Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
.....
We combat that problem by only scheduling half our slots in advance and leaving the other slots open for walk-in/urgent. Not all doctors operate that way, of course. The fear is: what if you don't get any walk-in/urgent patients? It's much safer to be fully booked every day.
....

Just a question here. How do HMOs schedule patients? The docs are usually salaried, so they don't have a financial incentive to fill every slot in advance; the parent company has to balance its financial considerations with customer satisfaction and quality of care. How hard is it to get a routine appointment at an HMO?
 
Just a question here. How do HMOs schedule patients? The docs are usually salaried, so they don't have a financial incentive to fill every slot in advance; the parent company has to balance its financial considerations with customer satisfaction and quality of care. How hard is it to get a routine appointment at an HMO?

HMOs are a different animal. They can run things differently than an independent practice. Basically, their model depends on the idea of getting people NOT to come in for doctor visits. They employ a wide variety of methods to achieve this. They might hire more NPs and PAs to provide cheaper care while still increasing access. They might provide more telehealth. Sometimes they limit the number of visits that a patient can have per year without cost share.

Even so, in my experience, it's still not easy to schedule an urgent visit with an HMO. The number of HMO providers in a particular area is still rather small and there's too large a pool of patients for the number of providers willing to contract with an HMO. This is changing in that many HMOs are contracting with or creating their own urgent care centers
 
Just a question here. How do HMOs schedule patients? The docs are usually salaried, so they don't have a financial incentive to fill every slot in advance; the parent company has to balance its financial considerations with customer satisfaction and quality of care. How hard is it to get a routine appointment at an HMO?

I've been in an HMO for decades. There are several options for rapid care, 24/7: walk-in clinics are in many locations and after 8pm only the urgent care in the ED stays open. There's always a consulting nurse and they can even order some things over the phone. I can pick meds up at the pharmacy or they will mail them to me.

If I need an appointment with my MD, I make the appointment online, it usually takes 1-2 weeks to get in. I can self refer to a specialist but usually you see for GP first. Those appointments take longer to get in but once you are with a specialist for care you just get used to making your follow-up appointments ahead of time.

When I broke my finger and needed surgery, I got the surgery and follow up right away with the hand surgeon in ortho specialty.

When I needed a full workup assessing heart and lungs and an MRI, I don't recall the appointments taking too long to get. Same when I needed an appointment for a drug reaction, they biopsied the rash that day.

It took two months to see a specialist outside of the HMO, but that was because it was the soonest that specialty clinic had an opening, had nothing to do with the HMO. My GP did have to clear up a mixup in the referral diagnosis where a mis-coded diagnosis caused a problem.

And I was very annoyed when my rheumatologist referred me to a dentist for severe mouth reaction. But it has turned out no one knows what I have after seeing 4 different specialists and 2 different rheumatologists so it's understandable when they don't know what you have they refer you to someone else. At the moment they are just treating the symptoms and I still don't have a diagnosis other than it is an auto-immune disorder.


BTW, the docs very specifically do not get involved with your coverage so it doesn't affect what they order. When my copays went up for labs, I'm the one that asked for fewer tests. If the docs had their way they'd be drawing my blood and repeating tests much more often. So no one is pressuring them to provide less care.
 
Last edited:
HMOs are a different animal. They can run things differently than an independent practice. Basically, their model depends on the idea of getting people NOT to come in for doctor visits. They employ a wide variety of methods to achieve this. They might hire more NPs and PAs to provide cheaper care while still increasing access. They might provide more telehealth. Sometimes they limit the number of visits that a patient can have per year without cost share.

Even so, in my experience, it's still not easy to schedule an urgent visit with an HMO. The number of HMO providers in a particular area is still rather small and there's too large a pool of patients for the number of providers willing to contract with an HMO. This is changing in that many HMOs are contracting with or creating their own urgent care centers
What experience is that? :rolleyes:
 
HMOs are a different animal. They can run things differently than an independent practice. Basically, their model depends on the idea of getting people NOT to come in for doctor visits. They employ a wide variety of methods to achieve this. They might hire more NPs and PAs to provide cheaper care while still increasing access. They might provide more telehealth. Sometimes they limit the number of visits that a patient can have per year without cost share.

Even so, in my experience, it's still not easy to schedule an urgent visit with an HMO. The number of HMO providers in a particular area is still rather small and there's too large a pool of patients for the number of providers willing to contract with an HMO. This is changing in that many HMOs are contracting with or creating their own urgent care centers

Staff model HMOs do pretty well in terms of streamlining the experience and balancing the provider-patient aspect. The downside is that there aren't very many of them, and there end up being limitations to choice - the patient can only see doctors that belong to that HMO system, and those doctors serve nobody except the patients of that HMO product (with exceptions for ER).

Contrast that with a contracted HMO, which is an altogether different beast. Staff model doctors are salaried, and the parent insurer takes the claim risk -
if there end up being more sick people than expected, it gets taken care of through parent insurer capital and reserves, the doctors aren't at risk In a contract HMO, however, the doctors aren't salaried - they're capitated. They get paid a fixed cost per enrolled patient per month. The capitation is based on an average expected utilization level. So if the doctor ends up with sicker patients who need more care, they end up footing that bill, and the cost of that care comes out of their profit margin.

Staff model HMOs have many fewer perverse incentives, but they're slow to grow/shrink as the patient population shifts. They're also geographically bound with very limited options for expansion.

Capitated contract HMOs are subject to a lot of perverse incentives, and patient experience is often much worse. They also end up being very risky enterprises, because the patient base is small so pooling of risk doesn't work so well.
 
What experience is that? :rolleyes:

What are you questioning exactly? Because you just replied to the same post I did with pretty much exactly what I said:

you said:
There are several options for rapid care, 24/7: walk-in clinics are in many locations and after 8pm only the urgent care in the ED stays open. There's always a consulting nurse and they can even order some things over the phone.

me said:
They might hire more NPs and PAs to provide cheaper care while still increasing access. They might provide more telehealth...many HMOs are contracting with or creating their own urgent care centers


you said:
If I need an appointment with my MD, I make the appointment online, it usually takes 1-2 weeks to get in. I can self refer to a specialist but usually you see for GP first. Those appointments take longer to get in...
me said:
Even so, in my experience, it's still not easy to schedule an urgent visit with an HMO. The number of HMO providers in a particular area is still rather small and there's too large a pool of patients for the number of providers willing to contract with an HMO.

So it seems my experience jibes with yours. :confused:
 
Staff model HMOs do pretty well in terms of streamlining the experience and balancing the provider-patient aspect. The downside is that there aren't very many of them, and there end up being limitations to choice - the patient can only see doctors that belong to that HMO system, and those doctors serve nobody except the patients of that HMO product (with exceptions for ER).

Contrast that with a contracted HMO, which is an altogether different beast. Staff model doctors are salaried, and the parent insurer takes the claim risk -
if there end up being more sick people than expected, it gets taken care of through parent insurer capital and reserves, the doctors aren't at risk In a contract HMO, however, the doctors aren't salaried - they're capitated. They get paid a fixed cost per enrolled patient per month. The capitation is based on an average expected utilization level. So if the doctor ends up with sicker patients who need more care, they end up footing that bill, and the cost of that care comes out of their profit margin.

Staff model HMOs have many fewer perverse incentives, but they're slow to grow/shrink as the patient population shifts. They're also geographically bound with very limited options for expansion.

Capitated contract HMOs are subject to a lot of perverse incentives, and patient experience is often much worse. They also end up being very risky enterprises, because the patient base is small so pooling of risk doesn't work so well.

Is captitation still a big thing? I know it isn't in my neck of the woods. We do participate in a couple of HMOs but they are fee-for-service. Here, "HMO" means small network with no out-of-network benefits.

I also understand that, under MACRA, one of the proposed models is a capitation-type system based on the Risk Adjustment Factor . . . but maybe I'm misunderstanding something ...
 
Trying to figure that out myself. If I were to speculate, I'd say it's a cost issue. The couple of hospitals that have UC clinics in them charge less than ER, but still quite a bit more than a regular doctor's visit. Stand-alone UCs, on the other hand, tend to charge only slightly higher than a regular doctor's visit. I would guess that insurance carriers haven't been supportive of the Hospital-based UC model for that reason, although I'm far from certain.

Well, I can only speak for us ignorant Aussies and our stupid Universal Health Scheme. In the Health precinct in Geelong, where both the Publicly Funded Geelong Hospital and the Privately funded Geelong Private Hospital reside another practice was set up on the opposite side of the road.

A privately owned medical clinic which is open 24/7, and bulk bills (i.e., only charges the rebate fee, the one directly paid by the Government), rather that the fee recommended by the AMA. So patients go there at no cost (well, except scripts if needed - $6 for a months supply if on the Government approved list)

It still seems to make sufficient enough profit to stay open all the time, and simultaneously reduces pressure on ER. But what would we convicts know?

Norm
 
Is captitation still a big thing? I know it isn't in my neck of the woods. We do participate in a couple of HMOs but they are fee-for-service. Here, "HMO" means small network with no out-of-network benefits.

I also understand that, under MACRA, one of the proposed models is a capitation-type system based on the Risk Adjustment Factor . . . but maybe I'm misunderstanding something ...

No, capitation is pretty rare these days... but it's not completely gone either. There are a handful of smaller physician groups that work on a capitated basis, and some of the "Accredited Care Organization" products that came out of ACA are operating under cap+risk arrangements. It's a captiated base, with some degree of risk-based reinsurance. The providers don't take all of the claim risk, but are still exposed to some. In my opinion, that's still a bad idea - doctors don't know anything about setting reserves. And unless it's a really large provider group, the pool size is going to be too small to accurately assess the risk anyway.
 
Well, I can only speak for us ignorant Aussies and our stupid Universal Health Scheme. In the Health precinct in Geelong, where both the Publicly Funded Geelong Hospital and the Privately funded Geelong Private Hospital reside another practice was set up on the opposite side of the road.

A privately owned medical clinic which is open 24/7, and bulk bills (i.e., only charges the rebate fee, the one directly paid by the Government), rather that the fee recommended by the AMA. So patients go there at no cost (well, except scripts if needed - $6 for a months supply if on the Government approved list)

It still seems to make sufficient enough profit to stay open all the time, and simultaneously reduces pressure on ER. But what would we convicts know?

Norm

That's more akin to a stand-alone urgent care center than to a hospital-based urgent care center. Also, I don't know what you're arguing here. Australia health care doesn't function like US healthcare, so I'm not exactly surprised that Australian health care doesn't function like US health care...
 
Last edited:
What are you questioning exactly? Because you just replied to the same post I did with pretty much exactly what I said:
So it seems my experience jibes with yours. :confused:
I don't know what you think you wrote, but it was inaccurate.
xjx388 said:
it's still not easy to schedule an urgent visit with an HMO.
Me:
There are several options for rapid care, 24/7: walk-in clinics are in many locations and after 8pm only the urgent care in the ED stays open.

How does not easy to schedule an urgent visit correlate with, you can walk in anytime, 24/7?
 
I don't know what you think you wrote, but it was inaccurate.

Me:

How does not easy to schedule an urgent visit correlate with, you can walk in anytime, 24/7?

You can't walk in to your regular doctor 24/7, now can you? That's what we were discussing -scheduling a visit with your regular doc in an HMO environment vs an independent doc. I addressed the urgent care availability, which is available to patients of most any insurance product.

Now who's inaccurate? ;)
 
You can't walk in to your regular doctor 24/7, now can you? That's what we were discussing -scheduling a visit with your regular doc in an HMO environment vs an independent doc. I addressed the urgent care availability, which is available to patients of most any insurance product.

Now who's inaccurate? ;)
You. You still are inaccurate.

Those walk-in clinics are part of my HMO. The PAs/NPs staffing them are employed by my HMO, they have access to my HMO medical records via the computers in the clinic.

Perhaps you should consider re-wording your assertion.

But on that same note, I had a dermatologist suggest one of my moles looked suspicious and my GP made time for me to come in that day to remove and biopsy it.

Also that hand surgeon had to rearrange his surgery schedule to repair my finger joint fracture after I waited too long to go in. He said the window to not have to re-break it to set it properly was closing. I went to the ED one day, saw him the next and had it repaired the day after that.
 
Last edited:
You. You still are inaccurate.

Those walk-in clinics are part of my HMO. The PAs/NPs staffing them are employed by my HMO, they have access to my HMO medical records via the computers in the clinic.
Uh-huh...but they aren't your PCP. I said that HMOs are increasingly operating their own urgent care clinics and staffing them with PAs/NPs to increase access. Those clinics are not your PCP, though.

The matter being discussed was getting an appointment with your PCP.

Perhaps you should consider re-wording your assertion.
Or, you could just admit that I basically said the same thing you did.

But on that same note, I had a dermatologist suggest one of my moles looked suspicious and my GP made time for me to come in that day to remove and biopsy it.

Also that hand surgeon had to rearrange his surgery schedule to repair my finger joint fracture after I waited too long to go in. He said the window to not have to re-break it to set it properly was closing. I went to the ED one day, saw him the next and had it repaired the day after that.
That's great but doesn't negate the fact that in general it's still not easy to get in with a PCP quickly. You yourself said that it takes 1-2 weeks.

Plus, you may be an outlier being that you are in the industry. I can get into just about any clinic I need same day because of the relationships I've developed. I'm sure your situation is similar. For the average patient, they aren't so lucky.
 
Uh-huh...but they aren't your PCP. I said that HMOs are increasingly operating their own urgent care clinics and staffing them with PAs/NPs to increase access. Those clinics are not your PCP, though.

The matter being discussed was getting an appointment with your PCP.

Or, you could just admit that I basically said the same thing you did.

That's great but doesn't negate the fact that in general it's still not easy to get in with a PCP quickly. You yourself said that it takes 1-2 weeks.

Plus, you may be an outlier being that you are in the industry. I can get into just about any clinic I need same day because of the relationships I've developed. I'm sure your situation is similar. For the average patient, they aren't so lucky.
Really? You can't just admit to poor wording of your sentence calling a GP an HMO? :rolleyes:
it's still not easy to schedule an urgent visit with an HMO.
See that period after HMO? See anything in the sentence that says one's GP within the HMO?

Because I don't.

Here's the full sentence falsely equating the GP with the HMO proper:
Even so, in my experience, it's still not easy to schedule an urgent visit with an HMO.

The HMO is not a GP. It is an entire medical care system that includes GPs as primary care specialists, specialists, clinics, labs, hospitals, and walk-in clinics.

HMO: Health Maintenance Organization.
 
Last edited:
... You yourself said that it takes 1-2 weeks....
And I noted how urgent care is managed including when I needed to see my GP urgently and a specialist urgently.

This is what I mean asking your experience with HMOs. You don't seem to realize they do provide good care most of the time.

And BTW, good luck getting in to see a GP if you don't have an established relationship with one.
 
Yep, it's really that bad all to get a tax cut for the rich.

The nation needs three GOP Senators with the political courage to stand against the party leaders and oppose this bill.

My GOP Senator has been hiding from his constituents since last November. There is zero chance that he will vote against this abortion of a health care bill.

:mad:
 
Uh-huh...but they aren't your PCP. I said that HMOs are increasingly operating their own urgent care clinics and staffing them with PAs/NPs to increase access. Those clinics are not your PCP, though.

The matter being discussed was getting an appointment with your PCP.

Or, you could just admit that I basically said the same thing you did.

That's great but doesn't negate the fact that in general it's still not easy to get in with a PCP quickly. You yourself said that it takes 1-2 weeks. Plus, you may be an outlier being that you are in the industry. I can get into just about any clinic I need same day because of the relationships I've developed. I'm sure your situation is similar. For the average patient, they aren't so lucky.

I am not in an HMO, I have Aetna PPO.
For a new patient visit you will have to call a dozen MDs to get an appointment sooner than 3 months, if you can find anyone with an open slot at all, even if you have a potentially serious problem.
As an established patient, when an acute problem arises, you can usually get in to see the NP, or PA in a few days, but you will not see the MD (unless you are literally having an MI, bleeding all over the room, or need immediate intubation (going to die in the exam room).
This has been the same situation I have encountered in several states over the past ten years. I don't know anyone who can get in the same day any time they want to see the MD, or any MDs who have that availability (and I know quite a few), unless you are talking about concierge medicine?
What country do you live in?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom