sunmaster14
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Feb 24, 2014
- Messages
- 10,017
Yeah, I'm assuming that he objects to measuring the system as a whole. The problem is that I pay for the system as a whole and I was commenting on the system as a whole, so I'll stick to metrics that measure the system as a whole.
No, I'm objecting to the double counting and circular reasoning. The claim is that the US pays the most for healthcare but gets worse results. But the metric they are using for results includes the fact that some people forego needed health care because it costs more than they're willing to pay (or are able to pay). Another metric is equity, which would make a place where everybody gets equally crappy health care score higher than a place where everybody gets better health care but some get phenomenal health care.
Also, the metric having to do with overall health is misleading since it fails to account for cultural and demographic differences, as well as differences in consumer preferences. Even some of the seemingly objective measures, like infant mortality, are not objective. First, infant mortality is measured more conservatively in the US (e.g. deaths of infants born severely prematurely, or with certain birth defects are counted in the US, and they are not in other countries; also the counting is more honest); second, infant mortality is closely tied to low birth weight which is closely tied to teenage pregnancy, which is far more of a problem in the US than in other developed countries.
The only objective measure is what percentage of people with serious diseases are restored to health? I have seen studies that show the US does extremely well on these objective measures (e.g. various types of cancer), although even here there are differences in measurement. It's possible, for example, that, in the US, breast cancers are flagged which wouldn't have been harmful even without treatment.
Perhaps the most fundamental "problem" is that the US has a culture of personal responsibility, at least greater than exists in European countries. If somebody doesn't make a minimal effort to take care of their health or see the doctor when they need to, then it's on them. In Europe, people are more likely to be treated as wards of the state. That will give you better results for the most irresponsible people, but I think for 75-80% of the people, it doesn't help.