CynicalSkeptic
Master Poster
- Joined
- Oct 18, 2006
- Messages
- 2,608
Because freedom.

Such situations are the issue in a nutshell. Preventative care is ethically equivalent but more drawn out in time.Yes, of course. The life and death, urgent care situation is the first (and only ) example any anti-free health care market people give when arguing that the health care market is fundamentally immune to free market solutions.
Ok, I don't get it then.No, apparently you don't see what I'm saying. What you wrote is a non sequitur.
Why not?You claimed we have a right to life. How does that work with such a definition? Do you really think that I have a right to call in the government to expend $1 million of health care resources to keep me alive?
We're talking about the means.They go hand in hand. If the means don't exist, then it makes no sense to talk about it as a right.
The dominant school of thought in liberal democracies is that the fundamental rights, like the right to life, exists prior to and independently of the state. Laws are to safe-guard these rights but do not establish them.And it would be really bad public policy to make laws that establish such a right.
Which definition is that?Yes, it does. State-of-the-art means resources at the leading edge of technology, which, by definition, exists only in limited quantities.
Not a Trump fan then.I am grateful that the rest of the world wants to hold dollars and thus is willing to run a large trade surplus with us. It means we can consume more than we produce, which is a nice situation to be in.
That's not clear to me. For one, the US has had a single payer system, for a substantial part of the population, for quite some time. Medicare pays for those above age 65, and those are the heaviest consumers of health care resources.In the case of health care, though, the rest of the world benefits from us not having a single payer system. Because of the high prices we pay for health care, particularly the state of the art stuff, health care companies are incentivized to develop new diagnostic equipment, new treatments and new medicines. Which the rest of the world eventually benefits from, with a small time lag after Americans get access. If we went to single payer, we would cut back our spending, and research and development would dry up.
Ok, I reread your previous statements and here's my attempt at putting it together:It means that instead of rich people buying access to better health care, you have politically connected or "important" people getting access to better health care. If a bureaucrat is making the decision about which treatment is covered, don't you think that the bureaucrat is susceptible to the normal pressures? Obviously, he will be doing favors for people. Might not even see it as immoral. After all, the people he helps are visible to him, whereas the people who are screwed (by being shuffled back in the queue) are largely invisible. This is simple human nature.
If that is the point of free markets, wouldn't it be best if everyone was provided with the same amount of money? To maximize their ability to express their preferences?The point of free markets is to let people spend money the way they see fit. According to their own cost-benefit calculus. If somebody is too poor to afford a treatment, then, yes, it's unfortunate, although perhaps they can convince their friends to help out, or a charity, or make a public fundraising effort. The point of a free market is to allow people to express their preferences, not to weed out unproductive people. That's just cynical nonsense.
I see now. The choice is the end, not a means to an end.Do I want to spend $10,000 to get knee surgery? Do I want to spend the extra money to get the best surgeon available, or will I seek a discount and let somebody a few years out of residency operate on me? Do I need a private room, or am I willing to save a few shekels by going semi-private? Do I want generic medicines or branded? Do I want the the state-of-the-art medicine with fewer side effects, or am I willing to tolerate a little incontinence of stomach upset in order to save a few more shekels. There are literally dozens of cost-benefit decisions to make for each procedure. Or at least there would be if we had a free market in health care.
Hmm... I think that would need a lot of work to hammer out. I can see how the system is supposed to incentivize taking care with your health so that you can get cash. But health care spending varies greatly with age and whether someone has a chronic condition.That's not what I was talking about. The government gives you the money regardless of whether you are sick. You make your health care purchasing decisions on your own, as needed. The main idea is here.
No, it would be a stipend outside of employment. See the link above.
Ok, I'll have to take your word for it. I couldn't tell state-of-the-art medical care today from 10 or 15 years ago. I think few people could. To us, that is still basically the same.No, they have Medicare for all. I'm talking about Medicaid, which compensates providers at a much lower rate and basically sucks. The British safety net is too high. I think we could guarantee a level of care commensurate with the state-of-the art as of 10 to 15 years prior. The British system is more like 2 years prior. Of course, they can only get away with that by relying on the US to pay the lion's share of R&D and also by having a somewhat healthier population (which is a cultural and demographic benefit rather than a consequence of policy).
I should have read your links before replying:
...snip....
Ok, I'll have to take your word for it. I couldn't tell state-of-the-art medical care today from 10 or 15 years ago. I think few people could. To us, that is still basically the same.
Yes, it does. State-of-the-art means resources at the leading edge of technology, which, by definition, exists only in limited quantities.
[...]
In the case of health care, though, the rest of the world benefits from us not having a single payer system. Because of the high prices we pay for health care, particularly the state of the art stuff, health care companies are incentivized to develop new diagnostic equipment, new treatments and new medicines. Which the rest of the world eventually benefits from, with a small time lag after Americans get access. If we went to single payer, we would cut back our spending, and research and development would dry up.[...]
The British system is more like 2 years prior. Of course, they can only get away with that by relying on the US to pay the lion's share of R&D and also by having a somewhat healthier population (which is a cultural and demographic benefit rather than a consequence of policy).
That is some of the most uninformed twaddle I've read in a long time.
It is kind of telling, though, that conservatives believe that profit is the only motive for health care.
They ought to make all politicians, of any political persuasion, who end up running a health department spend one day following a junior doctor, or an Ambulance crew.
I should have read your links before replying:
I leave it as an exercise to you to understand why most of those metrics are stupid and have little to do with whether or not the health care being delivered is high quality or not.
On average it is not, because more people in the US have to go without.I leave it as an exercise to you to understand why most of those metrics are stupid and have little to do with whether or not the health care being delivered is high quality or not.
On average it is not, because more people in the US have to go without.
By your logic pre-revolutionary France had no famine problem, because the people who did get to eat, ate like kings.
I leave it as an exercise to you to understand why most of those metrics are stupid and have little to do with whether or not the health care being delivered is high quality or not.
...snip...
I leave it as an exercise to you to understand why most of those metrics are stupid and have little to do with whether or not the health care being delivered is high quality or not.
That's the conservative ideology. Poor people don't matter.
Actually, you should have read the actual report those links reference. As a lawyer, I'm sure you would have quickly understood how meaningless they are (and how circular the reasoning is).
Here are the metrics used for the grade:
Quality: The indicators of quality were grouped into four categories: effective care, safe care, coordinated care, and patient-centered care. Compared with the other 10 countries, the U.S. fares best on provision and receipt of preventive and patient-centered care. While there has been some improvement in recent years, lower scores on safe and coordinated care pull the overall U.S. quality score down. Continued adoption of health information technology should enhance the ability of U.S. physicians to identify, monitor, and coordinate care for their patients, particularly those with chronic conditions.
Access: Not surprisingly—given the absence of universal coverage—people in the U.S. go without needed health care because of cost more often than people do in the other countries. Americans were the most likely to say they had access problems related to cost. Patients in the U.S. have rapid access to specialized health care services; however, they are less likely to report rapid access to primary care than people in leading countries in the study. In other countries, like Canada, patients have little to no financial burden, but experience wait times for such specialized services. There is a frequent misperception that trade-offs between universal coverage and timely access to specialized services are inevitable; however, the Netherlands, U.K., and Germany provide universal coverage with low out-of-pocket costs while maintaining quick access to specialty services.
Efficiency: On indicators of efficiency, the U.S. ranks last among the 11 countries, with the U.K. and Sweden ranking first and second, respectively. The U.S. has poor performance on measures of national health expenditures and administrative costs as well as on measures of administrative hassles, avoidable emergency room use, and duplicative medical testing. Sicker survey respondents in the U.K. and France are less likely to visit the emergency room for a condition that could have been treated by a regular doctor, had one been available.
Equity: The U.S. ranks a clear last on measures of equity. Americans with below-average incomes were much more likely than their counterparts in other countries to report not visiting a physician when sick; not getting a recommended test, treatment, or follow-up care; or not filling a prescription or skipping doses when needed because of costs. On each of these indicators, one-third or more lower-income adults in the U.S. said they went without needed care because of costs in the past year.
Healthy lives: The U.S. ranks last overall with poor scores on all three indicators of healthy lives—mortality amenable to medical care, infant mortality, and healthy life expectancy at age 60. The U.S. and U.K. had much higher death rates in 2007 from conditions amenable to medical care than some of the other countries, e.g., rates 25 percent to 50 percent higher than Australia and Sweden. Overall, France, Sweden, and Switzerland rank highest on healthy lives.
I leave it as an exercise to you to understand why most of those metrics are stupid and have little to do with whether or not the health care being delivered is high quality or not.
The Democrats have a leg up here because they like the ambulance chaser type. Hell, they even ran one for Vice President in 2004 (although he turned out to be a skirt chaser too).
I leave it as an exercise to you to understand why most of those metrics are stupid and have little to do with whether or not the health care being delivered is high quality or not.
It's up to you to explain your unique perspective as to why quality, access, efficiency, equity and mortality are "stupid" metrics. I doubt someone who needs care that he can't get -- more likely to be an American than anybody else in the First World -- would agree.