Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
Many people here seem to discuss healthcare systems as if they were some theoretical concept.

Numerous industrialized countries have, and have had for many decades, quite well-functioning healthcare systems that provide essential healthcare and hospital service for free or for a low, same for all cost. Prescription medicines are free or heavily subsidized. Dental care is usually subsidized.

It works, and it works well. Of course there are snags, and there is a limit to what is provided. Of course there is always the discussion of just how expensive treatments should be provided to keep certain patients alive. But we work it out.

Financing? Some have a standardized or income-dependent fee, others take it through taxes. Of course, the citizens have to pay, there IS nobody else.

Market competition? Still exists, only the healthcare authorities are the customer, not the individual patients (and a much more potent negotiator they are).

There are details. Tons of them. But this is something that can be done, is done, and should be done. All it takes is a government that wants to do it, and voters who will let them.

Hans
 
For profit yields the best results if there is a reasonable expected ROI and fast amortization of the equipment.
Only then will the venture be able to procure capital at reasonable rates. And only then
can there be real competition.
Providing health-care requires massive up-front investment in equipment, personnel and training - it is next to impossible for a newcomer to break into the sector.


But the more basic question is: is it desirable to have competition when it comes to health-care (and other infrastructure-like services) ?
We don't want three different companies to build and operate three different roads between two cities - that would be massively wasteful. We don't want two sewer systems or five train tracks in parallel.
 
But the more basic question is: is it desirable to have competition when it comes to health-care (and other infrastructure-like services) ?

We don't want three different companies to build and operate three different roads between two cities - that would be massively wasteful. We don't want two sewer systems or five train tracks in parallel.

IMO there can be competition at the point of delivery for some infrastructure services as long as there is some kind of overall management to ensure that there is sufficient capacity.

The development of the UK railways is an example of the alternative, no overall vision which meant that we ended up with some doubling-up and some areas devoid of service. Ironically once it came under central control, one of the major lines was closed because it was deemed surplus to requirement and duplicating existing lines. It's a pity now because we could use the additional capacity.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Central_Main_Line
 
Compared to other developed nations that figure is huge. Europe spends around 11% at most of GDP on healthcare.

There's a range of models European countries use to provide basic healthcare to all citizens. Hopefully Trump will use one of these going forward to replace the ACA.

If you could "only" save 5% of GDP on healthcare, that's a hell of a lot of money freed up for better purposes.

That would cost hundreds of thousands of jobs though, and cause people to lose millions. You think any job killing law like that could get passed?
 
Republican/Ryan healthcare plan:

It will be a tax deduction for insurance paid. No websites, no enrollment. The insurance plans are handled state by state, even the "free market plans." In many states it will look like buying cable TV. Red states! "What are my choices?" Cable or satellite. Insurance or no insurance.
 
True, but there is a basic assumption in the U.S. (and increasingly in the U.K.) that a profit-based delivery system will be far more efficient, cost effective and provide a higher quality service because of the profit motive.
A belief yes, but not everyone believes it. Unfortunately the US has been fed a steady diet of that propaganda since Reagan said the government is the problem.
 
For profit yields the best results if there is a reasonable expected ROI and fast amortization of the equipment.
Only then will the venture be able to procure capital at reasonable rates. And only then
can there be real competition.
Providing health-care requires massive up-front investment in equipment, personnel and training - it is next to impossible for a newcomer to break into the sector.
This is a rather superficial analysis of some very complex problems with free market health care efficiency. Yes, but there is a lot more too it than what you note.


But the more basic question is: is it desirable to have competition when it comes to health-care (and other infrastructure-like services) ?
We don't want three different companies to build and operate three different roads between two cities - that would be massively wasteful. We don't want two sewer systems or five train tracks in parallel.
This is one of the many problems I refer to.
 
For profit yields the best results if there is a reasonable expected ROI and fast amortization of the equipment.
Only then will the venture be able to procure capital at reasonable rates. And only then
can there be real competition.
Providing health-care requires massive up-front investment in equipment, personnel and training - it is next to impossible for a newcomer to break into the sector.


But the more basic question is: is it desirable to have competition when it comes to health-care (and other infrastructure-like services) ?
We don't want three different companies to build and operate three different roads between two cities - that would be massively wasteful. We don't want two sewer systems or five train tracks in parallel.


Many universal care systems around the world use private insurance companies. But they are regulated like public utilities as to prices, services and profits. Profit is not in itself the problem. Nobody works for free. The problem is a system that makes higher profits the primary goal and rewards insurance and hospital executives with profit-based performance bonuses.
 
Last edited:
Numerous industrialized countries have, and have had for many decades, quite well-functioning healthcare systems that provide essential healthcare and hospital service for free or for a low, same for all cost. Prescription medicines are free or heavily subsidized. Dental care is usually subsidized.


The usual argument is that the methods that work just fine in multiple other countries will fail miserably in the US because...reasons. It usually involves some sort of vague handwaving about the size of the population.
 
For profit yields the best results if there is a reasonable expected ROI and fast amortization of the equipment.
Only then will the venture be able to procure capital at reasonable rates. And only then
can there be real competition.
Providing health-care requires massive up-front investment in equipment, personnel and training - it is next to impossible for a newcomer to break into the sector.

That's ridiculous. The barriers to entry in other industries are way higher: car manufacturing, airplane manufacturing, semiconductor manufacturing, computer operating systems, smartphone operating systems, cloud based computing. The list goes on and on. A new radiology group can be started with less than $2 million. How much does it cost to hang out your shingle as a family practitioner? The biggest cost is the 10 years you devote to studying medicine.

But the more basic question is: is it desirable to have competition when it comes to health-care (and other infrastructure-like services) ?
We don't want three different companies to build and operate three different roads between two cities - that would be massively wasteful. We don't want two sewer systems or five train tracks in parallel.

By your logic, it's wasteful to have more than one car company and more than one computer software company and more than one cellular phone network. It is, at some level, of course, but the benefits of competition and choice far outweigh the duplicative effort.
 
That's ridiculous. The barriers to entry in other industries are way higher: car manufacturing, airplane manufacturing, semiconductor manufacturing, computer operating systems, smartphone operating systems, cloud based computing. The list goes on and on. A new radiology group can be started with less than $2 million. How much does it cost to hang out your shingle as a family practitioner? The biggest cost is the 10 years you devote to studying medicine.



By your logic, it's wasteful to have more than one car company and more than one computer software company and more than one cellular phone network. It is, at some level, of course, but the benefits of competition and choice far outweigh the duplicative effort.

That is not my argument at all, but thanks for giving me the chance to clarify:

I'm not saying that having multiple companies for one product is wasteful, but that sectors with very high initial investments are almost always not as competitive as those that require less investment. This is rather self-explanatory. Indeed it has long been the practice of the giants of industries to buy up any newcomer that might siphon off market share.

This is an intrinsic weakness of capitalism, in that markets become less competitive the bigger the players are.

We can easily see this when "too big to fail" companies screw up so badly that they need to be bailed out: this would never happen with smaller players because they could almost seamlessly be replaced by competitors.

And of course this becomes even worse in the case of infrastructure providers: you have to buy water and electricity at whatever price and quality (see Flint, Michigan).

I agree that most healthcare services don't require expensive equipment to start, but the big costs in healthcare do come from MRIs, cancer treatment, dialysis machines and operating theaters (plus the monitoring for Intensive Care).
That is why you hardly ever see hospitals with lots of spare capacity. Only if you did would it be a sign that actual competition is happening.
 
Compared to other developed nations that figure is huge. Europe spends around 11% at most of GDP on healthcare.

There's a range of models European countries use to provide basic healthcare to all citizens. Hopefully Trump will use one of these going forward to replace the ACA.

If you could "only" save 5% of GDP on healthcare, that's a hell of a lot of money freed up for better purposes.

It is amazing that we spend more to cover fewer people and have worse health outcomes. And yet we claim our system is more efficient and any other system would be inefficient. #alternatefacts
 
It is amazing that we spend more to cover fewer people and have worse health outcomes. And yet we claim our system is more efficient and any other system would be inefficient. #alternatefacts

We don't have worse health outcomes. That's a myth. Talk about alternate facts. :rolleyes:
 
Kill the ACA, kill Americans:
The biggest and most definitive study of what happens to death rates when Medicaid coverage is expanded, published in the New England Journal of Medicine, found that for every 455 people who gained coverage across several states, one life was saved per year. Applying that figure to even a conservative estimate of 20 million losing coverage in the event of an ACA repeal yields an estimate of 43,956 deaths annually.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/poste...43000-people-annually/?utm_term=.28b638ec13eb
 
We don't have worse health outcomes. That's a myth. Talk about alternate facts. :rolleyes:

I'm sorry, as a whole we do not have the best outcomes. And we are not as good as many of our peers who pay far less. Does that help your ocular condition?

ETA: I just reread my post ...<snip>... We do have worse outcomes. Maybe not the worst, but worse. We are bested by many of our peers, not just the Danes and Swedes.
Edited by jsfisher: 
Edited for compliance with Rule 0 of the Membership Agreement.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Well, we don't have worse outcomes than everybody. But we're not at the top of any lists either. . . .
http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/...care-system-in-survey/?utm_term=.f1c8b3c0cff0 . . .

I should have read your links before replying:

A report released Monday by a respected think tank ranks the United States dead last in the quality of its health-care system when compared with 10 other western, industrialized nations, the same spot it occupied in four previous studies by the same organization. Not only did the U.S. fail to move up between 2004 and 2014 -- as other nations did with concerted effort and significant reforms -- it also has maintained this dubious distinction while spending far more per capita ($8,508) on health care than Norway ($5,669), which has the second most expensive system.
 
That would cost hundreds of thousands of jobs though, and cause people to lose millions. You think any job killing law like that could get passed?

So we lose hundreds of thousands of insurance company employees. Why can't you then use some of the money saved to create jobs elsewhere.

Which people would "lose milions". Insurance company executives?

Or do you mean the people out of work collectively?

Spend a hefty chunk of the 5% of GDP you just saved on national infrastructure. Lots of building companies will need to hire lots of people. Net job loss could be zero.

No. I don't think such a bill would have a cat in hells chance of passing, particularly under a Republican Administration, because lobbyists. I can't think of any good reasons though why the USA shouldn't have a universal health care system, just about every other developed nation has.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom