Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
Here's the side-by-side of the debate process for the ACA and for Wealthcare. Notice the difference?

[IMGw=640]http://i1070.photobucket.com/albums/u492/rfstack/000000_127.jpg[/IMGw]

Here is what Claire McCaskill said about that.

“No, that’s not true, Mr. Chairman. Let me just say, I watched carefully all of the hearings that went on [when the Affordable Care Act was crafted]. I was not a member of this committee at the time, although I would have liked to be. [Republican Sen. Chuck Grassley of Iowa] was the ranking member. Dozens of Republican amendments were offered and accepted in that hearing process.

“And when you say that you’re inviting us – and we heard you, Mr. Secretary, just say, ‘We’d love your support’ – for what? We don’t even know. We have no idea what’s being proposed. There’s a group of guys in a back room somewhere that are making these decisions. There were no hearings in the House.

“I mean, listen, this is hard to take. Because I know we made mistakes [when the ACA came together], Mr. Secretary. And one of the criticisms we got over and over again that the vote was partisan. Well you couldn’t have a more partisan exercise than what you’re engaged in right now. We’re not even going to have a hearing on a bill that impacts one-sixth of our economy. We’re not going to have an opportunity to offer a single amendment. It is all being done with an eye to try to get it by with 50 votes and the vice president.

“I am stunned that that’s what [Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell] would call regular order, which he sanctimoniously said would be the order of the day when the Republicans took the Senate over. We are now so far from regular order that the newer members don’t even know what it looks like.”

http://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow-...s-slam-senate-republicans-health-care-process

It is almost as if being lying hypocritical scumbags doesn't bother Republicans.
 
1/ Why don't hospitals that have emergency rooms (probably not all, but certainly most) set up adjacent "urgent care" facilities?
All large hospitals have some system of managing non-emergent patients. Small hospitals might not. I don't know why this is such a surprise to EC. It's still more expensive to provide non-urgent care in a clinic attached to the ED, but less than using the ED resources.

2/ What percentage of people, even with insurance, don't have regular doctors? I suspect that the number is high. Parents of young kids usually have pediatricians, but many adults don't even get physicals, which is sort of the gateway to establishing a continuing relationship with a doc. I have good corporate insurance, but if I got sick (a rare occurrence) I would go to a walk-in clinic before I tried to make an appointment with a doc.
Which is why there is a good market for walk-in clinics.
 
1/ Why don't hospitals that have emergency rooms (probably not all, but certainly most) set up adjacent "urgent care" facilities? If you show up in an ambulance bleeding from a gunshot, you go to the ER; if you bring in your kid with a runny nose or a sprained ankle, you get routed to UC. Maybe the providers have a financial incentive not to make lower-cost care more available?
Most hospitals nowadays do have some kind of urgent care component to the ERs in order to deal with the large amount of patients who seek non-emergent care. The problem is that delivering urgent care through a hospital is still not cheap and therefore, almost nobody provides this urgent care for free. That kid with the runny nose or sprained ankle will be asked to pay for the care provided in the urgent care center or be sent home.

2/ What percentage of people, even with insurance, don't have regular doctors? I suspect that the number is high. Parents of young kids usually have pediatricians, but many adults don't even get physicals, which is sort of the gateway to establishing a continuing relationship with a doc. I have good corporate insurance, but if I got sick (a rare occurrence) I would go to a walk-in clinic before I tried to make an appointment with a doc.
This is a fundamental problem with our healthcare system -the tendency of most Americans to avoid doctors. Most of us don't really value preventive care or the idea of having a personal doctor. Hell, I'm married to a doctor, I run a primary care clinic and I have great insurance -I still don't ever go to a doctor unless I'm really feeling bad. It takes a health scare to get most of us motivated to see doctors.

The debate over healthcare, therefore, focuses on the wrong things. Why mandate all this preventive coverage that very few people actually want or use? We should design our system around the way most people interact with it.
 
Here is what Claire McCaskill said about that.



http://www.msnbc.com/rachel-maddow-...s-slam-senate-republicans-health-care-process

It is almost as if being lying hypocritical scumbags doesn't bother Republicans.


I am ashamed of Republicans in Washington, which is unfortunate because I am a registered Republican and a Republican who did not vote for Trump for the obvious reason that he has proven he is incompetent and unfit to be president of the United States. I am also a Republican who is against the GOP's healthcare bill, which I consider a bad joke. It is no longer a secret that Trump is now losing Republican support. We can also take a look at those angry townhouse meetings.
'
 
Last edited:
.....
This is a fundamental problem with our healthcare system -the tendency of most Americans to avoid doctors. Most of us don't really value preventive care or the idea of having a personal doctor. Hell, I'm married to a doctor, I run a primary care clinic and I have great insurance -I still don't ever go to a doctor unless I'm really feeling bad. It takes a health scare to get most of us motivated to see doctors.

The debate over healthcare, therefore, focuses on the wrong things. Why mandate all this preventive coverage that very few people actually want or use? We should design our system around the way most people interact with it.

I'm not sure that's true. I think women, if they have decent insurance, are more likely than men to have regular doctors for routine care, and parents of young children, again if they have decent insurance, usually have pediatricians. What's true for stubborn adult men isn't necessarily true for the entire population. In your particular case, I'll bet your physician-wife would drag you to a doctor if she observed something unusual, even if it didn't worry you.

The question is what came first: Do most people interact with our system as they do now because that's really what they want, or because that's what our system encourages? If the system changed to provide universal coverage with an emphasis on preventative care, would behavior change? Again, other countries seem to provide better care at a lower cost per person. We should be able to do that too.
 
Most hospitals nowadays do have some kind of urgent care component to the ERs in order to deal with the large amount of patients who seek non-emergent care. The problem is that delivering urgent care through a hospital is still not cheap and therefore, almost nobody provides this urgent care for free. That kid with the runny nose or sprained ankle will be asked to pay for the care provided in the urgent care center or be sent home.
.....

Obviously treatment will suit the circumstances. A patient with a nose bleed is not going to get a brain MRI. The question is whether that ER still bills that patient at ER rates, which usually include a fat facilities charge at the door, or whether the patient will be routed to an urgent care office with lower fees. From press reports, it sounds like everybody who sets foot in an ER gets charged for an ER visit, even if he gets sent home with a bandaid.
 
Obviously treatment will suit the circumstances. A patient with a nose bleed is not going to get a brain MRI. The question is whether that ER still bills that patient at ER rates, which usually include a fat facilities charge at the door, or whether the patient will be routed to an urgent care office with lower fees. From press reports, it sounds like everybody who sets foot in an ER gets charged for an ER visit, even if he gets sent home with a bandaid.
Were you aware a nosebleed in some patients can be fatal? Seriously.
 
Were you aware a nosebleed in some patients can be fatal? Seriously.

I believe you, although it would probably be more accurate to say it could be a symptom of a fatal condition, not deadly by itself (except maybe hemophilia, right?). And if it's the result of a kid catching an elbow at a soccer match, he's probably not going to need intensive care. My question was whether someone who presents and is treated for a minor condition at an ER is charged full, profitable ER rates, when he could be sent to an urgent care and be charged much less.
 
Last edited:
I believe you, although it would probably be more accurate to say it could be a symptom of a fatal condition, not deadly by itself (except maybe hemophilia, right?). And if it's the result of a kid catching an elbow at a soccer match, he's probably not going to need intensive care.
[sidenote] Cardiovascular disease mostly, but it's still the nosebleed that is the problem. Believe it or not, older men in particular have very serious nosebleeds, requiring cautery and packing.

You are right that nosebleed in kids is not going to be fatal.

Deaths occur when the ED staff believe erroneously that nosebleeds are not serious.

FATAL EPISTAXIS
An awareness on the part of the physician of the potentially fatal significance of his patient's nosebleed is the very best insurance against such an event.
[/sidenote]


My question was whether someone who presents and is treated for a minor condition at an ER is charged full, profitable ER rates, when he could be sent to an urgent care and be charged much less.
It's not so simple as being cheaper through door #1 and more costly through door #2. There are lots of variables I don't want to spend too much time going through. People can search the literature if they are interested.

Any patient showing up in the ED has to be triaged. Sending one to urgent care and one to the ED cost the same to that point.

Often the demand drops after hours so the urgent care won't usually be open 24 hours.

Anyway, there are lots of other variables.
 
Last edited:
The debate over healthcare, therefore, focuses on the wrong things. Why mandate all this preventive coverage that very few people actually want or use? We should design our system around the way most people interact with it.

Preventive coverage means a lot to those of us who had children.

Getting dental care for kids is paramount. It was possible with Medicaid but the waits
were at least 90 days and usually longer.

Preventive care will give children the skills needed to stay healthy as adults.

Age appropriate education about living a healthy lifestyle, including nutrition and
emotional balance will reduce costs in the long run.
 
Obviously treatment will suit the circumstances. A patient with a nose bleed is not going to get a brain MRI. The question is whether that ER still bills that patient at ER rates, which usually include a fat facilities charge at the door, or whether the patient will be routed to an urgent care office with lower fees. From press reports, it sounds like everybody who sets foot in an ER gets charged for an ER visit, even if he gets sent home with a bandaid.

An ER visit is paid at one rate, Urgent Care at another slightly lower rate and regular office visits a much lower rate than either. If you go to a hospital you will be charged a facility fee on top of the visit charges. Example: My wife is a family medicine doc currently employed by a hospital-based clinic. She bills the same office visit codes we bill in private practice (and is reimbursed at the same rate) but the hospital also tacks on a facility fee.

In hospitals that have attached urgent care centers, the triage nurses decide who goes where and the visit is charged accordingly. That's why they are allowed to bill facility fees. In the case of the clinic where my wife works, I have vehemently disagreed with the hospital charging a facility fee -it seems like gouging to me and they don't really have higher expenses than a private practice does. But since they are allowed to, they do it. Yet another example of the waste inherent in our system.

What I was getting at though, is that if you don't have an issue that requires ER stabilization (and therefore falls under ERISA) then most hospitals will turn away people who can't pay for urgent care services.
 
I am ashamed of Republicans in Washington, which is unfortunate because I am a registered Republican and a Republican who did not vote for Trump for the obvious reason that he has proven he is incompetent and unfit to be president of the United States. I am also a Republican who is against the GOP's healthcare bill, which I consider a bad joke. It is no longer a secret that Trump is now losing Republican support. We can also take a look at those angry townhouse meetings.
'

Do you mind telling us why you are still a registered Republican? Not that I mind a Republican that is against Trump and his attempt to take away healthcare away from tens of millions of people so rich people can get a tax cut.
 
I'm not sure that's true. I think women, if they have decent insurance, are more likely than men to have regular doctors for routine care, and parents of young children, again if they have decent insurance, usually have pediatricians. What's true for stubborn adult men isn't necessarily true for the entire population. In your particular case, I'll bet your physician-wife would drag you to a doctor if she observed something unusual, even if it didn't worry you.

The question is what came first: Do most people interact with our system as they do now because that's really what they want, or because that's what our system encourages? If the system changed to provide universal coverage with an emphasis on preventative care, would behavior change? Again, other countries seem to provide better care at a lower cost per person. We should be able to do that too.
In the UK the NHSs have a problem with (especially) young(ish) men not seeking early medical attention They have actually ran campaigns to try and encourage people to seek early medical attention. So it is very unlikely that costs causes this problem.

ETA https://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&s...IlYvko8BkHzOZlOKg&sig2=x37w2_Pyx2wrX6Gc01BoyA
 
Last edited:
In the UK the NHSs have a problem with (especially) young(ish) men not seeking early medical attention
My nephew died of colon cancer at the age of 47. He lived a long way from the rest of the family, unfortunately, and no-one had seen him for several months when he finally dropped in on another aunt, who insisted he go to a doctor when she saw how ill he was. The doctor took one look at him and called an ambulance. He died less than 3 months later.
 
1/ Why don't hospitals that have emergency rooms (probably not all, but certainly most) set up adjacent "urgent care" facilities? If you show up in an ambulance bleeding from a gunshot, you go to the ER; if you bring in your kid with a runny nose or a sprained ankle, you get routed to UC. Maybe the providers have a financial incentive not to make lower-cost care more available?
Trying to figure that out myself. If I were to speculate, I'd say it's a cost issue. The couple of hospitals that have UC clinics in them charge less than ER, but still quite a bit more than a regular doctor's visit. Stand-alone UCs, on the other hand, tend to charge only slightly higher than a regular doctor's visit. I would guess that insurance carriers haven't been supportive of the Hospital-based UC model for that reason, although I'm far from certain.


2/ What percentage of people, even with insurance, don't have regular doctors? I suspect that the number is high. Parents of young kids usually have pediatricians, but many adults don't even get physicals, which is sort of the gateway to establishing a continuing relationship with a doc. I have good corporate insurance, but if I got sick (a rare occurrence) I would go to a walk-in clinic before I tried to make an appointment with a doc.
Good points here, and you're pretty normal on this. Most healthy-ish people don't really have strong relationships with their primary care doctor. Unless they have a persistent condition of some sort, there's not relationship there. And yeah, it's often preferable even for me to go see UC doc for a cold than to try to get in to my primary.
 
All large hospitals have some system of managing non-emergent patients. Small hospitals might not. I don't know why this is such a surprise to EC. It's still more expensive to provide non-urgent care in a clinic attached to the ED, but less than using the ED resources.

What makes you think this is a surprise? Or are you merely speculating once again?
 
I'm not sure that's true. I think women, if they have decent insurance, are more likely than men to have regular doctors for routine care, and parents of young children, again if they have decent insurance, usually have pediatricians. What's true for stubborn adult men isn't necessarily true for the entire population. In your particular case, I'll bet your physician-wife would drag you to a doctor if she observed something unusual, even if it didn't worry you.
Most women only see a doctor regularly because they hold us hostage - if you want your oral contraceptive prescription renewed, you have to go in for a pelvic exam. But make no mistake - just because women go to a doctor once a year doesn't mean they actually build a relationship outside of the speculum and slides. Many women opt for gynecologists for their annual pelvic exam, which means they're not really talking to them about other health concerns or developments.

Most people (both male and female) will make sure to get their kids to a pediatrician. But adults (both male and female) don't really develop a strong relationship with their primary care doctor until they have a condition or a scare.

The question is what came first: Do most people interact with our system as they do now because that's really what they want, or because that's what our system encourages? If the system changed to provide universal coverage with an emphasis on preventative care, would behavior change? Again, other countries seem to provide better care at a lower cost per person. We should be able to do that too.
Little from column A, little from column B. I would guess that the largest influence is from column C: the US has way too many specialists and not enough generalists. It makes it difficult to get a timely appointment with a generalist, which complicates the whole "building a relationship" thing. You end up having to schedule your annual physicals and such two to three months ahead, and if you have something moderately urgent crop up, you're still often looking at a wait of several weeks.

The next most reasonable question would be" Why doe the US have so few generalists per capita? A lot of it is because it's a private market - specialists get paid a lot more than generalists.
 
Most women only see a doctor regularly because they hold us hostage - if you want your oral contraceptive prescription renewed, you have to go in for a pelvic exam. But make no mistake - just because women go to a doctor once a year doesn't mean they actually build a relationship outside of the speculum and slides. Many women opt for gynecologists for their annual pelvic exam, which means they're not really talking to them about other health concerns or developments.

Most people (both male and female) will make sure to get their kids to a pediatrician. But adults (both male and female) don't really develop a strong relationship with their primary care doctor until they have a condition or a scare.
I think this is pretty spot on. I don't think adult women are any better at consulting docs for preventive/routine care than adult men are. In my experience, pediatricians are extremely busy because everyone takes their kids to the doctor; a pediatrician has an extremely large patient panel and those patients each generate multiple visits per year each. Parents are hyper-concerned with the wellbeing of their children and I think there's a large amount of overutilization in the pediatric market. Practices that focus on adults, OTOH, have smaller panels and only a small percentage of the panel has multiple visits per year. Pediatricians see 50+ patients per day; adult specialists see 25 or so. Of course, the big caveat here is that this is only my experience in my neck of the woods, but reading the industry rags seems to bear that out in the larger market.

Bottom line: Everyone takes their kids to the doctor even for relatively minor things while most adults avoid doctors until they really need them. There are a lot of reasons for that: we have to take time off of work, we don't want to face our mortality, we don't consider it important . . . I don't think cost is a big factor for most people.

Little from column A, little from column B. I would guess that the largest influence is from column C: the US has way too many specialists and not enough generalists.
This is undoubtedly true. Primary care is not as lucrative but it's also a tougher field. A specialist makes more money but only has to focus on one system or disease process.
It makes it difficult to get a timely appointment with a generalist, which complicates the whole "building a relationship" thing. You end up having to schedule your annual physicals and such two to three months ahead, and if you have something moderately urgent crop up, you're still often looking at a wait of several weeks.
This is the number one factor as to why adults don't go to the doctor. It takes so long to get in that by the time you actually are scheduled to see the doctor, you probably aren't sick anymore. We combat that problem by only scheduling half our slots in advance and leaving the other slots open for walk-in/urgent. Not all doctors operate that way, of course. The fear is: what if you don't get any walk-in/urgent patients? It's much safer to be fully booked every day.

The next most reasonable question would be" Why doe the US have so few generalists per capita? A lot of it is because it's a private market - specialists get paid a lot more than generalists.
Yes. When you are in med school, it's almost looked at as a failure if you decide to choose Family Medicine or other Primary Care -as if you know you aren't competitive enough to get into the "good" specialties so you "settled" for Primary Care. I think that's a very sad situation but it is what it is.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom