Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
Most health insurance (there are a few exceptions, generally under short-term care or critical care policies) already emphasize prevention over catastrophic care, and have done so since before ACA.
There is no way to know at the time of the expense if the person will even be a client at the point where the savings actually occur. This reduces the incentive to really push preventative care. There is also the matter of people with no insurance, either by choice or necessity who skimp on preventative care only to “opt in” when the consequences of doing so come calling. Finally, there is an available cost saving option for catastrophic care, that being to find a way to drop the customer.

All this is going to add up to less effective preventative care and more reliance on catastrophic care than single payer universal systems, and the results bare this out. The US relies more on catastrophic care and spends more on catastrophic care per capita than anyone else, and this is a major source of higher healthcare costs in the US.


Who is responsible for paying the bill is independent of how much the bill tallies to.

This is wrong. In a market economy there is less incentive to spend now to save later if you may not be the one benefiting from those savings. Therefore any non-single payer system incentivises higher long term costs.
 
I was mentally compartmentalizing lobbyists with the 2nd bullet regarding shareowners who are concerned about lost future earnings.

All four categories probably have lobbying representation, as do patient advocates who are pitching single payer.

I was more trying to indicate the politicians as one of the problem groups, as opposed to the lobbyists. That might be my own natural cynicism though - I tend to think that very, very few politicians actually hold any solid ideological views; they mostly just adopt whatever position they think will get them elected next time around.

I would agree with lumping lobbyists in with the shareholders though :)
 
There is no way to know at the time of the expense if the person will even be a client at the point where the savings actually occur. This reduces the incentive to really push preventative care.

Question for anyone who might know: Do countries with single payer tend to put more resources into preventative care than the US? If yes, do those expenditures actually contribute significantly to overall lower health care costs?
 
There is no way to know at the time of the expense if the person will even be a client at the point where the savings actually occur. This reduces the incentive to really push preventative care. There is also the matter of people with no insurance, either by choice or necessity who skimp on preventative care only to “opt in” when the consequences of doing so come calling. Finally, there is an available cost saving option for catastrophic care, that being to find a way to drop the customer.
For a whole host of reasons, most comprehensive medical insurance does push preventive care. The degree of push might vary from company to company, but it's never absent. From personal experience, there've been long-running arguments about whether it makes sense to push for preventive screenings that don't prevent (they're actually early detection), especially when the cost of the screening applied across the board is significantly higher than the cost to treat the condition being screened for. Regardless of the economic sense of the argument, it's never been adopted at my company.

All this is going to add up to less effective preventative care and more reliance on catastrophic care than single payer universal systems, and the results bare this out. The US relies more on catastrophic care and spends more on catastrophic care per capita than anyone else, and this is a major source of higher healthcare costs in the US.

Well, no. I see what you're saying, but the vast majority of catastrophic care isn't anything that preventive care would have prevented. Most of it isn't even things that preventive care would have detected early. Even in those common cases like breast cancer and prostate cancer, the costs are still catastrophic, even with earlier detection - cancer is still cancer, even when identified early. Some of the biggest catastrophic costs come from trauma, complications of delivery during pregnancy (especially neonatal ICU cases), and orphan diseases. A bigger push on preventive screenings won't materially effect those.

It's true that the US spends a lot more on catastrophic things than other countries. But I don't think it's reasonable to attribute that to a lack of preventive care. One of the big confounding factors is end-of-life costs. The US spends far more on terminal cases than other countries, and spends a lot more on last-ditch hail-mary cures than anywhere else. That's a big contributor to those catastrophic costs that I think you're overlooking.

This is wrong. In a market economy there is less incentive to spend now to save later if you may not be the one benefiting from those savings. Therefore any non-single payer system incentivises higher long term costs.
I don't understand your statement here. Who is it that would be spending now to save later? I'm talking about the cost of delivered care - the prices that the doctors, hospitals, pharmaceuticals, and device & supply manufacturers charge to deliver actual care to patients. I suspect that your statement is aimed at something different?
 
Question for anyone who might know: Do countries with single payer tend to put more resources into preventative care than the US? If yes, do those expenditures actually contribute significantly to overall lower health care costs?

I think the challenge to answering that question is going to bog down in definitions.

The 'stitch in time' approach is less about preventive care than early detection of something that will get expensive later if left untreated.

To illustrate the difference... BC doesn't cover an on-demand annual checkup. I think that's what a lot of people have in mind when they year about 'preventive care'. Annual visits based on nothing more than a calendar - no symptoms - is a demonstrated waste of resources. So by that definition, we don't spend any resources on 'preventive' care like that.

On the other hand, I had a colleague who complained about his fingers sort of going to sleep a lot, pins and needles, like he'd slept on his arm wrong. He went to his GP and was referred immediately to a CT scan appointment, which showed a severely damaged C4, C5, C6 discs (congenital disorder), and he was operated on the next day. Back at work in a week. The surgeon said a few more days and the nerve would have been dead, my friend would have been on permanent disability, no use of right hand. At no time was there a gateway moment where my friend hesitated to proceed due to a cost.

And in contrast, I had a coworker who was an American contractor working at our plant in Richmond. He sliced his hand pretty badly. His GP said he had an opening in two weeks. OK: that's not on, so it took hours to locate an 'in network' hospital in Washington state (I drove him across the border). Copayment for the visit. He balked at the copayment for the various recommended tests and abandoned the primary assessment before getting results. He cleaned and bandaged it and grunted through his shifts. A month later he was off work with a severe infection that almost cost him his hand, and couldn't resume duties for about three months, lost his job.

These experiences jibe with the high level overview statistics. This isn't just a human tragedy: it's an economic fiasco that makes the USA uncompetitive in 2017. As a capitalist pig dog who started several businesses, the thought of entangling my business up in all that wasteful effing time and paperwork with my employees' health plans sounds like the last thing I'd want to divert my precious business resources into. And now Americans are facing four years of employers getting all up in their employees' reproductive rights and so on. Who would willingly choose this?
 
Last edited:
This might be a dumb question as I don't know much about this stuff.

I see above on this page that someone mentioned cutting costs - well I'll just get to the question.

I had an MRI at a county hospital once. My insurance was billed $4500 for that and the evaluation. I know the cost because I had to sue AAA after someone hit me and my car on the freeway (luckily I was in it ;)).

I had another MRI one year later, but this time I went to a private company. This MRI cost me out of pocket $515 out the door, including evaluation.

My question is, wtf? ;) 4500 vs 500 for the same thing? Is the 4500 paying for people without insurance? That seems pretty gawdamn high, especially since I had to pay it off after receiving my meager settlement!

Ripped. Off.

This may be oversimplifying the issue, but can't a gigantic amount of savings come from this? Like I said, totally ignorant question, ignore it if it's too stupid.

Is overhead that much at a hospital?
 
This might be a dumb question as I don't know much about this stuff.

I see above on this page that someone mentioned cutting costs - well I'll just get to the question.

I had an MRI at a county hospital once. My insurance was billed $4500 for that and the evaluation. I know the cost because I had to sue AAA after someone hit me and my car on the freeway (luckily I was in it ;)).

I had another MRI one year later, but this time I went to a private company. This MRI cost me out of pocket $515 out the door, including evaluation.

My question is, wtf? ;) 4500 vs 500 for the same thing? Is the 4500 paying for people without insurance? That seems pretty gawdamn high, especially since I had to pay it off after receiving my meager settlement!

Ripped. Off.

This may be oversimplifying the issue, but can't a gigantic amount of savings come from this? Like I said, totally ignorant question, ignore it if it's too stupid.

Is overhead that much at a hospital?

The marketing concept you're describing is called [Price Discrimination] (aka Discriminatory Pricing)

The actual baseline price is proprietary information for the supplier. They may find that they get more revenue from the capital by charging rich customers more money than poor customers and hoping they don't organize into a consumer's union.

I once worked in a mall that charged different customers different rent per square footage, depending on how well they were doing. (some malls have a percentage model, making it official)
 
Last edited:
This might be a dumb question as I don't know much about this stuff.

I see above on this page that someone mentioned cutting costs - well I'll just get to the question.

I had an MRI at a county hospital once. My insurance was billed $4500 for that and the evaluation. I know the cost because I had to sue AAA after someone hit me and my car on the freeway (luckily I was in it ;)).

I had another MRI one year later, but this time I went to a private company. This MRI cost me out of pocket $515 out the door, including evaluation.

My question is, wtf? ;) 4500 vs 500 for the same thing? Is the 4500 paying for people without insurance? That seems pretty gawdamn high, especially since I had to pay it off after receiving my meager settlement!

Ripped. Off.

This may be oversimplifying the issue, but can't a gigantic amount of savings come from this? Like I said, totally ignorant question, ignore it if it's too stupid.

Is overhead that much at a hospital?

And you've hit it in a nutshell.

It's so messy there's no good answer. There's no consistency in pricing. Average MRI costs run around $3000, give or take. The 'give or take' part of that depends on how new the MRI machine is, specifically what kind of MRI machine it is, how many uses that machine sees per measure of time, and the 'going rate' in that location... as well as whether that particular provider charges the same price to various different insurers let alone whether they charge a separate 'walk-in' rate for people who don't have insurance and are paying in full at the point of sale. Needless to say, there's a really large standard deviation on that average.

This is true for almost every other labtest, screening, and exam out there, as well as for every different doctor, specialist, and nurse.

And of course, there's also the fact that each different provider group will end up having a different method of contracting with each different insurance carrier they do business with. Some will charge fee-for-service, where every specific procedure is itemized. This is great if they're only doing one procedure... not so great when they start adding unnecessary procedures because that's how they get more money. Others will have capitated arrangements, where they're paid the same amount per month for each patient that is attributed to them. Again, that's great when they're seeing an average person for an average problem. It's not so great when one doctor ends up with a disproportionate number of more complex cases and loses money. It's also not great when a provider shrinks their time with patients in order to fit many more patients into their schedule so they get paid more money for having more patients. Some providers arrange for bundled pricing, or for pay-for-performance arrangements. Some put outcomes at risk and share profits. There are so many horribly complicated ways that insurers try to contract with providers to try to keep costs down and avoid perverse incentives... and none of them work well. They all have problems. And every time a problem is identified... someone invents another new and creative way to contract with providers that everyone is happy to give a go until it also breaks.

Holy cow, I think I may have been in this line of work too long. I've become quite jaded.
 
For a whole host of reasons, most comprehensive medical insurance does push preventive care. The degree of push might vary from company to company, but it's never absent.

I never said they were absent I said there is less incentive to do it as well as it should be done. The fact that there are different levels of attention to it highlights that this is indeed happening.

Well, no. I see what you're saying, but the vast majority of catastrophic care isn't anything that preventive care would have prevented.

Early diagnosis of cancer and heart disease, which are among the most costly things to treat, make treatment much more affordable and much more effective. This requires people actually see a doctor on a regular basis and go to one immediately of they think there is something wrong. This is something many people are unable to do or discouraged from doing under the US system.
I don't understand your statement here. Who is it that would be spending now to save later?

The insurance company you are paying now may not be responsible for costs in the future. You may switch insurance companies, you may get dropped, you may go on Medicare, etc. Free markets do not function efficiently when you have transitions like this where costs may not be paid by the parties involved. This skews the market to a less efficient state.
 
I never said they were absent I said there is less incentive to do it as well as it should be done. The fact that there are different levels of attention to it highlights that this is indeed happening.



Early diagnosis of cancer and heart disease, which are among the most costly things to treat, make treatment much more affordable and much more effective. This requires people actually see a doctor on a regular basis...

I half agree. This is the part that's hard to convey to the lay public: seeing a doctor on a regular basis probably isn't net beneficial, and may actually be net harmful.

and go to one immediately of they think there is something wrong.

This is the part I agree with.


This is something many people are unable to do or discouraged from doing under the US system.

And also agree with. This was the purpose of my long winded anecdotes in an earlier post. My coworker turned down recommended valid tests for his hand wound because of cost. That's just not even a thing in Canada.

I tripped over this yesterday: [1-In-4 Families Don’t Seek Medical Attention Because Of Financial Worries]



The insurance company you are paying now may not be responsible for costs in the future. You may switch insurance companies, you may get dropped, you may go on Medicare, etc. Free markets do not function efficiently when you have transitions like this where costs may not be paid by the parties involved. This skews the market to a less efficient state.

The economic / commerce terminology for that is "cost shifting."

Wikipedia: [Cost Shifting]

An advantage of single payer, is that it reduces (*) cost shifting, since the business units all roll up to the same consolidated budget. There is no bottom line incentive to dumping the problem into another caregiver, since they're just another part of the same organization. So rules are put in place to optimize responsibilities with a mind to overall metrics. (which can be a balance of cost containment versus patient health)

As a matter of interest, US insurers went through a phase where they were dumping patients onto the Canadian system to save money. It was a bone of contention because it was not using our cross border health emergencies agreement in good faith. Basically, they'd load patients who were on a waitlist for expensive surgeries within their own networks onto cruise ships that stopped at Port of Vancouver, wherein the patient would declare a health emergency and they would be hurried to SPH or VGH or UBC Hospital for urgent surgery.



(*) Note: single payer does not eliminate cost shifting. We have a problem in Canada called "golden tickets" for mental health patients. Let's say a person lives all his life in BC, then has a psychotic episode and flies to Ontario, where he's diagnosed. Ontario may buy him a bus ticket back to Vancouver telling him to check himself into a hospital when he arrives, when in fact, they should be caring for him in the province of diagnosis.
 
Last edited:
<snip>

(*) Note: single payer does not eliminate cost shifting. We have a problem in Canada called "golden tickets" for mental health patients. Let's say a person lives all his life in BC, then has a psychotic episode and flies to Ontario, where he's diagnosed. Ontario may buy him a bus ticket back to Vancouver telling him to check himself into a hospital when he arrives, when in fact, they should be caring for him in the province of diagnosis.


In the U.S version of that (and not just mental patients, although they are probably a high percentage of the total), the hospitals just hire a cab or something, load 'em up, and have 'em dumped out on the street in front of (hopefully) the nearest convenient homeless shelter or free clinic.

Where they may or may not find their way inside.
 
I never said they were absent I said there is less incentive to do it as well as it should be done. The fact that there are different levels of attention to it highlights that this is indeed happening.

Early diagnosis of cancer and heart disease, which are among the most costly things to treat, make treatment much more affordable and much more effective. This requires people actually see a doctor on a regular basis and go to one immediately of they think there is something wrong. This is something many people are unable to do or discouraged from doing under the US system.
Point is though that most of those still end up being catastrophically expensive. Somewhat less catastrophically expensive, perhaps, but still catastrophic. Pair that with the fact that many preventive screenings cost more in aggregate when applied to large volumes of people than the cost of treating a slightly later identification of an issue. And the very best preventative measures - healthy diet and exercise - are things that nobody can manage to get people to do, regardless of their tests coming back as pre-diabetic or hypertensive.

The insurance company you are paying now may not be responsible for costs in the future. You may switch insurance companies, you may get dropped, you may go on Medicare, etc. Free markets do not function efficiently when you have transitions like this where costs may not be paid by the parties involved. This skews the market to a less efficient state.
True. Thank you for the clarification :)
 
I half agree. This is the part that's hard to convey to the lay public: seeing a doctor on a regular basis probably isn't net beneficial, and may actually be net harmful.

This is the part I agree with.
Yes, agreed.

I'll add that a part of the problem with going to see a doctor immediately when something is wrong, as opposed to annual checkups when nothing is wrong... isn't necessarily about cost. A lot of it is scheduling.

My company sees a lot of avoidable ER visits. We've tried all kinds of messaging and education to get people to use urgent care or just go see their doctors. We finally did some deeper analysis and *gasp* talked to some of our customers! We found out a couple of things.

1) Time is a bigger factor than cost. The ER is going to cost waaaaay more than a regular doctor visit or an urgent care visit, but appealing to people's wallets doesn't get it done. Turns out people have a difficult time getting timely appointments with their doctors, they end up with appointments two to four weeks out.

2) Access to care is a problem. Lots of people in hourly jobs can't get time to see their doctor... and most urgent care clinics aren't open late. Many of them in my immediate vicinity are open mostly during business hours and on Saturday, but closed on Sunday. That's not a lot of help for many people. They can't get off work until the urgent care clinic is closed.
 
The economic / commerce terminology for that is "cost shifting."

Wikipedia: [Cost Shifting]

An advantage of single payer, is that it reduces (*) cost shifting, since the business units all roll up to the same consolidated budget. There is no bottom line incentive to dumping the problem into another caregiver, since they're just another part of the same organization. So rules are put in place to optimize responsibilities with a mind to overall metrics. (which can be a balance of cost containment versus patient health)

In the case of heath insurance everyone, expect maybe the US government is engaged in some form of cost shifting under the current system. This makes it a little like a giant prisoner’s dilemma game. Remember in the Prisoners Dilemma the rules of the game favor both parties betraying and accepting a less than optimal result because it’s still better than trusting the other party and being betrayed.

In the case of the US healthcare system insurance companies must shift costly subscribers to other insurance companies as aggressively as possible else they may end up as the victim of the cost shifting from other providers. This costs them a lot of money, but it’s still cheaper than having all the expensive subscribers dumped in your lap by other providers. Provider in this case could either be another insurance company of simply a subscriber who decides to be a free rider and “opt out” of paying premiums until they have an expensive condition.

The overall result is that everyone needs to spend lots of money to make sure they are not the victim of cost shifting, the resulting legal wrangling results in delayed diagnosis (If they don’t know about a condition they can’t bill me for treatment!), worse medical outcomes, more expensive treatment and high administrative overhead for providers of medical care. It's basically lose-lose-lose for everyone involved, but because the losses are less than playing honestly when everyone else is "cheating" everyone has to cheat.
 
In the case of heath insurance everyone, expect maybe the US government is engaged in some form of cost shifting under the current system. This makes it a little like a giant prisoner’s dilemma game. Remember in the Prisoners Dilemma the rules of the game favor both parties betraying and accepting a less than optimal result because it’s still better than trusting the other party and being betrayed.

In the case of the US healthcare system insurance companies must shift costly subscribers to other insurance companies as aggressively as possible else they may end up as the victim of the cost shifting from other providers. This costs them a lot of money, but it’s still cheaper than having all the expensive subscribers dumped in your lap by other providers. Provider in this case could either be another insurance company of simply a subscriber who decides to be a free rider and “opt out” of paying premiums until they have an expensive condition.

The overall result is that everyone needs to spend lots of money to make sure they are not the victim of cost shifting, the resulting legal wrangling results in delayed diagnosis (If they don’t know about a condition they can’t bill me for treatment!), worse medical outcomes, more expensive treatment and high administrative overhead for providers of medical care. It's basically lose-lose-lose for everyone involved, but because the losses are less than playing honestly when everyone else is "cheating" everyone has to cheat.


Unrestrained free market capitalism in a nutshell.

Cheaters win.

(They just don't win quite as much.)
 
Unrestrained free market capitalism in a nutshell.

Cheaters win.

(They just don't win quite as much.)

In this case they lose, they just lose less then they would have had they not used the underhanded tactics.
 
Unrestrained free market capitalism in a nutshell.
....


A physician's guide to why health care costs so much:
The Affordable Care Act was misnamed; it should have been called the Access to Unaffordable Care Act. In 2015 health care spending reached $3.2 trillion — $10,000 for every man, woman and child in America. While our health care system is the most expensive in the world by far, on many measures of performance it ranked last out of 11 developed countries, according to a 2014 Commonwealth Fund Report.
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/03/opinion/sunday/the-specialists-stranglehold-on-medicine.html

And Americans are starting to lean toward a single-payer system:
https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/03/us/democrats-universal-health-care-single-payer-party.html?_r=0
 
....
My company sees a lot of avoidable ER visits. We've tried all kinds of messaging and education to get people to use urgent care or just go see their doctors. We finally did some deeper analysis and *gasp* talked to some of our customers! We found out a couple of things.
.....

1/ Why don't hospitals that have emergency rooms (probably not all, but certainly most) set up adjacent "urgent care" facilities? If you show up in an ambulance bleeding from a gunshot, you go to the ER; if you bring in your kid with a runny nose or a sprained ankle, you get routed to UC. Maybe the providers have a financial incentive not to make lower-cost care more available?

2/ What percentage of people, even with insurance, don't have regular doctors? I suspect that the number is high. Parents of young kids usually have pediatricians, but many adults don't even get physicals, which is sort of the gateway to establishing a continuing relationship with a doc. I have good corporate insurance, but if I got sick (a rare occurrence) I would go to a walk-in clinic before I tried to make an appointment with a doc.
 
Last edited:
Conservatives near revolt on Senate health care negotiations

Conservative senators and allied outside groups are on the verge of rebellion against the Senate’s Obamacare repeal effort, potentially derailing delicate negotiations to overhaul the nation’s healthcare system.

As Obamacare repeal talks enter crunchtime with a vote as soon as this month, the Senate bill continues to tilt toward more moderate members of the GOP on keeping some of Obamacare’s regulatory structure and providing a more generous wind-down of the law’s Medicaid expansion. The movement has made Republicans increasingly pessimistic that two critical conservative senators, Mike Lee of Utah and Rand Paul of Kentucky, will be able to vote for the GOP’s ultimate agreement on healthcare, according to senators and aides.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom