Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, I'm assuming that he objects to measuring the system as a whole. The problem is that I pay for the system as a whole and I was commenting on the system as a whole, so I'll stick to metrics that measure the system as a whole.

No, I'm objecting to the double counting and circular reasoning. The claim is that the US pays the most for healthcare but gets worse results. But the metric they are using for results includes the fact that some people forego needed health care because it costs more than they're willing to pay (or are able to pay). Another metric is equity, which would make a place where everybody gets equally crappy health care score higher than a place where everybody gets better health care but some get phenomenal health care.

Also, the metric having to do with overall health is misleading since it fails to account for cultural and demographic differences, as well as differences in consumer preferences. Even some of the seemingly objective measures, like infant mortality, are not objective. First, infant mortality is measured more conservatively in the US (e.g. deaths of infants born severely prematurely, or with certain birth defects are counted in the US, and they are not in other countries; also the counting is more honest); second, infant mortality is closely tied to low birth weight which is closely tied to teenage pregnancy, which is far more of a problem in the US than in other developed countries.

The only objective measure is what percentage of people with serious diseases are restored to health? I have seen studies that show the US does extremely well on these objective measures (e.g. various types of cancer), although even here there are differences in measurement. It's possible, for example, that, in the US, breast cancers are flagged which wouldn't have been harmful even without treatment.

Perhaps the most fundamental "problem" is that the US has a culture of personal responsibility, at least greater than exists in European countries. If somebody doesn't make a minimal effort to take care of their health or see the doctor when they need to, then it's on them. In Europe, people are more likely to be treated as wards of the state. That will give you better results for the most irresponsible people, but I think for 75-80% of the people, it doesn't help.
 
The only objective measure is what percentage of people with serious diseases are restored to health?

Okay. You say you've seen studies on this subject. Can we see these studies, please?

If somebody doesn't make a minimal effort to take care of their health or see the doctor when they need to, then it's on them. In Europe, people are more likely to be treated as wards of the state. That will give you better results for the most irresponsible people, but I think for 75-80% of the people, it doesn't help.

What does this even mean? Do you think in Europe the government forces people to go to the doctor if they feel ill? Do you think in Europe that people who don't go to the doctor can sue the government for any negative consequences of not having done so?
 
Perhaps the most fundamental "problem" is that the US has a culture of personal responsibility, at least greater than exists in European countries. If somebody doesn't make a minimal effort to take care of their health or see the doctor when they need to, then it's on them.

No, it is on us. They walk into the emergency room a basket case and we have to stitch them back together at great cost.

Now, I think the right would like to change the law so that hospitals could turn away the indigent, but I don't see how that would improve your argument. And I think that is completely counter to the Trump quote that started this thread.

Do you think Trump wants to be the president known for removing the safety net so that poor people could be pushed out to die in front of the hospital?
 
Do you think Trump wants to be the president known for removing the safety net so that poor people could be pushed out to die in front of the hospital?

No, but he wants to be the proud Republican who repealed that Muslim-communist-atheist inspired Romneycare Obamacare and if the price for that is a few dead poor people then that's acceptable......
 
No, I'm objecting to the double counting and circular reasoning. The claim is that the US pays the most for healthcare but gets worse results. But the metric they are using for results includes the fact that some people forego needed health care because it costs more than they're willing to pay (or are able to pay).
The costs are also figured per capita. There's no double counting or circular reasoning, the US really does have crappier health care than our contemporaries.

Perhaps the most fundamental "problem" is that the US has a culture of personal responsibility, at least greater than exists in European countries. If somebody doesn't make a minimal effort to take care of their health or see the doctor when they need to, then it's on them. In Europe, people are more likely to be treated as wards of the state. That will give you better results for the most irresponsible people, but I think for 75-80% of the people, it doesn't help.
That is the precise opposite of how the US health care system works. For those who can't afford health insurance, regular checkups and preventative care are the first things to go. So problems develop and fester until they are genuine emergencies, and then it's on you, because your costs now need to subsidize their treatment.
 
Okay. You say you've seen studies on this subject. Can we see these studies, please?

Well, here's a Lancet study. Look at p. 993 (p. 17 of the PDF). I'll note also that health results/outcomes are often dependent on culture/ethnicity/genetics. I broke down the numbers once (as best as I could) and found that Japanese Americans live longer than Japanese, and that held true for other Americans of Asian descent. I think you'd find the same thing holds for Americans of European ancestry compared to Europeans of European ancestry. Also for African Americans compared to those of African descent in other countries. Despite the fantasy world in which progressives believe they reside, the real world actually has inconvenient genetic differences between different people, which impacts health and longevity (e.g. blacks are more prone to high blood pressure and obesity)

What does this even mean? Do you think in Europe the government forces people to go to the doctor if they feel ill? Do you think in Europe that people who don't go to the doctor can sue the government for any negative consequences of not having done so?

There is less hand-holding, and certainly less coercion, in the US when it comes to encouraging patients to take their medicines or come to followup appointments. One of the biggest problems with patients on Medicaid is not showing up for appointments (roughly 1/3 of appointments are no-shows) and not taking their prescriptions according to directions. There is certainly no penalty in the US for either, or even a stigma, except to one's health of course. Some of it is cultural. Americans are less trusting of and respectful of authority figures.
 
The costs are also figured per capita. There's no double counting or circular reasoning, the US really does have crappier health care than our contemporaries.

You misunderstand my point. The claim is that the US has worse quality health care despite the fact that health care costs more money per capita. And yet, one of the key measures of quality is the cost itself (part of what is called efficiency). Another measure is access (which depends on cost). Another measure is equality (which depends on cost).

That is the precise opposite of how the US health care system works. For those who can't afford health insurance, regular checkups and preventative care are the first things to go. So problems develop and fester until they are genuine emergencies, and then it's on you, because your costs now need to subsidize their treatment.

Preventative care in general is not cost-effective. That doesn't mean we shouldn't devote resources to it, since cost-effectiveness is not the only metric we're trying to optimize, but the fact is preventative care is not always a good thing. It doesn't make sense for me to get a colonoscopy every year, for example, even though it would probably lower my chance of getting colon cancer.
 
Health insurance for everybody is a good idea. In my country, we have had that for three generations. But where is Mr. Trump going to find the money?

Hans

okay, I'm a little slow... but isn't this the same argument made by the other side when it was ACA on the floor? Hasn't it been the republicans/conservatives saying "where will you find the money" and democrats/liberals saying "it doesn't matter, that's not the point, it's about the people"?
 
Well, here's a Lancet study. Look at p. 993 (p. 17 of the PDF).

This is a study that looks at survival of certain kinds of cancers. Your assertion was that the "only objective measure is what percentage of people with serious diseases are restored to health". This seems like a very small subset of the data you'd need to go some way to establishing that the US scores well there.

There is less hand-holding, and certainly less coercion, in the US when it comes to encouraging patients to take their medicines or come to followup appointments.

Citation?

There is certainly no penalty in the US for either, or even a stigma, except to one's health of course.

And you believe that there are legal penalties in Europe for missing a medical appointment or not taking prescribed medicine?

Some of it is cultural. Americans are less trusting of and respectful of authority figures.

Citation?
 
You misunderstand my point. The claim is that the US has worse quality health care despite the fact that health care costs more money per capita. And yet, one of the key measures of quality is the cost itself (part of what is called efficiency). Another measure is access (which depends on cost). Another measure is equality (which depends on cost).
I understand your point. Your point is wrong. They've factored those effects correctly.

Preventative care in general is not cost-effective. That doesn't mean we shouldn't devote resources to it, since cost-effectiveness is not the only metric we're trying to optimize, but the fact is preventative care is not always a good thing. It doesn't make sense for me to get a colonoscopy every year, for example, even though it would probably lower my chance of getting colon cancer.
This is also incorrect. Preventative care is very cost effective, up to a point. I notice you're not arguing for no colonoscopies at all, despite that being exactly what people without insurance or the means to pay are currently entitled to.
 
I'm going to have to ask to see your evidence for this one.
I know where he's going with this.

One current trend in health care is finding that too much screening can actually be disadvantageous, because all tests can throw false positives. If you get, say, a mammogram every week, sooner or later they'll find something that looks off enough for further investigation, despite it being intrusive, and expensive and almost certainly fruitless.

It may be hard to imagine someone able to understand the above without also coming to appreciate the positive effects of preventative care, but that's our sunmaster14. No facts are too apparent for him to circumspectly ignore in pursuit of his bias.
 
They ought to make all politicians, of any political persuasion, who end up running a health department spend one day following a junior doctor, or an Ambulance crew.

Come to think of it that might not be a bad idea for a lot of other professions too.

And Libertarians and Republicans need an education in how the free market works (they are working on drugs for Alzheimer's because that is a huge market) and doesn't work (new antibiotics won't be profitable compared to a copy cat, but not better, drug designed to take a slice of the viagra market) in health care.

It might open their eyes to the uninformed belief that pharmaceutical and medical device R&D investment only comes from yuuuuge profits as opposed to merely huge profits.
 
i.e. I can't come up with a suitable counterpoint to that, so here's a partisan joke that's tangentially related to the longest word in the paragraph.

Counterpoint: it is a myth that suing doctors for malpractice is the cause of skyrocketing health care costs.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom