Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
.....
The real reason our prices are so high is two-fold: (1) there is simply too much demand because people do not pay directly for their consumption (broad insurance coverage mandates exacerbate this problem); and (2) supply is restricted by our screwed up system for training and licensing doctors and our screwed up system for approving drugs and medical procedures.
.....

So it's the patient's fault? You don't say a word about prices charged by providers. Outside of things like nose jobs, health care is not a luxury good. People don't buy it unless they need it, and often they don't even know they need it because they weren't getting regular preventive care (blood pressure checks, diabetes screening etc.). And when the patient does need it, he's not usually in a position to comparison shop, and even if he wanted to, the necessary information isn't available. Other nations treat health insurance as a public utility providing an essential service, like power and water, and regulate insurers that way.

Journalist Steven Brill got a lot of attention last year for his investigation of medical pricing. Short summary: no rhyme or reason at all, incomprehensible even within the industry.
http://www.npr.org/sections/health-...-makes-case-for-why-health-care-law-wont-work
http://www.amazon.com/Americas-Bitt...rd_wg=46fW7&psc=1&refRID=Y7A66GQQ3APS5HS58ED1
 
Fairly confident are you? I can prove you wrong with a couple of lines of math. Before Obamacare, the percent of uninsured was about 15% (it rose a little during the Great Recession).

If those uninsured used health care resources at the same rate as the insured (which of course they don't - not even close, because a lot of them are young or, if not, simply do without), then the burden they impose on the 85% who are insured increases the insured's costs by 15%/85% = 17.6%. If you think that our health care costs are only inflated by 17.6% over what they would be in a free market, then I have ski lodge in Florida to sell you. Of course, even then I have grossly overestimated the effect, since the uninsured use far less health care than the insured.

The real reason our prices are so high is two-fold: (1) there is simply too much demand because people do not pay directly for their consumption (broad insurance coverage mandates exacerbate this problem); and (2) supply is restricted by our screwed up system for training and licensing doctors and our screwed up system for approving drugs and medical procedures.

Well, actually there is a third reason. The rest of the world freeloads off of the medical R&D that our high health care prices incentivize.

So I'll take that as a "no" on being able to support any of your previous statements, shall I?
 
What happens when the Queen gets sick?

The Royals have had their own private doctors for as long as there have been private doctors.
It's only in the past century that this has actually been to their benefit, but I digress.

I don't know how the bills are paid, but they most assuredly would be.

The super rich here get the same care that the super rich get anywhere in the world. They pay the same exorbitant prices for that care.
 
The Royals have had their own private doctors for as long as there have been private doctors.
It's only in the past century that this has actually been to their benefit, but I digress.

I don't know how the bills are paid, but they most assuredly would be.

The super rich here get the same care that the super rich get anywhere in the world. They pay the same exorbitant prices for that care.

It's not surprising. I don't think a hierarchy of services can be prevented, just controlled.
 
Other nations treat health insurance as a public utility providing an essential service, like power and water, and regulate insurers that way.

Virtually the only way to appeal to conservatives on this score is to make it a national security issue. For instance, regular Republicans don't seem to mind insurance subsidies paid to farmers when its framed as "protecting our food supply," and "avoiding dependence on foreign countries."

We need healthy citizens to defend the homeland and protect ze Führer. It's disgrace that so many young men are too overweight and unfit to serve in the military. Make America Glorious Again.
 
Meh. The mandate is still not particularly toothy - it has only a small bite. For 2017, the penalty is the maximum of:
A) $695 Annual
B) 2.5% of your annual income (not to exceed the annual cost of a Bronze plan)

Average Bronze plan price is around $300 per month, so about $3600 annually. So if you happen to make over $144,000 annually and are single, you're looking at a penalty that costs you as much as coverage. For anyone making less than that, the penalty is still less than the cost of coverage. For most people in the US, the penalty is much less than the cost of coverage - especially if you aren't single.

All in all, the mandate isn't that big a deal.
I recently had an argument with someone who insisted that when they looked at forgoing health insurance, it would be a $5000 penalty and he only makes $48,000. I asked him how he got to that number, and they stated that it's what the ACA says. I responded that's not what the law says, and in order to have to pay $5000 you would first have an adjusted gross income of
$200,000 and that's ignoring the cost of a bronze plan. He still insisted I was wrong and it was $5000. I showed him the law and various calculators to demonstrate it couldn't have been $5000. Didn't convince him - I was lying apparently even though he couldn't explain how he got to his figure.
 
In practice in the UK this means that if I get ill and need to see a GP, then I don't have to pay anything. If the doctor prescribes medicines, then these will likely be generic but I'll get treatment that's effective. I have to pay a nominal charge per prescription.

Just to nitpick. Prescriptions are free in Scotland.

Carry on :)

I feel fairly confident that costs are high because those who can pay are footing the bill for those who can't.
And this seems to me like the underlying issue. I apologise if my thinking is not clear here, I think about this emotionally rather than rationally in many ways.

That's what happens with socialised medicine, and that's a good thing. In the UK, public healthcare is paid for via taxation. More of that is contributed by those who can afford it and, broadly speaking, more of the service is used by those who can't. And that's a good thing.

I am relatively well paid, and have very little use of public health services. I don't care. If my contribution is helping others stay healthy, then I am happy. Indeed many people from the wealthy end effectively contribute twice because they pay their taxes (avoidance aside for the moment), but also have private healthcare provision which they pay for, so they are not only contributing to the public pot, they are also not taking anything out because they have their own arrangements.

The same is true of many public services. It's not about getting what I paid for, it's about trying to make sure that need is covered. Tax dollars are used to pay for all sorts of things that I don't use. And that's a good thing.

I get the sense that the US political culture is just not in a place to accept that underlying premise. Is that socialism? My political compass is nonexistant.
 
regular Republicans don't seem to mind insurance subsidies paid to farmers when its framed as "protecting our food supply," and "avoiding dependence on foreign countries." farmers vote for them.
A minor fix. Regular Republicans don't actually care about ideology, they'll change to whatever gets them the most votes. Currently the unions are turning red, so expect to see the farm subsidy rhetoric switch to "keepin' 'Merican jobs in 'Merica" without a hitch in between.
 
The real reason our prices are so high is two-fold: (1) there is simply too much demand because people do not pay directly for their consumption (broad insurance coverage mandates exacerbate this problem); and (2) supply is restricted by our screwed up system for training and licensing doctors and our screwed up system for approving drugs and medical procedures.

On this I completely agree with you. Both of these reasons are much easier to sustain in a complex market that puts insurers between the consumer and the provider. It makes the consumer think the insurer is looking out of their interest, but in fact the insurer is just looking out of rate bottom line.

Replace the complex web of insurers with a single entity and you increase the transparency and reduce the complexity. When one entity is paying the bills and we are that entity then we can demand more form our medical providers.
 
On this I completely agree with you. Both of these reasons are much easier to sustain in a complex market that puts insurers between the consumer and the provider. It makes the consumer think the insurer is looking out of their interest, but in fact the insurer is just looking out of rate bottom line.

Replace the complex web of insurers with a single entity and you increase the transparency and reduce the complexity. When one entity is paying the bills and we are that entity then we can demand more form our medical providers.

But that would put evil government bureaucrats in charge of our health. :rolleyes:

The ACA created a system that lets a private company run the paperwork. Think of it as a 10% to 15% tithe to the Gods of the free market in the memory of Saint Regan. A single payer system would be more efficient but totally unacceptable to the real Americans. Who know that government is pure evil and will kill grandma and force their daughter to have an abortion and their son to have a sex change.
 
.....
A single payer system would be more efficient but totally unacceptable to the real Americans.
.....

And yet Medicare is recognized as one of the most successful government programs, even when the doddering elderly shout "keep the government away from my Medicare!" A gradual introduction of a Medicare-for-All plan, starting with allowing younger people to buy into it with reasonable premiums, would probably get pretty broad acceptance.
 
It's funny when people interpret "free preventive coverage" to mean "free healthcare." They expect their insurers to cover all their visits for stuff like diabetes, hypertension, heart disease, etc under free, no-copay, preventive coverage. I hear arguments like: "but I come to the doctor to prevent problems from my {insert chronic disease}! They should cover that for free!" Or "This is just a follow up of my preventive visit, I shouldn't be charged because the law says preventive coverage is free!"

And then of course, they come in for their yearly preventive visit with a laundry list of medical problems and expect them all to be covered. And then when you ask them, "Have you stopped smoking? Have you implemented the dietary changes we talked about? Etc?" They either get mad and ask us to stop prying into their personal lives or just lie and say yes. In their eyes, a doctor's job is to fix the problems that come up as a result of their normal lifestyle. Preventive medicine=preventing the chronic problems they already have from becoming bigger problems. It's hard to convince some people that that isn't preventive medicine, that's medical treatment!

The biggest problem we have is that people don't actually take their health seriously. They treat their bodies badly and then whine when they can't afford the medical treatment required to mitigate their mistakes. If you make positive healthy changes to your life, you will prevent the most common problems that lead to death in our country. If you refuse to make those changes, then shouldn't YOU be the one that pays the bill?
 
It's funny when people interpret "free preventive coverage" to mean "free healthcare." They expect their insurers to cover all their visits for stuff like diabetes, hypertension, heart disease, etc under free, no-copay, preventive coverage. I hear arguments like: "but I come to the doctor to prevent problems from my {insert chronic disease}! They should cover that for free!" Or "This is just a follow up of my preventive visit, I shouldn't be charged because the law says preventive coverage is free!"

And then of course, they come in for their yearly preventive visit with a laundry list of medical problems and expect them all to be covered. And then when you ask them, "Have you stopped smoking? Have you implemented the dietary changes we talked about? Etc?" They either get mad and ask us to stop prying into their personal lives or just lie and say yes. In their eyes, a doctor's job is to fix the problems that come up as a result of their normal lifestyle. Preventive medicine=preventing the chronic problems they already have from becoming bigger problems. It's hard to convince some people that that isn't preventive medicine, that's medical treatment!

The biggest problem we have is that people don't actually take their health seriously. They treat their bodies badly and then whine when they can't afford the medical treatment required to mitigate their mistakes. If you make positive healthy changes to your life, you will prevent the most common problems that lead to death in our country. If you refuse to make those changes, then shouldn't YOU be the one that pays the bill?


Do you have insurance? If so, you are sharing your medical costs with everyone in your group. If not, and you get run over by a bus or develop a brain tumor, you will get expensive care that you will either pay for yourself well into six figures, or -- more likely -- you will get care without paying your bills, ultimately leaving all of us on the hook one way or another.

There are a variety of mechanisms to encourage more healthy habits. But ultimately everybody needs health care, sooner or later, more or less, and every other First World country finds ways of sharing the costs equitably. Telling everybody they're on their own is just a couple steps from returning to caves.

And it's just ridiculous to claim we wouldn't need health care if we would just shape up. Disease is a little more complicated than that, not to mention accidents and trauma.
 
The same is true of many public services. It's not about getting what I paid for, it's about trying to make sure that need is covered. Tax dollars are used to pay for all sorts of things that I don't use. And that's a good thing.

It's hard to calculate how much any specific person benefits from a universal healthcare program.

As a businessperson, I benefit when my employees and customers are healthy, for example. Severely ill employees don't produce profit for me. Severely ill people have less disposable income, and my customer base is smaller.

Health is like education: the rising water lifts all boats and pays dividends in excess of the original investment. This makes is a good model for a public service, which most countries have figured out.
 
It's funny when people interpret "free preventive coverage" to mean "free healthcare." They expect their insurers to cover all their visits for stuff like diabetes, hypertension, heart disease, etc under free, no-copay, preventive coverage.

and in every other developed nation in the world all of that is free. And more.
 
and in every other developed nation in the world all of that is free. And more.

It's also generally free or cheap under most U.S. group health insurance policies too. The issue under discussion is whether people who buy their own insurance in the individual market can get the same prices and services as someone who is able to join a group. The answer is "Why not?"
 
Do you have insurance? If so, you are sharing your medical costs with everyone in your group. If not, and you get run over by a bus or develop a brain tumor, you will get expensive care that you will either pay for yourself well into six figures, or -- more likely -- you will get care without paying your bills, ultimately leaving all of us on the hook one way or another.

There are a variety of mechanisms to encourage more healthy habits. But ultimately everybody needs health care, sooner or later, more or less, and every other First World country finds ways of sharing the costs equitably. Telling everybody they're on their own is just a couple steps from returning to caves.

And it's just ridiculous to claim we wouldn't need health care if we would just shape up. Disease is a little more complicated than that, not to mention accidents and trauma.
I never claimed we wouldn't need health care. But surely you can agree that people who don't smoke, eat a healthy diet, are not overweight, etc, tend not to develop the chronic diseases that are responsible for most of our death and disability. Just look at the CDC's stats: Heart Disease is the number one killer, followed by Cancer and Chronic Lower Pulmonary Disease. Let's focus on number one. Again, according to the CDC, Heart Disease risk factors include: High Blood Pressure, High Cholesterol, Smoking, Diabetes, Obesity, Poor diet, Physical inactivity, Excessive alcohol use. How much of that is lifestyle-related? I would say almost all of it. How much could we cut disease if people didn't smoke, ate right, moderated their drinking and lost some weight? I think it's clear that we could reduce those deaths by a significant margin.

A large percentage of people obviously don't really take their health seriously. If they did, they would fix their lifestyle. They would take their medicine the way they are supposed to. But since they don't, we have the high rates of lifestyle disease that we do.

You talk about dividing health costs equitably. How is it equitable that people who voluntarily and knowingly engage in behaviors that are detrimental to their health should pay the same as the people who don't? I don't really care if the rest of the world does it; I don't live there.
 
and in every other developed nation in the world all of that is free. And more.

It's not free. You pay for it in taxes and in cuts to other areas where the government might spend money: infrastructure, defense, etc. Let's not pretend that other developed nations are utopias. They have problems in other areas than health care and even health care isn't the perfect model. I believe we can do better.
 
It's not free. You pay for it in taxes and in cuts to other areas where the government might spend money: infrastructure, defense, etc. Let's not pretend that other developed nations are utopias. They have problems in other areas than health care and even health care isn't the perfect model. I believe we can do better.

Well, if you're going by that metric, then it's not free in the US, either, because it's paid for by those who pay for insurance.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom