Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
I know where he's going with this.

One current trend in health care is finding that too much screening can actually be disadvantageous, because all tests can throw false positives. If you get, say, a mammogram every week, sooner or later they'll find something that looks off enough for further investigation, despite it being intrusive, and expensive and almost certainly fruitless.

It may be hard to imagine someone able to understand the above without also coming to appreciate the positive effects of preventative care, but that's our sunmaster14. No facts are too apparent for him to circumspectly ignore in pursuit of his bias.

There is no reason ineffective preventative care can't be addressed when one offers preventative care. And in fact, that's why there are reviews in the first place of care that show if we are detecting/preventing disease or doing more harm than good.
 
Last edited:
I was thinking about this earlier - do you know what the figure was?

According to this, millions. And keep in mind that in the U.S. the vast majority of people are covered by group plans that must cover everybody in the group. Applicants with pre-existing conditions were rejected in the individual market at a high rate.

http://healthnetwork.com/blog/befor...ecause-of-pre-existing-conditions-today-none/
http://www.healthinsurance.org/blog/2015/08/19/why-pre-existing-conditions-mattered-to-millions/
 
Removing the state boundaries and the independent regulations within each state actually would help.

How? There's no Federal restrictions on insurance location, just local ones. Where the local restrictions don't exist the insurance companies have not taken up the offer to sell.

Its just the GOP mantra that they all say to make it seem like they have an idea. Its a variation on the 'we'll close tax loopholes' when asked how they would raise revenue on their lowering taxes.
 
I changed what I think was a mistake on your part. Preventative care is always less expensive than emergency care and is almost always more effective. All preventative healthcare should be free, especially female reproductive and prenatal care.

I agree with everything else you wrote.

[actuarial lecture]

Actually, preventive care is only less expensive when you're looking post-hoc at a person who contracted the condition. That is to say, the cost of a colonoscopy is less than the cost of chemotherapy and surgery for colon cancer. The problem is in the aggregations, and colonoscopies are a really good example.

These are made up numbers - I don't have real numbers easily accessible without having to do a lot of work AND there's a degree of confidentiality involved. The made up numbers are illustrative and directionally appropriate. appropriate.

Let's say that an average colonoscopy costs $250, and is recommended to all men age 50 and older, every 5 years. That equates to about 20% of men in that age range per year. Let's say that works out to 10,000 men in that risk pool. So that's a cost of $2,500,000 per year in colonoscopy costs.

Let's say colon cancer has an incident rate of 1 in 100,000. If colon cancer is identified early, it costs $250,000 to treat. If it is not identified early, it has a cost of $500,000 to treat. For the moment, we're going to ignore the survival rates - they add a high degree of computational complexity that is irrelevant to the pint I'm demonstrating.

The expected cost of early-diagnosis colon cancer treatment in a group that is all receiving preventive care is (incidence rate) * (number of people) * (cost to treat) = (1/100,000) * (10,000) * ($250,000) = $25,000.

The expected cost of late-diagnosis colon cancer treatment us (1/100,000) * (10,000) * ($500,000) = $50,000.

So even though the cost to treat is much higher than the cost to screen for an individual who is identified with colon cancer... the cost to screen everyone is massively higher.

Most preventive care is covered by insurers as goodwill. It's expected, it's the right thing to do, and it makes policyholders feel safer. But it's very rarely financially sound.

Childhood vaccinations, flu shots, and a handful of other immunizations are an exception. These are things that actually *prevent* an illness, and are generally low-cost to administer. Most of the other things that we call "preventive care" don't prevent anything, they're just early detection... and they're often not at all cost-effective.

[/actuarial lecture]
 
actually, the costs of preventive care can be even higher if you account for false positives which trigger an unnecessary operation...
 
Most preventive care is covered by insurers as goodwill. It's expected, it's the right thing to do, and it makes policyholders feel safer. But it's very rarely financially sound.

Actually, the fact (I agree) that preventative care is not financially sound is an argument why it is ludicrous to consider heath care from a free market perspective.

In your example, it is clear that it is far more cost efficient to let people develop advanced colon cancer and treat it than it is to catch it early and prevent it. But if you are going to let people get colon cancer, that means there are those who are going to die as a result. But hey, dying is more cost effective.

Screw that noise. Life has value beyond the cost of treatment.
 
Removing the state boundaries and the independent regulations within each state actually would help.

What that would do would drive insurance companies to move operations to the states with the laxest regulations, like the credit card companies moved to North Dakota in the '80s. What would have helped would have been a national public option, along the lines of Medicare-for-All, that anyone could enroll in if they didn't like the private options available in their states. No chance we'll get that from the Repubs.
 
Emily's Cat said:
respectful snip


I agree, but you're not counting all of the positive externalities. Reducing sick time with early detection and preventative care has an overall positive effect. You get a larger workforce that can work for years longer. You get grandparents who can babysit instead of being sick/dead. I think the positive externalities outweigh the costs.
 
Actually, the fact (I agree) that preventative care is not financially sound is an argument why it is ludicrous to consider heath care from a free market perspective.

In your example, it is clear that it is far more cost efficient to let people develop advanced colon cancer and treat it than it is to catch it early and prevent it. But if you are going to let people get colon cancer, that means there are those who are going to die as a result. But hey, dying is more cost effective.

Screw that noise. Life has value beyond the cost of treatment.

That's the real underlying difficulty. When life is given an infinite (or nearly) value, all the calculations go out the window. The only conceptual remedy I have found is to reframe the calculation from the specific to the general.

So, while my life (and the lives of those I care about) has an infinite value to me, when the available healthcare is finite, I must accept that my use of the system steals care from others. My calculation has to include others who are affected by my needs. Doing this allows me to cancel across infinities by setting one (mine) against other choices.

Maybe I can make another decision if I know the heart I'm not going to get is going to someone else and if I were to get the heart, they would die.

The same trick can be used for care that extends life or even just improves life. If I accept the care available is finite, any that I use necessarily takes away from the pool. Will I choose to live another year if I am convinced I am stealing this time from others?
 
That's a differnet "preventative" then we tend to use in the UK. Preventative healthcare would be helping people lose weight, helping people give up smoking, ensuring they are eating a suitable diet and so on.
 
I agree, but you're not counting all of the positive externalities. Reducing sick time with early detection and preventative care has an overall positive effect. You get a larger workforce that can work for years longer. You get grandparents who can babysit instead of being sick/dead. I think the positive externalities outweigh the costs.

But do those positives make it back to the insurance company? EC was doing that analysis from the perspective of the insurer. Not the employer or society at large.
 
That's a differnet "preventative" then we tend to use in the UK. Preventative healthcare would be helping people lose weight, helping people give up smoking, ensuring they are eating a suitable diet and so on.

If people can't figure that simple stuff out on their own then we deserve to pay for their catastrophic care!
 
But do those positives make it back to the insurance company? EC was doing that analysis from the perspective of the insurer. Not the employer or society at large.

Which is why the view from the bottom of an insurance company ledgers is one of the worst ways to look at healthcare policy.
 
....
The same trick can be used for care that extends life or even just improves life. If I accept the care available is finite, any that I use necessarily takes away from the pool. Will I choose to live another year if I am convinced I am stealing this time from others?

We know everybody dies, and we know that a lot of health care money is spent in the last few months of patients' lives. But serious discussions of how to responsibly identify useful measures vs. "prolonging the inevitable" are invariably portrayed as "death panels" or worse. So that's really a different issue. The question on the table is whether everybody should be able to get the same quality of health care, regardless of whether they have great corporate health insurance or must buy their own insurance in the individual market or must rely on public programs like Medicaid. If my insurance will keep me alive and active for another year, but yours (or your lack thereof) means you die without treatment, is that good for society as a whole? Most other major countries have determined that basic health care is every person's right as a human being. We have not made that decision.
 
We know everybody dies, and we know that a lot of health care money is spent in the last few months of patients' lives. But serious discussions of how to responsibly identify useful measures vs. "prolonging the inevitable" are invariably portrayed as "death panels" or worse. So that's really a different issue. The question on the table is whether everybody should be able to get the same quality of health care, regardless of whether they have great corporate health insurance or must buy their own insurance in the individual market or must rely on public programs like Medicaid. If my insurance will keep me alive and active for another year, but yours (or your lack thereof) means you die without treatment, is that good for society as a whole? Most other major countries have determined that basic health care is every person's right as a human being. We have not made that decision.

At first I was with you, but I think you switched horses there, mid-race.

Equitable division of healthcare would mean, not just that basic healthcare is available to all (at whatever price that happens to be) but that all available healthcare is equally portioned out. There would be no excess to buy because being able to buy more reintroduces the disparity we set out to get rid of.

So you'd not only have to provide basic healthcare, but disallow additional healthcare to anyone. Everyone gets it or no one does. At least that's what we'd need if we want to say it's equitable. But it sounds like you are going to allow for the purchase of services above and beyond "basic" healthcare.

How does this work in practice in countries with universal medical care? Is there still a hierarchy of service driven by the ability to pay?
 
How does this work in practice in countries with universal medical care? Is there still a hierarchy of service driven by the ability to pay?

In practice in the UK this means that if I get ill and need to see a GP, then I don't have to pay anything. If the doctor prescribes medicines, then these will likely be generic but I'll get treatment that's effective. I have to pay a nominal charge per prescription.

If I break my arm, I go to A&E and they patch me up. I pay nothing.

If I have serious accident, I go to A&E and they patch me up. I pay nothing.

If I have a serious illness my GP refers me to specialists and I get appropriate care, whatever that entails, provided that such a treatment is available via the NHS. I pay nothing. (A very small subset of treatments are not available, most things are covered)

For visiting GPs or A&E I might have a longer wait time if my case is not an emergency. I will need to wait a while for non emergency hospital care (things like hip replacements)

If I want to jump the queue and get immediate attention at A&E or the GP or for my non emergency health care. Or I want brand name medicines and not generics, then I am free to take out health insurance policies which can cover part or all of that, for various premiums.


Basically I get free healthcare if I choose. Some novel treatments might not be available, and I might have to wait a long time sometimes.

Private healthcare is available if I choose to pay for it too.

To pay for all of this I pay a higher rate of tax than my compatriots do in the USA, but this is more than offset by the fact that I never have to take out health insurance.

Employers health insurance schemes here are basically unheard of.
 
.....
How does this work in practice in countries with universal medical care? Is there still a hierarchy of service driven by the ability to pay?

In most systems people can buy more elective stuff for themselves: nose jobs, Lasik, etc. Or maybe you get on a waiting list for a covered knee replacement, but you can get one next week if you can pay for it yourself. But everybody gets pretty much the same care at a high quality for major illnesses and conditions. And I note again that many UHC systems work through private insurers that are closely regulated, like our Medicare; people still choose their own doctors and hospitals.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom