Cont: Trump "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA Part II

The Constitution never mentions a state-funded military: only militias.
So if you want to have a Small Government the way the Founding Fathers envisioned, get rid of the entire defense budget.
 
The Constitution never mentions a state-funded military: only militias.
So if you want to have a Small Government the way the Founding Fathers envisioned, get rid of the entire defense budget.

Likely just the army and airforce. A standing Navy was always understood to be of necessary to keep piracy under control.
 
The coast guard was never expected to act overseas. Look at the Tripolitan wars for how the navy was expected to operate

and neither did the Founding Fathers think that they would build a navy to rival England. That was inconceivable.
At most, they wanted to curtail smuggling and have early warnings on enemy ships.
 
Not zero, just 'as small as possible', huh?

Typical republican mantra.

"We tried cutting taxes and removing regulations, and things just got worse. So obviously we need more tax cuts and deregulation!"

"Eventually we will reach that magic spot where government is as small as possible but not quite zero, and everything will come up roses!".


Repeating the same action, expecting a different result.
 
Repeating the same action, expecting a different result.

I'm not sure that the objective is wider success for the economy as a whole (though if it happens to come about then that's no bad thing), but instead the success for the individuals who are paying the piper.
 
I'm not sure that the objective is wider success for the economy as a whole (though if it happens to come about then that's no bad thing), but instead the success for the individuals who are paying the piper.

The claims being made is broader success, despite the stagnation of the middle class for the past 35 years.
 
That can't be it. All the secrecy and short deadlines was about bouncing a measure through because they knew it would be toxic. The more time passes the worse it gets. This is them throwing their hands up and enjoying summer, because who knows what the political landscape will be like come fall? Who knew it would be like this in spring?

It's complicated. Trump has to launder the Russian money he is donating to the future campaigns of the 5 hold out Republican senators.
 
Repeating the same action, expecting a different result.

Exactly: there are all those examples historically and even present day in the USA and other countries where cutting to the bone regulations, government, and safety nets has worked really well for the vast majority of the citizens. Well I can't think of one right now but I am certain that there are many! Whereas countries that are the opposite are horrible failures with horrible qualities of life. Right?
 
Re dying without insurance, just found out today that one of the drugs I may need to take costs $10,000/month. Were I on Medicare (I'm not there yet) my share would be 33%, so $3,300/month for years or more.

A low income elderly person needing this drug would essentially be unable to buy it. Inadequate insurance coverage can indeed be a death sentence.
 
Re dying without insurance, just found out today that one of the drugs I may need to take costs $10,000/month. Were I on Medicare (I'm not there yet) my share would be 33%, so $3,300/month for years or more.

A low income elderly person needing this drug would essentially be unable to buy it. Inadequate insurance coverage can indeed be a death sentence.

Low income elderly people can qualify for subsidies, as well as potentially qualifying or Medicaid that coordinates with Medicare.

Also, Drug coverage under Medicare varies by carrier, the 33% may be a good ballpark estimate, but many PDPs use copays rather than coinsurances.
 
Low income elderly people can qualify for subsidies, as well as potentially qualifying or Medicaid that coordinates with Medicare.
Also, Drug coverage under Medicare varies by carrier, the 33% may be a good ballpark estimate, but many PDPs use copays rather than coinsurances.

Yes, and the key points are "can" which usually means maybe depending on the program and the details, and the definition of "low income." I would be exactly in this situation if not for having a good insurance plan through my employer ( the drug pricing is very similar). I am by no means low income and justifiably I am not eligible for subsidies form the drug manufacturer or state. I am a senior citizen. Yet there is no way I could afford $120,000 for one drug.

We've got to do a lot better than this as a society, rather than worse as the Trumpcare bills seek .
 
Low income elderly people can qualify for subsidies, as well as potentially qualifying or Medicaid that coordinates with Medicare.

Also, Drug coverage under Medicare varies by carrier, the 33% may be a good ballpark estimate, but many PDPs use copays rather than coinsurances.
Subsidies? Do you mean from the drug manufacturer? To qualify for Medicaid you have to have a low income, in Texas below $23,522. Also. you must be pregnant,disabled or caretaker of someone with a disability, or over 65. https://www.benefits.gov/benefits/benefit-details/1640

ETA: Or a parent of a dependent child under 19.
 
Last edited:
Subsidies? Do you mean from the drug manufacturer?

By subsidies, I mean Medicare Savings Program, Low Income Subsidies, and a couple of others.
https://www.medicare.gov/your-medicare-costs/help-paying-costs/get-help-paying-costs.html
https://www.ehealthmedicare.com/medicare-part-d-prescription/low-income-subsidy/

To qualify for Medicaid you have to have a low income, in Texas below $23,522. Also. you must be pregnant,disabled or caretaker of someone with a disability, or over 65. https://www.benefits.gov/benefits/benefit-details/1640

ETA: Or a parent of a dependent child under 19.
I don't know what the rules are for Medicare/Medicaid dual eligible. I believe they are different than for Non-Medicare-Eligible folks, but I'm fairly unfamiliar with them.
 
The BBC says that nine republican (at least, that's presumably what they mean) senators have said they will not support the Senate bill, but that Trump is optmisitic that they'll "get over the line". They also report a survey by USA Today saying that only 12% of Americans support the bill. (Most don't know, rather than opposing it.) I wonder what the chances of the Senate passing some version of it are!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom