectomy, radiation treatments, and reconstructive surgery, Goss is taking the drug tamoxifen to prevent recurrence.
"

http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/magazine/2012/03/junk-health-insurance/index.htm

That is the kind of great insurance policies that Obamacare outlawed that people want back.
 
Sure but often only a couple of grand worth see

"
“I was aware that it wasn’t a great plan, but I wasn’t concerned because I wasn’t sick,” she says. But in July 2011 she was diagnosed with breast cancer, at which point the policy’s annual limits of $1,000 a year for outpatient treatment and $2,000 for hospitalization became a huge problem. Facing a $30,000 hospital bill, she delayed treatment. “Finally my surgeon said, ‘Judy, you can’t wait anymore.’ While I was waiting my tumor became larger. It was 3 centimeters when they found it and 9 centimeters when they took it out.” After a double mastectomy, radiation treatments, and reconstructive surgery, Goss is taking the drug tamoxifen to prevent recurrence.
"

http://www.consumerreports.org/cro/magazine/2012/03/junk-health-insurance/index.htm

That is the kind of great insurance policies that Obamacare outlawed that people want back.

Or one discussed in these forums where someone linked the lady complain her $350 per year insurance was discontinued and on some deeper digging it turns out that the maximum yearly payout was $500 and she had basically been giving her money away to the insurance company.
 
Or one discussed in these forums where someone linked the lady complain her $350 per year insurance was discontinued and on some deeper digging it turns out that the maximum yearly payout was $500 and she had basically been giving her money away to the insurance company.

But they were happy with them, or not in the case I cited.
 
If that were the case then it would have been easy to see exactly what I meant.

I did see what you meant, you meant to equate the HMO with the GP because you don't understand that an HMO is an entire health care system. A person making the mistake you made sees an HMO only in terms of the doctors and doesn't get it that it is a system.
 
That is true,; however lomiller replied to my comment specifically about urgent care, which was covered by insurance prior to ACA, just as it is now. lomiller seemed to be implying that before ACA, insurance did not cover urgent care, which is not true.

OK. But this does not relate to urgent care coverage.

:confused: EDs can and do turn away patients who are not experiencing emergency conditions; EMTALA does not apply to anything except emergency conditions. Non-emergency patients are directed to urgent care facilities instead which is the whole point. Urgent Care centers have been around for awhile now and have been covered under insurance plans -ACA did not affect that one bit.
Your answers again suggest you do not work in health care.

I've never seen an ED turn a patient away with the exception they sometimes have to kick out malingerers. It doesn't matter what the EMTLA says, EDs treat everyone that walks in the door with few exceptions. Maybe they only give a cursory exam and offer little treatment besides a referral, but they still see the patient.

Otherwise you'd have to have triage nurses turning people away, and that's not within their scope of practice. So at a minimum the patient is checked in and evaluated by an NP/PA or an MD.

Or maybe you'd have the clerk decide who to turn away.
 
Last edited:
I did see what you meant, you meant to equate the HMO with the GP because you don't understand that an HMO is an entire health care system. A person making the mistake you made sees an HMO only in terms of the doctors and doesn't get it that it is a system.

No, that's not at all what xjx meant, as appears to be clear to everyone else in the thread. Xjx did not make the mistake you insist has been made.
 
Your answers again suggest you do not work in health care.

I've never seen an ED turn a patient away with the exception they sometimes have to kick out malingerers. It doesn't matter what the EMTLA says, EDs treat everyone that walks in the door with few exceptions. Maybe they only give a cursory exam and offer little treatment besides a referral, but they still see the patient.

Otherwise you'd have to have triage nurses turning people away, and that's not within their scope of practice. So at a minimum the patient is checked in and evaluated by an NP/PA or an MD.
Or maybe you'd have the clerk decide who to turn away.

This is not true. Not everyone is checked in, nor is everyone evaluated. *Most* are, as *most* cases are are Emergent/Urgent or cannot be determined to be non-emergent until being evaluated. But it's not universally true.

I myself spoke with a triage nurse about a cut that wouldn't clot (it had bled for 20 minutes before I decided to leave for the hospital, suspecting it needed stitches). When I got there, the triage nurse asked to see the wound. We spoke briefly about the volume of blood, and the fact that the seepage had substantially reduced. She recommended that I give it another 15 minutes or so, since I had previously had an alcoholic beverage which can slow clotting. She did not take my name, she did not check me in, and I was never billed for the encounter.

FYI - I live in the Seattle metro area, which is where you have claimed to practice. There is no possibility of being subject to different local regulations.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom