Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
Of course any action people take is because they choose to do it. Choosing to carefully test drugs before widely using them is a good choice. As mentioned, thalidomide provided an except example of what happens if one chooses to do otherwise.

Thalidomide is a lot more complicated than that. This off topic, I know, but thalidomide's right-handed isomer was tested, was safe, and was very good at controlling morning sickness. At that point in time we didn't even know that chirality *could* be a problem. It wasn't until the left-handed isomers got in the mix that we saw problems.

Yes, 100% testing is important. But you can't test for a thing you don't know is a thing.
 
No I am not, I am trying to help you understand what NICE's role is. It is to determine what treatments are available in NHS England and what constitutes good practice. What "rationing" takes place in the NHSs are at a different point.

Speaking as an actuary, NICE does a pretty nice job. We applied their QALY scores in some of our formulary development, and drug management policies.
 
Last edited:
A cost benefit analysis requirement is a form of rationing healthcare.

No it isn't. It's a measure of value. It might get applied when someone does rationing, but it's not implicitly a form of rationing.

NICE defines the value of a treatment or medicine, as based on the quality and life impact of that treatment.
 
Trump signs executive order that could effectively gut Affordable Care Act’s individual mandate

President Trump signed an executive order late Friday giving federal agencies broad powers to unwind regulations created under the Affordable Care Act, which might include enforcement of the penalty for people who fail to carry the health insurance that the law requires of most Americans.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/poli...-0905pm:homepage/story&utm_term=.bf22632a84ee

Meh. The mandate is still not particularly toothy - it has only a small bite. For 2017, the penalty is the maximum of:
A) $695 Annual
B) 2.5% of your annual income (not to exceed the annual cost of a Bronze plan)

Average Bronze plan price is around $300 per month, so about $3600 annually. So if you happen to make over $144,000 annually and are single, you're looking at a penalty that costs you as much as coverage. For anyone making less than that, the penalty is still less than the cost of coverage. For most people in the US, the penalty is much less than the cost of coverage - especially if you aren't single.

All in all, the mandate isn't that big a deal.
 
Let me give you another one.

Everything that is provided in a free market system will only be provided if the provider can make a profit. To make a profit, a provider has to charge the cost of the product, plus enough of a profit margin to make it worthwhile for the provider to take the time to provide it. i.e. He has to make a living.

Medicines, health appliances (wheelchairs and such), the true cost of all the products used during surgery, never mind the actual salaries of surgeons and nurses, is more than poor people can pay. There is absolutely zero profit in providing certain forms of health care to poor people, because they don't have enough money to cover the base cost, let alone provide a profit margin to investors, or a reasonable salary for the specialized labor providing the service.

A free market system would mean that poor people don't get health care, whether that's viagra, physical therapy, or heart surgery. Whether it's improving the quality of life, or keeping someone alive another day, the free market will leave poor people out.

So you have to have subsidies of some sort, or you have to let poor people do without, and suffer the consequences, whether that means dying or leaving their wives sexually frustrated.

ETA: And that doesn't mean there is no place at all for market forces in a health care system. You are alluding to that in your own posts. I was just reacting to the idea that a "free market solution" can solve health care problems. It can't. A true free market solution means some people don't get health care.

And, once you accept the idea that a pure free market solution can't solve the problem, Obamacare is about the closest thing to a free market system there is. The better one would be to get rid of the employer as the provider. That's a really stupid thing to do, but it's engrained in our culture.

Hey! Here's a novel idea! Why don't we take a look at the profit margins being made by those doctors, hospitals, pharmaceutical companies, and device manufacturers? Maybe we take a step back and question whether it's ethical for a medical supply company to make 40% profit year over year on something that can save lives. Maybe instead of just pumping more and more money into the system, maybe we take a look at whether or not the costs are reasonable. I mean, yes, medical school is expensive, but I'm not really convinced that my neurologist needs to me to pay the $800 per hour "protection" money to get her to write the Rx I need so I don't fry my brain in an epileptic seizure. Maybe she could get by with one fewer Mercedes and only a 3600 sf house... Worth a thought maybe?
 
The usual argument is that the methods that work just fine in multiple other countries will fail miserably in the US because...reasons. It usually involves some sort of vague handwaving about the size of the population.

In my view, the challenge in the US is one of infrastructure. It's that the industry itself has evolved in a for-profit environment, and the insurance mechanism evolved with it. Insurance invariably disrupts the supply-demand curve, because the financial intermediary explicitly protects the consumer of the good from the true cost of the good. The net effect of this is that the presence of a protective financial intermediary invariably increases the cost of the good sold. What we've ended up with is a highly entwined system. The number of people working in the medical industry (not just nurses and doctors, but the encompassing system of devices, orderlies, drug chemists, insurance agents, etc.) is very large, because the cost of the product is high... which is high because the industry exists in the form it does.

If you change that structure too quickly (a sudden shift to single-payer universal health care) without due consideration of the intricacies... you create many other subsidiary problems. How much of a spike in unemployment is acceptable in order to reduce the health care cost burden? If we switch it all to single-payer, how many people will be out of work, and how much will that increase the financial burden in other areas?

Intellectually I can argue for single-payer universal coverage... but only if I compartmentalize it and ignore all of the secondary impacts.

More pragmatically, I favor a highly subsidized private market, with a minimum care coverage requirement - similar to Switzerland's approach, and very much like Medicare Advantage today. Ideally, this would be paired with some degree of government negotiated cost controls on the delivery side.
 
I was thinking about this earlier - do you know what the figure was?

I don't remember with any real accuracy. I want to say it's somewhere in the 3 to 5 million range, but I'm not sure the stats on it were ever really solid. More than none, less than the 30 million that got care through expanded Medicaid.

I'm making a minor distinction here, by not considering those who could not afford care (which make up the bulk of the increase in the Medicaid population).

The overall size of the Individual Market only grew by about 10% over the last few years... but I'd have to go do research to get you any real numbers.
 
What that would do would drive insurance companies to move operations to the states with the laxest regulations, like the credit card companies moved to North Dakota in the '80s. What would have helped would have been a national public option, along the lines of Medicare-for-All, that anyone could enroll in if they didn't like the private options available in their states. No chance we'll get that from the Repubs.
I believe you misunderstood my post. Get rid of the ability for states to have different regulations. Move to a standardized and shared regulatory environment.
 
I agree, but you're not counting all of the positive externalities. Reducing sick time with early detection and preventative care has an overall positive effect. You get a larger workforce that can work for years longer. You get grandparents who can babysit instead of being sick/dead. I think the positive externalities outweigh the costs.

:confused: You snipped everything include the thread linky button. I'm not sure which post you're referring to. I'm guessing you're referring to the preventive care one?

The positive externalizes still don't outweigh the cost for most early-detection screenings. The incidence rate is still very low for the things being screened for, and the prevalence of screening is very high.

It unquestionably has high value to the individuals impacted. That's obvious. But taken from a policy perspective, it's not effective and the externalizes don't offset the increased cost burden.

But as I said, it's goodwill and it's the right thing to do. It's just not at all cost effective, no matter how you slice it up.
 
But do those positives make it back to the insurance company? EC was doing that analysis from the perspective of the insurer. Not the employer or society at large.

Also note that the perspective of the insurer is the perspective of the people paying the premiums. The cost of care is a direct and substantial element of the premium cost.
 
We know everybody dies, and we know that a lot of health care money is spent in the last few months of patients' lives. But serious discussions of how to responsibly identify useful measures vs. "prolonging the inevitable" are invariably portrayed as "death panels" or worse. So that's really a different issue. The question on the table is whether everybody should be able to get the same quality of health care, regardless of whether they have great corporate health insurance or must buy their own insurance in the individual market or must rely on public programs like Medicaid. If my insurance will keep me alive and active for another year, but yours (or your lack thereof) means you die without treatment, is that good for society as a whole? Most other major countries have determined that basic health care is every person's right as a human being. We have not made that decision.

The same way no one attempts to divert the trillion dollar useless supplement industry into more productive forms of medical care.

We should reassess both priorities, but .... death panels.
 
:confused: You snipped everything include the thread linky button. I'm not sure which post you're referring to. I'm guessing you're referring to the preventive care one?

The positive externalizes still don't outweigh the cost for most early-detection screenings. The incidence rate is still very low for the things being screened for, and the prevalence of screening is very high.

It unquestionably has high value to the individuals impacted. That's obvious. But taken from a policy perspective, it's not effective and the externalizes don't offset the increased cost burden.

But as I said, it's goodwill and it's the right thing to do. It's just not at all cost effective, no matter how you slice it up.
I still subscribe to the broken windows theory. A healthier populace will lead to a healthier populace. When people see while-life medical treatment working, they'll want more of it. They'll want to twice smoking and drinking, clean the water, etc.

This may not be the best post on the day Trump started gutting the EPA.
 
But do those positives make it back to the insurance company? EC was doing that analysis from the perspective of the insurer. Not the employer or society at large.
More people plaguing premiums longer. I think it can be made to work. In any case, I'd certainly like to try living in that kind of society.
 
Actually, preventive care is only less expensive when you're looking post-hoc at a person who contracted the condition. That is to say, the cost of a colonoscopy is less than the cost of chemotherapy and surgery for colon cancer. The problem is in the aggregations, and colonoscopies are a really good example.
OK.

These are made up numbers - I don't have real numbers easily accessible without having to do a lot of work AND there's a degree of confidentiality involved.
Confidentiality of who? Physician owners of colonoscopy machines? Any profession that sucks this much revenue out of government or quasi-government entities ought to be transparent.

Let's say that an average colonoscopy costs $250, and is recommended to all men age 50 and older, every 5 years.
That's not too far off; in terms of physician billing. Facility billing, however, is $736.85.

Now: How many doctors benefit from facility billing? Does facility billing accurately reflect amortization/depreciation costs?

The lack of transparency helps drive up costs, IMO. For example your ballpark estimate was $250 against a reality of $1,000+. We treat medical costs like voodoo - utterly opaque magic, and questions are taboo.

So even though the cost to treat is much higher than the cost to screen for an individual who is identified with colon cancer... the cost to screen everyone is massively higher.
Bringing me back around to why screening costs are so high. Hate to be such a cynic here but doctors are very interested in their own bottom line and often have ownership interest in diagnostic equipment.
 
Last edited:
The lack of transparency helps drive up costs, IMO. For example your ballpark estimate was $250 against a reality of $1,000+. We treat medical costs like voodoo - utterly opaque magic, and questions are taboo.

Bringing me back around to why screening costs are so high. Hate to be such a cynic here but doctors are very interested in their own bottom line and often have ownership interest in diagnostic equipment.


I feel fairly confident that costs are high because those who can pay are footing the bill for those who can't. It's almost as if we need a system where healthy people are required to buy medical insurance and companies/government can negotiate rates with the providers.
 
The lack of transparency helps drive up costs, IMO. For example your ballpark estimate was $250 against a reality of $1,000+. We treat medical costs like voodoo - utterly opaque magic, and questions are taboo.

Bringing me back around to why screening costs are so high. Hate to be such a cynic here but doctors are very interested in their own bottom line and often have ownership interest in diagnostic equipment.


I feel fairly confident that costs are high because those who can pay are footing the bill for those who can't. It's almost as if we need a system where healthy people are required to buy medical insurance and companies/government can negotiate rates with the providers.
 
I feel fairly confident that costs are high because those who can pay are footing the bill for those who can't. It's almost as if we need a system where healthy people are required to buy medical insurance and companies/government can negotiate rates with the providers.

Sure, that's a big part of it. Since Obamacare there are theoretically fewer free riders.

But IMO there's also an awful lot of price gouging just because it's possible. And it's possible because in the past, a hospital that billed insurance $7,000 for an emergency appendectomy could bill an uninsured patient *$35,000* for the same procedure. So you get your appendix out, then keel over from a heart attack when you get the bill.

I googled "wildly disparate costs for similar procedures" and "widely disparate costs for similar procedures." Maybe this problem has been fixed by now.
 
Last edited:
I feel fairly confident that costs are high because those who can pay are footing the bill for those who can't. It's almost as if we need a system where healthy people are required to buy medical insurance and companies/government can negotiate rates with the providers.

Fairly confident are you? I can prove you wrong with a couple of lines of math. Before Obamacare, the percent of uninsured was about 15% (it rose a little during the Great Recession).

If those uninsured used health care resources at the same rate as the insured (which of course they don't - not even close, because a lot of them are young or, if not, simply do without), then the burden they impose on the 85% who are insured increases the insured's costs by 15%/85% = 17.6%. If you think that our health care costs are only inflated by 17.6% over what they would be in a free market, then I have ski lodge in Florida to sell you. Of course, even then I have grossly overestimated the effect, since the uninsured use far less health care than the insured.

The real reason our prices are so high is two-fold: (1) there is simply too much demand because people do not pay directly for their consumption (broad insurance coverage mandates exacerbate this problem); and (2) supply is restricted by our screwed up system for training and licensing doctors and our screwed up system for approving drugs and medical procedures.

Well, actually there is a third reason. The rest of the world freeloads off of the medical R&D that our high health care prices incentivize.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom